Apuntes
Mung & Wong (2019) - Depression and Coping
Contenido del apunte (10)
Página 1
Mung & Wong (2019) - Depression and Coping:
ABSTRACT
This longitudinal study examined the association between Chinese children’s coping strategies and depressive symptoms within the context of the transition from preschool to primary school in Hong Kong.
Research Findings: Principal component analyses of children’s strategies for coping with stress during the transition to school revealed three factors: negative coping, positive coping, and distraction.
Children’s strategies were moderately stable over time, but the relationship between coping and depressive symptoms differed for boys and girls.
Girls’ positive coping strategies at Time 1 predicted fewer depressive symptoms at Time 2, whereas girls’ use of distraction positively predicted later depressive symptoms.
Boys’ depressive symptoms at Time 1 predicted negative coping strategies at Time 2.
The present findings show that distraction may not always be an effective way to help young children reduce depressive symptoms, and that coping strategies may have a greater impact on reducing later depression risk for girls than for boys.
Practice or Policy: Implications for future studies and practices are discussed at the end of this paper. This study provides information for educators and government and non-government organizations in developing programs to help children with effective coping strategies during their first year at school.
Página 2
Introduction:
Depression is one of the most significant contributors to illness and disability for both boys and girls ages 10 to 19 years (World Health Organization, 2014).
Childhood depression is associated with children’s relationship problems, school problems, somatic symptoms, and suicide risk (Son & Kirchner, 2000; Vogel, 2012).
A study of 8- to 15-year-old Chinese children found that children had significantly higher Children’s Depression Inventory scores than American children (Yu & Seligman, 2002).
A survey of 1,301 Chinese primary Grade 3 to Grade 6 pupils (8- to 12-year-olds) was conducted in Hong Kong. The findings showed that 1 in 7 pupils showed signs of depression, and 1 in 10 pupils suffered from serious depression (Ng, 2017).
In contrast, another survey of school children’s depressive symptoms, conducted by City University, found that 32% of participating primary school children in Hong Kong (N= 334) had depressive symptoms, and 12.6% were diagnosed as suffering from depression (Ming Pao, 2015).
Consistent with the response styles theory of depression (Nolen-Hoeksema, 1991), most research on adults and adolescents supports the proposition that individuals’ coping strategies determine both the severity and the duration of their depressive symptoms (Evans et al., 2015).
Hence, it is important to explore the early emergence of depressive symptoms among children younger than 8 years old and the associations between young children’s coping strategies and depressive symptoms.
If researchers can identify effective coping strategies used by children in their first year of primary school that are associated with less depressive symptoms, effective programs can be developed to decrease the severity and duration of these symptoms when children transition from preschool to primary school.
Previous research has shown that a child’s gender may moderate the links between his or her coping strategies and adjustment to school.
For instance, school-age girls tended to appraise stressors as being more distressing than boys did (Zimmer-Gembeck, Lees, Bradley, & Skinner, 2009).
Active coping was found to be negatively associated with depressed moods in preadolescent girls, and avoidant coping was found to be positively associated with adolescent girls’ depression (De Boo & Spiering, 2010; Seiffge-Krenke & Stemmler, 2002).
These factors were not found to be associated with depression in boys.
The present study aims to add to the literature on the links between coping strategies and depressive symptoms among children by exploring gender differences in young children’s coping and depressive symptoms during the transition to primary school.
Página 3
Stressors during the transition to primary school
Numerous stressors occur as children undergo the transition from preschool to primary school, including:
(a) changes in the curriculum, with hard work and limited play time (Einarsdottir, Dockett, & Perry, 2009; Margetts, 2013);
(b) changes in school rules (e.g., no speaking in class; Wong, 2015,2016, 2018; Dockett & Perry, 1999; Yeo & Clark, 2005); and
(c) changes in friendships and relationships (e.g., meeting new friends and new teachers, experiencing peer conflicts or aggressive behavior; Wong, 2017; Griebel & Niesel, 2002; Ladd, Kochenderfer, & Coleman, 1996; Margetts, 2013; Peters, 2003; Yeo & Clarke, 2005).
Education in Confucian-heritage settings (such as Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, and Hong Kong) is highly examination oriented, emphasizing competition among students and academic success (Carless & Lam, 2014).
Even though early childhood education is not compulsory in Hong Kong, because of the intense emphasis on education almost all 3- to 5-year-old children attend preschool programs (Wong & Rao, 2015).
