Help shape GoConqr. What should we add next?

Mind map

Loss of control:

Elinor Rhodes English

Then a mind map on Loss of control defence: Special defence, Partial defence, Burden of proof is on prosecution

Mind map: Loss of control defence

Map content

Loss of control:

  1. Special defence

    • Only a defence to murder
  2. Partial defence

    • Only reduces liability- does not result in acquittal
  3. Burden of proof is on prosecution

    • Must disprove the defence beyond reasonable doubt
  4. The CORONERS AND JUSTICE ACT 2009 abolished the common law rule of provocation and replaced it with a new partial defence of 'loss of control'

    • Under s.54 (1) of the CORONERS AND JUSTICE ACT 2009 the partial defence of loss of control has 3 elements to it which have to be satisfied:
      • D's acts or omissions in killing V resulted from D's loss of self-control; and
        • Did D lose his or her self-control?
          • Must be evidence to show that there was a complete loss of self control by D and that as a result of this, D caused the death of V
          • S.54 (2) of the 2009 Act makes it clear that the loss of control need not be sudden. The defence might still apply where there was a delay between the provocative incident and the killing.
          • If there is any evidence of a considered desire for revenge on D's part, then the defence is not available: S.54 (4). The greater the level of deliberation by D, the less likely it will be that the killing followed a true loss of control.
            • IBRAMS AND GREGORY (1981)
          • D may have suffered provocative behaviour from v over a long period of time (eg abusive relationship). The jury will take into account all previous things done or said to help decide whether the last incident of provocation actually caused D to lose their self-control.
      • The loss of self-control had a qualifying trigger; and
        • S.55 of the 2009 Act says that a loss of control has a qualifying trigger if D's loss of self-control was due to: D's fear of serious violence; or certain things done or said that amount to extremely grave provocation and cause D to have a justifiable sense of being seriously wronged.
          • D will need to show that he or she lost self-control because of a genuine fear of serious violence. D's fear does not have to be reasonable.
            • Trying to aid 'battered women' and a person who uses excessive force in self-defence.
            • The threat of violence need not be from V. However the fear of serious violence needs to be in respect of violence against D or against another identified person.
            • D's fear of serious violence must not be caused by something D deliberately encouraged in order to provide an excuse to kill V: S.55 (6)(a)
          • S.55 (4) sets out when things done or said can amount to a qualifying trigger for the loss of self-control: the things done or said must amount to extremely grave provocation; and cause D to have a justifiable sense of being seriously wronged.
            • Appears to be an objective test
              • Jury must be convinced that D's sense of being seriously wronged by the things done or said would have been shared by a reasonable person.
                • ZEBEDEE (2012)
            • What is meant by 'justifiable' and 'seriously'?
            • D's sense of being seriously wronged is not justifiable if D deliberately encoiraged the thing done or said in order to provide an excuse to kill: S.55 (6)(b)
            • Something done or said that amounts to sexual infidelity is not on its own a qualifying trigger:S.55 (6)(c). However, where other factors count as a a qualifying trigger, sexual infidelity may be taken into account in assessing whether there was a sufficient qualifying trigger.
              • 'Sexual infidelity' is undefined. Unclear what amounts the this.
      • A person of D's sex and age, with a normal degree of tolerance and self-restraint and in the circumstances of D, might have reacted in a similar way to D.
        • Under S.54 (1) of the 2009 Act, loss of control is only available if the jury is satisfied that a person of D's sex and age, with a normal degree of tolerance and self-restraint and in the circumstances of D, might have reacted in a similar way.
          • Limits defence
          • The reference to 'in the circumstances of D' means the jury can take into account all of the circumstances D finds himself, except those which impact upon D's general level of self-control:S.54 (3)
            • Circumstances other than sex and age of D taken into account include: if D is unemplyed, suffers from mental illness, has a history of being abused at the hands of V, or if they are taunted about a severe alcohol or drug problem.
              • ASMELASH (2013)
            • The defence will fail if the jury consider that the reasonable person might have lost control but might not have reacted in the same or similar way to D.

Information

Description
Mind Map on Loss of control:, created by Elinor Rhodes on 30/11/2014.
Created by
Elinor Rhodes
Views
15
Rating

More on Partial defences to murder

Feedback

What is it about?

What should we add next?