Flashcards
Week 3 LNS (typed)
Flashcards do conjunto (31)
- 1What model produces the R^-6 occurrence varying with binding energy What happens if a repulsive interaction is inserted and what can be obtained from this?model of two
coupled linear quantum harmonic oscillators at a distance R
The Lennard Jones potential is obtained which can be used to determine the most stable
crystal structures of van der Waals crystals, their cohesive energy and equilibrium
interatomic distances - 2State a general importance of Van der waals binding (materials)Van der Waals forces are not only important in certain types of weakly bound
crystals, such as the noble-gas crystals, but also in soft matter in the form of colloidal suspensions and liquid crystals. They can even be observed in macroscopic
systems such as (clean) gecko feet sticking to a glass pane. - 3Define the van der waals interaction and how it leads to a positive interaction from fluctuating dipoles. What type of treatment is needed?In Physics of Matter, the van der Waals interaction was introduced as originating
from charge fluctuations in the electron distribution of an atom, corresponding to a dipole moment, which then induce another fluctuating dipole moment in
a nearby atom. The interaction between these fluctuating dipoles creates the
attraction.
We will now treat the idea of fluctuating dipoles quantum-mechanically and
show that this does indeed lead to an attractive interaction. A classical treatment
would not yield an attractive interaction! A more rigorous quantum-mechanical
treatment would start from the atomic electronic states (rather than fluctuating
dipoles) and obtain the van der Waals interaction via 2nd-order perturbation
theory, which is beyond the scope of this course - 4For the 1D dipole model, describe the case for an unperturbed system, mention; nuclei interaction between oscillators Hamiltonian natural angular frequencies zero point energyWe start with two independent, one-dimensional harmonic oscillators. The positive charges (“nuclei”, charge +𝑒) are separated by a fixed distance 𝑅. The case
of independent oscillators corresponds to 𝑅 → ∞. 𝑥1,2 and 𝑝1,2 are the position
and momentum operators of the two oscillating electrons. They have both the same natural (angular) frequency 𝜔0, given by the force constant 𝐶 and mass 𝑚 of
each negative charge. The energy of this system is given by twice the zero point
energy (ZPE). - 5For the 1D dipole model, describe the case for a perturbed system where coupling between two oscillators exist via Coulombd interaction; Mention... units, operator H1, |x1| < < R,we write the Coulomb interaction in cgs or atomic units. In standard SI
units, 𝑒
2 needs to be replaced with 𝑒
2/4𝜋𝜖0, where 𝜖0 is the vacuum permittivity.
The interaction operator 1 comprises four terms for the Coulomb interactions
between the four charges, where one charge is on the left oscillator and the other
charge on the right. In a realistic system of atoms in a gas or solid, |𝑥1|, |𝑥2| ≪ 𝑅.
Rather than dealing with all four contributions and the difficulties arising from
the four different denominators, we combine all terms into a single fraction
and identify the leading term.
The Hamiltonion with the approximate form for 1 now needs to be diagonalised,
which can be achieved with a coordinate or normal mode transformation. These
normal modes 𝑥𝑠 and 𝑥𝑎 correspond to symmetric and antisymmetric modes,
respectively. We express the original coordinates 𝑥1,2 in terms of the new coordinates 𝑥𝑠,𝑎, and the momenta transform correspondingly. We can then rewrite the
approximate form of H = H0 + H1 in the new coordinates. - 6For the 1D dipole model, describe the case for a perturbed system where coupling between two oscillators exist via Coulombd interaction, describe the resulting Hamiltonian and state the zero point energy for the system...The resulting Hamiltonion has the structure of two independent harmonic oscillators, as in 0, but with the new coordinates and with renormalised natural
frequencies. We express now the two natural frequencies 𝜔𝑎,𝑠 of the coupled oscillators in terms of the natural frequency 𝜔0 of the initial, uncoupled oscillators
and a coupling term and simplify the solution further by expanding the square
root.
