Karteikarten
Biogeography 2
Karten in diesem Stapel (200)
- 1What is the case study for the altitudinal shift of the native and introduced flora of California?• Wolf et al (2016) examine changes in the distribution of species through time in different altitudinal gradients in California.
• To estimate mean shifts in elevational and climatic space: 681,609 georeferenced herbarium of 4426 plant taxa from Consortium of California Herbaria.
• Aim: to compare mean altitudes during two periods (1895-1970 vs 1971-2009).
• But...missing environmental (altitudinal) information from specimen labels
• Climate and elevation: PRISM Climate group (Oregon state University).
• Monthly temperature grids at 2.5-arcmin resolution were recalculated into annual sums, means, and associated with each herbarium record for the year of its collection.
• Digital elevation model for the study area to infer such information
• Significant altitudinal increase in 15% of species.
• 17.9% of taxa show an increase in mean annual temperature across their niche.
• 18.5% of taxa experience a similar increase in precipitation.
• Altitudinal changes are mainly due to climate change! - 2What are other applications for herbaria?• Red List and Priority Areas
• Plant extinctions and their causes
• Introduction of non-native species
• Genetic studies - 3What are native species/ alien species/ invasive species?• Native species:
o An indigenous species that occurs in the wild in a given region
• Alien (AKA: introduced) species:
o A species that has been introduced to a part of the world to which it is not native
o Also referred to as exotic or simply introduced species.
• Invasive species:
o Species that reproduce in large numbers and spread over a considerable area causing damage to native communities.
o They affect, economically, environmentally or ecologically, habitats where they have been introduced, either accidentally or deliberately, outside their normal past or present distribution (Masters & Norgrove 2010). - 4What is an invasive specie?• An introduced species that spreads rapidly and cause damage to habitats
o 1. Most introduced species are not invasive.
o 2. A species may be invasive in some regions but not in others.
Depends on the tolerance of each specie (i.e. the bell shaped (Gaussian) curve of tolerance - 5What are the characteristics of invasive species?1. General diet and habitat requirements
2. Habitat transformer (when they arrive to a new environment, they can change it)
3. High abundance (expanding range)
4. Small body size
5. High reproductive potential
6. Good competitors
7. Social
(e.g. Mosquito going back to the Mediterranean coast, Bamboo difficult to eradicate) - 6Why are Invasive Species problematic?1. Alteration of habitat – hard then for management
2. Change in the diversity, abundance, and distribution of members of the pre-existing natural communities (changes networks - of food webs etc.)
3. Competition with native species (for food/ space and other resources)
4. Broad and cascading effects throughout communities and ecosystems.
- Ladybird introduced as a control for another specie – now seen to have damaged other communities - 7What is the case study of Hydrangea macrophylla as an invasive specie in the Azores?• Introduced by the Japanese in the 19thC
• They used the flowers to divide the lands and it brings beauty to the island
• Now part of the island (brings tourism etc.)
• Species introduction not always negative! - 8What is the case study for ornamentation plants as an invasive specie on Poor Knights islands (Tawhiti Rahi), New Zealand?- Pollen grains used as a proxy for vegetation
- Metrosideros shown to be around only more recently – it may have meant the native species disappeared and is thought to have been preferred as looks nice.
o Should we bring back the other two more native species back?
- The bottom section of 3 shows the pollen before the human era - 9What is the case study of Dreissena polymorpha as an invasive specie?• Zebra mussel (small freshwater mussel).
• This species was originally native to the lakes of southern Russia and Ukraine
• Changes the communities they arrive in
• Arrives through boats - 10What does a new specie need to do to expand its range?• To expand its range, a species must be able to:
o 1. Travel to a new area.
o 2. Withstand potentially unfavourable conditions during its passage (BARRIERS!).
Some species won’t be able to cross the barriers
o 3. Establish a viable population upon arrival. - 11When does an introduced species become an invader?• An introduced species has invaded when it establishes a self-sustaining population
- 12What is The invasion process?• Invasion: the establishment of a species outside of its natural range.
• According to Williamson and Fitter (1996), only 10 % of all introduced species succeed in the establishment of new populations.
• To be an invasive specie, a specie must successfully transition through each stage (on the left).
• The proportion of species that proceed from one stage to the next is less than the previous one
1. Introduction – start a process of colonisation and establish (the environmental conditions are good)
2. Integration and spread then make a species invasive - 13What are the Barriers to the establishment of an introduced species?Establishment
• To be invasive, this requires dispersal across barriers, colonization, and successful reproduction!
• A subset of these species may not only survive, but become invasive, dominating the new community and even causing the extinction of natives.
- Biographic filter – mountains etc.
- Physiological filter – climate etc.
- Biotic filter – competition etc.
- Many species don’t become invasive, as don’t make it the whole way through all filters - 14What are the Barriers to the establishment of an introduced species when human impact is considered?- Humans may facilitate introductions initially, and allow a filter to be passed (biogeographic filter) that otherwise wouldn’t have been able to be passed
- 15What allows a species to become invasive?• Plasticity and adaptive evolution can lead to greater invasiveness
• Broad Environmental Tolerance: life history traits that confer superior colonizing ability or ability to acclimate to a wide range of habitats.
o Need to be aware of each tolerance range for each specie
• Local adaptation: adapt to local selective pressures. - 16Mechanisms of introductions: How they travel to a new area?• Natural invasions: Invasions without human influence.
o Rare on human time scales!!
o Hard to extract humans from a natural environment
• Require the removal of either:
o 1. Geographic barrier - The creation of dispersal corridors through glacial retreat, continental drift (long time scales), or chance
o 2. Physiological barrier - For example a thermal barrier removed by climate change
• Anthropogenic introductions: intentional and/or accidental.
o Potentially more frequent in recent years
• In all type of ecosystems, from Oceanic Islands to tropical rain forest (Pimentel et al, 2000).
- More than 1.500 native species in Brazil
- 514 native breeds in Europe, 27 non-natives (but these are part of the biodiversity) - 17How can invasive species be transported via ships?• The number of non-native species. That are transported via ship ballast has increased with the rise in global commerce (35000 commercial vessels across all the oceans). 7000 to 1000 species.
• Global hot spots for biological invasion from ballast water (water carried in the ships tanks)
- These kinds of maps can show where there might be higher chances of invasion rates - 18How can invasive species be transported through aquatic systems?• California: 48/137 sp. of fish are exotic.
o 46 Are suspected to have negative effects on native sp.
o Extinctions of species and a consequent reduction in biodiversity
• Lake Victoria: introduction of Nile perch (Lates niloticus) appears to have been primary cause of the extinction of 200 endemic cichlids! (Goldschmidt et al, 1993).
o A cascading effect through the communities
o Should we eradicate the fish through the lakes (they are reproducing fast..!) - 19What is the case study of the Kamchatka red king crab (Paralithodes camtschaticus) as an invasive species?• Native to the Bering Sea, north Pacific Ocean (Kamchatka peninsula).
• 1960: Introduced to the Barents Sea from the North Pacific a total of 1655 egg-bearing females, 954 large males, and 10000 juveniles.
• Temperature tolerance: −1.8 to 12.8 °C
• The red king crab has become a valuable marine resource but as an introduced species, it also poses a potential threat to the ecosystem (Oug et al., 2011).
o Tried to be included in the diet in the area (good for economy, but potentially bad for environement) - 20What makes certain ecosystems susceptible to invasion?• A database of 52480 vegetation plots throughout contrasting climatic conditions and containing a wide range of flora.
o Tried to cover as wide a range of habitat types and floras around the whole world
• Found that local habitat characteristics are better at predicting the risk of biological invasions (Chytry et al, 2008):
o Climate
o soil nutrients
o existing flora
o human impact
• In harsh climatic conditions and nutrient-poor habitats, invasion levels are low
• Alien plants tend to thrive in nutrient- rich and man-made habitats.
• This paper makes good conclusions for management (but might not be exhaustive) - 21What makes certain ecosystems susceptible to invasion?• Mountains, cliffs, bogs, dry grasslands and coniferous woodlands: tend to resist alien invasion.
• Human-made habitats, coastal and riverine habitats, where nutrient availability and disturbance can be high: more prone to invasion.
• Most invaded habitats include broadleaved deciduous forestry planta5ons, forest clearings or riverside willow scrub habitats.
• Islands: little history with competitors, predators, parasites, or diseases.
o Species evolve without any other species from other areas providing competition
• Introduced species can directly compete with or prey on native sp. - 22How are invasive species relevant for management?• Global Island Partnership
o PRIORITY: Catalyze commitments to ecosystem- based adaptation, mitigation and reducing the threat of invasive species
• IUCN Island Initiative Program and other IUCN Commission Groups including the Invasive Species Specialist Group (ISSG), World Commission on Protected Areas (WCPA)
• Invasive species now included in many policies
• Controlling invasive species was among the most pressing challenges identified by the World Heritage Committee when it recommended Galapagos be placed on the list of World Heritage in Danger - 23What are the implications for Management with invasive species?1. Ecologically appropriate restoration
a. requires the accurate determination of species’ provenance: Is a species native or introduced to a region? Track the vector: look at import/export records. Look at pathways that airlines & ships utilize. Assess at genetic composition of the populations in introduced areas and source areas
2. The risk of applying inappropriate management to what are in fact native species
a. wider implications for the classification of invasive species.
3. Small isolated areas such as oceanic islands seem to be especially vulnerable to invasions
a. species poverty (because of great distances from continents), evolution in isolation, early colonisation, small spatial scales, crossroads of international trade, and ecological release (invasive species may arrive without natural pests). - 24What management examples are there for invasive sepecies?1. Invasive in Island ecosystems- management
a. Galápagos
b. South Georgia
c. Falkland Islands
2. The Cane Toad and the northern Australian fauna
a. Competition
b. Native prey and native predators
c. Public perceptions - 25What is the significance of invasive in Island ecosystems-management Oceanic island (islands cover 3% of Earth)?• 60% of all documented mammal and bird introductions have occurred in oceanic islands.
• Lots of unique biodiversity
- In latitude 20-30, there seems to be more introduced than native species
- Native birds seen to decline with introduced species increasing - 26What is the significance of Galápagos and invasive species?• Some of highest extinction rates in the world (64% of vascular plant taxa and 49% of vertebrates are classified as threatened).
o Many species only occurring in the Galapagos
• Human influence is believed to be relatively recent (AD 1535) - can realistically describe pre-anthropogenic impact conditions.
o Research showing the correlations between human settlement and the number of species becoming threatened
• Greatest conservation threats: invasive species, habitat degradation in the highlands, increasing human impact.
o Increasing number of tourists (although contained and well listed) thought to be a new vector for introducing invasive species - 27‘Doubtful Natives’: how many invasive species are really native??• At least 60 doubtful native plant species in the Galapagos Islands (those thought to be introduced)
• Galapagos a hotspot of research and answering questions such as;
o Are they introduced or natives?
o When did they arrive?
o What is their rate of spread?
• Take a paleoecological approach to understand the ecology of the species
- True natives!
- Hibiscus listed as an invasive species – spreading a lot, very pretty and although the researchers didn’t know when it arrived, it showed the characteristics of an invasive specie
• Native status of doubtfully native / presumed invasive plant species (graph shows the species targeted for eradication)
• (van Leeuwen, Froyd, et al. 2008)
- Pollen counts show no presence of the species. But then find that it did occur around 8000 years ago
o Pollen does disperse though
o Instead then looked at seeds rather than pollen grains (then knew the species did indeed live in the islands in historic times)
- The managers had to make decisions on whether to allow it to thrive or remove it - 28What implications for Management are there?- Need to know the vector which may have transported the specie
1. The risk of applying inappropriate management to what are in fact native species is highlighted by these results.
2. Paleoecology also has wider implications for the classification of invasive species (when climate may have changed etc.) - 29What is the case study of the Falklands in terms of invasive specieS?* Recent impact in terms of human settlement
*Virtually the entire land area of the islands is used as pasture for sheep.