Chinese students start primary schooling at the age of 6 in Hong Kong.
Students starting in Primary 1 are generally expected to spend a lot of time after school on academic work and preparing for examinations (Bray & Kwok, 2003; Carless & Lam, 2014).
A qualitative study of Year 1 to Year 3 primary school students in Hong Kong showed that lower primary school students’ (6- to 8-year-olds’) sense of satisfaction and negative feelings were associated with their academic performance (Careless & Lam, 2014).
A total of 36% of children’s responses indicated a positive affective response to examinations (e.g., feeling good or happy), and 47% showed a negative response to examinations (e.g., feeling scared, stressed, afraid, or unhappy).
Chinese children as young as 5 years old thought that a child with higher examination scores deserved more rewards than a child with lower scores (Wong & Nunes, 2014), and parents generally expected children to work hard in order to get good examination scores (Bond, 1991).
Thus, academic stress may be one of the stressors that contributes to Chinese children’s depressive symptoms.
It is likely that children’s depressive symptoms are associated with multiple stressors at school, such as:
-increased learning activities
-and reduced play time,
-nervousness about not meeting authority figures’ expectations in regard to academic performance,
-and peer competition and conflict at school.
Not much is known, however, about the early development of depressive symptoms before 8 years of age or about the link among Year 1 children’s stress, coping strategies, and depressive symptoms.
Much of the previous research on children’s transition to school has relied on reports from parents and teachers (e.g., Wong, 2013; Chan, 2012; Dockett, Manson, & Perry, 2006), although some studies have examined children’s perspectives on the transition to school (Wong, 2016, 2018; Dunlop, 2002; Einarsdottir et al., 2009; Griebel & Niesel, 2002; Peters, 2003; Yeo & Clark, 2005).
Margetts (2013) argued for the importance of interviewing children directly about their school life in order to acknowledge their agency in their own schooling. In this study, we interviewed children about how they coped with stress during the transition to school.
Página 4
Methods
Participants
In Hong Kong, 79% of primary schools are government funded (Hong Kong Census and Statistics Department, 2017).
Mothers and children were recruited for participation in this study through two government-funded primary schools in Hong Kong. Children’s ages at Time 1 ranged from 70 to 89 months old (M= 76.39, SD= 4.218).
Consent forms were sent to all Year 1 parents at the participating schools (about 150 families in total).
A total of 103 mothers, representing about a 70% response rate, gave written consent for their own and their children’s participation in this long itudinal study.
Questionnaire data at both time points were available for 99 mothers (100 mothers completed questionnaires at Time 1 and 99 mothers completed questionnaires at Time 2);
103 and 102 children were interviewed at Time 1 and Time 2, respectively.
Of the children, 55.3% were male.
In terms of family social class, the children were living in two districts:
(a) the North District, where the median monthly household income is lower than the median monthly domestic household income across all districts (i.e., 25,200 HKD per month);
(b) Tai Po, where the median monthly household income is higher than the median monthly domestic household income across all districts (Hong Kong Census and Statistics Department, 2017).
A total of 80% of the children were living in two-parent families.
Mothers’ ages ranged from 27 to 51 years (M= 37.27, SD= 4.66).
As can be seen in Table 1, most mothers had completed secondary school or a higher level of education. Finally, 46% of the mothers had full-time jobs, 11% were working part time, and 40% were homemakers.
Procedures
This article explores children’s use of coping strategies at two time points during their first year in primary school:
their third month in Year 1 (Time 1)
and their last month in Year 1 (Time 2)
and the association between children’s coping strategies and depressive symptoms at both time points.
Before child interviews and adult surveys (with the parents and teachers) were conducted, consent forms and information sheets introducing the purpose and procedures of the study were sent to heads of schools, parents, and teachers to ask whether they and their children/students would like to participate in the study.
Participation in the study was voluntary. All procedures were reviewed and approved by the university’s Human Research Ethics Committee.
After the schools and families had indicated that they were interested in participating in the study, ques- tionnaires were sent to the schools and families in November (the academic year starts in September in Hong Kong).
One interview was conducted with the children at school (the Children’s Stress and Coping Hypothetical-Enactive Interview, including children’s report of depressive symptoms). The interview lasted for about 20 min.
The interview began after we explained the procedure and gained the children’s verbal consent.