This gives us the zero point energy 𝐸
′
0 of the coupled system and the change Δ𝑈
in zero point energy due to the coupling between the two oscillators. - 7For the 1D dipole model, describe the case for a perturbed system where coupling between two oscillators exist via Coulombd interaction, describe the reduction in zero point energyIt is clear
that Δ𝑈 must be negative; the ground state energy is lowered by the coupling
between the oscillators and the energy gain increases with decreasing separation
as 𝑅^−6. This is the attractive van der Waals interaction - 8Explain the meaning of a strong repulsion by mentioning; He ground state and shellsConsider the energies of the ground state and first excited state of helium. As
far as the electronic system is concerned, they can be treated as originating from
overlapping two hydrogen wave functions. Overlapping a spin-up 1𝑠 and a spindown 1𝑠 state gives the He 1𝑠
2 ground state. If one tries to overlap two spin-up 1𝑠
states, one electron needs to be promoted to the spin-up 2𝑠 state, corresponding
to the first excited state of He. The energy in the excited state is about 20 eV
higher than in the ground state. Apart from hydrogen, all atoms have a filled 1𝑠
2
shell, and possibly other filled shells as well. Overlapping these filled shells leads
to a strong repulsion, much stronger than the Coulomb repulsion between the nuclei
(at least at realistic distances and under realistic conditions for a solid). - 9How does the PEP prevent a complete overlap of electron clouds of two atoms?by increasing the energy of the system more and more rapidly
(“exponentially” in the non-mathematical sense) as the two atoms are brought
closer together. - 10Explain what the Lennard Jones potential combines, its parameters and what is required for a crystalThe Lennard-Jones potential combines the attractive van der Waals potential with
a repulsive term of the 𝑅
−12 type. 𝜖 and 𝜎 are parameters of the energy and length
scale, respectively. The equilibrium distance 𝑟0 in a diatomic molecule is obtained
as the distance that minimises the potential energy.
In a crystal, we will need to add up the energy contributions from all atom
pairs in the crystal. This will lead to a deeper minimum in the potential and a
slightly different equilibrium separation between the nearest neighbours. - 11The following math relate to finding the total energy of a static crystal, explain each lineWe start with calculating the total energy 𝑈tot by summing the Lennard-Jones
potential energies 𝑈𝐿𝐽(𝑟𝑖𝑗) for every pair of atoms in the crystal. The doublecounting of each pair in the double sum is corrected by the prefactor of 1/2. We
are considering a crystal with such a large number 𝑁 of atoms that the effect of
atoms near the surface, which are surrounded by fewer atoms than those deep
in the crystal, is negligible for the overall energetics. We can then simplify the
summation by choosing one reference atom, labelled 𝑖, and summing over all
pairs involving this reference atom. The total energy for the whole crystal is
then recovered with the prefactor 𝑁. Altogether, this yields the energy of a static
crystal, i.e., we neglect the motion of the atoms about their equilibrium positions.
The vibrational energy is usually small compared to the static binding energy (but
not always, as we will see), and a crystal will melt when the vibrational energy
approaches the binding energy upon heating.
After inserting the Lennard-Jones potential explicitly, we express all interatomic - 12Find the lattice sums for a 2D crystal with a square lattice (explain) and describe some values for 3D structures for fcc hcp and bccTo illustrate the principle of the calculating the lattice sums, we evaluate the 𝑎12
lattice sum for a two-dimensional crystal with a square lattice. For every distance
𝑝𝑖𝑗, we need to count the number of atoms at that distance and then sum all
terms accordingly. The series converges very quickly, and the same holds for
three-dimensional crystals. The lattice sums for 3D crystal structures can easily
be obtained manually or with a small computer program.
𝑎12 is essentially an approximation of the number of nearest neighbours — 𝑎12 ≈
12.13 for fcc and hcp (the coordination number or number of nearest neighbours
is 12). Note how 𝑎12 ≈ 9.1 is notable larger than the coordination number 8 for
bcc. The reason is that bcc is densely, but not close-packed, and that the six
second-nearest neighbours in this structure are only somewhat further away than
the nearest neighbours of the reference atom. - 13From the total energy of the static crystal; Find Ro/sigma and explain the differences from fcc, hcp and bcc for Ro
- 14From the total energy of the static energy and the equilibrium nearest neighbour distance find the equilibrium total energy and binding energy per atom explaining each step.