• Introduced species include reindeer, rabbits, Patagonian foxes, brown rats and cats
• No trees – just grasslands and shrubs
o Managers ask how long the landscape has been like this (were there once trees)
o Over last 8000 years there has been no trees
Impacts of invasive species on native biodiversity
1. The detrimental impact several of these species have caused to native flora and fauna has led authorities to attempt to contain, remove or exterminate invasive species such as foxes, rabbits and rats.
a. Endemic land animals have been the most affected by introduced species.
b. Rats bad for sea birds as eat the eggs
2. No long-term records! The extent of human impact on the Falklands is unclear, since there is little long-term data on habitat change. However, ongoing work shows that for the past 8000 years...no trees! - 30What is the case study of South Georgia in terms of invasive specieS?• Lots of mountains with permanent snow and glaciers
• First introductions in 1700: Dandelions, rats, reindeer!
• South Georgia is one of the most important seabird sanctuaries in the world.
• Reindeer in South Georgia are an example of an animal which has been introduced outside its native range.
• South Georgia a Norwegian whaling station – brought rats and cats too
• 3 introductions between 1911-1925 by the Norwegians
o (3 male, 7 female)
o To provide both recreational hunting and fresh meat for the numerous people working in the whaling industry on the island at the time
• In 1958, the population had increased to approx. 6000 animals!!
• The populations split in two across the valley – they were competing and destroying the local fauna
• Managers had to decide about what to do with the reindeers
o Cull
oTranslocate (a few were translocated to the Falklands in the end, couldn’t do all 6000, as it’s expensive)
oAllow for people to come and hunt the deer (for a price) - 31What did the authorities decide to do in South Geogria?• In 2010 authorities made the decision to remove reindeer from the Island – hunted them all in different periods of time and at different seasons.
• Rats and mice also eradicated (March 2011 had a trial that tested the poison wasn’t dangerous for the local flora/ fauna – helicopter the poison)
o Endemic species then seen to increase and spread their native ranges once more
• The dandelions that were introduced through the seeds in soil in Norway (to bury the dead people – a tradition)
o Eradication of plants is more difficult than fauna – so far haven’t been sucsessful - 32What is the case study of the cane toad as an invasive specie?- Toxic toad
• Upper map: current toad arrival and spread (arriving around 1935) – the North seems to be constraining them
• Lower map: predicted final range in which toads can live and breed for >3 months per year.
o Black dots current recordings.
• Native to Americas – large, and toxic throughout its life
Problems with the Toads
• Toads eat a lot – reduce population size of invertebrate prey?
• Because they are toxic, they kill native PREDATORS – none of the Oz predators knew not to eat cane toads
• Major problem for wildlife conservation
• Public also concerned—topic of major public debate
- There are cascading effects into interactions with the community
Predators susceptible to toad toxin
- Tried to identify native species vulnerable to the toads
- How to manage the toads if it is seen their populations will only expand (especially with the climate)
• Yellow-spobed goanna (Varanus panoptes)
• King brown snake (Pseudechis australis)
• Northern quolls (Dasyurus) - 33Toad biology – what has led to cane toad success?1. Multiphasic life history and variable adult size—many habitats and scales of interaction
2. Eggs toxic but have non-toxic covering (have to eat it to be toxic)
3. Allometry in toxic content (the larger the toad...) – affects predators with large body size (eg male northern quolls)
4. Toad population structure (very specific to the toads): toads at the advancing range (the edges of their current range that is expanding) are large and tend not to reproduce (may also have more toxin) – makes the range limit deadly as there are no small toads that predators could ingest but not die from to develop aversion behaviour—however, in regions behind expanding front, there are many smaller animals too. - 34What are the effects of the Cane toads, and how do native animals deal with them?Effects
• Difficult to quantify effects since toads arrived (1935).
• Populations of animals vary with weather and with many other anthropogenic effects like habitat destruction or transformation
1. No evidence to date of native species extinction. (yet…)
2. Population declines then recoveries in some species.
Phillips et al 2007 – Radio-tracking toads
• Cane toads move very fast – for toads
• Spread accelerating (55 miles per year) – why?
o 1. Differences in populations – dispersing toads have longer legs
o 2. In new landscapes that favour their spread: N Aus – wet-dry climate – more similar to original habitat
They favour the newer habitats, so keep expanding
Ways native species deal with toads
1. Evolutionary responses based on intra-specific variation in susceptibility to toxin.
a. Trying to make the populations less susceptible to the toxins
2. Genetic and biogeographic linkages – evolved resistance in Asian descendants cf long-isolated lineages.
a. Trying not to feed on the toxic toad in the first place
3. Evolved aversion – either via experience and survival or unlinked - 35What are the Research and land management needs for the Cane Toad?1. More understanding of networks and foodwebs
2. Focus on key taxa (quolls)
3. Strategic land management to allow native populations best chance of recovery
• Targeted the quolls – trained the animals to then not eat the toads (these then had better survival) - 36The language of invasive species biology – is it a problem?• ...the language of invasion biology has a xenophobic “resonance” for many people (Simberloff 2003).
- 37What is the significance of Islands in Biogeography?• Islands have inspired biologists from Charles Darwin and Alfred Russel Wallace onwards, providing natural laboratories for testing ideas in ecology and evolution
o Tried to understand why species are on islands and not anywhere else
o Krakatau explosion and long distance dispersion case study
• Size and isolation of islands make them interesting to study - 38What is an island?- Continental style islands, islands could also be a lake on top of a mountain
- Islands really just isolated spaces
- Also island nations where humans also reside and people use the natural resources
• The Island nations - 39What is a continental island?- It is hard to differentiate between continental or oceanic islands without looking at geology
Continental islands
• Different geological process make Madagascar a continental island
• Part of the continent shelf, and of the same geologic composi0on as the continent, but separated from the mainland by water.
o Were part of other areas, but just became isolate (geology tends to be different)
• Rifs, erosion, subsidence, or a rise in sea level.
• Ages of islands
o Greater Antilles—80 my
o Madagascar—100 my
o New Caledonia—50 my
o New Zealand—80-90 my
o Seychelles—65 my - 40What are oceanic islands?• Islands that are not part of continental shelf areas, they are not, and have never been, connected to a continental land mass, most typically these are volcanic islands.
o Different geology to continental shelves
• Fairly recent origin that have emerged from the ocean floor
• Islands formed at mid-oceanic ridges
o Ascension Island
o Azores,
o Tristan da Cunha
o Hawai’i
- Tristan de Cunha pretty much the most isolated island
- Used to test which species has arrived there and what evidence there is for species having lived there on a temporal scale
- Can geologically date each individual island in Hawaii
o To see which species evolved first, look at the furthest island
o Time is very important – need to know when an island emerged (for knowing when evolution has occurred)
• Insular dynamism: change from island to peninsula (to island again) through the Pleistocene (Tasmania, New Guinea, Sumatra, Java, Borneo, etc. )
o This complicates the timing of original species
• The reiterative island- peninsular shift of land- bridge islands in the Pleistocene is exemplified in the A - 41How can New islands always being born?• Islands can appear very quickly if there is an explosion
• The last including:
o Anak Krakatau
o Surtsey,
o Tuluman
o Mot-mot
• Submarine eruption at El Hierro, the Canary islands (will need time to surface - 42What are the Different types of insularity?- Mountains a bit like islands through insularity
1. Islands
2. Mountains summits
3. Lakes
4. Forest Fragments
- First image – islands, insularity also on to of mountains (mountain, valley and another mountain) - 43What is the significance of Body size and Islands?• Body sizes behave differently on islands (mainly for mammals)
• Small mammals are bigger (insular gigantism)
• Larger mammals are smaller (insular dwarfism)
• Small birds on the continent (Moas) can be bigger on islands (Dodos)
- Insects somewhat standard body sizes everywhere
- Rodents much bigger on islands
- Some of these sizes have been found from bones - 44Why there are a disproportionate incidence of particular types of species on islands - speciation?Speciation in islands
• Species concept (revise lecture 3)
• Forms of speciation: geographic (allopatric, peripatric, parapatric, simpatric)
o Allopatric – separation by space: island biota (Gaápagos finches, tortoises)
o Adaptive radiation. It is a rapid evolutionary radiation
o The term is taken here to refer to the evolutionary development of distinct species from a single ancestral form, where the radiation is distinguished by niche differentiation among the members of the lineage. - 45Why there are a disproportionate incidence of particular types of species on islands?1. Speciation on islands
2. Endemic Species
3. Adaptive radiation - 46Why there are a disproportionate incidence of particular types of species on islands - adaptive radiation?• Adaptive radiation is one of the most important outcomes of the process of evolution, and islands are places where it is best observed
• The most widely recognized “trigger” for adaptive radiation is the opening up of ecological space
• Rapid evolution radiation
- Oldest running to the present time (top to bottom)
- C returning to B speciates, so cannot reproduce with B
- Time evolves the species to another new specie and when they meet again, they cannot reproduce - 47What is the case study for Long-jawed spider genus Tetragnatha as adaptive radiation?• Spectacular adaptive radiation in the Hawaiian islands
• Huge spectrum of colors, shapes, sizes, ecological affini0es, and behaviors. Archipelago (unlike in continent!).
• Appears to have colonized Hawai’i twice from the American continent, most likely by ‘ballooning’ on air currents (Gillespie et al. 1994)
- Adaptive radiation, different colours, sizes, shapes
- Sometimes species can colonise twice, which confuses things - 48How are Darwins finches an example of adaptive radiation?Darwin’s finches
- Process of arriving to an island, radiating and then processes of sympatry
Grant & Grant research in Galápagos
• Examined the behavior and life cycles of finches (over 40 years) in the island of Daphne Major, with the results strongly supporting Darwin’s theory of evolution
• Measured weight, length etc.
• Even in smaller temporal scales, have seen changes in diet and weight of the birds (strongly supporting evolution)
• “The struggle is mainly about food (different types of seeds) and the availability of that food is drama(cally influenced by year-to-year weather changes”. - 49What is the significance of the Silverswords for adaptive radiation?Silverswords (Argyroxiphium sandwicense)
• Endemic from a crater in Maui
• Large plant, with large seeds and downward facing flowers
• Descendants of a single ancestral plant species have evolved into many different forms in Hawai’i, collectively called the silversword alliance.
- Found all of these plants came from the same ancestor
- 28 species of Hawaiian plants from the same ancestor (huge phenotypic variation and plasticity)
- Descendants of a single ancestral plant species
Silversword Origins
• A phylogeny based on Chloroplast DNA suggests that the closest relatives are California Tarweeds (Deinandra) (Baldwin et al, 1991).
• To California it is a 3900 km open ocean crossing.
o Long distance dispersal?
• Also looked at the genome to see if there was another
o Silverswords have
- With the decrease in number of species it shows which have moved through the newer islands
- Adaptive radiation in terms of importance for biogeography – explain these case studies - 50What is Genetic drift?• Change in allele frequencies (genes) in a population due to a chance event.
• More likely to occur in small population (ISLANDS!).
• Unlike natural selection (favours beneficial traits) genetic drift is random.