During the children’s last month in Year 1, the same questionnaires were sent to the parents and the children were interviewed using the same methods.
All items in the adults’ and children’s Hypothetical-Enactive Interview (including the younger version of KIDCOPE ) were independently forward- and back-translated by the first author and staff from the university, who are fluent in both Chinese and English.
Discrepancies between translators were resolved through discussion.
Permission to use the Chinese version of the Center for Epidemiologic Studies–Depression Scale for Children (CES-DC) was given by the authors (Li, Chung, & Ho, 2010).
This study focused on analyzing the relationship between children’s coping strategies and their reports of depressive symptoms. Other questionnaires completed by mothers and teachers were not discussed in this article.
Página 5
Measures
Children’s Stress and Coping Hypothetical-Enactive Interview
The Hypothetical-Enactive Interview has been widely used to explore children’s awareness of moral rules, moral emotions (Wong & Nunes, 2014; Woolgar, 2001), the representation of attachment security (Fairchild, 2006), and coping strategies (Green, Cillessen, Rechis, Patterson, & Hughes, 2008; Smetana, Wong, Ball, & Yau, 2014).
In the current study, children were presented with hypothetical dilemmas that reflected children’s daily experiences and were asked structured questions about how they would respond if they were the main character in the scenario.
‘The children in this study were interviewed during their third month (Time 1) and last month (Time 2) of Year 1 at primary school.
Three hypothetical situations were created by the first author based on findings from a previous study of Chinese children’s stress and coping during the transition from preschool to school (Wong, 2015,2016, 2018).
These hypothetical situations reflected stressors that are commonly experienced by children during the transition in both local and global contexts (Wong, 2016, 2018; Dockett et al., 2006; Einarsdotir et al., 2009).
The hypothetical stressful situations used here were:
(a) reduced play time and increased learning activities at home (“After going to school, the mother asked the child to do some reading every evening; as a result, the child did not have time to play with her doll or his robot”),
(b) nervousness about authority (“Being afraid to talk to the teacher during class and accommodating the school rule about not talking in class”),
and (c) bullying at school (“A peer took away the child’s snacks and called her names”).
The gender of the main character was matched to that of the child being interviewed.
After hearing each hypothetical situation, each child was asked what he or she would do if he or she were Siu Mei (for girls) or Siu Ming (for boys).
Each child was asked to state whether he or she would use any of 15 coping strategies to cope with the specific stressor.
These 15 coping strategies were adapted from the younger version of KIDCOPE (Naar-King, Ellis, & Frey, 2004, p. 250).
The younger version of KIDCOPE is a 15-item individual measure of children’s coping strategies.
Spirito, Stark, and Williams (1988) validated KIDCOPE for the assessment of coping strategies in children and adolescents ages 6 to 18 years; the internal reliability was found to be .83.
Other studies have reported moderate to high concurrent validity with other coping scales (Donaldson, Prenstein, Darcovsky, & Spirito, 2000; Spirito, Francis, Overholser, & Frank, 1996; Spirito, Stark, Williams, & Guevremont, 1989).
KIDCOPE has been used in different studies to explore 6- to 10-year-old children’s coping strategies (Barry, Callaghan, Wheeler, & Grocke, 2010; Bingen et al., 2012; Cadamuro, Versari, Vezzalim, Giovannini, & Trifiletti, 2015; Holen, Waaktaar, Lervag, & Ystgaard, 2012; Kaplan, Turner, & Badger, 2007).
These 15 strategies included:
problem-focused coping strategies (e.g., “Tried to fix the problem by doing something”), cognitive restructuring (“Tried to see the good side of things”)
blaming oneself or someone else for causing the problem, distraction/avoidance strategies (e.g., “Did something to forget it”),
support-seeking coping strategies (e.g., “Tried to feel better by spending time with others”),
emotion-focused coping strategies (“Yelled, screamed, or got mad”),
social withdrawal (e.g., “Stayed by myself”),
wishful thinking (e.g., “Wished I could make things different”), and resignation (e.g., “Did not do anything because the problem could not be fixed”; for details, see Table 2).
If the answer was yes, the response was coded as 1;
If the answer was no, the response was coded as 0.
Each child’s responses were tape recorded and marked on a record sheet. The following is an example of a story script (for girls): See table in article
Página 6
Reports of children’s depressive symptoms
The CES-DC was developed to identify depressive symptoms in population-based samples (Barkmann, Erhart, & Schulte-Markwort, 2008; Weissman, Orvaschel, & Padian, 1980).