- 15Define cohesive energythe energy that is required to separate a crystal
into its neutral constituting atoms. - 16For NaCl ionic crystals briefly describe the two types of interactions that contribute the mostThere are three types of interaction between the ions: The omnipresent van
der Waals interaction and the short-range repulsion as discussed before, and
additionally the long-range Coulomb interaction between the charged ions. 𝑟 is
the distance between two ions. The van der Waals interaction is much weaker
than the direct Coulomb interaction: Binding energies are in the order of 0.1 eV
versus several eV per ion, and we will neglect the van der Waals contribution in
the following. The positive and negative signs in the Coulomb terms correspond
to pairs of charges of the same and opposites signs, respectively, and ±𝑞 is the
charge of each ion. As before, 𝜆 and 𝜌 define the energy and length scales of
the repulsive interaction. Note that we consider here only the simplest types of
ionic compounds, where all ions carry the same amount of charge, |𝑞|, and where
the structure is highly symmetric. - 17Describe the contributions and total energy for the ionic crystalsconsider only the energy 𝑈𝑖 from
the interactions of one chosen reference atom 𝑖 with all other atoms (𝑗 ≠ 𝑖) in
the crystal. 𝑧 denotes the number of nearest neighbours around this reference
atom 𝑖. (For example, 𝑧 = 6 for the three-dimensional NaCl structure type.) This
is the point where we assume a sufficiently simple crystal structure as noted
above. In the summation of the Coulomb terms, we need to take into account
whether a pair of ions has the same or opposite charges. By convention, one
considers the number 𝑁 of ion pairs rather than the number of atoms as for
the Lennard-Jones crystal. In analogy to the lattice sum 𝑎6 used in the previous
lecture, we introduce now the Madelung constant 𝛼 that captures the structure
dependence of the Coulomb energies - 18For ionic crystals, state and describe; Madelung constant Total energy Madelung energyThe Madelung constant 𝛼 must to be positive for a crystal to be stable. Otherwise,
𝑈tot(𝑅) would have no minimum, and the lowest total energy would be obtained by separating the ions, 𝑅 → ∞.
As an aside, in order to remember the expressions for the total energy and the
Madelung energies in the future (e.g., for the exam), it helps to carefully consider
their structure and recognise their physical meaning. The repulsive energy comes
from the empirical expression for the repulsive potential, 𝑉𝑟(𝑟) = 𝜆𝑒−𝑟/𝜌
, scaled
up by the number 𝑧 of nearest neighbours and the number 𝑁 of ion pairs in the
crystal. The Madelung energy is the Coulomb energy 𝑞
2/(4𝜋𝜖0𝑅) of a pair of ions
with charges ±𝑞 at a distance 𝑅, scaled up by the Madelung constant 𝛼 and the
number 𝑁 of ion pairs in the crystal. - 19Calculate the madelung constant for a 1D infinite chain of ions with alternating chargesWe pick any atom
in the infinite chain as the reference atom. As the problem is symmetric, we need
to consider only one side and multiply the result by 2. The resulting series can be
recognised as being that of the Taylor expansion of ln(1 + 𝑥) with 𝑥 = 1. - 20For finding the madelung constant for 3D crystals; What problems needs to be considered when finding convergence? What is the problem when using a summation over the ions in growing spheres of the crystal with carefully balanced chargesThe Madelung sums for three-dimensional crystals are only conditionally convergent. A naive summation over the ions in crystal cubes of growing size has the
problem that numbers of positive and negative ions are not the same and that
the summation ends at different distances along different directions of the crystal.
The problem is that the Coulomb interaction decays as 𝑟
−1 and the number of
atoms at distance 𝑟 increases as 𝑟
2
. The contributions from positive and negative
ions need to be added up in the right sequence and with balanced charges in order
to achieve convergence. A summation over the ions in growing spheres of the
crystal with carefully balanced charges is possible, but converges slowly. The
existence of NaCl and other ionic crystal shows that this is merely a mathematical
problem. - 21For finding the madelung constant for 3D crystals; How is the convergence issue solved?The Ewald method (after Paul Peter Ewald) for evaluating Madelung sums overcomes these convergence problems (by evaluating an equivalent of the Madelung
sum in Fourier space, which turns out to converge quickly). It is an essential
ingredient of all modern computer programs for electronic structure calculations.