• Can cause an increase of: beneficial, detrimental, or neutral traits.
o Grant and Grant finding evolution, but could just be genetic drift? - 51What are the Types of genetic drift?1. Founder effect: change in gene frequency due to colonization of a new area by a limited number of individuals. Founder populations are essential to the study of island biogeography and island ecology.
a. This is what happens in islands
b. I.e. first people moving to an island mainly from a family with an eye problem. The island years on will have a higher percentage of this eye condition over the general continent
2. Population bottleneck: change in gene frequency due to a drastic reduction in the size of the population. For example, a natural disaster.
a. The only species remaining carries certain traits and these are the ones that are then passed on and evolved from - 52What is the case study of the Krakatau islands?• A classic series of studies on founder population effects was done following the catastrophic 1883 erup0on of Krakatoa, which erased all life on the island
- Can bring one trait, both or the other trait
(SEE IMAGE) - 53What is the importance of islands for Conservation?• It is well established that islands contribute disproportionately to global biodiversity
• Unfortunately, they also have contributed disproportionately to species extinctions since around 1500, the point from which we have reasonably good data on human impact on islands as European naturalists accompanied the voyages of exploration and conquest.
• In this time, about 60% of known terrestrial species extinctions have been island endemics.
• Lots of extinction on islands
• These data were compiled from: IUCN, The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species (IUCN, 2017); www.iucnredlist.org.
• Inset: The Rodrigues Solitaire, by Frederick William Frohawk, 1907: an ex0nct island endemic bird
• We don’t have precisely known dates for species extinctions for all island losses.
• But for those birds, invertebrates, mammals and plants for which we can reasonably es0mate the timing of species extinctions, we can see that the losses have shown a pattern of increase over time
• This reflects increased pressures placed by human activity on many island ecosystems around the world. - 54What are the priorities for conservation on islands?• PRIORITY: Catalyze commitments to ecosystem-based adaptation, mitigation and reducing the threat of invasive species
• IUCN Island Initiative Program and other IUCN Commission Groups including the Invasive Species Specialist Group (ISSG) – link the small island states and their issues, World Commission on Protected Areas (WCPA) - 55How are islands biodiversity hotspots?• Predictions of vascular plant species richness for 17,883 islands >1 km2 (constituting ∼98% of global island land area) worldwide based on generalized additive models and model averaging.
- Islands contribute massively to biodiversity hotspots
- Number of species only on islands
• Threatened Island Biodiversity Database
- Links to the threat to species - 56What is meant by immigration?• Islands can be both close or far from continents
o There are different ways species arrive at islands (passive/ active)
• Along a gradient of increasing isolation (greater distances away from the continent), species richness should decline.
• Immigration decreases with isolation.
• Successful colonization decreases with species richness, due to increased competition (i.e. fewer available niches).
o This can be the case in closer islands, so it can be hard to see whether islands further away have less species in the trend
• Wallace (1880): birds, bats, and flying insects tend to be well represented on distant oceanic islands.
o Use active dispersal by flying - 57What happens through seed immigration?• Avian-dispersed plants: Zoochory (seeds transport by animals).
• Propagules (seeds): anemochory and hydrochory.
- Seeds can arrive to islands and need to settle, colonize the different habitat types and then breed
- Also useful to think of in terms of range expansion - 58What happens to the chance of dispersed propagule through isolation?***SEE IMAGE***
The chance of randomly dispersed propagule (passively) will decrease as an exponential function of its isolation
- Isolation (distance from source km), depending on type of dispersal (active/ passive) there are different curves
o Sigmodial curve from active dispersal
Flat beginning shows the active dispersal capacity is there (birds cannot fly forever…)
o Exponential curve from passive dispersal
Not expected a flat/ high immigration rates
Depends on the wind/ birds carrying seeds etc - 59What is meant by extinctions?• Insular communities are biased in favour of good dispersers.
o Plenty of birds/ bats/ insects on islands
• Species that require less energy to maintain their populations.
o Don’t require so much from the islands
• Function of island area:
o Smaller islands have higher extinction rates
More competition, less resources/ food
o Smaller islands provide fewer resources & lower habitat heterogeneity
o Smaller islands support fewer individuals within a species: more vulnerable to extinction!
Genetic impacts that could lead to extinction - 60What is MacArthur and Wilsons island biogeography theory?Mac Arthur and Wilson’s theory embraces two very general and long-known patterns in Island Biogeography:
1. Number of species to increase with island area.
a. More space
2. Number of species to decrease with island isolation.
- Created links in their data sets to produce a few relationship theories; - 61What is the species area relationship?1. One of the best documented community ecology’s few laws.
2. Regardless of the taxonomic group or type of ecosystem, species number tends to increase with increasing area.
a. In any species there is an increase in area
3. This relationship is NOT linear: richness increases less rapidly for larger islands.
a. Gets to a point where there is competition and less resources - 62What is the proposed mathematical generalisation pattern (1920, 1921)by Olaf Arrhenius for island biogeography principles?****SEE IMAGE***
• This equation is linearized by taking the log of both sides of the equation:
o log(S)=log(c) + zlog (A).
o Used by lots of researchers
o Shouldn’t be a linear relationship in reality, but makes it easier to analyse
• Z a fitted parameter from the data set - 63What is the Empirical relationship between number of species and island area for reptiles and amphibians of the Western Indies?***SEE IMAGE***
• Blue square - In arithmetic space (straight from the equation without linearization) - 64Why is the species area relationship important?• Why is important?
o The species–area relationship is widely used in conservation science to predict the number of species likely to go extinct as a result of habitat loss.
• Applying the species/area relationship to climate change predictions (Nogué et al, 2009)
• Predicted amount of extinct species using the species/ area relationship due to a reduction in habitat - 65What is the species isolation relationship?• Species-isolation relationship: less clearly established than species-area relationship
- 66What should happen to species through isolation?Species should decline as a function with isolation
(***SEE IMAGE***)
- Further from New Guinea, the less species
• Birds in the Maluccan and Melanesian islands.
• Influences immigration! - 67What is the equilibrium theory of island biogeography?- McArthur and Wilson put these concepts in one graph
• Species richness on an island represents a dynamic equilibrium controlled by the rate of immigration of new species and the rate of extinction of previously established species. - 68What is the Simple model: combination of species area relationship and species isolation relationship?***SEE IMAGE***
- Simple model
o Graph going up with extinction (pink)
o Graph going down with immigration (green)
o There is a point in the middle at equilibrium where immigration and extinction are the same
o Immigration higher than extinction in the part on the left
o Extinction higher than immigration in the part on the right
o Does not include area - 69What are the assumptions for the simple model of island biogeography?Assumptions
• E only influenced by size
• I only influenced by isolation.
• Continued turnover (T) occurs. - 70What is the concept of species turnover?- Equilibrium may not be the same if species turnover
o Will be the same for thousands of years, but there may have been more bats etc over birds at one time
• Species composition is constantly changing on islands!
• The composition of the community is dynamic and changing even if the number of species is reliably stable about some equilibrium point. - 71What is MacArthur and Willson’s 1963 equilibrium model of island biogeography?***SEE IMAGES****
- If island is near or far/ small or large included
- Species small far, species large far (on the bottom)
- The crossing of the two lines show the characteristics of the island and what we should expect* Effects on the equilibrium number of sp. & rate of sp. Turnover:
1. Island size (different extinction rate curves)
2. Isolation (different immigration rate curves) - 72What are the assumptions for MacArthur and Wilsons equilibrium model of island biogeography?1. Extinction is only influenced by island size
a. Can accept this as a very strong relationship
2. Immigration is only influenced by island isolation.
a. Depends on dispersal capability
3. Continued turnover occurs. - 73What is MacArthur and Willson’s 1963 equilibrium model of island biogeography?*** SEE IMAGE***
• Number of sp. at equilibrium
o SSFTSF≈ TLN>TLF
o Turnover differ species type, but same numbers of species on the island
• The theory is also now fitting modern genetic testing (so quite before its time) - 74What has to be considered in MacArthur and Wilsons theory of island biogeography?*** SEE IMAGE ***
- Need to think of immigration rate (high/ low), extinction rate (high/low) and number of species on island (high/low) in terms of area size of island and distance of island from the continent.
• They suggested (A) that islands typically reach an equilibrium species diversity, set by opposing rates of natural immigration by dispersing organisms, and species extinction by natural popula6on declines within the island
• As the island fills with species extinction rates increase to balance the tendency to increase through immigration and speciation (which happens especially on more isolated islands)
• Larger islands hold more individuals per population, so have slower rates of extinction; more distant islands have lower immigration rates
• They also saw (B) that over time, distant islands would show gradual increase in diversity as evolution filled more empty niches through speciation, leading to (C) gradual increase in the equilibrium diversity pattern
• Whitiaker et al, 2018 - 75What are the strengths and weaknesseds of MacArthur and Wilsons island biogeography model?• Positive
o Produce clear hypotheses and indicates the kind of data needed to test them.
Not just seeing the relationship, but it has been tested in different climates/ taxa/ summits/ lake systems
o Try to explain the processes in a simple way
o Can be used in many contexts – biogeography, conservation and now genetics
• Negative
o Too simple?
o More factors will affect species richness?
Adaptive radiation changing species numbers etc.
o How to measure isolation?
What can be isolation (km from which part – to the continent or to the nearest island)
New Guinea chosen as the source of species, why not New Zealand etc.
o Importance of speciation?
o Paid no attention to the life cycle of islands and has not done so well in explaining the diversity patterns of remote oceanic islands?
When they emerge (volcanic explosions)
o Doesn’t define what constitutes a small or large islands etc. - 76What combination of island biogeography would support less species?2. Near shore small islands
3. More distant big islands
4. Near shore big island
- Being further away more important than size of island (if not getting there, cannot establish either way
- Authors revise the biogeography theories and try to improve the equilibrium theory (including the geology on different islands) - 77What is the most influential contribution to island theory?• Whittaker et al, 2018
• Within the last hundred years the single most influential contribution to island theory was the dynamic equilibrium model of Robert H. MacArthur and Edward O. Wilson, published 50 years ago in 1967
• The MacArthur-Wilson model focussed on the essential biogeographical processes of colonization, speciation and extinction, but largely ignored geological and environmental dynamics - 78What is the version of a general dynamic model of oceanic biogeography?*** SEE IMAGE ***
- The above is a version of the general dynamic model of oceanic island biogeography, first published 2008, modified in 2016.
• The integration of the island life cycle with the biological processes of MacArthur and Wilson is summarized in the diagram to the len.
• Richness (R) shows a humped pattern, constrained by the humped trajectory of island carrying capacity (K), set by the island life cycle of the previous slide
• Immigration starts low but as the island establishes and grows, it picks up, to reach an early maximum as the island gains immigrants from other nearby islands in the archipelago
• Speciation follows, with sufficient time, as empty niches get filled by adaptive evolution, but extinction begins to rise as the island fills and shrinks; in the end, all is lost as the island sinks - 79What is fragmentation?• Fragmentation (and its functional opposite: coalescence) is a concept that spans biogeography, ecology and conservation biology. It refers to the break-up of continuous habitat into smaller areas. It operates on different scales of time and space, and it can lead to evolutionary changes and diversity and population dynamics. Fragmentation of many forest biomes has occurred worldwide, largely (but not entirely) coinciding with the Anthropocene.
• Fragments are terrestrial habitat islands, and their functioning relates in some ways to island biogeographical processes. In lecture we discussed evolutionary features of island biotas (e.g., gigantism, radiation, opportunism) and saw that the Andean páramo islands share some of these features though probably for different reasons. Dispersal probably limits plant species success on oceanic islands, but in the Andes most woody plants are not adapted to the harsh diurnal conditions of the tropical alpine zone. Other differences from oceanic islands include the matrix is variable and may a filter to dispersal rather than a barrier. - 80What did Pleistocene climate cycles do for fragmentation on mountain tops?• The Pleistocene climate cycles have generated fragmentation and coalescence on mountain top islands. This is a short timescale for macroevolution but not for microevolution. In Jim Brown’s mammals on mountaintops study, the main effect of the Holocene was species loss from islands. But climate change here greatly affected the spaces between islands, making immigration very difficult.
