Condemns Catiline +
Supporters, poor
"seditious", Sullan
Veterans without money
Rome = Greedy/Corrupt, poor
desperate, turn to crime,
embellished version of speech,
not quite word or word, but
close
Politically motivated, emotionally involved, no
liable law, unrivalled access to sources,
intended for public consumption, win support for
him + senate, justify execution, invents 1st
conspiracy, poor sullan veterans around at time
- credible.
Orations Pro Murena
Says Military glory greatest
glory to be had - Cicero
rhetoric? court of law
defending murena after
accusation of bribery -
prevalent in Rome, "Man of
character and principle".
Politically motivated, emotionally involved,
no liable law, Cicero did not hold Military
success but valued it
Letters to Atticus
Complains of high interest rates 48% interest
rates - Scaptius (corruption) and Clodius gangs,
private letters to trusted friend, not intended or
publication. Also no-one knowing where he had
been during province Sicily.
Good overview of all events,
contemporary, private correspondence -
suicidal thoughts, published by Tiro,
Contemporary to events - access to
Crassus letters, references lack of 1st
conspiracy - might of defended Catiline
- would not defended someone who
tried to bring down republic.
Letters to Cato
Wants a triumph over a small military
victory in Cilicia - border dispute. Cato
refuses suggesting a thanksgiving instead.
Cicero wants military success - desirable
to attain, still not associated/intergrated
well with the Roman optimates faction.
Good overview of all events,
contemporary, high position/politically
savvy
Pro Sestio
defends Cisius on charges on of
corruption. Calls him a man of
"character and principle"
Agrian Law
Changes name of
populares to optimates
Sallust
Catiline Conspiracy
Catiline fails 3 consulship
attempts.Tries to take Rome by force
with poor and disparate. Includes
speech of Catiline - minority have all
power, not Roman. Speech of
Caesar/Cato - whether the prisoners
should be executed, decide they
should - Catiline letter to Catalus -
birth right to be consul as optimates.
Admits own corruption, contemporary - in Senate
house during events, part of political elite, access to
Imperial archives, attempts objectivity, equal blame
on optimates/populares, reliant on orations by Cicero
- believes the first conspiracy, Apologist for Caesar?
Sallust reinstated into the senate house by Caesar
later - trying to excuse Caesar of involvement -
populares, uses own set speeches to show off
rhetoric, called Roman thucydides, letter from
Catalus to Catiline word for word, senator of the time
- knows intimate detail.
Histories: Speech of Macer
Macer appeals to the people, "do not change
name of slavery to peace", Senators corrupt,
riles people to revolt, Demagouge, Pompey
solution - restore the tribune (73BC still dead
end job under Sullan reforms. Source somewhat
out of context as only fragments survived.
Contemporary, admits own corruption, Imperial
archive, was a popularise tribune - would know
what a ambitious Tribune might say, set
speeches - show off Rhetoric, similar to words
of Catiline.
Quintus Cicero
Handbook to electioneering
Talks of being Novus Homo - use Rhetoric to establish
connections, congregate with those of rank that you wish to
achieve, be known and seen in Rome - C.F. Letters to Atticus,
coming back from province in Sicily and no-one knowing where
he had been.
Private correspondence? may have been intended for public consumption, explains steps
needed to take for the Cursus honorum, brother/supporter of Cicero, Contemporary, authorship
questionable, tailored to show how Cicero can succeed, good account of a Novus Homo, but
cannot generalise,
Plutarch
Life of Pompey
Money: triumprhiate had access to loans - Crassus (richest
Roman ever), also loot from campaigns in East -
Kings/Triumphs, Connections:Crassus, Caesar, Pompey,
father was a military general/noble. Rode alongside Sulla on
conquest of Rome - hailed as "Imperator" by Pompey. Military:
Spain, East, Lucullus (Italy), Sertorious (went to Spain to raise
tribes+knew Roman military system), Mithridates (East). Luck:
Spartacus - mopping up the remainder of the rebellion,
claiming triumph over Crassus.
Life of Caesar
Connections, Marius marrying his Aunt - family ties, Caesar then
reinstated statues of Marius after Sulla, Daughter married
Pompey - seal connections within Triumphriate. Money, puts on
massive games as Aedile - 300 pairs of gladiators in silver
armour, bribes the tribunes to get what he wanted - Cisalpine
Gaul through popular assembly opposed to Forests of Italy.
Military glory, Gaul - defeating Germanic tribes course of 10 years
- (from 59BC). Shows qualities needed for Roman success.
Life of Cicero
Corroborates with his letters to
Atticus, had a post consular command
in Cilicia.
Lived 100 years after, objective, access to range
of sources (Lycurgus consults 50 authors),
primary sources - Sulla's memoirs, removed from
emotional time, Roman - knew how system
worked, set template may force people to fit,
show cultural similarity of Rome/Greece - justifies
own conversion to Rome, time distant, focusses
on facts not gossip like Suetonius, will say if
unsure - Lycurus, short serious biographies,
embellishes with anecdotes to give a character
sketch.
Appian
Civil Wars
Moral decline of Rome since 146BC, describes
Catiline as evil, high level of support but easy eventual
defeat - "design of a madman", little coverage of
Conspiracy suggesting little importance/threat but
moderate interest, corroborates with much of sallust.
Access to sources - cites them
(proper historian), citizen of Rome -
lived in Roman Egypt, factual style,
epic history of Rome, Catiline
Conspiracy event of interest but not
massive deal - small coverage
provides context, good Hindsight.
Suetonius
The Twelve Caesars
Deified Julius
Connections, Marius marrying his Aunt - family ties,
Caesar then reinstated statues of Marius after Sulla,
Daughter married Pompey - seal connections within
Triumphriate. Money, puts on massive games as
Aedile - 300 pairs of gladiators in silver armour, bribes
the tribunes to get what he wanted - Cisalpine Gaul
through popular assembly opposed to Forests of Italy.
Military glory, Gaul - defeating Germanic tribes course
of 10 years - (from 59BC). Shows qualities needed for
Roman success.
Suetonius writes 100 years after - hindsight, objectivity, less likely
to promote individuals, broadly corroborates with Plutarch life of
Caesar, Director of Imperial archives, Writes under Emperors -
censorship? Set formula of biographies - exclude events - similar to
Arbituary - character centric, inflation of importance unlike Cassius
Dio who gives perspective. Reports rumour/gossip/sex lives of the
Emperors.
Cato uses a form of corruption/bribery to manipulate
the system: use of filibuster to prevent the senate
from voting Caesar to be able to stand in absentia for
consul - Caesar had gone to the Tribunate to get
Cisalpine gaul and so would be prosecuted if not in
office/out of Rome.