The CES- DC consists of 20 standardized items used to evaluate depressive symptoms.
The items consist of statements in the first person about the emotional, cognitive, and behavior-related components of depression.
All items are evaluated on a 4-point Likert scale in relation to the child’s feelings during the previous week.
Responses to each statement are scored from 0 to 3 (0 = not at all, 1 = a little, 2 = some, 3 = a lot).
Total possible scores range from 0 to 60. Higher scores indicate a greater number of symptoms (Li et al., 2010).
Fendrich, Weissman, and Warner (1990) validated the CES-DC for screening for depressive disorder in children and adolescents (from 6-year-olds to adolescents).
The excellent construct validity and internal consistency reliability of the CES-DC across ages were reported in a study by Barkmann and colleagues (2008).
The CES-DC is currently “an internationally-used test that is based on a multidimensional approach to measuring depression in children and adolescents aged 6 to 17 years” (Li et al., 2010, p. 2583).
The reliability of the Chinese version of the CES-DC has been reported with test–retest reliability and internal consistency (Li et al., 2010).
Internal reliability was found to be .82 and .85 for the test and retest, respectively.
Test– retest reliability after a 2-week interval was .71 (intraclass correlation coefficient).
The average equivalence of the semantic rate was 96% and the Content Validity Index was 95%, which indicates that each item in the Chinese and English versions remained conceptually and idiomatically the same, which helps validate the content of the Chinese version of the CES- DC (Li et al., 2010).
Four choices were given to the child for each sentence (not at all, a little, some, and a lot). The coefficient alpha in the current sample was .87.
Página 7
Preliminary data analyses and approach to the main analyses
Before conducting the main analyses, we ran two principal component analyses to reduce the number of child coping variables for the main analyses.
The items entered into these analyses were the means of the 15 coping items (adapted from the younger version of KIDCOPE), averaged across the three situations at each time point.
An examination of the scree plot for the first time point showed that the results yielded three components accounting for 25%, 18%, and 8% of the variance, respectively (see Table 2).
The loadings showed that the first component was made up of negative coping strategies (i.e., kept quiet about the problem; blamed oneself for causing the problem; blamed someone else for causing the problem; yelled, screamed, or got mad; did not do anything because the problem could not be fixed).
The second component, in contrast, was made up of positive coping strategies (i.e., tried to see the good side of things, tried to fix the problem by thinking of an answer, tried to fix the problem by doing something or talking to someone, tried to calm down, wished one could make things different).
The third component (made up of only two items) assessed distraction (i.e., tried to forget it, did some- thing to forget it).
Coefficient alphas for the three scales were .74, .74, and .77, respectively. When the analysis was repeated on the Time 2 responses, the same three components were obtained, with only minor differences in the items making up the components (i.e., one difference per component).
To allow for direct comparison across the two time points, we calculated the components the same way at each time point using the Time 1 results.
The alphas at Time 2 were .66, .67, and .80. We calculated factor scores using unit weighting.
Because the negative coping scores were highly skewed at both Time 1 (skewness = 2.48) and Time 2 (skewness = 2.36), the natural log of these scores was used in the analyses.
After calculating the coping scores, we examined bivariate correlations between the coping measures and children’s depressive symptoms at both time points separately for boys and girls.
To examine predictors of changes in depressive symptoms over time, a cross-lagged panel model tested the direction of effects between children’s coping strategies and their reports of depressive symptoms.
This model involved examining all paths among the four main study variables (i.e., positive coping, negative coping, distraction, and children’s depressive symptoms) at each time point.
Children’s age at the first time point was a control variable in the analysis. We determined model fit by examining the chi square (ns), the comparative fit index (CFI; >.95), and the root mean square error of approximation (RMSEA; <.06; Hooper, Couglan, & Mullen, 2008).
We conducted structural equation modeling using AMOS (Version 24).
Because previous research in this area indicated that different patterns of results might be found for males versus females (Wang & Patten, 2002), a multiple group model was run to compare a model in which the parameters for boys and girls were constrained to be the same with a model in which they were allowed to differ.
Given the relatively small sample size (especially when results were considered separately for boys versus girls), and because this is the first study of its kind in this population, we discuss significant (p < .05) and marginally significant (p < .10) results to increase power and reduce the probability of Type II error.
