Flashcards
Sexual Offences Flashcards
Cards in this deck (36)
- 1The Extent of Sexual Offending2-3% of total police recorded crime.
38% increase in recorded sexual offences in England and Wales last year.
There has been a huge push for the police to record more offences - possibly linked to revelations about Jimmy Saville etc. - 2RapeRape has increased by 41% and assault has increased by 36%.
Rape is a gendered crime, but can be done by a post-operative transsexual.
It is governed by Sexual Offences Act 2003, s1 which lays out an objective test - linked to a social standard and not an individual mindset. - 3Assault by PenetrationGoverned by Sexual Offences Act 2003, s2.
It is a new offence and is the gender neutral equivalent to rape. - 4Is non-consensual sexual penetration harmful?It causes societal harm by promoting unacceptable attitudes towards women - serious sexual assaults towards women should be seen as violence, because it is an expression of domination and hatred of women.
Feminists, such as MacKinnon, argue that when you are a woman living in a patriarchal society, you are uanware of whether you are being raped. We need to be critical of consent.
Morgan argues that women often consent to sex when the sex is unwanted.
McGregor: The wrong of rape is the expression of disrespect for the value of the victim - the failure to secure their consent.
Rape very clearly expresses the inferiority of women.
It violates autonomy -
Without consent, sex is a breach of our autonomy. We should have the right to choose our sexual partners.
It is a harmful violation of bodily integrity - 5Pure RapeThe "sheer use of another person"
- 6Feminist scholar - Robin WestRape is a 'murder of the spirit'
- 7Intoxicated Sexual IntercourseGoverned by Sexual Offences Act 2003, s75(2).
It is a grey area of the law and presumes non-consensual sex.
It needs to be a lack of reasonable belief to constitute a sexual offence - it is not about your own perception. - 8Factual ConsentState of mind - someone saying 'yes' - statement of fact without moral circumstances.
- 9Legal ConsentWhere you are legally deemed to have consented, regardless of factual consent.
Section 74 of the Sexual Offences Act 2003 - 'a person consents if he agrees by choice, and had the freedom and capacity to make that choice.'
Intoxication - concerns us about capacity and freedom and choice. - 10R v BreeLeading case on intoxicated sex.
'...a drunken consent is still consent.' per Sir Igor Judge P.
C and D had had a long night of heavy drinking. C vomiting in the bathroom and D helps her. They go to bed and have sex. He claimed she consented but she cannot remember if she consented. D was charged with rape.
Consent doesn't happen at a static point. - 11Can the capacity to consent disappear whilst conscious?R v H
Capacity to consent is a purely legal question, and can diminish before C is unconscious. - 12Policy ImplicationsThe law should reflect common practice. If the rule on consent changed, we would end up with mass criminalisation. The number of rapists would rise exponentially.
- 13The Significance of Sexual AutonomyCapacity = autonomy.
Infringement of autonomy allows us to criminalise for a lack of legal consent.
Munro: setting high standards for what qualifies as consent will thus protect negative at the expense of positive autonomy, and vice versa.
1. Drunken, factual consent should = legal consent.
2. Capacity may not be relevant where a person is happy with their factual consent.
3. A woman may become drunk in order to consent and lose capacity. - 14The Ched Evans caseR v Evans
Evans and McDonald were accused of raping a woman in May 2012. V was very drunk - McDonald took her back to the hotel and text Evans saying "I've got a bird". Sexual acts happen and Evan turns up and has sex with her. They leave her and go home. V passes out and wakes up the next day. She reports it to the police. Her blood alcohol level is low.
Evans said she consented - she was enthusiastic and conscious. McDonald was acquitted but Evans convicted. He contested, saying it was inconsistent for one of them to be convicted - reasonable belief is context specific.
McDonald believed she consented - Evans knew that she most likely hadn't.
Intention is irrelevant - the law is only concerned with capacity to consent. - 15Should there be degrees of rape?Some argue that Evans did not violently rape her, and therefore he should be less culpable.
We consider 'rape' to have degrees but there is only one label - i.e. a 15 year old consenting to sex with an 18 year is rape, but a man forcibly having sex with a women also comes under the same label. - 16Unwanted sex in the absence of forceJulian Assange - was accused of 2 sexual assault cases.
1. Sex without a condom when contraception was agreed.
2. Sex with someone unconscious.
He denies the allegations.
George Galloway talked about Assange being brutish, but not a rapist.
Dripps: unwanted sex is not as bad as violence.
We therefore need degrees of rape.
Violence matters - not consent. - 17Low Conviction RatesRape has a low conviction rate. People will be unwilling to convict - juries don't like deciding against the law.
Attrition rate (crimes reported to the police and convicted) is 6% - disparity between reports and convictions.
Conviction rate is 56.9%
Norfolk: the conviction rate is regularly quoted without any proper explanation, analysis and context.
Vera Baird: there has been progress on tackling rape; but the fact is conviction rates are far too low.
Lees: the criminal justice system is 'actively perpetuating a world in which rape goes unpunished.' - 18The Role of Rape MythsDuncanson and Henderson: 'the jury are regularly held responsible for their failure to convict men accused of rape, because of the rape supportive attitude jurors are thought to bring with them into court.'
- 19What are rape myths?Burt: 'prejudicial, stereotyped, or false beliefs about rape, rape victims or rapists.'
'Nothing happened, no harm was done; she wanted or liked it; and she asked for or deserved it.' - 20Example 1 Rape Myth: Victim BlamingTempkin Krahe and Bieneck: 'blaming the victim for sexual assault is a robust phenomenon.'
