Notas
Children's Book Assignment: Humpty Dumpty
Conteúdo das notas (1)
Página 1
MEMORANDUM
To:
Rhetoric: Material Thing Theory & Visual Communication
From:
R. Dean Straight
Subject:
Children’s Book Assignment
Rationale
RWS
5328 has been tasked with producing two parts to an exercise designed to apply
theoretical frameworks offered in Rhetoric: Material Thing Theory & Visual
Communication. Through a combination of color and shapes, this report will
offer observations about Marxist and Freudian methodologies as lenses to
explore possible analysis of “Humpty Dumpty.”
Summarization
“Humpty
Dumpty” dates back to the turn of the 19th century (Opie, 2004) as
an English nursery rhyme. There are a number of origins associated with this
fable; however, for the purposes of this exercise, Carroll’s (1872) version
where the character is represented by an anthropomorphic egg will be used (p.
72). While
the rhyme is short, consisting of four lines to produce a single quatrain, the
literature value is not the focus of this exercise. What will be examined in
detail is the rhyme as an artifact with various elements that will be analyzed
as they function as a whole and part and parcel of children’s books.
Picture
This
A
combination of shapes, and diagonal shapes and angled movement from top to
bottom are used to create motion and disorder (Bang, 2000) in the visual
portion of this exercise. Bang (2000) explains that “diagonal shapes are
dynamic because they imply motion or tension (p. 46),” and that while there is
power in relation to the reader regarding the placement of objects at the top
or bottom of the page, “these principles are used not one by one, but always in
combination and always in some context” (p. 58). When I designed the movement
of Humpty Dumpty falling through various frames within the children’s book, my
intention was specific: to create gravity for the reader. Shape is specific to
the requirements of the rhyme; Humpty Dumpty is an egg, hence I used the oval
shape to reproduce him. However, Bang (2000) offered that color and contrast
produce emotions which help the reader move through the story without words (p.
80) and produce dimension within the two-dimensional space (p. 81). These
principles were key to the production of my rendition of “Humpty Dumpty.”
Marxism
Marxism
offers a methodology that works well with “Humpty Dumpty.” The gist of this
methodology can be understood to be that Marx argued that consumer needs “are
not real … but are artificially imposed upon us” (Berger, 2016, loc.
1135) through
signs designed to persuade society that products are the avenue to happiness.
This is combined with the sense of alienation we feel from other members of our
community because we cannot obtain a sense of cohesion within our community,
because there is always a sense of mistrust of members of the community (loc.
1141). In
short, we purchase artifacts to signify our position within a capitalist
community, but cannot ever reach a state of harmony or acceptance because there
will always be something more extravagant to make people feel inferior. This is
coupled with a fear of loss, or theft because, through the process of showing
off shiny new things, the attention of others who “take [things] away from you
by one means or another” (loc. 1141) always looms in the shadows –
figuratively speaking. As a whole, and through its parts, the artifact is rife
with potential meaning that can be attributed to success and failure within a
capitalist society. The significant methods associated with Marxism include
class conflict, conspicuous consumption, and publicity as defined by Berger (locs.
1128-1328).
Class conflict
Class
conflict is a method of data collection which explores the disparity between
goods and the distribution of them along class lines; it also is defined as “a
basic Marxist theory” (Berger, 2016, loc. 1146). This lens works
effectively for “Humpty Dumpty” because Marx asserts, through class conflict,
that strife is averted by the bourgeoisie through “the indoctrination of
members of the proletariat with” a false consciousness. This concept is built
around the idea that anybody can be successful, and therefore gain class status
within the bourgeoisie, if they work hard enough. Through the “Humpty Dumpty”
analogy, the proletariat is represented by Humpty Dumpty and hard work is
represented by the wall upon which he/she sits. The fall, or the actuality
related to class, results in the bourgeoisie asserting they can fix the lower
classes by putting them back together. However, from a Marxist perspective,
this is an impossible venture in the current capitalist model.
Conspicuous consumption
This
method is framed around functional analysis which examines the
consumer model which is based on competitiveness amongst males, as per Veblen (loc.