Página 8
Results
Descriptive statistics
Children in this sample reported high levels of depressive symptoms (29% of children at both time points scored the clinical cutoff of 15 or greater).
A comparison of the children from the two schools across all variables showed that children from the school with the lower socioeconomic status reported higher levels of use of negative coping strategies at both Time 1 and Time 2: Time 1, t (97) = 2.38, p < .05; Time 2, t(97) = 2.03, p < .05.
There were no other significant differences between children from the two schools in regard to the other coping scores or the depressive symptoms.
Presented in Table 3 are bivariate correlations between the study’s variables organized separately by child gender (correlations for boys are above the diagonal, and correlations for girls are below the diagonal).
As can be seen in the table, the coping strategies were moderately stable over time (.25–.56), with children’s depressive symptoms stable only for boys (boys, r = .36, p < .01; girls, r = .08, ns).
As expected, positive coping strategies were negatively associated with negative coping strategies, primarily within time points.
Distraction, in contrast, showed inconsistent relationships with the other coping strategies within and across time points.
The relationship between coping and depressive symptoms differed for boys and girls.
For boys, negative coping strategies and depressive symptoms were positively related within both time points. There were no significant correlations for either positive coping strategies or distraction.
For girls, in contrast, only at Time 1 did coping predict depressive symptoms,
-with positive coping strategies at Time 1 being negatively correlated with depressive symptoms at both time points,
-negative coping strategies at Time 1 being positively correlated with depressive symptoms at both time points,
-and distraction at Time 1 being positively correlated with depressive symptoms at Time 2.
Table 4 reports changes in mean levels of the coping variables and depressive symptoms over time as assessed by four 2 × 2 (Time × Sex) repeated measures analyses of variance (multivariate analysis of variance approach).
No effects of child sex were significant, nor were any of the Time × Sex interactions.
As can be seen in the table, although depressive symptoms did not change over time, the use of positive coping and distraction strategies increased significantly and the use of negative coping strategies decreased significantly.
Página 9
Path analyses
Presented in Figures 1 and 2 are the results of the cross-lagged panel analysis. Only statistically significant (p< .05) and marginally significant (p < .10) paths are shown in the figures.
Marginally significant paths are presented because of the limited power when examining the genders separately.
All of the Time 1 predictors were allowed to correlate with one another.
These are not shown in the figures but are the same as the bivariate correlations in Table 2.
To achieve satisfactory fit, we allowed one pair of errors to correlate: the errors between positive coping and distraction at Time 2.
These errors were correlated (r = .35, p < .001, for girls; and r= .49, p< .001, for boys).
After we allowed these errors to correlate, the fit of the unconstrained model was good,χ2(10, N = 102) = 13.57, p = .19, CFI = .97, RMSEA = .059.
The constrained model (i.e., with parameters constrained to ensure that boys and girls were equal) showed unacceptable fit, χ2(40,N = 102) = 58.03, p = .03, CFI = .86, RMSEA = .067.
The unconstrained model showed significantly better fit than the constrained model,Δχ2(30, N = 102) = 44.46, p< .05, which suggested different patterns of results for boys and girls.
An examination of the paths in Figures 1 and 2 showed that, for both boys and girls, all except one of the coping strategies in the model (negative coping for girls) showed stability over time (standardized path coefficients ranged from .26 to .51).
Depressive symptoms were also stable over time but for boys only (.52).
For girls, two additional paths were found: both were paths from coping strategies at Time 1 to depressive symptoms at Time 2 (see Figure 1).
Specifically, girls who used positive coping strategies at Time 1 showed fewer depressive symptoms at Time 2, and girls who used distraction strategies at Time 1 showed more depressive symptoms at Time 2 (when we controlled for Time 1 depressive symptoms).
The finding that girls’ depressive symptoms at Time 1 did not predict any of the coping strategies at Time 2 is consistent with a causal model in which children’s coping influences later depressive symptoms as opposed to a model in which depressive symptoms lead to changes in children’s coping.
The results were very different for boys (see Figure 2).
Besides the significant stability of the paths and a negative path from children’s age at Time 1 to depressive symptoms at Time 2, several paths were found between Time 1 and Time 2 coping strategies (i.e., positive coping strategies at Time 1 positively predicted both negative coping strategies and distraction at Time 2, negative coping strategies at Time 1 positively predicted distraction at Time 2).
