Mind map
Loss of control:

Mind map: Loss of control defence
Map content
Loss of control:
Special defence
- Only a defence to murder
Partial defence
- Only reduces liability- does not result in acquittal
Burden of proof is on prosecution
- Must disprove the defence beyond reasonable doubt
The CORONERS AND JUSTICE ACT 2009 abolished the common law rule of provocation and replaced it with a new partial defence of 'loss of control'
- Under s.54 (1) of the CORONERS AND JUSTICE ACT 2009 the partial defence of loss of control has 3 elements to it which have to be satisfied:
- D's acts or omissions in killing V resulted from D's loss of self-control; and
- Did D lose his or her self-control?
- Must be evidence to show that there was a complete loss of self control by D and that as a result of this, D caused the death of V
- S.54 (2) of the 2009 Act makes it clear that the loss of control need not be sudden. The defence might still apply where there was a delay between the provocative incident and the killing.
- If there is any evidence of a considered desire for revenge on D's part, then the defence is not available: S.54 (4). The greater the level of deliberation by D, the less likely it will be that the killing followed a true loss of control.
- IBRAMS AND GREGORY (1981)
- D may have suffered provocative behaviour from v over a long period of time (eg abusive relationship). The jury will take into account all previous things done or said to help decide whether the last incident of provocation actually caused D to lose their self-control.
- Did D lose his or her self-control?
- The loss of self-control had a qualifying trigger; and
- S.55 of the 2009 Act says that a loss of control has a qualifying trigger if D's loss of self-control was due to: D's fear of serious violence; or certain things done or said that amount to extremely grave provocation and cause D to have a justifiable sense of being seriously wronged.
- D will need to show that he or she lost self-control because of a genuine fear of serious violence. D's fear does not have to be reasonable.
- Trying to aid 'battered women' and a person who uses excessive force in self-defence.
- The threat of violence need not be from V. However the fear of serious violence needs to be in respect of violence against D or against another identified person.
- D's fear of serious violence must not be caused by something D deliberately encouraged in order to provide an excuse to kill V: S.55 (6)(a)
- S.55 (4) sets out when things done or said can amount to a qualifying trigger for the loss of self-control: the things done or said must amount to extremely grave provocation; and cause D to have a justifiable sense of being seriously wronged.
- Appears to be an objective test
- Jury must be convinced that D's sense of being seriously wronged by the things done or said would have been shared by a reasonable person.
- ZEBEDEE (2012)
- Jury must be convinced that D's sense of being seriously wronged by the things done or said would have been shared by a reasonable person.
- What is meant by 'justifiable' and 'seriously'?
- D's sense of being seriously wronged is not justifiable if D deliberately encoiraged the thing done or said in order to provide an excuse to kill: S.55 (6)(b)
- Something done or said that amounts to sexual infidelity is not on its own a qualifying trigger:S.55 (6)(c). However, where other factors count as a a qualifying trigger, sexual infidelity may be taken into account in assessing whether there was a sufficient qualifying trigger.
- 'Sexual infidelity' is undefined. Unclear what amounts the this.
- Appears to be an objective test
- D will need to show that he or she lost self-control because of a genuine fear of serious violence. D's fear does not have to be reasonable.
- S.55 of the 2009 Act says that a loss of control has a qualifying trigger if D's loss of self-control was due to: D's fear of serious violence; or certain things done or said that amount to extremely grave provocation and cause D to have a justifiable sense of being seriously wronged.
- A person of D's sex and age, with a normal degree of tolerance and self-restraint and in the circumstances of D, might have reacted in a similar way to D.
- Under S.54 (1) of the 2009 Act, loss of control is only available if the jury is satisfied that a person of D's sex and age, with a normal degree of tolerance and self-restraint and in the circumstances of D, might have reacted in a similar way.
- Limits defence
- The reference to 'in the circumstances of D' means the jury can take into account all of the circumstances D finds himself, except those which impact upon D's general level of self-control:S.54 (3)
- Circumstances other than sex and age of D taken into account include: if D is unemplyed, suffers from mental illness, has a history of being abused at the hands of V, or if they are taunted about a severe alcohol or drug problem.
- ASMELASH (2013)
- The defence will fail if the jury consider that the reasonable person might have lost control but might not have reacted in the same or similar way to D.
- Circumstances other than sex and age of D taken into account include: if D is unemplyed, suffers from mental illness, has a history of being abused at the hands of V, or if they are taunted about a severe alcohol or drug problem.
- Under S.54 (1) of the 2009 Act, loss of control is only available if the jury is satisfied that a person of D's sex and age, with a normal degree of tolerance and self-restraint and in the circumstances of D, might have reacted in a similar way.
- D's acts or omissions in killing V resulted from D's loss of self-control; and
- Under s.54 (1) of the CORONERS AND JUSTICE ACT 2009 the partial defence of loss of control has 3 elements to it which have to be satisfied:
Information
- Description
- Mind Map on Loss of control:, created by Elinor Rhodes on 30/11/2014.
- Created by
- Elinor Rhodes
- Views
- 15
- Rating
More on Partial defences to murder