- 81What ways could a landscape contain habitat islands?• Other ways that a landscape could contain habitat islands can relate to soils, geology, burn patterns, drainage, and human land use. Landscape-scale fragmentation, is common today. We looked at Madagascar, the Pacific Northwest and England. SLOSS-type debates about the design of nature reserve size, shape and arrangement are often a luxury—changes are so rapid now that conservation operations may just take what they can get—but the principles of metapopulation dynamics, and various aspects of island biogeography still apply. Edge effects and meso-predator release are another important factors (see readings).
- 82What are the conclusions associated to fragmentation of landscapes?• Conclusions: we are surrounded by habitat islands and more or less distinct metapopulations (spatially distributed populations that have the potential to interact–immigration/re- population, local extinction, and changes in gene frequencies). Many are natural, but more and more the islands ae anthropogenic and small, with large “oceans” of cultural habitat. In fact much of the cultivatable world is now a landscape of fragments of original (actually, usually modified) land cover and associated fauna. Our own British countryside is an example of this.
- 83What is the example for fragmentation?• Fragmentation important for biodiversity conservation
• Fragmentation a widespread feature around the world, having an impact on conservation
• Islands and island biogeography important for this land habitat islands
***** SEE IMAGE ****
- Plots the change of forest cover in North America
- How from there was a continuous cover of the ‘natural habitat’, then human activity has caused the habitat to fragment into islands
- Habitat fragmentation islands (rather than oceanic islands - 84What is meant by fragmentation/ coalescence?• These patterns often, but not always, apply to transformation of forests
• What processes may operate on species in relation to these kinds of spatial and temporal change?
*** SEE IMAGE ***
- Often talking about forests, but also praries (in North America)
- Forest fragmentation in Europe and N.America very prominent
- Matrix of the original habitat with gaps and holes to a matrix of new land cover with pockets of habitat islands
- Coalesence, parts of habitats now then joining up and reclaiming land (happened in agricultural areas in America that were abandomed in the 1800s)
o Also in Pleistocene changes
- Need to think of species area relationship/ edge effects (for vulnerability of habitat)/ extinctions - 85What is the Paramo?Paramo (in the Andes)
- The Paramo habitat is a treeless mountainous area
o Vertically organised landscapes
- Large scale climatic changes - 86What is meant by the Espeletia?- Famous genera of the andes, related to daisies (but much larger… gigantisism, space to become big as well)
o Quite furry – reduce heat loss at night (stop the issue of changes diurnally) and prevents UV reflectance from scorching the plants (adaptations)
o Harsh environment so if lineages readily developed the adaptations to high elevation they can withstand the environments, so can get bigger
- Similar seen in similar latitudes in Africa
- Plantation of a pine in the Andes (still change occurring – afforestation within natural vegetation) - 87What are ice-age climate changes and mountaintop islands?• How do terrestrial habitat islands differ from oceanic islands?
- Steep mountains and large valleys (on the mountain there is many different vegetation types)
- True tree forest is much higher up in modern environments
- The paramo vegetation tends to be more squished
- Rhythmic changes in the climate of the ice ages can increase and decrease the paramo through time
- Mountain tops can become islands
- Expansion off mountain tops into wider areas
- Coalescence and fragmentation on a big space – isolation can make for allopatric speciation
********** SEE IMAGE **********
- Long term patterns in steep topographic locations with high elevational ranges
- Not as simple as the Pleistocene and Holocene
o Lots of changes between habitat zones ebbing between increasing and decreasing areas - 88What is the Great Basin cousin?- Lower elevation of the Andes
- Different climate changes
- ice ages and interglacial changes have changed the vegetation and the shape of the basin many times
- The islands made by the mountain tops would we expect the species distributions on land islands to be related to oceanic islands? - 89What to expect in islands—size and isolation affect survival of species’ populations?• Same applies to habitat islands, but with some modifications
- Absence more likely with small area, large distance of isolation
- Study looked at a particular species on the mountain tops on the great basin and followed the isolation patterns seen on oceanic islands
o Landscape islands behaving the same way as oceanic islands
• Glacial-interglacial climate changes in the southwest: “pluvial”—wet– periods in LGM and late glacial, then drying in Holocene. R
• elated to the path of the jet.
***** SEE IMAGE ****
- Still need to think about the history, as this is only a snapshot
- Real switch between water (great basin particularly dry)
o This was really different in glacial times (ice sheet diverted westerly storms right across the great basin (now quite a wet place) Lake Bonnerville was massive (similar to what has occurred in Lake Chad, which is now very small) - 90What is the difference between Pleistocene and present vegetation elevation gradient?**** SEE IMAGE ****
- Vegetation really different in the different climates (wet in Pleistocene)
- Pat racks – take leaves, twigs etc and bury them and urinate on them, preserving little packages of what types of habitats occurred (worked out through radiocarbon dating)
- Not much desert
- Lots of forest
- Lots of alpine spruce fie forests and woodlands
- Lots of the landscape joined (coalesced) in the upland areas
o Especially for pinion-juniper
- There is now desert covering much larger expanses
- Pinion become lesser in area (and a bit more fragmented)
- Forests fragmented now (forest islands beginning to be created)
- Have to think about how organisms disperse when things are joined up to not joined up - 91What is the case study by Jim Brown about mammals on mountaintops?• A test of island biogeography theory
• Only area significantly predicted spp number in small mammals (not height of highest pass, elevation, distance to next island); compared with “mainland” fewer species, more small species than large, more herbivores, more generalists. NON-equilibrium: only effective colonization is in the Pleistocene pluvials—since then “relaxation” – general slow loss of species.
- Species numbers – interested in mammals
**** SEE IMAGE ****
- Number of species present in the islands decreases below what is expected in the mainlands
- Fewer species on islands than mainlands
- Looked at what controlled the number of species on these fragmented islands
- Had a starting point in the Pleistocene, but as fragmentation of upland islands occur, species die out
- More small species than large species more common
- Generalists do better
- Herbivores do better than carnivores
- Population extinction as the climate went from wet to dry within the Great Basin - 92What do Murphy and Weiss say in 1923 about 3'C warming in future?**** SEE IMAGE ****
• Greatly reduces boreal forest area on the main ranges of the basin (mammals average 44%; butterflies average 23%).
• Birds will be least affected (why?) birds can fly
o Differential effect depending on mobiltiy
- Still in Great Basin, but put what if scenarios for future climates (over and above the Pleistocene/ Holocene transition) – future reductions in species as habitat fragments
- (Black what we would have left) - 93What other ways are there of creating habitat islands (Serpentine)?- Other ways of creating habitat islands
- Serpentine rock hard to grown in (high magnesium etc.)
o Other plants have learnt to deal with it
o High levels of endemism on the serpentine outcrops
o Rare outcrops and rare species therefore
o Rock and soil based island pattern - 94What is the fragmentation of lake and wetland?- Lakes and wetland (what is matrix, what is the island?
- The forest forms discontinuous, narrowly connected strands of forests
- The forest hugs the water courses through the wetlands
o Easy to get nutrients
o Geomorphic processes around rivers, levees drain away water from the roots - 95What is meant by meta populations?- When there is fragmentation in small isolated populations, population ecologists called meta populations
- Not contiguous, but not so isolated there is gene flow between them
- May extinct, but then come back (the whole lot is not extinct)
o Can also get spatial differentiation
- Each meta population is vulnerable (isolated)
(** SEE IMAGES **) - 96What is the fragmentation pattern of natural habitats?Fragmentation of natural habitats is widespread
• Human impacts of fragmentation
• There are many biodiversity conservation implications
- Forestry fragmentation from agriculture common
- In many places where there haven’t been particular population/ agricultural pressures, they are now being exposed to this (Amazon rainforest – logging)
- Fragmentation occurring very quickly and going to be hard to be reverse (unlike climatic changes) - 97What is meant by SLOSS in fragmentation? (single large or several small)- What are the best things to look for in Nature reserve to protects
- Many now having to just save what they can
- Certain features and characteristics that would help;
- Big areas contain more species (edge effects tend to be bad, so even if small areas amounted to one big area, still going to be less good than one big areas, as will be more vulnerable to habitat destruction and species reductions)
- Fragments that are close better than those that are further away (connectivity helps to join landscapes)
- Edge effects – ciricular better. Compact shapes best for minimising boundary lengths
- Buffer zones good to help with edge effect issues (protect against fires etc.).
o Also good for community activities
(**** SEE IMAGE ****) - 98What is the fragmentation in Madagascar?• Sequential fragmentation of the eastern and upland forest
• Contested example of how much fragmentation there has been since human colonisation (2000 years ago)
• Madagascar trade winds to the east – wet on east, but dry on west
• Mountain forest on the east side
• The forest is diminishing and moving up into the high areas
****** SEE IMAGES ****** - 99What is the conservation corridor?*** SEE IMAGE ***
- Satellite based interpretation of covers
- Climate modelling has projected this into the future
- Dividing range in Australia to promote species movement from north to south
- Want to keep the lines of communication open with habitat corridors
- Linear patterns need to be kept joined up - 100What are the Madagascan highlands?- Western edge of the green belt
- Forest fragmentation already winking out
- Not much of the landscape left
- Forest left is way away from where people are
- Scotland much like this (over millennia) clearing and grazing of forestry
o Meta population study used Scottish highlands as a model (not just in Madagascar…!) - 101What is the minimum viable patch size for brown lemurs?• Lemurs endemic to Madagascar - they need forest
o Minimum viable patch size making a conservation challenge for the lemurs
o Fragmentation gone as far as it has is making this harder
• Madagascar is an extreme and highly challenging example of fragmentation for biodiversity conservation
o Need for land and poverty
o Traditional upland pasturage uses fire – incrementally destroys forest fragments
Played a role in forest reductions
o Poor governance and corruption – nobody really in charge --conflicts (local people vs inappropriate laws)
o Biodiversity hotspot with large endemic flora and fauna (much of the larger Holocene fauna already extinct) - 102What is the case study of the forest industry in Pacific Northwest of N America?- Matrix the forest, exploitation of logging is making logged areas larger in extent than the original area
- Loggers thought owls were putting them out of a job
o Conservationists wanting to save forest for the owls - 103What is the case study for old growth fragmentation in the Pacific Northwest (northern spotted owls)?****SEE IMAGE****
- Maintain critical species
- Reduce edge effect
- Now more second growth forest, which has less species than the original forest - 104What is the importance of hedges?*** SEE IMAGES ***
- Hedges really important as connectivity corridors (especially for smaller species)
- Planning and conservationists see the importance of hedges
- Deforestation in Warwickshire happening since roman times - 105What is Warwickshire’s habitat connectivity mapping case study?• Joint project WBRC, York Universtiy and HBA – 2011
1. Woodlands
2. Hedgerows
3. Grasslands
4. Wetlands
- Map connectivity
- Could pin point where another connection could be made through another hedge corridor - 106What is the summary of fragmentation?• We are surrounded by habitat islands and more or less distinct metapopulations with processes and immigration, local extinction, and changes in gene frequencies
• Many natural, but more and more islands are anthropogenic and small, with large ‘oceans’ of cultural habitat. In fact, much of the cultivatable world is now a landscape of fragments of original land cover associated fauna. - 107What are conservation models?Conservation models (Colchester, 2004)
- Started in the sense of protected areas (NF originally for royals to hunt deer, now for the habitat)
- National parts for aesthetics etc. which got incorporated into laws
- American national parks colonised slowly – not many people live in the area
- South downs in UK – aesthetic, rather than for biodiveristy - 108What is meant by fortress conservation?1. “Fortress Conservation” –developed in the US in the late 19th century
• Dominated by contemporary politics and power structures and a view of nature as landscape for aesthetic consumption—as “primordial wilderness” (Yosemite, Yellowstone)
• Exported world-wide – exclusionary model: landscapes, nature preserved but local people ignored and displaced
• A National Park must remain a primordial wilderness to be effective. No men, not even native ones, should live inside its borders (quoting arguments for setting up the Serengeti NP).
o Exlusionary model led to trouble
o Tribal people expelled
o No one able to enjoy the habitats
• Worldwide hundreds of thousands of tribal people expelled from their lands, livelihoods removed.
