Fichas
Cases
Fichas del conjunto (15)
- 1Lux Traffic v Pike Signals(Novelty)
- Concerning: What use amounts to disclosure to the public.
- A prior publication must contain clear and unmistakable directions to do what the patentee claims to have invented; a signpost will not suffice. Where prior use is concerned, there is no need for a skilled person actually to examine the invention as long as they were free in law and equity to do so, an dif a skilled person had seen it they would have been able to understand what the inventive
- no need to prove that anybody actually saw the disclosure - 2Synthon v SmithKline(Novelty)
-Concerning: the differing roles of the skilled person in relation to concepts of disclosure and enablement.
- Enablement and disclosure are 2 different concepts.
- According to Lord Hoffmann
“Enablement means that the ordinary skilled person would have been able to perform the invention which satisfies the requirement of disclosure.” - 3Windsurfing Test(Inventive Step)
- Concerning : Structured way of approaching the problem of whether an inventive is obvious to a person skilled in the art.
1a. Identify the PSA
1b. Identify the relevant CGK of the person
2. identify the inventive concept
3. Identify the differences of matter claimed between the invention and prior art
4. view without knowledge, if the differences constitute steps would have been obvious to PSA - 4Conor v Angiotech(Inventive Step)
- Concerning: What to consider when identifying whether an inventive step was obvious.
-There was no requirement that the specification had to explain how or why an invention worked. If there was enough in the specification to show that it was plausible that TAXOL would work, that was sufficient - 5Human Genome Sciences v Eli Lilly(Industrial Application)
-Concerning: What constitute industrial application in relation to biotech inventions.
- Where, in the light of the CGK, a new substance has a plausible claimed use, this can satisfy the requirement of industrial application. This must be contrasted with the case where the patent application merely indicates that a programme of research should be undertaken to determine whether the substance has a particular effect. - 6IDA Ltd v University of Southampton(Entitlement)
- Concerning: Right to be considered the inventor.
- To be considered as an inventor, a person does not have to be skilled in the art in question: all that is required is that the person provided the inventive aspect to the patent. Having CGK was not enough to be inventive. Routines trials are not inventive; the question is whether they had contributed the heart of the invention. - 7Catnic Components v Hill & Smith(Infringement)
- Concerning the interpretation of the claim and whether a minor variation would avoid a successful infringement action
- A patent specification should be given a purposive construction aimed at the skilled worker in the field rather thatn the pure literal interpretation favoured by lawyers. - 8Improver v Rayond(Infringement)
Conerning: Guidance on how to interpret a claim when there is an equivalent
The court should ask itself the following 3 questions.
1. Does the variant have a material effect on the invention works? If yes – the variant is outside the claim.
2. If no – Would this have been obvious at the date of publication to PSA? If No – the variant is outside the claim,
3. If Yes – Would the PSA have understood from the language fo the claim that the patentee intended that strict compliance with the primary meaning was an essential requirement of the invention? If yes – the variant is outside the claim. - 9Kirin Amgen v Hoechst(Infringement: Purposive Construction)
- Concerning: whether the protocol questions could be used to decide whether the PSA could envisage how a new technology would work.
- The protocol questions are merely a guide to determine what the PSA would have understood the patentee to be using the language of the claim to mean. It is the principle laid down in Catnic that must be followed - 10Auchincloss v Agriculturall(Defences)
- Concerning: What acts amounted to experimental use for section 60(5)(b)
- Trials to discover something unknown or to test a hypothesis are regarded as legitimates experiments, but trials carried out to reaffirm what is already known or to show hat a product works or to obtain official approval are not. - 11Schutz v. Werit(Defences)
- Concerning: the existence and scope of the right to repair.
- ‘Makes’ has no precise meaning: It is a matter of fact and degree and depends on the circumstances. One must consider whether the part being replaced was a subsidiary rather than a main component of the article, whether there was a much shorter life expectancy, whether it was free-standing and replaceable and whether, as here, there was no connection with the claimed inventive concept. On these facts the defendant was repairing, not making the article. - 12Coco v Clark(Breach of Confidence)
- Concerning: Basic Requirement of Breach of Confidence
1. The information is capable of being protected.
2. The defendant owes the claimant an obligation to keep the information confidential.
3. The defendant made an act that breaches the duty. - 13Faccenda Chicken v Fowler(Breach of Confidence)
- Concerning: an ex-employee taking sales information
- Trivial information, easily accessible information and employee know-how are not protected as trade secrets. Trade secrets are so confidential that there is a duty even without a contractual agreement to keep them secret after the end of the employment relationship. - 14Michael Douglas v Hello!(Breach of Confidence)
- Concerning: whether unauthorised photographs were taken in breach of confidence.
- Make it clear that photographs should not be taken, together with strict security measures, can give rise to a duty of confidence. - 15Campbell v Mirror(Breach of Confidence)
- Concerning: Misuse of private information and whether disclosure was in the public interest.
- By a majority decision, the court decided that a role model can be exposed for hypocrisy; consequently drug treatment after denial of addiction was open to exposure. However, there is still a ‘reasonable expectation of privacy’ and the photograph was not necessary in order to demonstrate that she had lied.
Información
- Descripción
- MSc Patent Law Fichas sobre Cases, creado por Jasmine Law el 22/04/2015.
- Creado por
- Jasmine Law
- Visitas
- 0
- Valoración