Zusammenfassung der Ressource
Yun Sung Bum's Argument
- FIRST STEP
- Moral for religious
- Ancestor Rites are not Confucian
- Independent Moral Significnance
- Ancestor rites aren't Shamanic
- Service for spirits versus service for ancestors
- Idol Identity
- Anything can be an idol
- SECOND STEP
- Misunderstanding was the cause of persecution
- Non-religious Civility
- A relation between two individuals
- Between parents and children
- Recognize the kindness parents showed
- THIRD STEP
- Not religious, but civil
- Tablets not idols
- Religious Opinions on Shinto
- Catholic Koreans
- Followed Vatican
- "So long as Shinto isn't religious."
- Protestant Koreans
- Presbyterians strongly disagreed
- Methodists weakly disagreed
- FOURTH STEP
- Different Reactions come from differences in interpretation
- Appeal to St. Paul
- Those boasting superior knowledge are wrong
- Making an idol out of knowledge
- We know there is only one god, therefore idol worship impossible
- FIFTH STEP
- When the question of memorial rituals or Shinto shrine worship is viewed from the standpoint of St.
Paul, it certainly does not have any religious contents