Is the US Constitution Still fit for purpose?

jmrboswell
Mind Map by , created over 5 years ago

Politics Mind Map on Is the US Constitution Still fit for purpose?, created by jmrboswell on 04/26/2014.

340
0
0
Tags No tags specified
jmrboswell
Created by jmrboswell over 5 years ago
Higher Politics Essay Notes
Daniel Cormack
Functions of a Political Party
Phoebe Fletcher
Britain Under Margaret Thatcher - Timeline
Alanna Pearson
Basic Physics Concepts
Andrea Leyden
Biology 2b - Enzymes and Genetics
Evangeline Taylor
How Parliament Makes Laws
harryloftus505
How the European Union Works
Sarah Egan
The Cold War: An Overview
Andrea Leyden
HSC Economics
lydia le
The Cold War: An Overview_2
Andrea Leyden
Is the US Constitution Still fit for purpose?
1 Yes!
1.1 Federalism is a good compromise between strong national government and decentralisation (required do to diversity)
1.2 Text has adapted to changes in American society
1.3 Demanding amendment process has usually prevented ill-conceived amendments
1.4 Enumerated rights and freedoms have been protected
1.5 Judicial review has made it even more adaptable - 'interpretative amendment'
2 No!
2.1 Formal amendment is very difficult, even with majority support
2.2 Judicial review gives unelected justives too much power
2.3 Some parts are outdated (electoral college, second amendment, congress' power to declare war etc.)
2.4 The Founding Fathers wanted to prevent factions, but the Constitution institutionalises gridlock - bipartisanship has been replaced by hyperpartiasnship
2.5 Global foreign policy significance of the US unexpected - growth of presidential power

Media attachments