1184). The symbolic nature of possessions, in particular those that would be
seen as coveted by other members of a community, offers a “heightened
self-evaluation,” (loc. 1189), and ultimately, an inflated or “enhanced sense of self”
(loc. 1191). Examining the artifact, “Humpty Dumpty,” offers an observation
about the fall of man from his physical position upon the wall. The latent
function of the wall is that it affords Humpty Dumpty a place in society above
his neighbors, but when he falls, no effort of man can restore his sense of
failure and loss. This broken metaphor can also illustrate the inability for
man to easily recover financially from actions that might lead to destitution
in a capitalist society.
Publicity
Berger
structures the method of publicity as one which is not about competition within
the message, but rather, duplicity of meaning or values that
are “always being used to make the same general proposal” (loc. 1306). While there may be a
number of competing products within the framework of publicity, the system of
publicity offers only a singularity. Berger explains that the system’s proposal
is one of transformation or modification of class through consumerism. This
concept relies on tangible appetites for pleasure through external possessions.
By focusing on things we need, but also have the tertiary benefit of improving
look, social positions, and style, publicity draws people up to a wall which
they can see. Humpty Dumpty then represents consumers who continuously fall for
the need for transformation and therefore can never be fixed in a place of stasis.
Freudian
As a methodology, Freud’s (Berger, 2016, loc. 425)
approaches offer a solid basis for analysis through a variety of lenses. The
connections that can be draw from the data offer terministic screens with which
to explore the nursery rhyme as a dynamic allegory for social engagement. Freud
emphasized a resistance associated with sexuality through repression called the
psychoanalytic approach (loc. 427). This methodology requires an examination of
symbolic meanings and hidden values built into artifacts in material culture (loc.
431). There is a direct correlation between what an object’s latent meaning, which
can only be understood by applying theoretical lenses such as the topographic
hypothesis, symbolic aspects, and sexual development. The data obtained can
offer observations about the “Humpty Dumpty” artifact.
Topographic hypothesis
Freud
established that for this hypothesis psychoanalytic trained therapists
would be aware of “three levels to the human psyche: consciousness,
pre-consciousness, and the unconscious” (loc. 440). Berger (2016) offers an
analogy of an iceberg to understand this three-tier concept. He explains that
consciousness is what we are alert to existing. This is represented by what we
can physically observe above the water level (loc. 445). The preconscious sits
just below the water; it is murky, and slightly challenging to observe, but we
are aware of it. The unconscious is that part of the iceberg which is
completely unknown to us because we are not able to see it “buried deep beneath
the water line” (loc. 445). Freud established that it is the unconscious which molds
who individuals are and has the most significant impact on our behavior
(loc. 447). From
this lens, it could be observed that the conscious understanding of “Humpty
Dumpty” is that we cannot, as humans, take risks which can cause us physical
harm: falls from great distances can be life threatening. A preconscious
understanding might be more focused through the wall being a symbol of keeping
others out. Humpty Dumpty would then be seeking to peek beyond this barrier,
and his fall could represent the problem with isolating ourselves too far from
others. No amount of repair can reconnect those bridges we have burned through
neglect or avoidance. An unconscious observation might be built around how
males travel in groups when they are seeking the attention of women. The
mindset of these groups is that they are working toward a singular goal, which
is to end the night with at least one of them taking a woman home. It is never
mandatory that all men reach this goal, because they all are willing to live
vicariously through the stories that come from this conquest. However, if they
all work to lift one man, Humpty Dumpty, above them in an effort to reach their
aspirations of sexual conquest, then if he fails, they all fail and usually are
unable to recover from the damage done in that environment. The wall represents
the spiraling heights that come with the culture of union associated with night
clubs. The flirting, dancing, drinking, and chicanery that is part of the
rites of gaining the attention of women; Humpty Dumpty sits upon this wall of
actions, a fragile vessel seeking to attract the opposite sex. When he falls, a
toppled king, his men will struggle unsuccessfully to fix the situation.
