Notas
Disciplinary Writing Exercise
Conteúdo das notas (2)
Página 1
Silvana Rodarte
Disciplinary Writing Exercise
RWS 3365
Dr. Foster
The University of Texas at El Paso
Object
The
object that I own is a perfume called “Chance” by Chanel.
Semiotic
Saussure
set out the fundamentals of what he called semiology. Semiotics is the science
of signs, and a semiotic approach to material culture regards artifacts as
signs whose meaning and significance have to be determined by the use of
semiotic concepts (Berger, 2016, 640). Semiotics studies signs in society,
which means it is a social science, and explains what signs are and how they
function (Berger, 2016, 663). According to Saussure, objects are signifiers,
and the task of the semiotician is to figure out their various signifieds (Berger,
2016, 674). He also states that that concepts (which is part of signs) derive
their meaning from their opposites (Berger, 2016, 674).
Analyzing my object and applying Semiotic
approach according to Saussure
My
perfume has a very simple design. Physically it is a transparent sphere bottle
with a mirror-effect lining the circumference of the bottle. The smell of the
perfume is very fresh and delicate. It has a mixture of lemon, citrus, jasmine,
amber and other “nature” aromas.
The Signifier is
the bottle itself and the signifieds are the different smells that the perfume
offers. When I wear this perfume I get different types of smells like jasmine,
amber, and even a small amount of wood. It has a variety of floral with a
minimum amount of fruity smells. We can also look at the shape (round), size
(50ml), and texture (smooth and made out of glass) of the bottle as signifieds.
This creates a denotation method because I am providing exact measurements and
descriptions about my object (Berger, 2016, 799). The concept of my object is that it
establishes my femininity. I am a young woman who loves to put on my perfume
before leaving the house. The opposite of femininity would be masculinity. A
woman who is not interested in what is considered “girly” like make-up,
perfume, high heels, purses, jewelry, and much more would be more lenient to
not having a preference in what other women are into. The concept of my object would then be
femininity and the idea of having a preference to smell good. I know that I had
to have a certain amount of knowledge (object and general) to be able to
interpret the object (my perfume bottle) from a semiotic perspective. The most
interesting detail about this is that the sense of smell is very strong and
easily identifiable. Even if I don’t see the bottle of perfume from another
individual, if that individual passes by and I recognize the smell, then I know
that she is using the same perfume I am. The bottle can also express details
about your personality and interests. With this bottle, I found delicateness
(because of its mirror linings and it is made out of glass), sweet (green
liquid), and reserved (minimum amount of words not too much detail into the
bottle).
Semiotic according to Peirce
Peirce
is also known as the other founding father of semiotics and the one that gave
it its name (Berger, 2016, 719). He suggested that the universe is made up of
signs and that the interpreters of signs have to supply some of the meanings,
writing that a sign is “something which stands to somebody for something in
some respect or capacity” (Berger, 2016, 719). Peirce mentioned that there are
three kinds of signs: iconic signs which are resemblance or what you can see,
indexical signs which are cause and effect or what you can determine, and
symbolic signs in which meaning must be learned or what you can learn(Berger,
2016, 732). We can combine Saussure’s and Peirce’s approaches to semiotics and
use both approaches to analyze material culture (Berger, 2016, 732).
Analyzing my object using Peirce’s
approach
My
perfume bottle can be used to create a deductive reasoning based on Peirce’s
three kinds of signs. I found my perfume bottle to be considered iconic because
you can see it and when you see it
you know what it is. It can be found in my own home; my dressing table. It can also be found in multiple stores, commercials, and the fashion industry. Of course, you also need to have background knowledge that
this perfume is Chanel, which is considered in society as a high brand and that
individuals will more than likely conclude that it is a perfume of quality.
This object can also be known as having indexical sign because it does have a
cause and effect reaction. For example, you see the perfume being advertised
(cause). It’s Chanel and because it is a popular and renowned brand, you
consider to buy it. You smell the perfume and you love it. You hope that others
will like it too leading to boosting up your self-esteem (effect). If
individuals comment on your smell, you feel confident and will more than likely
purchase the perfume again (effect). In rare cases, if you smell someone else
wearing the same perfume, you also feel confident because you now know that
others thought it smelled good as well. It’s important to remember that meaning
comes from a network of relations. So what can be determined from this? The
fact that you bought it to either boost your self-esteem or simply to try a new
perfume because you want to smell good helps, express your femininity. This can
include connotation because society has made women become interested and
involved with beauty and its products leading to cultural meanings (Berger,
2016, 799). Women tend to want to look and smell pretty. The perfume bottle can
help us understand women’s interests. The Semiotic approach to material culture
involves searching for the way objects function as signs and generate meaning
to others. Perfume smells vary because each woman has a unique preference. A
type of smell and its packaging (bottle) can tell us a lot about their
interests and tastes.
