Miracles

Description

OCR A2 Philosophy notes on Miracles
pkayy11
Note by pkayy11, updated more than 1 year ago
pkayy11
Created by pkayy11 over 10 years ago
132
5

Resource summary

Page 1

Miraculous events - reported as long as humans have lived in communities- Jesus pictured as healing people and calming storms- Moses turns his rod into a snake and summons plagues of locustsMore modern times..- Statues of Nandi in a Hindu mandir (temple) drinking milk (1995)- People being cured of Aids in Zimbabwe (Oratorian priest)- Virgin Mary appearing at Lourdes

For religious believers - occurrence of miracles (i.e. Bible) is an example of God acting within the world and being involved in the world- Joshua 10:1-15 - God holds back the sun in order to help Joshua's army in battle- Exodus 13 - God sends a wind to drive back the Red Sea to make dry land; Moses leads the Hebrews across the sea bed to safety.- When the pursuing troops of Pharaoh cross the ocean floor, God returns the waters of the Red Sea to the sea bed and the soldiers of Pharaoh are destroyed

Bible - pictures God as involved and active in the worldPhilosophers - biblical image of God shows God as omnipotent and immanent- Immanent - God is active and closely involved in the physical universe

Traditional definitions of miracles: An event caused by God - traditionally supported by Christians (Thomas Aquinas) A violation of the laws of nature - commonly associated with David Hume

TWO PRELIMINARY DEFINITIONS OF MIRACLES

Thomas Aquinas' definition of a miracle'that which has a divine cause, not that whose cause a human person fails to understand' (Thomas Aquinas, Summa Contra Gentiles)Highlights fundamental point for religious believers - miracles are events caused by God - Reflected in the meaning of the word 'miracle' - comes from the Latin word 'miraculum' (object of wonder)- Jesus curing the paralytic (Mark 2:1-12) - no interest to religious believer how Jesus cured the man; point is that God caused the man to be cured and it is an event to be wondered atAquinas' idea of miracle comes from Aristotle - Aquinas and Aristotle both believed that everything which exists has a nature - what the thing is able to do- Example: Part of the nature of human beings that makes them different from animals is that they can thinkabout the future and the meaning of life and death- 'Divine cause' - the event in question is not a normal part of the nature of thingsMany Christians today would also add that miracles also reveal something about God to people

David Hume's definition of a miracle'violation of the laws of nature' (David Hume, Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding) Hume - miracle, such as Jesus curing the paralytic, is an example of an event which suggests that something happened which broke the laws of nature - Uses the laws of nature to show how the universe works - Example: If we throw this textbook off the desk you know it will fall to the floor due to gravity

The Bible and God's activity

Bible - paints a picture of God being closely involved with creation and acting in it - Seen in the story of Joshua's defeat of the 5 kings (Joshua 10)

Number of important points to note in this story: Victory over the king's is God's, not Joshua's - Joshua is the player who does the acting; God is the director and producer with the real power and control

God is described as throwing the enemy into confusion - idea of God's presence bringing confusion is found in other parts of the Jewish Scriptures as well (Exodus 14:24, 23:27; Judges 4:15)- Emphasises the involvement of God in victory

God's divine control is illustrated by referring to God's power over nature - (Joshua 10) God is described as throwing hailstones or stones from on high- For the people living in the times of the Jewish Scriptures - no such thing as 'nature'; natural world is unpredictable and at times it displays amazing powers- Example: Today we would explain lightning in terms of weather patterns and the laws of physics- Jewish Scriptures come from a pre-scientific world in which the natural world is seen as chaotic at times- God's power and involvement in the world are clear - God's will operates through the events in the world- Completely different from the modern ideas about the world and nature being governed by scientific laws

New Page

Show full summary Hide full summary

Similar

Breakdown of Philosophy
rlshindmarsh
Who did what now?...Ancient Greek edition
Chris Clark
Reason and Experience Plans
rlshindmarsh
The Cosmological Argument
Summer Pearce
AS Philosophy Exam Questions
Summer Pearce
Philosophy of Art
mccurryby
"The knower's perspective is essential in the pursuit of knowledge." To what extent do you agree?
nataliaapedraza
The Ontological Argument
daniella0128
Religious Experience
alexandramchugh9
Chapter 6: Freedom vs. Determinism Practice Quiz
Kristen Gardner
Environmental Ethics
Jason Edwards-Suarez