Symbolic aspects
Freud’s
psychoanalytic theory offers another method to examine “Humpty Dumpty”:
symbolic aspects. The concept of symbolism is specifically built
around male and female contexts about objects and artifacts. (loc. 530) Berger
(2016) offers that symbols represent “unconscious aggressive and sexual desires”
(loc. 538). The penis can be represented by a variety of descriptions
associated with rigid, “long and upstanding” (loc. 542) or otherwise symbolically
represent the “property of penetrating and consequently” (loc. 542) damaging values. A list of items
including almost all weapons is offered as examples of this phallic context.
Berger (2016) further asserts that Freud specifically valued this concept
through the medium of dreams, but that it is not impossible to
make the same connections about objects and artifacts in material culture.
Consequently, Freud also offered that symbolism was found in objects within the
context of female genitalia: specifically, the uterus. His discussion revolved
around “all such objects as shared with them the process of enclosing a space
or are capable of acting as receptacles” (loc. 547). “Humpty Dumpty,” when
examined under this lens, could represent several sexualized symbols. The wall
meets Freud’s value associated with the penis, the egg has female genitalia
characteristics: ovaries and the king’s men could be identified in this context
as failed semen. The fall itself could be seen as a defect in the egg and
therefore infertility. As a whole the story could be seen as a male’s inability
to impregnate a woman because of some genetic condition or other variable.
Sexual development
Freud
offers three phases of sexual development which he sees as essential to
understanding, and explaining, the development of people. These three stages
are oral, anus, and phallic. Early in a child’s life they are gratified through
“the mouth, lips, and tongue” (Berger, 2016, loc. 592) because
these are the organs which are used for feeding, pleasure, and contact with
others; usually the mother through breastfeeding. As a child grows they begin
to be controlled through the regulation of defecation and urination. Parents
start potty training and this becomes a source of pride and tension for the
child because it is so central to their existence. Once a child has control of
their habits in the bathroom, they reach the third stage: the phallic element.
The transition becomes one of procreation and pleasure, which is found,
according to Freud, through the penis or clitoris (loc. 598). In short, Freud
asserts that we are guided by our need to eat, control our environment, and
sexually procreate. The nursery rhyme, as an artifact, potentially reflects the idea
that women are taught that physical contact is the best means to gain
affection, specifically through genitalia, and her fail, through this medium,
will only result in a series of failed attempts to fix the loss of the value of
love. Another potential explanation of this analysis would be how young men are
taught that the penis must be something destructive toward women, and the end
result is that other men who eventually become involved in the woman’s life
will always attempt to fix the damage done through this ignorance.
Conclusion
“Humpty Dumpty” is a simple rhyme that offers a complex
number of interpretations through methods associated with Marxism and Freudian
methodologies. While the assignment required us to explore how the data is
collected and interpreted in isolation through each methodology, I believe that
there is no valid way to explore then without understanding that there are
multiple terministic screens in play from a variety of different methodologies.
There is no absolute way to create the isolation required to produce a true
examination with a focus on one exclusive method. Even those provided above
worked across methods within methods in alternative methodologies while still
illustrating an analysis associated with one method.
References
Bang, M. (2000). Picture this: How pictures work. San Francisco,
CA: Chronicle Books.
Berger, A. A. (2016). What
objects mean: An introduction to material culture. London: Routledge.
Carpenter, A. S. (2002). Lewis Carroll: Through the Looking Glass
(p. 98). Minneapolis, MN: Lerner.
Carroll, L. (1872). Through the Looking-Glass (p. 72).
Raleigh, NC: Hayes Barton Press.
Opie, I. (2004). Playground
rhymes and the oral tradition. In P. Hunt & S.G. Bannister Ray (Eds.), International Companion Encyclopedia of
Children’s Literature (p. 76). London: Routledge.
Appendix:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Humpty_Dumpty
Informações
- Descrição
- RWS 5328 has been tasked with producing two parts to an exercise designed to apply theoretical frameworks offered in Rhetoric: Material Thing Theory & Visual Communication. Through a combination of color and shapes, this report will offer observations about Marxist and Freudian methodologies as lenses to explore possible analysis of “Humpty Dumpty.”
- Criado por
- R. Dean Straight · set 2016
- Atualizado
- 6 abr 2018
- Visualizações
- 41
- Avaliação