Apuntes
Gellner: theories of nationalism and nation-states
Contenido del apunte (1)
Página 1
BALAKRISHNAN G., (ed) (1999), Mapping the Nation, Great Britain, Guildford and King's Lynn
Ernest Gellner, The Coming of Nationalism and Its Interpretation: The Myths of Nation and Class, pp. 98- 145
A world in which nationalism, the linking of state and of 'nationally' defined culture, is pervasive and normative is quite different from one in which this is relatively rare, half-hearted, unsystematized and untypical.
A world consisting of neat political units, systematically and proudly differentiated from each other by 'culture', and all of them striving, with a great measure of success, to impose cultural homogeneity internally. These units, linking sovereignty to culture, are known as nation-states.
Agro-Literate society
pp. 99 Agro-Literate society characteristics: society based on agriculture, food production and food storage, with fairly stable technology through innovations and improvements, stable partnership between nature and society, in which nature not merely provides a modest but fairly constant material provision, but also endows somehow underwrites, justifies the social order, and mirrors its arrangements. values of the members of society are generally directed towards coercion and hierarchy.
pp. 100 Increased production will only benefit the privileged power-holders does benefit the successful aspiring individual himself. So he must strive to enhance his power and status, and should not waste effort on increasing output.
An agro-literate society constitutes a complex system of fairly stable statuses.
pp. 101 Two possibilities of maintaining order: coercion and consent.The two mechanisms are not separated, but work in conjunction. They are intertwined so intimately that it becomes impossible to disentangle their contributions to the maintenance of the social order.
society also endowed with a more or less stable agricultural base, but also with literacy. Writing is a technique which makes possible the recording and retrieval of data, ideas, information, formulate and so forth. Pre-literate society is not devoid of techniques of preservation of affirmations and meanings: important formulae can also be maintained by ritual and repetition. But writing greatly enlarges the scope of preservation and transmission of ideas, affirmations, information, principles.
Writing tends to increase the status-differentiation of this kind of society. It is a skill which requires sustained and fairly prolonged initiation, known as 'education.'
pp. 102 Literacy becomes a badge of rank, as well as constitutiong a guild mystery.
Most ordinary members of this kind of society acquire their 'culture', their stock of ideas and symbols, 'on the job', in the course of the very process of living, as part of the daily interchange between kinsmen, neighbours, masters and disciplines.
Skills such as literacy are transmitted in the course of prolonged and specialised training, inculcated, not by ordinary people in the course of doing ordinary things, but by full-time specialists, dedicated to perpetuating and exemplifying superior norms.
pp. 103 Culture is "A society of this type is constantly given to as it were secreting, engendering, elaborating cultural differentiations within itself. It constitutes a system of differentiated ranks and statuses, and these need to be recognised, highlighted, externalised.
pp. 104 The overall conclusion must be that in such societies, shared culture is seldom a plausible basis for the formation of political units. The term 'nation', if used at all, is more likely to denote a loose corporate body, the politically enfranchised gentry of a given territory, those committed to take part in politics, than literally the sum total of participants in a culture.
pp. 105 Political units in such a society have a strong tendency to be either smaller or larger than cultural units. Tribal segments, city states, seldom exhaust the culture which they practise, but rather, they share it with a much wider-area....
People in this kind of society have plural and nested and cross-cutting memberships and loyalties, some of them vaguely related related to what later comes to be called nationality, but most of them bearing no relation to it. great cultural diversity, complex political units and groupings
pp. 105 Advanced Industrial Society
radically different from agro-literate society, it is self-consciously based on sustained, continuous innovation, and on exponential growth in productive resources and output. theory of knowledge which makes nature intelligible without recourse to Revelation, and this also renders nature effectively manipulable and a source of ever-growing affluence.
Economic growth is the first principle of legitimacy of this kind of society: any regimes which fails to attain and maintain it is in trouble.
pp. 106 Human beings are usable only if educated, and education is expensive. Quality not quantity of personnel counts, and quality depends on the machinery of cultural production of men, in other words on 'education'. Offspring are not valued by authority for their military or productive potential, or by parents as a form of insurance. Offspring are expensive and must compete, often unsuccessfully, with other forms of satisfaction and indulgence.
Work involves controlling, managing and maintaining a machine with a fairly sophisticated control mechanism. (...) It involves the rapid manipulation of meanings and people through computers, or, at worst, telephones and typewriters and faxes, computerised tills, and so on.
pp. 107 Roughly speaking, the syllogism runs: work has become semantic, and work requires impersonal, context-free communication between individuals, members of a broad mass. This can be only done if the members of that broad mass share the same rules for formulating and decoding messages. In other words, they must share the same culture, and it will be a high culture, for this standardised skill can only be acquired in formal schooling. Access to the appropriate high culture, and acceptability within it, is a person's most important and valued possession: it institutes a pre-condition of access not merely to employment, but to legal and moral citizenship, to all kinds of social participation.
pp. 108 Society basically egalitarian: it cannot easily ascribe rank, for such permanent rank would often come into conflict with the standing entailed by the actual occupational effectiveness of the person in question.
pp. 109 The standardised educational system which processes the totality of the human material which goes to make up the society, which turns the biological raw material into an acceptable and serviceable cultural product, is enormous, and exceedingly expensive.
pp. 110 A mobile, atomised, egalitarian society with a standard culture is a literate, 'high' one, and where its dissemination, maintenance and boundaries are protected by a state. One culture, one state. One state, one culture.
materialist theory of nationalism: it derives the phenomenon to be explained from the basic manner in which society ensures its own material self-perpetuation.
The new society, based on expanding technology, semantic not physical work, on pervasive impersonal and often anonymous communication by means of context-free messages, and on an unstable occupational structure, is destined for a standardised, educationally transmitted high culture, more or less completely and pervasively diffused amongst all its members.
No ethnicity, with it we have Nationalist Irredentism triumphant and self-defeating
pp. 112-113 example of Europe on eve of French Revolution and afterwards economic growth and sustained political and ideological change with extensive urbanisation, fairly centralised polities, states had effective bureaucratic apparatus, Reformation introduced the idea of a direct private appeal to a socially independent fount of authority based on reason or experience. scientific revolution then philosophical thought. Enlightenment as a vision of secular, individualistic, and naturalistic world. civil society, separation of powers, liberal states became centralised and military.
18th century: individualistic pattern of kinship and household formation. Literacy and use for secular purposes.
Información
- Descripción
- Apunte sobre Sin título, creado por mjnous el 02/11/2015.
- Creado por
- mjnous · nov 2015
- Actualizado
- 19 feb 2016
- Visitas
- 9
- Valoración