Flashcards
Sexual Offences & Consent
Cards in this deck (31)
- 1Consent is an attitude that is formed in the mind of the consenter. Any actions are merely evidence of that mental state but don't, in themselves, constitute consent.Hurd, 1996
- 2Consent is constituted by a set of actions of behaviours performed in a certain way. Parties change their rights and obligations by giving permission, achieved by speaking or doing.Brett, 1998
- 3The law on consent should avoid the mind/body dichotomy by encapsulating both elements. There must be a positive state of mind and an expressive action before consent is present.Cowan, 2008
- 4Rape now required a lack of consent and a recklessness as to whether there was consent.Sexual Offences Amendment Act 1976
- 5The case made it clear that rape was not limited to those cases which were a result of force, fear or fraud to denote a lack of consent. There was no need for the victim to physically resist. Consent was left undefined and said to be a common word.R v Olugboja
- 6Consent is defined as agreement and choice with the freedom and capacity to make that choice.s 74, 2003 Act
- 7Incapable of consenting because of being incapable through intoxication.s 13(2)(a), 2009 Act
- 8Rebuttable presumptionss 75, 2003 Act
- 9Irrebuttable presumptionss 76, 2013 Act
- 10A positive model of consent challenges normative ideas of sexually active men being sexual initiators whilst women are the passive sexual gatekeepers.Frith, 2009
- 11In England, whilst it is clear that the reference is not to total freedom or choice, the level of liberty is not clear.Tempkin and Ashworth, 2004
- 12England: it is not clear whether consent must be articulated by words or actions.Tadros, 2006
- 13It is necessary that juries are given a standard direction on the meaning of consent, particularly since they will have their own understandings of ‘freedom’ and ‘choice.Tempkin and Ashworth, 2004
- 14Used to be the case that a man having sex with a woman who was asleep could not be rape because it did not involve overcoming the will of the woman with force. This constituted a separate offence of clandestine injury .Rodgers v Hamilton
- 15England: Rebuttable presumption of no consent where unconscious or asleep.s 75(2)(d), 2003 Act
- 16Argued that it was impossible to consent whilst asleep when Bill going through Parliament.Rape Crisis Scotland
- 17In relation to the 2003 Act, illogical that the lack of consent of a sleeping person could be rebutted.Tempkin and Ashworth, 2004
- 18No consent when asleep compromises the autonomy of partners who choose to engage in this.Cowan, 2009
- 19Whilst it may be unlikely that a person in this situation would make a complaint, this does seem too wideTempkin and Ashworth, 2004
- 20Over-criminalisation by limiting the autonomy of the genuinely consenting sleeping person and their partner.Chalmers, 2009
- 21Apply the rule only to rape and assault by penetration with the other cases being left to the general definition of consentTempkin & Ashworth, 2004
- 22The purpose of the dual framework to defining consent is to educate police, prosecutors, juries and the general towards a better understanding of the term consent .SLC Report, 2007
- 23Dual framework on defining consent framework implies a moral hierarchy, where the most serious cases of non-consent are embodied within the list and the less serious falling within the general definition.Tadros, 2006; Cowan, 2009
- 24These cases that do not fall under the listed situations may then not be seen as “real rape”.Estrich, 1987
- 25The concept of consent should be used as little as possible because it is ambiguous, vague and distracts participants in trials from the question of whether the A respected B’s autonomy sufficiently.Tadros, 2006
- 26Many assume that an element of force by the perpetrator and physical struggle by the victim was required.Kelly, Lovett and Regan, 2005; Ellison and Munro, 2009
- 27Judgments by the jury as to whether consent was given were often on the basis of gendered expectations of socio-sexual behaviour.Ellison & Munro, 2009, 2010
- 28Consent was presumed where women invited men into their homes.Ellison & Munro, 2009, 2010
- 29Consent presumed where women acted in a provocative manner.Burt, 1980; Benedict, 1992
- 30Rather than defining sexual violence around consent, there should be a differentiated set of offences where reference is made to the different ways in which rape can be perpetrated.Tadros, 2006
- 31Steps could also be taken to educate the public as to what consent and a lack thereof can look like as changing attitudes over the long term is essential to preventing stereotypes being taken into account.Tempkin & Krahe, 2008
Information
- Description
- Flashcards on Sexual Offences & Consent, created by Shannon Russell on 06/05/2017.
- Created by
- Shannon Russell
- Views
- 1
- Rating