Zusammenfassung der Ressource
Material & Cultural Deprivation
- Cultural
- Keddie ('73)
- Cultural deprivation is a 'myth'.
- Blames the
victim - Culturally
different, not
deprived - The
school system
fails in
recognising &
nurturing W/C
values
- Troyna & Williams ('86)
- Teachers have a 'speech hierarchy'
- MIDDLE CLASS SPEECH
- WORKING CLASS SPEECH
- BLACK SPEECH
- W/C parents fail to socialise
their children to an adequate
standard and that makes
them 'culturally deprived'.
- Bereiter &
Englemann ('66):
W/C use
gestures, single
word answers &
disjointed
phrases in
speech -
underdeveloped
skills
- THE RESTRICTED CODE
- W/C people with limited
vocabulary.
Grammatically simple.
Descriptive not analytic.
Context bound.
- W/C feel excluded from a young age because they might speak
differently - accents e.g. Posh London, common Essex.
- THE ELABORATED CODE
- M/C people with a
wider vocabulary.
Grammatically
more complex.
Analytic
descriptions. Not
context bound.
- Used by teachers/exams/books
- Statistical correlation:
is cannot prove that
deprivation is THE
cause for
underachievement.
Other factors such as
lifestyle must be
considered.
- 87% of children who
do not recieve FSM are
all lumped together,
even though they
range from super-rich
to people just above
the poverty line
- Material
- Poverty & lack of material necessities is a better
explanation of why lower social classes underachieve
and not values, attitudes and culture.
- In 2006 33% of children recieving FSM gained 5 or
more A*-C grades. 61% of non-FSM pupils
achieved the same.
- OVERCROWDING
- TEMPORARY
ACCOMODATION
- HEALTH
- Emotional & behavioural problems occur more
in materially deprived students
- ADHD Levels are higher in lower classes
- Howard ('01): Poor food &
lack of vitamins
= Poor immune
system
- Enter text here
- SAFE AREAS TO PLAY
- THESE ALL AFFECT EDUCATION
- WORKING CLASS
- FATALISM:everything
happens for a
reason.
- IMMEDIATE GRATIFICATION:
being rewarded immediately, not
thinking of the long term outcome.
- COLLECTIVISM:
giving appreciation
to a group not just
an indiividual
- 20% of those
eligible for FSM
don't use their
entitlement
because they feel
they'll get bullied
or be forced into
certain social
groups
- OPERATION HEAD START 1960's
- US Citizens could get: Parenting Classes,
Nursery Classes, entitlement to Health Visitors
and the role out of Sesame Street
- UK ROLES OUT SURE START IN 2000