Gestalte GoConqr mit. Was sollen wir als Nächstes hinzufügen?

Notizen

International Research Ethics

Eleanor Farenden Global Health Englisch 1 Seite

Inhalt der Notizen (1)

Seite 1

Biomedical Research

Uses systematic

scientific methods to develop new preventative, diagnostic, therapeutic and

palliative interventions

It has important

social value

Precondition for safe and

effective treatments

Precondition for medical

progress

Research interventions

expose study participants to risks primarily to generate generalisable

knowledge

Ethical conflict

between promoting valuable research, and protecting participants' rights and

interests

Ethical Principles and How to Apply Them

General ethical

principles

Respect for persons -->

informed consent or surrogate consent

Capacity to make decisions

Disclosure of relevant

information

Understanding of relevant

information

Voluntariness of agreement

Agreement given

Beneficence and non-maleficence

--> risk-benefit evaluation

Ensure minimum social value

Minimise risks to participants

Ensure reasonable relation of

risks and potential individual benefits/social value

Limit risks when participants

cannot or do not consent: minimal risk threshold for 'non-beneficial'

research procedures

Justice --> fair selection

of participants

Enrol participants (or not)

for scientific reasons, not convenience

Include vulnerable groups with

appropriate 'special protections', such as:

Risk limits

Group benefit

Surrogate consent or consent

advocate

Community consultation

What Makes Research Ethical?

At least (in

chronological order):

Socially valuable research

question

Scientific validity

Fair subject selection

Acceptable risk-benefit ratio

Informed consent

Annual research and

development expenditures

$268.4 billion in North

America/Europe/Asia-Oceania (45% in US)

Largest growth in spending in

Asia-Oceania

37% public, 63% private

Research in LMICs

Many sponsors

Public: external/internal,

governments/international organisations

Private: external/internal,

NGOs/industry

Many goals

Understand or improve local

health problems

Build research capacity &

infrastructure

'Outsourcing' of research

Culture and power

Cultural differences: different

habits, beliefs or systems of value

Differences are dynamic and

often unexamined

All cultures are heterogeneous

Power differentials: asymmetry

in the ability to 'impose one's will on others' due to social, economic or

political factors

Background injustices

Individuals have a right to

basic infrastructure (e.g. health care, sanitation), but in many LMICs

this right is not fully realised

Due to these background

injustices, there are many unmet needs in LMICs, both on the individual

and population

It is often unclear or

controversial what the general ethical principles for research imply when

studies are conducted in LMICs (especially when they are conducted by external

researchers)

Area of ongoing debate

in research ethics

Respect for Autonomy

Who should make

decisions?

Different conceptions of

autonomy - spousal consent, community consent

When are decisions

voluntary?

Power differentials, unmet

needs

Example: community

consent

Must individual informed

consent always be obtained? (Yes)

Should community consent be

obtained where it is the cultural norm?

Communities can limit options

for individuals

Community decisions can unduly

influence individual decision making

If so, who speaks for the

community?

Beneficence and Non-Maleficence

What is the

appropriate standard of care in clinical trials?

E.g. what's locally available

or medically best

Should sponsors and

investigators provide ancillary care for conditions that are not the focus of

the research?

What are participants

owed when the research is over (post-trial benefits)

Example: ancillary

care

What grounds the obligation to

provide ancillary care?

Therapeutic obligations of

clinician-investigators

Duties of non-maleficence of

investigators

Natural duties of all persons

(e.g. duty to rescue)

Entitlements as a matter of

justice

What are the limits to this

obligation?

Fair Participant Selection

Must the research be

responsive to local health needs (responsiveness requirement)?

Should the benefits of

the research (e.g. new intervention) be made available to the community

(reasonable available requirement)?

If so, who is the

community?

Example: reasonable

availability

What grounds the obligation to

make new interventions available?

Duties of non-exploitation

Duties of reciprocity

Entitlements as a matter of

justice

What are the limits to this

obligation?

Informationen

Beschreibung
Global Health (International Research Ethics) Notiz am International Research Ethics, erstellt von Eleanor Farenden am 15/03/2017.
Erstellt von
Eleanor Farenden
Aufrufe
1
Bewertung

Feedback

Worum geht es?

Was sollen wir als Nächstes hinzufügen?