Mapa mental
Construction and Entitlement
Conteúdo do mapa
Construction and Entitlement
Construction
- Lord Diplock in Catnic v Hill & Smith: a patent specification should be given purposive construction rather than a purely literal one
- Too lenient a response to monopolisation?
- One must ask what 'purpose' the person skilled in the art would see in the specification
- Whether 'vertical' meant 90 degrees and nothing else in order to determine if the defendant's same creation which was 6 degrees less, was an infringment
- Lord Diplock in Catnic v Hill & Smith: a patent specification should be given purposive construction rather than a purely literal one
Entitlement
- s7(4): the person who makes the application is taken to be the person entitled to be granted a patent (a rebuttable presumption)
- Inventor = 'actual deviser' of the invention
- Henry Brothers: 1) patent must be interpreted to ascertain the inventive concept 2) then it must be determined who contributed that concept
- Inventive concept: doing something which helps solve a particular problem (Yeda) or posing the problem to be solved (Staeng's Patent)
- Yeda: it is insufficient to ask who contributed to the claims, because the claims can include non-inventive matter derived from the prior art. The question is whether someone has contributed an inventive concept.
- Contributions: unnecessary detail (University of Southampton) or provision of money, material or facilities are classified as non-inventive contribution
- Joint inventorship: a person who comes up with and communicates an idea consisting of all the elements of the claim will normally be treated as an inventor (Stanelco)
- contributing advice or assistance is, on its own, unlikely to amount to inventorship (Staeng's Patent) and merely applying the common general knowledge will not be regarded as inventive (University of Southampton)
- Henry Brothers: 1) patent must be interpreted to ascertain the inventive concept 2) then it must be determined who contributed that concept
- Employment Inventorship
- s39(1) an invention made by an employee must be taken to belong to him employer if:
- s39(1)(a): made in the course of employee's normal duties (or those specifically assigned) and reasonable to expect invention to result from carrying out such sduties
- Scope of duties:consider job description and contract (Staeng's Patent), employee's actual activities can be considered (LIFFE), was the invention made in the scope of the duties? When and where was it made? Relationship between invention and employer's field? Whose facilities did the employee use?
- Reasonable expectation: need not be an expectation that this precise invention would be made, but also not enough to expect 'any' invention - might mean expectation of this kind would be made. Also, was the employee engaged to invent/design? If so, more likely to satisfy (Harris)
- s39(1)(b): made in the course of employee's duties and there is a special obligation to further interests of employer's undertaking because of the nature of those dutie
- "Special obligation" generally means holding a senior position within the organization (senior executive, director, manager). Can include ower to hire, fire, agree holiday dates, attendance at board meetings, degree of financial control may all play a role in determining seniority. (Harris' Application) Or attendance at board meetings, acting in a similar capacity to directors, control over budgetary matters, discretion over whether to solve problems themselves may indicate sufficient seniority. (Staeng's Patent)
- s39(1)(a): made in the course of employee's normal duties (or those specifically assigned) and reasonable to expect invention to result from carrying out such sduties
- s39(1) an invention made by an employee must be taken to belong to him employer if:
- s8(1)(a): determination of entitlement BEFORE grant - any person may refer to the Comptroller (UK IPO) whether they are entitled.
- s8(1)(b): any of two or more co-proprietors of an application for a patent may ask whether any right in or under the application should be transferred or granted to any other person;
- s37(1): determination of entitlement AFTER grant - any person having or claiming a proprietary interest in the invention can ask a) WHO is the true proprietor(s), b) WHETHER the patent should have been granted to WHOM IT WAS GRANTED to or c) WHETHER any right SHOULD BE TRANSFERRED
- Must be within 2 years of the grant
Compensation
- s40(1): the employee has made an invention (and patent) belonging to the employer which is of outstanding benefit to the employer and the employee should be awarded compensation to be paid by them
- "Outstanding benefit" = must arise from the intention or patent / meaning money or money's worth that has been ACTUALLY achieve (Shanks)
- s40(2): where the employee has assigned their rights to the employer and the benefit derived by the employee from the derivation is inadequate in relation to the benefit derived by the employer, the employee should be awarded compensation to be paid by the employer in addition to the benefit derived
- s40(1): the employee has made an invention (and patent) belonging to the employer which is of outstanding benefit to the employer and the employee should be awarded compensation to be paid by them
Informações
- Descrição
- Intellectual Property (Patents) Mapa Mental sobre Construction and Entitlement, criado por Abi Simpson em 06-02-2019.
- Criado por
- Abi Simpson · fev 2019
- Atualizado
- 14 abr 2019
- Visualizações
- 6
- Avaliação