• We now need to develop partnerships to preserve biodiversity and give cultural/ recreational use
• Keep out philosophy high in America still - 109What is meant by inclusive modes of conservation? = integrated2. Move to inclusive modes of conservation – in theory – but not necessarily in practice
• Rio Earth Summit 1992: ...respect, preserve and maintain knowledge, innovations and practices of indigenous and local communities embodying traditional lifestyles relevant for the conservation and sustainable use of biological resources....... etc
o Big revision in how we work with protected areas
• Over following decades there have been advances, statements, but still many fortress models out there
• Issues:
o Sustainability – if biodiversity not sustainable, what is the point?
o Land tenure
o Trust – between locals and those trying to protect the area
o Other routes of “development” compete – multiple use conflicts
o Poor governance
o Lack of suitable training – people running parks not well enough trained - 110What is the case study of the 2003 World Parks Congress, Durban?2003 World Parks Congress, Durban (Colchester, 2004)
• ....protected area authorities are encouraged to ‘promote the conditions and ensure the means for the effective engagement of Indigenous Peoples, local communities and other local stakeholders in conservation. The focus of attention should be on building the capacity of communities to engage effectively....
- Protected areas valued by many different types of people (visitors/ researchers/ indigenous people)
o Hard to listen to all the stakeholders
o Community of people running protected areas need to mangage this
*** SEE IMAGE *** - 111What has to be recognised in conservation?• Recognition that for many ecosystems/conservation areas, there is no clear pristine state any more (see baselines lecture)
o We need to know where on the trend of loss of species we are
Need to know what the original habitat looked like – defining a pristine state – how far to go back in time?
Re-wilding in Britain (how far back to go – were there even large animals that churned up the ‘original’ habitat)
o Climate change may radically transform what we even have now – is there any point in going back in time?
• More important is conserving biodiversity in the most effective way
• Also recognition of development needs of local communities
• Integrated Conservation and Development Plans (ICDPs)
o Try to state what all interests in the area are
o How to manage the park to make the systems work and better the park
• Biodiversity and development not usually very compatible
o Do benefits of protecting an area really feed through to the local people of the area so they are encouraged to protect the area - 112Why have assessment of progress often revealed conservation have not delivered?HOWEVER—assessment of progress has often revealed such programs have not delivered...why? (Wells and McShane 2004)
1. Over-ambitious
2. Isolated geographically when problems are more widespread
3. Key erroneous assumptions
a. That biodiversity conservation and development are usually mutually compatible
b. That benefits fairly distributed and encourage conservation
c. That LOCAL people’s actions are the problem
i. Prejudice idea
4. Local institutions not strong enough to participate, thus power remains outside the conservation area (regional, national level)
a. Village committee/ local council have no power and get railroaded by conservation group or interests that don’t want to do anything or government who may not have thought things through properly - 113What is the case study of the Madagascan highlands?- Forested and forest islands (fragmentation studies)
- Diverse forests
- Grasslands surround the forests
o Zeebo cattle
o Grass burned every 2 or so years
- Reduction in forest catchment as the fires ruin the forest edges
- People live down in the valley and cultivate rice while tending their cattle on the grasslands
- Landscape history narratives sometimes don’t have much evidence
- There are concerns for local development
- Small but important reserve ecologically, so management strategy
*** SEE IMAGE*** - 114What are conservation paradigms?1. Top down (paternalistic) -- practially, this one
2. Bottom up (inclusive, partnership, populist) – being pushed for the area to coordinate management
a. Madagascar—GELOSE – theoretically, this one
• Key actors: ANGAP ( the park managers) and SOFRECO
• Local villages in several traditional jurisdictions
o A local actor in the conservation efforts
• ANGAP are the national park managers (central government)
o Say the people are the issue
• SOFRECO are a consultancy from Switzerland – tried to put into place the partnership approach to manage the forests
• Wanted to meet with the local people to stop them burning the forest edges (but made some assumptions around this being the cause of the issues) - 115What was ANGAP and SOFRECO’s assumptions about the local communities:?• Local people use the forest
• Local people burn the grassland, maybe the forest
• The local society is traditional, poor, suspicious of innovation, and disorganized
• The local society is homogeneous: ‘the rural community’
Therefore....
• There is a general problem of poverty, and, if alleviated (new land-use techniques, new sources of income) people have less need to burn and use forest
• Development projects in villages can help provide such alternative resources (plant trees, make coffee plantations, etc)
• Several development projects took place during the 1990’s, the most recent after ANGAP took over the reserve. In general, these have failed........WHY? - 116Were the starting assumptions correct for in Madagascan case study?Were the starting assumptions correct?
• What is not understood about the people, their relation to the land and the authorities?
• Requires knowledge of local social organization and of ANGAP’s relation to the local people
• Study carried out by Réau and Team, Kalland, and Klein (see Klein et al 2007) –PRA, interviews, documentary research
o Objectives
1. Explore local people’s perception of their environment and their approach to land use and natural resources, especially their use of fire
2. Explore the social and political structure of the local communities
• power relations
• land-use hierarchies (essential to all forms of negotiation between the local people and the conservation authorities)
3. Increase our knowledge base on resource use in RSA and surrounding area
• Used rural interviews to try to document what was going on (told people what they thought they’d want to hear – so didn’t get correct results) - 117What are the major points about Maharidaza?- Maharidaza village – riverine forest along a stream organised into very efficient rice fields. Also other crops and common grazing area
• People are migrants (aspire to grow rice and raise zebus) – because they have come from other areas, they can’t prove they have land tenure
• Land tenure is insecure (unwritten): land is appropriated and developed by demonstrating use
• Society is hierarchical (caste system, governance through tarika chiefs) - the Madagascan society is clearly complicated
o •Hova (richest, zebu breeders) are in conflict with Mainty (political power)
o •People are in general suspicious of central government and outsiders
o •Light use of the forest accommodated (too far, too scary)
• Distant grass fires are set by big zebu owners (and zebu thieves) – many practical uses
o Lots of people in the vilalges saying it is the big zebu owners
o People don’t put out the fires as there is a law to say not to light fires, if putting it out makes you look guilty
• Since the government edict against burning, people are reluctant to put out fires – so more fires do damage, but - 118What are the conclusions about development projects and local communities from the Madagascan case study?• Development actions (giving people the coffee plantations etc) not in tune with local realities
o People can’t even get to market to sell coffee plantations
o Need bridges (to get sick children to clinics), not coffee plantations
• Do not provide for the real needs of the population
• Forestry activities proposed to rice growers are
o i) not of great interest to them;
o ii) not useful in terms of stopping burning, as these people not responsible for the fires
• The traditional organization of the villages (tarikas) was not taken into account
• Planting trees on tanety (infields) fails because planting is perceived as appropriation of common land by the planters
o When they planted the trees, people thought they were trying to steal the common land, so cut them all down
• A nursery established on an individual’s plot is not perceived as something for the community - 119What are the conclusions for conservation perspectives on the Madagascan case study?1. Not huge pressure on the forest in the reserve (but depends on zebu numbers). There is actually little conflict.
2. Thus firebreaks and vigilance may preserve the status quo, and some small restoration work may be possible in the resesrve area, with ANGAP.
3. The ANGAP team in the field has little support or expertise to do development work, whereas they are good at managing the reserve
4. Their interests mainly overlap with the Hova zebu herders, as these are the people who use fire in the uplands near the forest. Carbon credits?
a. There may be corruption with the big owners
• Local people desperately need development support but tying it to forest conservation will not be fruitful.
• The main threat to the reserve is from OUTSIDE the local area.
• Village people not relevant to the forest, more the big Zebu farmers and these coming from the big towns to take trees down with trucks for coal
o Local people don’t want or need to be partners in the forest conservations - 120What are the revised approaches for management?REVISED APPROACHES (Wells and McShane 2004)
1. Broader integration of key stakeholders (beyond the local)
2. Replace off-the-shelf plans with customized approaches
3. Adopt ADAPTIVE MANAGEMENT — monitor, assess, learn, revise
a. Need to learn
4. Respond to the pace of the local communities, not external deadlines
a. Not bullied by governments or NGOs
5. Abandon the win-win “myth” of conservation and development – honestly address winners and losers and look for compromise
6. Consider the large spatial and temporal scales processes affecting biodiversity—ecological processes, evolution. This provides a better context for setting up project and identifying stakeholders. Manage broader landscapes.
7. Help and support community-based organizations
8. Support environmental education - 121What is the case study in the Philippines for management?• http://www.iapad.org/wp- content/uploads/2015/09/tongson-McShane.pdf
• “Securing land tenure lays the foundation where local support for biodiversity conservation can be institutionalized and sustained”.
- One of the smaller islands with forest that may want to be protected
• Little forest protection, rapid forest loss due to migration into uplands
o Population pressures
• Community-based Forest Management (CBFM) replaced government-run logging concessions (corruption, illegal logging, forest degradation, local poverty)
o Got rid of corruptions
• ..greater participation, equity, empowerment, ecological sustainability, cultural integrity and gender equity in the management of the forest resources....
• Indigenous people ca 12M or 18% are socially and economically disadvantaged
o Wanted to help the lives of the indigenous – they have no proof of land ownership and migrants trying to legally make it theres
• Movement to claim ancestral lands (which overlap with high biodiversity areas) - 122What is the case study in the Philippines for management? (2)• Governmental act established National Integrated Protected Areas System—multi-stakeholder, partnership-oriented approach to forest management
• Originally, the government indigenous peoples’ commission viewed people as passive recipients of development aid
o Raised the profile of the local people, made a plan that was good for the local people
• BUT NGOs view the goal to be the recognition and attainment of rights and brought them in as stakeholders
• This project is Mt Guiting-Guiting Natural Park (MGGNP) and the local people Sibuyan Mangyan Tagabukid (SMT)
• A ICDP was developed (Netherlands GVT support)
• Overall goal -- protect the biodiversity of MGGNP through the development of sustainable livelihoods
• Major objective -- improve the tenure security of the indigenous SMT
o Make sure all stakeholders know the indigenous people were there first and have a right to be in the area
• Field: anthropological research and documentation, participatory mapping and planning, capacity building, legal assistance, farm support and joint ventures.
• Developed a management plan - 123What is the case study in the Philippines for management? (3)• ...new found rights have encouraged the Sibuyan Mangyan Tagabukid to become more vigilant over their domain and to regulate access by outsiders. Illegal logging in the forest overlap has been significantly reduced as a result...
o Seen as they felt included, thought they’d help
• Not perfect – there have been violent incidents where powerful outside interests have been thwarted by the new arrangements
• There is not enough money to support the full aims of the National Integrated Protected Areas System
• But this project considered a success and an example to others
o Identified correct local stakeholders
o Improved social status of locals - 124What are the conclusions to partnership conservation?1. Involvement of local communities and stakeholders is essential in conservation planning
2. But often there is a larger range of stakeholders
3. Local involvement will only work if certain conditions are met, in particular Land tenure, people will only invest if they have a real stake and can see advantages
a. People need to see they have a stake in the project to encourage their best practice
4. All biodiversity conservation projects are an uphill battle against other interests
a. HS2 and ancient woodlands
5. DISCUSS Are “fortress” situations [or similar] ever warranted?
a. Or should you always go for the partnership? - 125What is meant by baselines?Baselines (Willis et al 2010, Gillson et al, 2011)
• Baselines (or ‘reference’ conditions) are frequently derived from historical literature or from palaeoecological studies based on biological proxy, fossil or sub-fossil evidence
• Trying to understand what happened in the past to find a baseline which could be useful for conservation - 126What is the importance of understanding baselines?• Recent work within restoration ecology has highlighted that ecological history is important not only to determine the degree of change that has occurred from baseline reference conditions, but also the level of intervention required to restore an ecosystem that has been modified by human impacts to a more naturally functioning state.