The Ewald method was published in 1921, long before the invention of computers. - 22In regards to the equilibrium nearest neighbour distance; What does it minimise? Can its equation be solved analytically? For realistic values of the madelung constant and repulsive potential parameters what is the order of the length scale parameter of the short range repulsive interaction? Explain the alternative solution for R << pWe can now try to find the equilibrium nearest-neighbour distance 𝑅0 as the distance that minimises the total energy. Unfortunately, this leads to an equation that
cannot be solved analytically for 𝑅0. We see in the graph that the 𝑅0-dependent
part has a peak structure. For realistic values of the Madelung constant 𝛼 and the
repulsive potential parameters, one obtains an 𝑅0 in the order of 10𝜌, where 𝜌 is
the length scale parameter of the short-range repulsive interaction.
As an aside, note that there is a second mathematical solution with 𝑅 ≪ 𝜌, which
corresponds to a maximum in the total energy. This maximum is spurious and
not physically meaningful because the empirical, repulsive potential is not valid
at 𝑅 ≲ 𝜌. - 23Where is the zinc blend structure found?The zinc blende (ZnS) structure type is related to the diamond structure, but with
two types of ion placed alternatingly. It is very common among semiconductors
used in optoelectronics, such as GaAs, GaN, GaP. The zinc-blende type is often
found in materials with mixed ionic and covalent bonding. - 24Explain what produces covalent bindingCovalent bonding results from an energy-minimising overlap of atomic wave
functions and the formation of molecular orbitals. Unlike the other three types of
crystal binding, covalent binding produces directional bonds - 25Explain with (also with a sketch) covalent bonding of two hydrogen atoms and a hypothetical He2 moleculeWhen two H
atoms are brought together, their initial atomic 1𝑠 wave functions are no longer
eigenstates. Instead, a lower-energy bonding molecular orbital 𝜎1𝑠
is formed as
well as a higher-energy anti-bonding orbital, 𝜎
∗
1𝑠
. The anti-bonding 𝜎
∗
1𝑠
(A) state
has parallel spins and an anti-symmetric wave function. The bonding 𝜎1𝑠
(S)
state has anti-parallel spins and a symmetric wave function. Covalent bonding
requires partially-filled shells in the free atoms so that the lower-energy bonding
molecular orbitals are occupied, but not the higher-energy anti-bonding ones.
Therefore, the H2 molecule has a lower energy than two separate H atoms, and
the molecules form spontaneously. In contrast, in a hypothetical He2 molecule,
the anti-bonding molecular states would also be occupied, and there would be no
energy gain from forming the molecule. Helium is a monatomic gas at normal
conditions. - 26For the two hydrogen atoms covalent binding, explain the classical stateThis refers to a classical state with overlapping free-atom charge
densities, which yields already a weakly bound molecule. Note how the potential
minimum is much deeper in the quantum-mechanical bonding state. - 27State briefly the differences of covalent and metallic binding
- 28Why must covalent binding be treated quantum mechanically instead of classically?because it
represents a quantum-mechanical many-electron problem (∼1020 electrons!). - 29State the different types of binding in most materialsVan der Waals binding is present in all crystals, and a combination of ionic,
metallic and/or covalent bonding can exist in addition - 30Why do refractory metals have high melting points?Refractory metals [1] such as the 𝑑 transition metals molybdenum (Mo) and
tungsten (W) have high melting points and high hardness thanks to mixed metallic
and covalent bonding - 31What type of binding do crystals range from? What do the different electron affinities of Si and C mean?Crystal binding in semiconductor and insulator crystals ranges from purely covalent in C, Si, Ge to almost purely ionic in the alkali halides. Si and C have slightly
different electron affinities of 1.39 and 1.27 eV, respectively, which explains the
slightly ionic character of SiC. The technologically relevant III-V semiconductors
(InP . . .GaSb) all have the zinc-blende crystal structure, which is favoured by the
high covalent binding contribution.
Informações
- Descrição
- Year 4 ICMP FlashCards sobre Week 3 LNS (typed), criado por R S C em 29-06-2024.
- Criado por
- R S C
- Visualizações
- 3
- Avaliação
Mais sobre Crystal Structures and Bonding