Ajude a dar forma ao GoConqr. O que a gente deve adicionar?

Notas

Product Liability - CASE LIST

Morgan Moriarty Tort Law FE 1 Inglês 1 página

Conteúdo das notas (1)

Página 1

Liability for Defective Products

Liability for Defective Products Act 1991 -

Definitions -

Damage - death, personal injury, damage to property - property must have been used for private purposes.

Injured Person - person who has suffered damage wholly or partly due to the defective product.

Product - a movable or immovable product - even if it is incorporated into another product.

Personal injury - includes any disease and any impairment of a person's physical or mental condition.

Producer, Supplier and Basis of Liability

Section 2(1) - regime of strict liability - producer is liable for damage caused by defect in product.

Producer - Section 2(2) - (a) manufacturer or producer of finished product - (b) manufacturer or producer of any raw material or component part - (c) in cases of products of soil or fishing - person who carried out processing of product (d) any person who has added his trademark to the product to indicate it as theirs (e) any person who has imported the product into a member state from outside the EU - (f) any person liable as producer from section 3

McGarry v McGarry - person who built the flat pack table which collapsed on an infant was liable as a producer.

Section 2(3) - suppliers can be liable if they fail to identify producers - (2) if producer cannot be easily identified by taking reasonable steps - (3) injured party requests the producer to be identified (4) request is made within reasonable time of the harm and (5) supplier fails to identify the producer

Limitation of Damages

Section 3 - provides damage must be over €350 - damages will be difference between award and minimum threshold of 350

You can seek remedy for damage caused but you cannot recover for loss of product - that would be done under contract law or the sale of goods and supply of services act.

Defective:

Section 5 - product is defective if it fails to provide the safety which a person is entitled to expect

(1) presentation of the product - adequate warnings and instructions for safe use or installation

(2) use to which it could be put - objective test of reasonableness -

X v Johnson and Johnson - gross misuse of the product - tampon placed in urethra - not a defect.

(3) Time it was put into circulation - what the person can expect of the product.

Consumer expectation test.

A v National Blood Authority - consumer entitled to expect blood not to be contaminated

Bogle v McDonald's - hot drinks are meant to be hot so they were not defective.

Pollard v Tesco - consumer may have expected a carton of dishwasher powder to be impossible for a child to open but the court found they were only entitled to expect the cap to be harder to open than a normal screw cap - no defect.

Connolly v FÁS - complying with EU directives on product safety was insufficient and irrelevant where the EU directive was inadequate itself.

Causation

Section 4 - claimant must prove the damage, the defect and the causation between the two.

Riboux v SA Schweppes - suffered injury when a bottle exploded - could not prove the causation but court inferred it as bottles would not be expected to explode absent a defect.

Richardson v LRC Products - top fell off condom but users were not entitled to expect a condom to work 100% of the time so he did not have a claim under defective products

Defences

Section 6 -

1 - producer did not put the product into circulation - Veedfald v Aarhus - (1) person other than the producer has caused the product to be put into circulation - (2) product used contrary to producer's intention (3) where manufacturing process is incomplete.

O'Byrne v Sanofi - product in circulation when it leaves the production process operated by producer and enters marketing process in the form in which it is offered to the public to be consumed.

2 - Defect came into existence after the product was put into circulation - this is a defence unless the defect came into existence during production.

3 - non-commercial producers - you will not be statutorily liable for messing around in a garden and creating a product - this is meant for commercial activity.

4 - compliance with mandatory statutory requirements - hard to envisage many cases where statutory requirements are defective - Connolly v FÁS ?

5 - Development Risks / State of the Art Defence - only applies to design defects - must involve state of scientific and technological knowledge at the time of development or production -

Scholten v Sanguin - HIV contracted from blood but was during 3 month window where it was impossible at the time to detect it.

6 - component producer defence - if you adequately provide a product for use in a larger product which is then used incorrectly leading to a defect - i.e. nuts and bolts in a larger product.

Limitation Periods -

three year period for personal injury

10 year long-stop defence for defect in product.

Other sections:

Section 9 - contributory negligence - using the product unreasonably - consumer expectation test.

Section 10 - producer cannot limit liability for defective products with terms in contract

Section 11 - action in negligence is available if no strict liability can be availed of under the act.

Informações

Descrição
FE 1 Tort Law Notas sobre Product Liability - CASE LIST, criado por Morgan Moriarty em 07-08-2020.
Criado por
Morgan Moriarty
Visualizações
0
Avaliação

Fale Conosco

Sobre o que é sua mensagem?

O que a gente deve adicionar?