The other a 69 year old
British woman Annie Besant
Based closely on the
campaigns for home
rule in Ireland in late
C19th
In Ireland took 4 attempts
between 1886 + 1914
Was then suspended
because of outbreak of
war
Showed Indians HR was a challenge
Congress discussed home
rule since 1905
Control of moderates
ensured never happened
Only involve
management of Indian
affairs
Besant stated was
"freedom without
separation"
Tilak emphasised it sought "reform of
the system of administration and not
the otherthrow of government"
Tilak stated in 1917 "if you want
Home Rule be prepared to defend
your home... you cannot reasonably
say that the ruling will be done by you
and the fighting for you"
SUCCESS
Tilak's Home Rule League for India
rapidly gained 32,000 members -
despite being based on 2 religions
(Maharastra and Karnataka)
Besant's All-India Home Rule was
smaller and grew slower but
network of committees covered
most of rest of India
Joined each other's organisations
Toured country giving
lectures and giving leaflets
RESPONSES
Congress was reluctant to
demand something as big
as Home rule even though
people joined Home Rule
leagues in great numbers -
including 2 future national
leaders Nehru + Jinnah
Other Indian groups also resistant -
especially Muslims and lower-caste
Hindus who thought government would
entrench Brahmin Hindu dominance
Viewed British as more
as protecting their
interests
British finally calmed agitation
caused by Partition of Bengal
by reuniting it in 1911 + liked
tame approach of the
moderate-controlled congress
One official reported "moderate
leaders can command no
support among the vocal
classes who are being led at the
heels of Tilak and Besant"
Orders given for swift arrest of Home
Rule campaigners whenever possible +
students forbidden to hold meetings
where Home Rule might be discussed
Tilak arrested and required
to put up 4,000 rupees as
surety of good behaviour.
Besant was interned
CONSEQUENCES
Montagu Declaration -
20th August 1917
declaration which promised
eventual self-government
When Besant freed -
elected president of
Congress in December
1917
Home Rule
movement quickly lost
momentum + failed to
achieve its objectives
Widely believed to have prepared the
way for the campaigns of Gandhi from
the 1920's onwards