• For restoration work, there are queries for the ecological history of places or where to restore/ how far back to go
o An invasive species may have been slowly changing the landscape. A baseline may want to look at how the landscape looked before the invasive specie
• May need to do eradications prior to restorations
- Maximum datasets on biodiversity don’t go all that far back to understand what is happening in the landscape - 127What are 3 important purposes of baselines (Willis et al., 2005)1. Conservation practitioners and policy makers highlight the need to develop ‘biodiversity baselines’ to measure changes in biodiversity over time and the effectiveness or otherwise of conservation strategies.
2. The palaeoecological record can help to distinguish between ‘normal’ ecosystem fluctuations and unprecedented degradation and thereby enable recognition of potential thresholds for concern. Furthermore, understanding how ecosystems responded to past climate change and disturbance can help in predicting how ecosystems might change in response to present-day global warming, and in evaluating the outputs of climate–vegetation models through the reconstruction of known past climate events.
a. What happened thousands of years ago – how far back to go
3. Many ecologists argue that the concept of baselines is problematic, because most ecosystems are spatially and temporally variable!
a. Policy makers don’t particularly like baselines
b. Costs money to find the baseline before restoration is even undertaken - 128What is meant by multiple baselines?Multiple Baselines (Nogué et al, 2017)
• The complexity of managing island ecosystems varies depending on what baseline is used:
1. a functioning and biodiverse ecosystem
2. a particular cultural landscape
3. a pre-human ecosystem when the island was uninhabited
• When you want to restore, you need to understand what the aim is and then understand how to go about meeting the aim - 129What is the example of going from baselines to multiple baselines?(Fernández-Palacios et al, 2016)
*** SEE IMAGE ***
- Not as easy to understand what the baseline should be
- Need to also ask if it’s feasible
o Pre- historic colonisation as the baseline or just before Portuguese colonisation - 130Where in conservation management the concept of baseline is important?1. Design of protected areas (M)
2. Fragmentation (M)
3. Restoration
4. Translocation
5. Rewilding – to what baseline?
*** SEE IMAGE ***
- Putting together potential baselines (pre-human settlement/ industrial revolution etc)
- Put together what impacts there could have been
- Can find the best management option depending on what consequences there were compared to the baseline - 131What information is needed in order to restore to pre-human baselines (that may be good for managerial decisions)?1. Determination of the reference’ conditions baseline
2. Determining the degree of change from reference conditions.
3. Identification of main factors of change (e.g. climate and/or humans)
4. Is it feasible to restore? - 132What is the case study for wildfires in La Gomera, 2012?Example 1: Laurel forest in La Gomera
• Mean annual precipitation 659 mm^3
• Mean annual temperature 13.5 C
• Laguna Grande (1250 m), 2 hectares
• Took a core
• The Laguna was dry
• Asked whether the laural forest had been there for very long
Needed to know where the baseline was, ***SEE IMAGE***
- Laurel forest had been around for 9600 years, even if pollen count is low
- Phoenic carariensis – much lower now compared to 9000 years ago (when it was wetter)
- Change happened much before time when humans were changing the landscape with fire (climate rather than human mediated) - 133What conclusions are made for the La Gomera case study?1. Low frequency of fires for the past 10000 years
2. Fire events suggest a climatic shift as regional fires reached their maximum at 4800 cal.yr BP
3. Local fires increase at 3000 cal. yr BP. Human arrival
- Climate plotted against charcoal (human made fires)
- Vegetation changing in response to climate
- There are two waves of human arrival, but not big changes in the laurel forest
o Ericia now
- The managers wanted to know what to do (very big fire in 2012) - 134What is the case study for Past Climate change in Garajanoy National Park?* A case study of recovering the early Laurel forest baseline composition
HUMID
• Rapid respond to moisture-balance variability
• Laurel forest taxa along with Phoenix canariensis and Salix canariensis
• EXPANSION
DRY
• increase of the Macaronesian heath community together with a gradual loss of laurel taxa may be expected.
• Increasing fire events and the opening of the forest - 135What is meant by “Palaeo results and baselines”?• Despite the presence of people for several thousand years, there was little impact on the Laurel forest.
• No evidences of selective forest clearance, intensive grazing, and plantations.
• The immediate challenge to the management it might not be the approach of climate change, but the environmental pressure by growing population and fire management (+23% since 2000).
• The current management strategy: controlling leisure activities in the park -probably the correct strategy- - 136What is the example of pre-human arrival diversity as a baseline?Example 2: Pre-human arrival diversity (Cañellas-Boltà et al 2014)
• Good for eradication and restoration programmes
• Easter Island, primarily covered by grasslands, but palaeoecological studies have shown the former presence of Dianella.
• Much of its original biota has been removed during the last two millennia, most likely by human activities, and little is known about the native flora!
• Macrofossil and pollen analyses of a sediment core from the Raraku crater lake have revealed the occurrence of a Dianella cf. intermedia/adenanthera (Xanthorrhoeaceae): grew and disappeared at the Raraku site long before human arrival. - 137What is the example of pre-human arrival diversity as a baseline? Easter island- It was hard to taxonomically describe the pollen and seeds found initially (but found in the other islands of the Pacific – easy to show it could have migrated)
• Dianella is currently extinct from the island!
• The occurrence of Dianella within the Raraku sedimentary sequence (between 9.4 and 5.4 cal. kyr B.P.) could have been linked to the existence of favourable paleoenvironmental conditions (peatland rather than the present-day lacustrine environment) during the early to mid Holocene
• Current distribution of Dianella
• Native to Easter Island! - 138What are the conclusions from Easter Island?• This finding contributes new knowledge about indigenous plant diversity on Easter Island and reinforces the usefulness of further macrofossil and pollen analyses to identify native species on Easter Island and elsewhere.
• The risk of applying inappropriate management to what are in fact native species is highlighted by these results. Paleoecology also has wider implications for the classification of invasive species throughout the Pacific Islands.
• It is probable that these six species are native to other regions in the Pacific where they may have been classified as nonnative and also that there may be other presumed invasives that have been incorrectly designated. - 139What other examples are there for setting baselines?• Example 3: Appropriate species classification (native or introduced) was determined using baseline data of species presence on the islands.
• Good for eradication and restoration programmes.
• True natives!
o At least 6 doubtful native plant species in the Galapagos Islands (Van Leeuwen et al, 2009; Coffey et al, 2011)
o Now not targeting the species for eradication - 140What are the conclusions for baselines?• Appropriate fire management, restoration, eradication, and/or monitoring programmes in island ecosystems require:
1. to consider the impacts of multiple human arrivals (and colonization) through time. Multiple baselines.
2. the accurate determination of species’ provenance e.g. is a species native or introduced, and therefore identified for potential eradication or conservation?
3. providing a temporal framework for the examination ecological changes, with a special focus on island biodiversity conservation. - 141How is information used about baselines help in restoration programmes?- Depending on the degree of change and the time, level of intervention could be modest/ intensive or prohibitive
- Orange – could do something about restoration
- If the turnover of species is so large, restoration is not worth it (prohibitive) – the species may not be around anymore/ climate hugely different/ issues of eradicating other species and the huge costs associated - 142What is the case study about what to conserve from baselines?(Wilmshurst et al, 2013)
• Poor Knights islands (Tawhiti Rahi), New Zealand
- Three baselines found (prehumen, Maori and European)
• + aDNA
• Restore to the baseline? - 143How should people restore on Poor Knights island?- Big question about should we restore?
• Fossil pollen showed that
o 1, Complete species turnover
o 2. Extripation of a dominant conifer (Podicarpus) and a palm tree (Rhopalostylis)
o 3. Native but novel angiosperm- dominated forest of Metrosideros
o 4. No modern analogue of the pre-human forest at any northern New Zealand island
• When questioning whether they should restore, found;
o 1. The degree of change is high
o 2. Level of intervention prohibitive
o 3. Restoration programmes prohibited
o 4. Acceptance of novel ecosystems - 144What is the case study for Auckland in island in terms of baselines?- Auckland island
• Olearia lyallii - (subantarctic tree daisy).
• Olearia endemic in NZ, but questioned whether it existed in Auckland island, so took a core
Restore to the baseline?
- The Olearia was only on the island since 1800 – Sealers (those that kill seals), arrived at the same time as the sailors reaching the island
- The humans brought Olearia lyallii
- Considering the species isn’t endemic on the island, it may be best to eradicate the species (it is invasive), but it does have minimal risk to the ecological integrity of the island (from NZ anyway)
- Suggest that as the degree of change is low, level of intervention is modest – so best to monitor/ eradicate?
- Cost involved, so probably just monitor - 145How can changes in climate will affect at many levels (why it is important to understand resilience)?- Biomes are responding to these changes
• Physiological and behavioural response of organisms
• Population growth – if environmental conditions are good
• Community structure
• Biome distribution, extinction, migration – Carolina Tovar lecture
• Productivity and nutrient cycling - - 146What is Scheffer (2001)'s idea of changes in ecosystem compositions (resilience)?M Scheffer et al. (2001), Nature, 413, 591-595.
• “All ecosystems are exposed to gradual changes in climate, nutrient loading, habitat fragmentation or biotic exploitation. Nature is usually assumed to respond to gradual change in a smooth way. However, studies on lakes, coral reefs, oceans, forests and arid lands have shown that smooth change can be interrupted by sudden drastic switches to a contrasting state. Although diverse events can trigger such shifts, recent studies show that a loss of resilience usually paves the way for a switch to an alternative state. This suggests that strategies for sustainable management of such ecosystems should focus on maintaining resilience”
o Tipping points
o No smooth transition in changes (sudden and drastic)
o Loss of resilience tends to lead to a shift
Conservation should focus on resilience - 147What is the resilience framework?***SEE IMAGES***
- Grassland to shrubland could go through a threshold into different ecological states
• ‘Resilience is speed of return to an equilibrium state following a perturbation from that state’ (Nystrom et al. 2000)
• ”Resilience is the capacity of a system to absorb disturbance and still retain its basic function and structure” (Holling, 1973) - 148What is the three uses of the resilience framework?• Biodiversity conservation: aim to create ‘resilient’ species/population /communities
• Ecosystem service: ‘persistence of resilient ecosystem services’
• Restoration ecology: what are the alternative stable states and how quickly can a system switch back to a preferable state?
o Where is the threshold? - 149Where has ecological resilience literature been used before?• Resilience theory well- established in ecological literature
o Needs to be in different protocols/ discussed at different summits
• Shift in theoretical framework from ‘successional model’ to ‘multiple stable states’ model
• Multiple stable states recognised in space and time• ‘By 2050 we will have created resilience in the southern oceans’ WWF-UK 2009
• Very important as one of the first to introduce resilience and gave it a time frame
• Lots of scientific literature and then less than 10 years the scientific resources that show the non-linear shifts and it is being taken up by policy
- Target 15 particularly important
- Scientific documents transitioning to policy
- Now is the time to implement the targets - 150What is target 15?• “By 2020, ecosystem resilience and the contribution of biodiversity to carbon stocks has been enhanced, through conservation and restoration
• “strategies for sustainable management of ecosystems should focus on maintaining resilience” (Scheffer et al., 2001)
o Need strategies to meet the goals
• A major research challenge (where biogeography is helpful!) is to quantify and spatially define ecological resilience on landscapes at scales relevant for policy and planning decisions
o Work of the scientists to put concept of resilience into the frameworks to help management solutions - 151What information is needed in order to manage and create resilient ecosystmes?1. Determination of the alternative stable states of an ecosystem
2. Understanding how close an ecosystem is to an alternative stable state
a. Where is the threshold?
