Mapa mental
Anthropocene

Contenido del mapa
Anthropocene
three ontological claims which form the ground for the scientific Anthropocene narrative
- post-natural
- biophysical / geological / natural scientific approach
- While the Anthropocene clearly has the potential to draw ‘the humanities and the natural and social sciences into dialogue in new and exciting ways’ , the concept has its home in the environmental sciences and is dominated by a persuasive science narrative of escalating human- induced environmental change.
- humankind has become a global scale force with the ability to fundamentally reshape the planet.
- new geological era ‘when natural forces and human forces are so intertwined that the fate of one determines the fate of the other’
- The deep intertwining of natural and human systems is at the heart of the scientific Anthropocene narrative
- symbolize the ability of ‘civilized man’ to alter natural systems to the extent that they cannot be considered ‘natural’ anymore.
- human ‘footprint on the planet’
- symbolize the ability of ‘civilized man’ to alter natural systems to the extent that they cannot be considered ‘natural’ anymore.
- In the Anthropocene, nature is domesticated, technologized and capital- ized to the extent that it can no longer be considered natural. As proclaimed by Crutzen and Schwa ̈gerl (2011) ‘(i)t’s no longer us against ‘‘Nature’’. Instead, it’s we who decide what nature is and what it will be’.
- end of nature
- The deep intertwining of natural and human systems is at the heart of the scientific Anthropocene narrative
- The Anthropocene puts humans at the centre of global environmental change.
- the proposed ‘geology of mankind’ is not grounded in an analysis of social relations, but in a naturalized and aggregated account of the human species
- Focus on 'humanity' / an aggregated account of the human species
- dominated by the natural sciences and focused on environmental rather than social change
- No attention given to the cultural social and political context
- In the quest for solutions to urgent collective action problems, the focus has primarily been on means rather than ends and attention has hereby been diverted away from the social and cultural norms, practices and power relations that drive environmental problems in the first place
- No attention given to the cultural social and political context
- the proposed ‘geology of mankind’ is not grounded in an analysis of social relations, but in a naturalized and aggregated account of the human species
- new geological era ‘when natural forces and human forces are so intertwined that the fate of one determines the fate of the other’
- biophysical / geological / natural scientific approach
- post-social
- Socio cultural/ societal dynamics focus
- Given this emphasis on the human dimensions of environmental change it is remarkable, and highly paradoxical, that the resulting Anthropocene narrative to date has told us so little about societal dynamics
- human beings are always and everywhere embedded. Individuals, groups and organizations live in a world of biophysical properties and material artefacts, but also in a socio-cultural world of meanings and motivations
- In order to explore the dynamics and trajectory of the Anthropocene, we thus need to understand the situated social drivers and implications of ‘human activities’ such as land-use change or energy use, and the meanings and forms of political agency they produce at particular times.
- uneven distribution of environmental risks and vulnerabilities across all scales of human society. When linking environmental change to social categories such as class, race, gender, power and capital we thus find that the challenges of the Anthropocene are far from universal. Rather, they emerge from different socio-political settings, produce different kinds of vulnerabilities and will therefore most likely generate different kinds of political responses
- We contend that a deeper involvement of the social sciences in the study of the Anthropocene will help to overcome this post- social ontology.
- When the complex environmental challenges of our times are accounted for in aggregated terms, we lose sight of the situated conflicts, warped distribution of wealth and unequal power relations that engine ‘the great acceleration’.
- In order to explore the dynamics and trajectory of the Anthropocene, we thus need to understand the situated social drivers and implications of ‘human activities’ such as land-use change or energy use, and the meanings and forms of political agency they produce at particular times.
- eco-marxism (Bonneuil, Foster)
- Instead of undifferentiated population and focussing on economic growth Look at ‘processes of dispossession and commodification associated with the logic of capitalist expansion, along with the mechanisms of imperial domination, [as] the essential causal forces of the geological turn’.
- Capitalocene?
- Instead of undifferentiated population and focussing on economic growth Look at ‘processes of dispossession and commodification associated with the logic of capitalist expansion, along with the mechanisms of imperial domination, [as] the essential causal forces of the geological turn’.
- Socio cultural/ societal dynamics focus
- post-political
- We refer to this paradoxical relationship between environmental apocalyptic thought on the one hand, and institutional status quo on the other, as the post- political ontology of the Anthropocene.
- When the complex environmental challenges of our times are accounted for in aggregated terms, we lose sight of the situated conflicts, warped distribution of wealth and unequal power relations that engine ‘the great acceleration’. As a conse- quence, the space for political contestation, debate and reorienta- tion is also restricted. We believe that a deeper involvement of critical social science in global environmental change research represents an important step out of this post-political situation.
- see Beck
- The political and economic elites mask the origins and consequences of the catastrophic risks and dangers of late industrialisation
- The political and legal systems of capitalist societies are not neutral but structurally biased in their allocation of power to environmentally problematic interests.
- although the environemtnal situation is getting worse and worse, no ones is held accountable for it
- The political and legal systems of capitalist societies are not neutral but structurally biased in their allocation of power to environmentally problematic interests.
- The political and economic elites mask the origins and consequences of the catastrophic risks and dangers of late industrialisation
- We refer to this paradoxical relationship between environmental apocalyptic thought on the one hand, and institutional status quo on the other, as the post- political ontology of the Anthropocene.
- post-natural
There are 3 narrative stages to the Anthropocene:
- 1. Our large-scale, systematic impact started with the industrial revolution (1750), which constitutes the first stage and the initial turn into the Anthropocene.
- 2. Then after the WWII, there was a period of acceleration with increasing technology, free market and ideology of growth.
- 3. And today, since the 2000s, we are in a period of realisation of our true and deep impact and major environmental crisis.
what is it?
- deep intertwining of the fates of nature and humankind
- ‘the age of man’
- The concept of the Anthropocene can be viewed as an awakening or humankind’s impact of the Earth’s systems.
context
- The Anthropocene concept was coined by the chemist and Nobel Laureate Paul Crutzen and biologist Eugene Stoermer at the turn of the new millennium to describe a new geological era fully dominated by human activity
- far from a settled concept
- an idea in the making
- far from a settled concept
- climate change emerges as the primary signal of the Anthropocene
- increasing environmental degradation with the emergence of tipping points and overshoots
- The Anthropocene concept was coined by the chemist and Nobel Laureate Paul Crutzen and biologist Eugene Stoermer at the turn of the new millennium to describe a new geological era fully dominated by human activity
effects
- powerful narrative of human resource exploitation, planetary thresholds and environmental urgency
- we have entered a much more unpredictable and dangerous time when humanity is undermining the planetary life- support systems upon which it depends
- In order to counter an immanent ecological catastrophe, leading Anthropocene advocates have begun to define safe planetary boundaries beyond which the Earth System will no longer function in a stable, Holocene-like state
- we have entered a much more unpredictable and dangerous time when humanity is undermining the planetary life- support systems upon which it depends
- powerful narrative of human resource exploitation, planetary thresholds and environmental urgency
Lovbrand et al. (2014) challenge the framing of the Anthropocene.
- They want to:
- Radicalise the post-natural;
- Highlight social diversity and difference
- Reintroduce the political
- They want to:
Imágenes y archivos del mapa
Información
- Descripción
- Mapa Mental sobre Anthropocene, creado por Lea Rüegg el 25/05/2019.
- Creado por
- Lea Rüegg
- Visitas
- 3
- Valoración