Help shape GoConqr. What should we add next?

Flashcards

Sexual Offences & Consent

Shannon Russell English 31 cards

Cards in this deck (31)

  1. 1Consent is an attitude that is formed in the mind of the consenter. Any actions are merely evidence of that mental state but don't, in themselves, constitute consent.Hurd, 1996
  2. 2Consent is constituted by a set of actions of behaviours performed in a certain way. Parties change their rights and obligations by giving permission, achieved by speaking or doing.Brett, 1998
  3. 3The law on consent should avoid the mind/body dichotomy by encapsulating both elements. There must be a positive state of mind and an expressive action before consent is present.Cowan, 2008
  4. 4Rape now required a lack of consent and a recklessness as to whether there was consent.Sexual Offences Amendment Act 1976
  5. 5The case made it clear that rape was not limited to those cases which were a result of force, fear or fraud to denote a lack of consent. There was no need for the victim to physically resist. Consent was left undefined and said to be a common word.R v Olugboja
  6. 6Consent is defined as agreement and choice with the freedom and capacity to make that choice.s 74, 2003 Act
  7. 7Incapable of consenting because of being incapable through intoxication.s 13(2)(a), 2009 Act
  8. 8Rebuttable presumptionss 75, 2003 Act
  9. 9Irrebuttable presumptionss 76, 2013 Act
  10. 10A positive model of consent challenges normative ideas of sexually active men being sexual initiators whilst women are the passive sexual gatekeepers.Frith, 2009
  11. 11In England, whilst it is clear that the reference is not to total freedom or choice, the level of liberty is not clear.Tempkin and Ashworth, 2004
  12. 12England: it is not clear whether consent must be articulated by words or actions.Tadros, 2006
  13. 13It is necessary that juries are given a standard direction on the meaning of consent, particularly since they will have their own understandings of ‘freedom’ and ‘choice.Tempkin and Ashworth, 2004
  14. 14Used to be the case that a man having sex with a woman who was asleep could not be rape because it did not involve overcoming the will of the woman with force. This constituted a separate offence of clandestine injury .Rodgers v Hamilton
  15. 15England: Rebuttable presumption of no consent where unconscious or asleep.s 75(2)(d), 2003 Act
  16. 16Argued that it was impossible to consent whilst asleep when Bill going through Parliament.Rape Crisis Scotland
  17. 17In relation to the 2003 Act, illogical that the lack of consent of a sleeping person could be rebutted.Tempkin and Ashworth, 2004
  18. 18No consent when asleep compromises the autonomy of partners who choose to engage in this.Cowan, 2009
  19. 19Whilst it may be unlikely that a person in this situation would make a complaint, this does seem too wideTempkin and Ashworth, 2004
  20. 20Over-criminalisation by limiting the autonomy of the genuinely consenting sleeping person and their partner.Chalmers, 2009
  21. 21Apply the rule only to rape and assault by penetration with the other cases being left to the general definition of consentTempkin & Ashworth, 2004
  22. 22The purpose of the dual framework to defining consent is to educate police, prosecutors, juries and the general towards a better understanding of the term consent .SLC Report, 2007
  23. 23Dual framework on defining consent framework implies a moral hierarchy, where the most serious cases of non-consent are embodied within the list and the less serious falling within the general definition.Tadros, 2006; Cowan, 2009
  24. 24These cases that do not fall under the listed situations may then not be seen as “real rape”.Estrich, 1987
  25. 25The concept of consent should be used as little as possible because it is ambiguous, vague and distracts participants in trials from the question of whether the A respected B’s autonomy sufficiently.Tadros, 2006
  26. 26Many assume that an element of force by the perpetrator and physical struggle by the victim was required.Kelly, Lovett and Regan, 2005; Ellison and Munro, 2009
  27. 27Judgments by the jury as to whether consent was given were often on the basis of gendered expectations of socio-sexual behaviour.Ellison & Munro, 2009, 2010
  28. 28Consent was presumed where women invited men into their homes.Ellison & Munro, 2009, 2010
  29. 29Consent presumed where women acted in a provocative manner.Burt, 1980; Benedict, 1992
  30. 30Rather than defining sexual violence around consent, there should be a differentiated set of offences where reference is made to the different ways in which rape can be perpetrated.Tadros, 2006
  31. 31Steps could also be taken to educate the public as to what consent and a lack thereof can look like as changing attitudes over the long term is essential to preventing stereotypes being taken into account.Tempkin & Krahe, 2008

Information

Description
Flashcards on Sexual Offences & Consent, created by Shannon Russell on 06/05/2017.
Created by
Shannon Russell
Views
1
Rating

Feedback

What is it about?

What should we add next?