3. Determining the triggers that cause switch to alternative stable state
a. Conservation may then want to try and prevent these triggers (fire/ drought/ increasing nutrients in the ocean)
4. Identification of factors that enhance resilience
a. How can the system be made more resilient?
5. How resilient is a landscape to environmental perturbation? - 152What is the image for the different states an ecosystem can be in?*** SEE IMAGE ***
Folke et al. (2004) Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution & Systematics, 35, 557-581
- Ecosystem in 1 compared to 4 is in a different state
- Triggers are in step 2
- Have to consider how fast the change between states is
- Not only one reason that will shift one state to another one
- Fast state changes in 1977 and 1989
• Determination of the alternative stable states of an ecosystem
• M Scheffer et al. (2001), Nature, 413, 591-595. - 153What is the determination of the alternative stable states of corals?- State A = healthy coral, Stae B = bleached coral
- 1883 to 1994
- instead of being successional and happening slowly, it happened very quickly
• IPCC project rising sea temperatures with global warming Very warm water is associated with coral bleaching (Trigger!)
- Corals a special example as it is also symbiosis between the algae and the corals
• Most severe outbreak associated with 1998 ENSO – a trigger
• Probable cause: physiological disruption of algal symbionts (zooxanthellae) - 154What is the case study for the resilience of corals?How resilient are corals likely to be? (Hughes et al. 2003 Science)
• Used modelling to look at the evolution of the algae and coral together
• If the stress-caused bleaching is not severe, coral have been known to recover.
o Go back to state A
o Not known how long this takes
• If the algae loss is prolonged and the stress continues, coral eventually dies.
- There are some corals where they reach thresholds and change state quickly, others have resilience - 155Are corals more resilient than first thought?Corals more resilient than first thought? (Baker et al 2004)
• Built in resilience?
o epigenetic change – changes to genes induced by environmental stress or other pressure
o symbiont and coral animal evolution
o French Polynesia study shows the resilience varies in corals
o May be changes that occur in the genes – not hereditary, but change due to the environmental conditions
• Initial fears that widespread bleaching will occur rapidly have been reduced somewhat, as corals are proving more resilient to warming in a number of ways. - 156What methods can determine how can how close an ecosystem is to an alternative steady state?Which parts of the landscape are close to a threshold event? (i.e. which parts have lost resilience?)
• Two potential methods:
o 1. Use long-term records to determine trend in variability
i.e. what concentration would cause tipping points
what is the temperature in coral that was close to threshold
o 2. Use present-day spatial patterns in combination with environmental variables to predict landscapes closest to threshold events
- Shows big shift on the bottom left with quick recovery time, on right there is a big shift, but take a long time to get back
• Does the resultant vegetation pattern look any different between a resilient and a non-resilient site? (left and right) - 157Does the resultant vegetation pattern look any different between a resilient and a non-resilient site? (Rietkerk et al., 2004, Science)- Used remote sensing to see if biomass changes in satellite images and whether they are close to threshold
• Self-Organized Patchiness and catastrophic Shifts in Ecosystems
- Looked at different images and their patterns
- Found at fine-scale interactions there is feedback between plant growth and availability of water
• Patterned vegetation and associated patchiness results from spatial self- organisation
• Emerges from fine-scale interactions e.g. positive feedback between plant growth and availability of water
• Proposed the hypothesis that imminent regime shifts in ecosystems can be predicted by self- organised patchiness
- Determining patterns of resilience of semi-arid socio-ecological systems – can we actually see a landscape and see if there is a gradient/ pattern that could suggest in the future the system may shift in the (near) future to a different state - 158How resilient is the landscape to environmental disturbance? (Cole et al, 2014)• Recovery rates of tropical forests to disturbance events
• Faster recovery following larger infrequent events such as cyclones and earthquakes.
o Constant faster recovery if a tropical forest has a cyclone
o Creating gaps
• Slower recovery following small- scale human-induced impacts such as burning!
o The impact is worse
o Whole area has issue - 159How resilient is a landscape to environmental perturbations (Seddon et al, 2016)The state of the world's plants example
- Red less resilient to climate change – can expect shifts in the system - 160What is the summary for baseline resilience?• Ecological resilience and factors contributing to it are highly complex in space and time
• To date, much of the focus has been on describing the processes & mechanisms leading to abrupt ecosystem change
• A major research challenge is to now quantify and spatially define ecological resilience on ecosystems at scales relevant for policy & management
• Need to understand what resilience is, the two types of resilience and remember to show how the examples can be implemented in conservation important for exam
o Corals
o Remote sensing examples
• How maps can show where efforts may want to be made, landscapes that are less resilient to climate change - 161What is conservation biology?• The application of biogeographic principles to the conservation of species and ecosystems (Gillson et al, 2015)
• Revise concept of species, and ecosystems from lecture 3!
• Putting all concepts and applying them to conservation biogeography – application of biogeographic principles to biogeographic species - 162What is meant by human society as a super organism?Malhi, 2017
- Lots of debate whether human society is a super organism – humans all connected (internet/ roads/ politics)
- Dividing how we can put the connections into theory – metabolism of humanity
- Roads/ shipping routes (Amazon not have lots of connections – wanting to put a trans-Panama route in which cuts Amazon into two – fragmentation issues, endemic species in Amazon)
- Sahara a huge barrier - 163What is meant by population growth at a nearly exponential rate?• How humans become a super- organism
• Estimated growth of the human population over the las 10000 years.
• However, because resources limit growth, and many environments are unsuitable, no organisms actually increase indefinitely.
• Every hour, 10000 people join the global populaJon... Impacts?
o Big problems in changing the landscape
o When did all the changes start, what impacts have occurred?
• https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CJdT6QcSbQ0
o First homosapiens 120000 years ago
o Different dispersal routes
70,000 years ago = Pleistocene, cross red sea and across to Papua New Guinea and second route up into China etc.
Many migration routes
As ice age occurs, dispersal occurs
12,000 years ago – agricultural revolution
• Crossing Panama Isthmus - 164What is the evolution and genetic range expansion of some of the key members of the genus homo?- Homo sapiens migrating across whole world
- Evolved from homo erctus – 2.1 million years - 165What is the history (classical theory) of how Homo dispersed across continental landmasses and oceanic archipelagos?- How we as a species managed to get around the whole world
- Landscape changes somewhat (e.g. getting to Paupana New Guinea)
o Pleistocine important for Homo Sapiens (2.5 million years – 11,000 years ago)
The ice age - 166What is the significance of the Pleistocene (2,588,000 - 11,700 years ago) in terms of humans?• In the Pleistocene, earth experienced intensification towards climatic cooling (colloquial “the ice Age!”).
• Culminated with a series of glacial interglacial cycles and major geographic shift`s in habitats across Africa, including mesic grassland, woodland, and savanna ecosystems as well as the more xeric habitats.
• Isotope used as proxy data – climatic oscillations promoting human expansions in the earth- Show desert was more mesic
- More species at this time - 167What are the theories to dispersal and range expansion of the homo?• Consensus: Africa homeland of Homo erectus and H. sapiens
• 3 potential dispersal routes (two North, 1 South): Geology- African and Arabian plates collided with the Eurasian plat. 35 million years earlier the first fossil of H. erectus appeared in the fossil record:
o 1. North-western passage across Gates of Hercules (Strait of Gibraltar) – crossing Sahara and then into Iberian peninsula.
o 2. North-eastern along the Nile Valley and across the Sinai into the Arabian Peninsula.
o 3. South-eastern across the Gates of Grief (Red Sea).
• Geographic range expansion of Homo sapiens sapiens from the species’ African homeland to its eventual global distributions was strongly influenced by contemporary landscapes, seascapes, and climate (millions of years)
• Very influenced by the climatic upheavals that marked the 2-million-year record of the Pleistocene – most favourable moment to human expansion
• (Disparities in the arguments for human dispersal, but all agree Africa the homeland) – Anthropological/ geological studies - 168What are the barriers to dispersal of homo?1. North-western passage across Gates of Hercules (Strait of Gibraltar)
a. Sahara was an expansive desert (was expanding) that prevented early humans from reaching the north-western passage.
2. North-eastern along the Nile Valley and across the Sinai into the Arabian Peninsula.
a. 120000 years ago H sapiens-glacial cycle caused widespread acidification of the Arabian Peninsula and extinctions of earliest humans. Failed! – because of climate/ ecological factors and died
3. South-eastern across the Gates of Grief (Red Sea).
a. Archaeological and genetic analyses suggest current H. sapiens used this route when glacial conditions lowered sea levels by approximately 100m! Reaching the Arabian Peninsula 90000 years ago.
- Need to analyse genetics in humans with the bones found (3rd hypothesis explain the genetics humans have now – glacial conditions lowered sea level enough that early humans went across the red sea
• JUMP DISPERSAL+ RANGE EXPANSION- settle and expnd through generations- through diffusion (revise lecture!). – go through the barrier - 169What are the types of dispersal?1. Jump dispersal (or long-distant dispersal): dispersal that is accomplished by movement of individuals within relatively short period. (Birds in USA – mediated by humans initially)
2. Diffusion: a form of range expansion that is accomplished over generations by individuals spreading out from the margins of the species range. (Homo sapiens out of Africa)
a. Much slower than jump dispersal! But often follows jump dispersal. - 170What is the significance of sea level change for homo?• The lowering of sea levels during glacial maxima of the Pleistocene caused the exposure of continental shelves and the forma
- 171What are the prehistoric impacts for homo and their dispersal?(Daansgaard 1984/Avery 2009)
- 0.01% of time humans have been around
- Humans colonising all the globe – adapting to different ecosystems
- Sea levels risigna and glaciers melting – start of agrciulture
- Evidence from end of glacial – temperature much lower
- Towards the present, many changes, including the recent Holocene climatic optimum (warming and increase temps), roman climatic optimum – warming just in Europe and the Medieval warm period
- Paintings showing more glaciated times in Europe – cultural help
- Impacts in the ecosystem - 172What are the origins of agriculture?(Diamond 2002, Nature)
- Regions of agriculture – the origins and where now are the most productive areas for agricultures
- Mesoamerica
- Arabia, sahel, Ethiopia, China
o Shift from ancient times to now (7000 years ago, lots of agriculture in Paupa new Guinea)
Phytolids – mineral in cells in plants, when plants die, they are fossilised
o In Thailand = pre-historic measurements
Targeted agricultural activities
- Changing now – yellow area - 173How old is the rainforest?(Willis & Birks, 2004)
- Can see the impacts in landscape and the forests
- A classic paper of what we think is pristine (e.g. Amazon) found landscape impacted 1150 years ago
- Agriculture the main impact
(FOUND: 1. New Georgia 'Virgin' rainforest is 150 years old/ 2. Papua New Guinea agriculture from 7000 years ago/ 3. Gabon had iron-working furnaces from 961 BC/ 'terra preta' soils in Central Aamzonia from 3500 years ago) - 174What is the example of pristine rainforest?(Bayliss-Smith et al, 2003)• New Georgia, Solomon Islands
• “pristine” rainforest is 1150 years old and is enriched in ‘useful’ tree species
o When researchers looked at tree rings, more young than thought
o Useful trees are those that promote ecosystem services
• Found charcoal
• Invasive species in the area
• Colonisation at the time - 175What is the example species turnover affects from homo?(Wilmshurst et al, 2013)
• Poor Knights islands (TawhiJ Rahi), New Zealand
• + aDNA
- When humans arrive, we produce species turnover – where to put the baseline? – fire starts and then change in species and introduced others – managing land and chanfin composition of species (turnover) - 176What is the example of palaeofires in the Congo from homo?(Tovar et al., 2015)
- Why in the landscape there is fragments of particular types of forest and a little further down there is a compeletely different patch of forest
o Fires in one 200 years ago, other throuseands of years ago
o Management impacts of the forest – ecen in very remore places the human impacts are seen
1. Open canopy and a very dense understory of giant herbs
2. Monospecific forest dominated by Gilbertodendron
a. Fires occurring in past 200 years
3. Most diverse & widespread forest - 177What is the case study of the first human contact to the Canary Islands?(Parsons 1981)
- Not just isolated islands/ tropics etc.
