CA Strengths and Weaknesses

Alice Buchanan
Mind Map by Alice Buchanan, updated more than 1 year ago
Alice Buchanan
Created by Alice Buchanan over 6 years ago
28
1

Description

Strengths and Weaknesses of the Cosmological Argument

Resource summary

CA Strengths and Weaknesses
  1. STRENGTHS
    1. Richard Swinburne: God may just be the simplest explanation.
      1. An a posteriori: based on evidence.
        1. The Big Bang Theory shows that there is a start.
          1. Scientists cannot show what caused the big bang so it could be God.
          2. WEAKNESSES
            1. David Hume and Bertrand Russell.
              1. Aquinas contradicts himself.
                1. Why does the prime mover have to be God?
                  1. Principle of Entropy: everything will eventually collapse and decay.
                  2. David Hume
                    1. Argument begins with a familiar concept but moves on to something that we cannot understand.
                      1. All particle matter can be destroyed and anything can be altered
                        1. Inconsistent not extend this to a deity
                        2. Why should it be the God of classical theism? Even if we do believe in a necessary being it does not have to have the characteristics of the classically theistic God.
                        3. Bertrand Russell
                          1. "Every man who exists has a Mother, and it seems to me that your argument is that, therefore the human race must have a Mother, but obviously the human race hasn't a Mother - that's a different logical sphere.
                            1. Russell Claims that not everything needs an explanation - 'the universe is a brute fcct'
                              1. He does not dismiss completely the quest for an explanation.
                              Show full summary Hide full summary

                              Similar

                              Breakdown of Philosophy
                              rlshindmarsh
                              Reason and Experience Plans
                              rlshindmarsh
                              Who did what now?...Ancient Greek edition
                              Chris Clark
                              The Cosmological Argument
                              Summer Pearce
                              AS Philosophy Exam Questions
                              Summer Pearce
                              Philosophy of Art
                              mccurryby
                              "The knower's perspective is essential in the pursuit of knowledge." To what extent do you agree?
                              nataliaapedraza
                              Religious Experience
                              alexandramchugh9
                              The Ontological Argument
                              daniella0128
                              Chapter 6: Freedom vs. Determinism Practice Quiz
                              Kristen Gardner
                              Environmental Ethics
                              Jason Edwards-Suarez