Common argument - the behaviour is the fault of the complainant.
People are scared of reporting rape because of the 'blame culture' we live in.
Ken MacDonald: 'the jury brings into the courtroom a lot of attitudes we have been reading about.'
Finch and Munro: 'attributions of responsibility may be shared, but ultimately blame may not.' - 21Example 2 Rape Myth: 'Real Rape'Temkin and Krahe: belief in the 'real rape' stereotype is 'widely shared.'
Ellison and Munro - mock jurors were willing to accept that rapes 'do not involve strangers in the bushes' and were very receptive to the idea that the rapist did not need to be unknown to the victim. - 22Example 3 Rape Myth: She was 'asking for it'If a woman invites a man back for a cup of coffee after a night out, is this consent?
Men must now prove that a woman said 'yes' under tough new rape rules. - 23Post-sexual History EvidencePeople want to withdraw from these defence tactics. A link between past behaviour and what may have happened on a particular occasion. It is more reasonable to believe that C was more likely to have consented if they have had many past sexual partners.
- 24The movement to an objective test for belief in consentThe 2003 Act made it harder for men to argue that they had reasonable belief. Problem: it may be contingent on the jury.
The objective test takes on subjective realities. - 25Which beliefs are reasonable?Morgan: a man told his friends that his partner wanted to have sex with them all and he told them she would retaliate for sexual arousal. The men were all convicted of rape, despite their honest belief that she was consenting.
The jury did not believe that honest belief was possible. There is no purely objective or subjective test in law because the reasonable man is non-existent. - 26Deception and ConsentMediocre lies can deceive people into having sex - but do lies vitiate consent? Do they negate free choice?
Drawing a line would lead to mass criminalisation - we are desensitised to deceit. It is a normal part of life.
Gross: Words are understood to be 'part of a game that lovers play.'
Sexual intercourse is prima facie a good thing.
R v Williams - it is not acceptable to deceive someone into sex. The girl was deceived into the nature and purpose of the act. Conclusive presumption = strict liability.
Temkin: there is a moral distinction between different kinds of deceit.
R v DPP and A - A wife consented to sex with her husband on the condition that he did not ejaculate inside her. He did so purposely. The CPS did not prosecute, but the Court held her consent to have been negated = rape. - 27R v LinekarA man slept with a prostitute and ran away without paying her. The court said the deceit was detached from the sexual act in itself.
- 28Deception as to GenderR v McNally - McNally and V met online. She was an alleged man called Scott. They had an online relationship for 3 and a half years. They met up and had sex, but D used a strap-on. The victim was unaware that she was actually female. She was convicted of assault by penetration. The deception didn't give her the choice to consent.
- 29Gayle NewlandNewland posed as a man and introduced herself to V. They developed a 2 year physical relationship. V and 'Kai' had sexual encounters but V was blindfolded. Kai said he was self-conscious about his body. The blindfold came off and V saw that Kai was female. The prosthetic penis was said to be roleplay. She was convicted of assault by penetration.
The law should uphold our right to choose which gender we have sex with. - 30Sexual Intercourse with Animals and CorpsesThe level of offending is less serious than rape or assault by penetration.
Intercourse with an animal is only relevant to living animals and is more regular than the occurrence of sex with a corpse.
It is governed by Section 69 of the Sexual Offences Act 2003. - 31The History of Sexual Intercourse with Animals and CorpsesGoverned by the Buggery Act 1533. It was an offence of sodomy, and resulted in a death sentence.
It is now less serious because of the increasing role of religion.
We are interested in the criminalisation of sex with animals because they cannot consent (section 74, SOA 2003) - BUT they don't consent to being slaughtered for meat?
The relationship between an animal and its owner is a slave/master relationship - animals therefore have the same capacity as children.
Animals have dignity and we should respect that - but why does this matter with sex but nothing else? - 32Sexual Penetration of a CorpseGoverned by section 70 of the Sexual Offences Act 2003.
Feinberg's offence principle: offence is less serious than harm
'Deep person affronts': if you do something to someone you are so deeply involved with, it feels like it could relate to you personally. - 33Difference between animals and humansHumans intrinsically have greater worth than animals. Even when an animal is alive and a human is dead. We have natural empathy with other humans.
Singer argues for animal rights. He says that a baby has less capacity than some animals. If we want to protect the baby, we must protect the same animals. You cannot pick out species. - 34DisgustNussbaum: Disgust regulates and deals with most of our behaviour.
Is that enough for criminalisation? - 35The law prior to 2003Condemned as 'archaic, incoherent and discriminatory.'
SOA 2003 supposedly modernised the law to reflect changes in societal attitudes.
Concern remains - the criminalisation of some behaviour is unwarranted and there is a great deal of complexity and overlap between the offences.
Baroness Stern: "the policies and laws enacted since 2003 are the right ones, but the real failure lies within their implementation."
The Home Office documents 'Protecting the Public' and 'Setting the Boundaries' resulted in the 2003 Act. - 36The Changes in the LawThe offence of rape has been broadened - it covers oral and anal penetration too. The previous law only covered vaginal.
The statute encompasses gender-neutral language to some extent - Herring said it covers transsexuals.
Huge emphasis on consent - SOA abolished the standard approach of the 'word consent should be given its everyday meaning.' There is now a definition in S74.
Mens Rea - abolished the position of genuine belief in Morgan (the belief could be unreasonable) to a reasonable belief test, which is problematic and confusing.
Information
- Description
- Flashcards on Sexual Offences Flashcards, created by emhutton on 14/04/2016.
- Created by
- emhutton
- Views
- 2
- Rating