- In Canaries – two waves of migrations 1300AD and Guances 3000 – 2000 years ago - 178What is the case study for La Laguna and homo?- Ancient map of La Laguna (Torriani, 1588)
- Lots of houses, but la laguna a lake
- Cored gardens and collected cores ½ m, from present to ancient
- Found when aborignals arrived 2500 years ago, biodiversity shifted
- Final output found species were extinct
• L. Torriani in 1588
Tree extinctions! (de Nascimento et al,2009)
- Two currently extinct species not now here
o Pollen grains just dispersed? – but amount of pollen grains allow assumption of population of trees were in the area
o If we put in a baseline – would it be good to restore the species (from N.Africa/ Europe etc.)?
We don’t even know what type of oak they were – local or distant anyway?
Species not there?
o Bones and archielogical remains of extinct species all around in the area - 179What is the effect of homo on fauna and vegetation extinctions - archaeological evidence?(Meco, 1992; Machado, 1996; Rando & Perera, 1994)
- When humans arrive, they change the landscape and cause many outcomes – one of which can be making fauna extinct
o 2 islands – when rat arrived to Fuerterventura it completely out competed the local fauna (rat) and caused its disspaearnce to the fauna
o Found using the bones
• Fuerteventura
o Small mouse, (Malpaisomys insularis) replaced by Mus musculus introduced by the
pre-Hispanics
o Seal, (Monachus monachus) - now no population in the island
• Lanzarote
o Small mouse, (Malpaisomys insularis) – now extinct
o Sea bird (Puffinus olsoni) - dissappeard
- Trace back extinctions directly linked to expansion of homospaien ranges
- Extinct species - 180What is the effect of homo on islands?• Development of advanced techniques
• Navigational skills!
• Range expansion of early humans across Oceania were unpredictable and dependent of winds. – suggested it is difficult to understand patterns of colonisation of the islands
• Still debate on the time of colonization of the Pacific Islands (Wilmshurst et al. 2010).
• Hawai’i 1400 years ago.- humans arriving all around the world
• Now theories on human metabolism – quantifying the amount of human metabolism and a new idea
• Not just continental colonisation from humans
• Lots of investment to understand colonisation events in Pacific - 181What is speciation?• The process in which two or more contemporaneous species evolve from a single ancestral population
(SEE IMAGE)
- Tree of life
- Some can lose the whole branch (lose whole families) - 182What are the causes that underline modern extinctions?Main causes of modern extinction
1. Habitat loss and fragmentation - (lecture on fragmentation)
2. Invasive species (lecture on invasive species)
3. Overharvesting/overhunting
a. Long history of humans and extinctions
4. Climate change (highly controversial) - 183How many species are there according to the United Nations Environmental Programme (UNEP)?• Eight million seven hundred thousand (give or take 1.3 million)
- Lots of insects, fungi etc
SEE IMAGE - 184Where I can find information on risk of extinction?• 17291 species out of the 47677 assessed species are threatened with extinction.
- IUCN puts order in extinctions, species
o Helps managers understand species are under threat/ at risk to extinction
o Use the scientific name of the species in the website and it will give full species taxa, their category for extinctions and any subspecies
Proportion of species, by Red List Category, in comprehensively assessed groups on The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species
- Split world into different regions (Africa/ Asia etc.) and shows percentages of threatened species
o Majority are not concerned (least concerned) and are shown in green
- Green bar shrinking on graph C – percentage of endemic species. Found 23% in Africa are threatened, in Americas 26%, Europe/ Central Asia 28%
- When showing this to managers may take the idea they are not doing so badly, but if fragmentation etc. occurs it is may be that they become more endangered etc.
- Shows Caribbean species may need policies in place to protect them - 185What is extinction?1. Extinctions occur when the last individual of a species dies out.
2. Functional Extinctions occur when individuals remain, but the odds of sustainable reproduction are low.
a. i.e. the species is effectively extinct even though individuals remain
b. (If species are just in zoos, there may be no way of co-ordinating regrowth)
c. High isolated areas, high levels of genetic drifts
3. (CAN ONLY HAPPEN AT SPECIES LEVEL AND QUITE RARE) Mass extinction: episode of relatively abrupt (few millions of years – geological time) replacement of virtually entire biotas. Exact causes still debated! But... drastic environmental changes. - 186What is meant by being 'possibly extinct'?- Idea of being possibly extinct – cant actually count their populations (may need a period of 20 years to class it as extinct), however we do know there is still good environment for them, so may still be around
o Some have been found 30 years later right at the other end of their ranges etc.
- 5 mass extinctions and a 6th one thought to be coming by the end of this centaury
- Tonnes of extinction in islands (small populations, invasive species competing in niche, humans) – also apply theory of island biogeography - 187What are the examples for recent extinctions and overhunting?• Bias towards insular biotas
• Causes
o Isolation and “naive” biota
Naïve- friendly animals on islands that hadn’t seen humans, but didn’t fear them and were effectively sitting targets
o Humans
Habitat loss, population decline
Introduction of exotic species
Over hunting
- Mauritius had big Tortoises (took long time to reproduce), but taken as pets and not allowed to breed properly
- Bird taken for the royal family, took yellow feathers from the tiny birds to make clothes (80,000 birds per piece of clothing). In Hawaii 80,000 birds would have been enough to start wiping out whole populations - 188What is meant by the long history of humans and extinctions?• Insular extinction typically follow initial human colonization, new extinctions follow each new human colonization:
o Polynesian colonization of Hawaii
o Maori colonization of New Zealand
o European arrivals in the Mascarene
o Extinct trees in Macaronesia
2 extinct trees in Teneriefe
Plants difficult to test whether it was climate or humans
• In different cultures, cliamtes, areas all extinct through humans
• Flightless birds prime targets (especially in islands)
o Dodo and Moa
Moa tested and agreed it was human impacts (not climate) - 189What is the Great Auk?Great Auk – Pinguinus impennis
• Large flightless bird, extinct in mid-19th century (1835)
• Not a penguin
• Large flightless bird – easy species threatened by extinction
• Had had good niche – no big predators, easy food, ocean etc.
• Small populations in the islands, but a volcano or big explosion collapsed the islands and only a few survived of a small island – Eldey.
o At this point only 80 individuals
o People started taking individuals for museum collections etc.
o Last eggs sold and then the species lost
• Considered extinct as hasn’t been seen for 30+ years
• Island characteristics – threatened through this and also had very small populations - 190What is the Thylacine - Tasmanian Tiger?• Extinct since 1933 (Union for conservation of Nature)
• Carnivorous marsupial of modern times.
• Native to continental Australia, Tasmania and New Guinea,
• Last extant member of its family, Thylacinidae.
• Top individual the last member of the family (not just the species…!) - 191What is meant by the effect of invasive species on extinctions?- Percentage of introduced (non-native) sp. of plants among geographical regions
o Bermuda 65%
o Turkey 5%
• Anthropogenic introductions of exotic species (intentional or accidental)
• Transform all types of ecosystems
- High mountains easier to be invaded (and islands) - 192Why are Invasive Species problematic?• Alteration of habitat.
• Change in the diversity, abundance, and distribution of members of the pre-existing natural communities.
• Competition with native species.
• Broad and cascading effects throughout communities and ecosystems.
• Extinction
- Harmonia axyridis (Harlequin ladybird)
- https://www.cbd.int/idb/2009/about/ examples/ - 193What happened in Lake Victoria and invasive species and extinction?(Goldschmidt et al, 1993)
• Lake Victoria: introduction of Nile perch (Lates niloticus) in 1950s appears to have been primary cause of the extinction of 200 endemic cichlids! - 194What is meant by climate change affecting extinctions?3) Climate change?
- Very difficult to decide whether species have gone extinct through humans or climate
Melomys rubicola
A small rodent that lived only on a single island (Bramble Cay) off Australia is likely the world's first mammal to be a casualty of climate change.
Sea level rise!
May still see it again?
Climate change?
• The golden toad has not been seen since 1989.
• According to IUCN is believed to be extinct.
• Climate change?
• Was abundant in a small, high-altitude region about 4km2 in Costa Rica.
• Endemic to elfin cloud forest.
• From Costa Rica - 195What are mass extinctions?• Occurs in different habitats, we know they have gone extinct
o Find fossils to know they were once around
• Five major mass extinctions in the history of the planet (some may say more/ less)
• Changes in biota due to abrupt change
• Separations of plates give earthquakes/ volcanic eruptions/ chemical changes in air composition- Need to know what happened in the mass extinctions
o Processes not dates
- Bar on the left the different composition of the continents (changes through time Inc. Pangea etc.) - 196What are the 5 mass extinctions?1. Ordovician- Silurian (439 My)
2. Late Devonian (367 My)
3. Permian- Triassic (245 My)
4. End Triassic (208 My)
5. Cretaceous -Tertiary (65 My
• Ordovician – 50% of animal families, including many trilobites
o When looking at species from fossils
o May not be all families found (hard parts only preserved)
• Permian – 60% of animal families, including many marine species, insects, amphibians, and all remaining trilobites
• Cretaceous – 50% of animal families, including the last of the dinosaurs and many marine species - 197How have mass extinctions been found?- Scientists collected fossils from museums from marine environments – found there was lots of fossils from some time scales then not seen again
- Build ups and collapses
- Created data sets and found extinctions
- Look at number of families - 198What is the Great Oxygenation event?• 2.3 billion years ago
1. Biologically induced appearance of O2
2. The increased production of oxygen set Earth's original atmosphere off balance.
3. Free oxygen is toxic for the organisms...
4. Extinction event
- Cynobacteria evolve to multi cellular forms
- Lots of microorganisms killed off from this period
- Produced more oxygen – some families allowed to thrive and expand
- Huge increase of oxygen produces a huge extinction but of very primitive flora and fauna - 199What are thought of as the causes of mass extinctions? (SEE IMAGE)E.g. for End Cretaceous/Tertiary: causes
• Asteroid: Chicxulub crater (180 km diameter and 20 km in depth)
o Now trying to core to the centre of the impact (to see when the impact occurred and look at the geochemical composition)
• Asteroid strike (Cretaceous/Tertiary):
• Acid rain, fires, climate cooling due to dust and smoke, earthquakes, and volcanic eruptions.
o Lots of changes to the atmosphere - 200What is meant by the conservation action of rewinding?
Informationen
- Beschreibung
- Karteikarten am Biogeography 2, erstellt von Pippa Holman am 18/04/2018.
- Erstellt von
- Pippa Holman
- Aufrufe
- 3
- Bewertung