Artifacts and the Unconscious: Freud’s
Topographic Hypothesis
There
are three levels to the human psyche: conscious, pre-conscious (material we can
access and of which we are dimly aware), and unconscious (which we cannot
access without guidance from psychoanalytic trained therapists) (Berger, 2016, 433).
Analyzing Freud’s Topographic Hypothesis
using my object (perfume)
Conscious:
Perfume spray bottle.
Preconscious:
To smell good; to have other people notice us.
Unconscious:
Sexual union or making us feel successful.
Freudian Psychoanalytic Approach
Psychoanalysis
is a procedure for investigation, for method of treatment disorders, and for a
collection of aggregated information (Berger, 2016, 425). It’s important to
keep in mind how our unconscious mental process plays an important role in our
lives (Berger, 2016, 433). The definition of Structural Hypothesis according to
Freud is that it suggests that our psyches have three components: id, an ego,
and a superego (Berger, 2016, 482). His theory suggests that objects can have
different levels of significance (Berger, 2016, 482).
The definition
of Structural Hypothesis according to Charles Brenner (author of “An Elementary
Textbook of Psychoanalysis”) is: id comprises the psychic representatives of
the drives, the ego consists of those functions which have to do with the
individual’s relation to his environment, and the superego comprises the moral
precepts of our minds as well as our ideal aspiration (Berger, 2016, 482).
Analyzing my psyche in relation to my perfume
I
believe that Chanel “Chance” represents women’s drive. I think that because we
know or at least society has made us understand, that Chanel is a high quality
brand, it is in our drive to want their products. Chanel tends to have eye
appealing bags, shoes, dresses, and when we see perfumes, we know that it is
going to be just as attractive. The id provides that energy that we really want
the product. Because society has shaped us to believe that women need to look
pretty, we want everything that has to do with that term, “pretty”. For
example, if we see our favorite actress or singer modeling the perfume or being
the “face” for that brand of perfume, we have established a defense mechanism
known as identification. We desire to be like that actress or singer and tend
to buy products like they own so we can be like them. This will try to convince
you that by buying the perfume you will have a positive impact on social life (Berger,
2016, 528).
Symbolic Aspects, Sexual Development,
Material Culture
Psychoanalytic
theory would suggest that people are not aware of the symbolic significance of
objects they use, but quite obviously a large number of artifacts have either a
masculine penetrating or female incorporative character to them (Berger, 2016, 557).
We can use Freud’s typology to classify objects according to whether they are
primarily oral, anal, phallic, or genital in nature, recognizing that people
who use these objects are generally not aware of their sexually symbolic nature
(Berger, 2016, 604). Example: Pacifier is oral, Potty is anal, Cigar is
phallic, and condom is genital (Berger, 2016, 604).
Analyzing my object in terms of symbols,
and sexual development
Chanel
“Chance” perfume has a round shape which can suggest hidden signs (phallic/
male and female organs/sexual roles assumed by genitals (Berger, 2016, 597). I
ask myself if this object could have a hidden sign about the female body,
possibly the breasts. Also, the size is a 50 ml bottle meaning it is the small
size (phallic/female organs) out of three other options. Picking the smallest
size provides the opportunity to test the perfume to see if I like it for the
short amount of time it will be used (compared to the larger sizes). The
texture of the bottle is smooth, and transparent glass. This could express my
personality of being delicate and the soft; kinds of personality found among
women (being maternal). These are some ways to interpret my bottle of perfume.
Summary
I
think the most difficult to write was the Freudian approach because it has many
methods in which you can interpret an object. There are different ways in which
an object can reveal a hidden message and it can be challenging to unveil that
hidden message and understand it. Signs and symbols can be interpreted
differently because we all have different experiences and background knowledge.
We use these experiences and knowledge in order to interpret something. I think
writing about this was challenging because I used my own thoughts which can be
completely different from someone else’s.
I believe the
one that was most revealing was the Freudian approach because apart from the
obvious of having a perfume bottle, there are hidden messages as to why I have
it, what can be said about its shape, size, texture, and what it means to wear
it. It’s not simply a bottle of perfume. It has a personality, a taste, and a
trait of being a woman. Individuals can have different interpretations but I
think that even the different types of aromas in the bottle can describe your
personality.
References
Berger, A. A. (2016) What Objects Mean: An Introduction to Material Culture (Kindle 2nd
ed.). NY, NY: Routledge.
Página 2
Informações
- Descrição
- By Silvana Rodarte
- Criado por
- Silvana Rodarte · set 2016
- Atualizado
- 3 dez 2016
- Visualizações
- 37
- Avaliação