protecting witnesses

Youth justice and criminal evidence act 1999

Lord Haldane
Scott v Scott [1913]

R v Smellie (1919)

R v X, Y, Z (1989)

Advisory group on video evidence - the pigot committee (home office 1989)

criminal justice act 1991

problems with criminal justice act 1991

YJCEA 1999

s16 YJCEA 1999

s17 YJCEA 1999

special measures available

s23 screen

s24 live video link

s25 clearing court

implementation of s28

special measures only available under s16

coherence

s16(5)

s19(2)

s21 YJCEA 1999

s22A YJCEA 1999 inserted by 2009 act

special measures and art 6
R (on the application of D c Camberwell green youth court 2005

R (on the application of S) v Waltham forest youth court 2004

SC v UK 2005

s 33A YJCEA 1999 inserted by s47 police and justice act 2006

s103 of 2009 act inserts ss33 BA and 33BB into the 1999 act

victims and witness intimidation: findings from the british crime survey HO 2000

s39 criminal justice and police act 2001

subpoena witness to attend

witness protection programme
witness intimidation

witness intimidation
adduce written statement as hearsay s116 CJA 2003

Mayers 2008

Al-Khawaja and Tahery v UK 2011

Davis Ellis and others 2008
facts

Davis Ellis and others 2008
House of Lords

Davis Ellis and others [2008]
the conclusion

The criminal evidence (witness anonymity ) bill 13th july

Coroners and justice act 2009

s86(2) 2009 act
s87
s88

Horncastle 2009

sexual offences and recent complaint

R v Osbourne 1905

s120 CJA 2003

Coroners and justice act 2009
time of complaints

Milton Brown 1998

Criminal justice act 1991

s34 and 35 YJCEA 1999

s36 YJCE 1999

common law on sexual history evidence

s2 sexual offences (amendment act 1976

criticisms of 1976 act

ss41-43 yjcea 1999

s41 YJCEA
sexual offences

s62 YJCEA definition of sexual offence

R v Cartwright [2007]

s41(1)(c) YJCEA 1999

R v Ben Rejab [2011]

R v T 2001

R v AM [2009]

R v RP [2013]

s41(6) YJCEA 1999

s41(2) YJCEA 1999

gateway 1
s41(3)(a)
YJCEA 1999

s42(1)(b) YJCEA 1999

gateway 1
examples of issues which are not issues of consent

Gateway 2
S41(3)(b)
YJCEA 1999

R v A (No 2) 2002
HL

gate way 3 s41(3)(c)
YJCEA 1999

R v A (no2) in relation to gateway 3

s41(4) YJCEA 1999
sting in the tail
gateway 1,2 and 3

R v Islam [2012]

gateway 4 s41(5)
YJCEA 1999

R v A (No2) 2001
in relation to art 6

R v A No 2 2001
Lord Steyne

R v R [2003]
application of lord steyns admissibility test

R v White 2004

R v B [2007]
application s41 to male victims