Zusammenfassung der Ressource
The Challenge of
Cultural Relativism
- Different Cultures Have
Different Moral Codes
- Callatians (a tribe of Indians) customarily
ate the bodies of their dead fathers
- Eskimos commonly
committed infantcide
- Cultural Relativism
- challenges our ordinary
belief in the objectivity and
universality of moral truth
- 1. different societies have
different moral codes
- 2. the is no objective
standard for comparison
- 3. our moral code is just
one of many
- 4. there is no universal truth in ethics
- 5. the moral code of a
society determines what is
right within that society
- 6. we should adopt an
attitude of tolerance
- The Cultural
Differences Argument
- premise
- different cultures have
different moral codes
- conclusion
- there is no objective truth
in morality
- right and wrong are matters of opinion
- is not sound
argument
- the conclusion does not
follow from the premise
- proves nothing
- The Consequences of Taking
Cultural Relativism Seriously
- 1. we could no longer say that the
customs of other societies are
morally inferior to out own
- 2. we could decide whether actions
are right or wrong just by consulting
the standards of our society
- 3. the idea of moral
progress is called into doubt
- Why There Is Less
Disagreement Than It Seems
- the difference lies in our belief
systems, not in our values
- All Cultures Have Some
Values in Common
- there are some moral rules that all societies
will have in common, because those rules are
necessary for society to exist
- What Can Be Learned From
Cultural Relativism
- warns us about the danger of assuming that
all our preferences are based on some
absolute rational moral standard
- teaches us to keep
an open mind