Finally, depressive symptoms at Time 1 positively predicted negative coping strategies at Time 2.
None of the coping variables for boys at Time 1 predicted depressive symptoms at Time 2.
So, unlike the case for girls, for boys the results are consistent with a causal model in which depressive symptoms lead to negative coping strategies over time, not the reverse.
To identify which paths contributed the most to the differences in the models for boys versus girls, we ran follow-up chi-square analyses, constraining each of the parameters separately and comparing the fit of these models to the unconstrained models.
Only the two largest differences between the parameters for boys and girls were significant: stability of depressive symptoms over time, χ2(1, N = 102) = 7.75, p < .01 (boys = .52, girls = −.09); path from child age at Time 1 to depressive symptoms at Time 2, χ2(1, N = 102) = 4.89, p < .03 (boys: −.33, girls: .07).
Given the small sample size and the complexity of the model, the other paths did not differ significantly from one another.
Página 10
Discussion
This study is the first exploratory study to examine the relationships between 6-year-old children’s coping strategies and levels of depressive symptoms.
It did so by examining young children in the Asian context during a time in which children were experiencing stress during the transition to primary school.
Given that this study was longitudinal, we can draw tentative inferences about the direction of causality between the children’s coping strategies and their depressive symptoms.
A surprising finding concerned the high levels of depressive symptoms reported by the 6-year-old children in this study—more than one quarter of the children (29%) exceeded the clinical cutoff on the CES-DC.
This number is considerably higher than the 10% to 13% reported in previous surveys of slightly older children (ages 8–12) in Hong Kong (Ming Pao, 2015; Ng, 2017).
Although the definitions of serious depression differed across studies, the current findings suggest that the stresses associated with the transition to primary school in Hong Kong might lead to particularly high levels of depressive symptoms in children in the first year of primary school.
However, given the small sample size in the present study, future research needs to examine the prevalence of depressive symptoms with more representative samples before such a conclusion can be drawn.
Despite the initially high level of depressive symptoms that children reported at the end of the third month of the school year, levels of depressive symptoms did not decrease by the end of the first year.
Children’s coping strategies, in contrast, did change over this time period, with children showing an increase in distraction and positive coping (e.g., problem solving and help seeking) and a decrease in negative coping (e.g., blaming themselves, blaming others, and doing nothing).
Therefore, by the end of the school year, children were learning to approach school stresses in much more adaptive ways, which could possibly reduce the likelihood of depressive symptoms in the future.
Previous research has shown that positive coping strategies (e.g., problem solving) are signifi- cantly associated with higher levels of perceived control and lower levels of depressive symptoms and hopelessness (Abela, Venderbilt, & Rochon, 2004; De Boo & Spiering, 2010; Evans et al., 2015; Smith & Somhlaba, 2015; Sugimura et al.,2014; Sun et al., 2010).
In the present study, girls’ use of positive coping strategies at Time 1 was associated with fewer depressive symptoms at Time 2.
Girls who used positive coping strategies were active in regard to problem solving, planning, and positive thinking and may have experienced a greater sense of control over their stressors and were therefore better at regulating their negative moods.
However, consistent with the work of De Boo and Spiering (2010) we did not find any association between positive coping strategies and levels of depressive symptoms among boys.
Boys’ and girls’ use of positive coping was stable over time, but boys who used positive coping strategies at Time 1 were more likely to use negative coping strategies and distraction at Time 2. Girls’ use of positive coping was not associated with distraction.
Girls’ use of distraction at Time 1 in this study increased depressive symptoms at Time 2; boys’ use of distraction was not significantly related to their depressive symptoms.
The present study’s findings are consistent with previous research showing that distraction may not always be an effective way of helping young children to reduce depressive symptoms.
Abela et al. (2004) argued that when young children use distraction, “they may be less likely than adults to attempt to cope with the problems once their sad mood is alleviated”(p. 668).
Thus, distraction may only help children to forget about the problem without solving it and therefore does not reduce stress or depressive symptoms in the long run.
Contrary to our predictions, we did not find that depressive symptoms were predicted by the use of negative coping strategies (blaming oneself or blaming others; keeping quiet about the problem; yelling, getting mad, or being resigned).
Research on Finnish adolescents found that emotional discharge (e.g., the venting of anger) and self-blaming were positively associated with depressive symptoms (Hänninen & Aro, 1996).
These differences in findings may be the result of differences in the children’s developmental stage.
Young children’s venting of anger or blaming strategies may be perceived as more acceptable coping strategies by parents and teachers, but adolescents’ venting of anger or self-blaming may receive different responses from others.
It is likely that a child who gets mad or yells will get more support from adults compared with an adolescent who does the same thing, as older children are expected to show greater competence in regard to emotional regulation.
We need to further confirm this hypothesis in future studies using a wider range of age groups and larger sample sizes.
We did not find an association between boys’ coping strategies at Time 1 and their depressive symptoms at Time 2.
However, boys’ depressive symptoms at Time 1 were associated with a greater use of negative strategies at Time 2.
Moreover, boys’ depressive symptoms, in contrast to girls’, were stable over time.
Evidence from this study shows that depressive symptoms during the first 3 months at school (Time 1) may have caused boys to use more of the less effective coping strategies at Time 2 (e.g., keeping quiet about the problem, blaming oneself or others, yelling, screaming, or being resigned).
The gender difference in stability was not due to differential reliability of the CES-DC for boys versus girls.
The coefficient alphas at Time 1 and Time 2 were .74 and .76 for boys and .73 and .75 for girls, respectively.
Girls’ use of positive coping strategies may have reduced depressive symptoms over time, but this was not the case for boys.
Boys’ and girls’ positive coping strategies may have been different from one another; however, with our sample size, we could not explore the association between specific types of positive coping strategies (planning, problem solving, positive thinking, trying to calm down, or wishful thinking) and depressive symptoms.
Wong’s (2018) study of Chinese children’s perceptions of school life found that, compared to boys, girls were more positive about learning before they started school, and more girls expressed positive attitudes toward teachers during their first year of school.
Even though girls talked more about negative peer relations during the first 3 months of school, girls expected more positive relationships among peers during the last month of kindergarten, and girls talked more about good peer relationships at school during the first 3 months and the last month of Year 1.
Girls in the current study may have been more effective at creating positive emotions than boys and, as a result, reduced their negative feelings about experiencing stress.
We need to investigate whether the association between coping strategies and depressive symptoms is moderated by children’s positive emotions and/or positive reappraisal in future studies.
Depressive symptoms in children may be determined by multiple factors (e.g., social support, parenting strategies, perceptions of the seriousness of the problem, positive or negative emotions) other than types of coping strategies used.
Future studies need to examine which factors may moderate the effects of coping strategies on depressive symptoms, such as:
-parenting stress,
-parent–child relationships,
-teacher–child relationships,
- peer relationships,
-parenting strategies (suppor- tive or negative),
-children’s interpersonal problem-solving skills,
-and a sense of helplessness.
The current findings need to be considered in light of the study’s limitations.
This study relied on questionnaire assessments to assess coping and depressive symptoms, and only single measures of each construct were available.
Moreover, the small sample size limited our ability to find significant differences between boys and girls in regard to some of the parameters in the models. Some of the findings were marginally significant.
The small number of schools also limits the generalizability of the findings.
Future studies need to replicate these findings with larger samples using multiple assessments of children’s coping and adjustment.
This study shows that different prevention programs may be needed for boys and girls.
Girls’ use of positive coping strategies predicted fewer depressive symptoms, but the results for boys’ coping strategies were consistent with a causal model in which depressive symptoms led to negative coping over time, not the reverse.
Previous research has shown that a positive association exists between depressive symptoms and negative coping strategies, and a negative association exists between positive emotions and depressive symptoms (Folkman & Moskowitz, 2000).
Other studies have shown that individuals who used negative coping strategies reported decreases in depressive symp- toms over time if they received social support (e.g., discussed their loss with friends; e.g., Abela et al., 2004; Nolen-Hoeksema, 2000).
Hence, helping children (especially boys) to make new friends and use positive thinking skills during the transition to school are important strategies that can help to reduce children’s depressive emotions during their first 3 months at school and can reduce children’s depressive symptoms in the long run.
Información
- Descripción
- Education Apunte sobre Mung & Wong (2019) - Depression and Coping, creado por Mon Lepouris el 18/03/2019.
- Creado por
- Mon Lepouris · mar 2019
- Actualizado
- 19 mar 2019
- Visitas
- 12
- Historial
-
- Creado por Mon Lepouris · 18 mar 2019
- Copiado por Mon Lepouris · 18 mar 2019
- Valoración