Help shape GoConqr. What should we add next?

Mind map

Schrader: FILM NOIRS

Jonny South English

Mind map on Schrader film noirs: Paul Schrader's 'Notes on Film Noir', stylistics, themes and existentialism

Mind map: Schrader film noirs

Map content

Schrader: FILM NOIRS

  1. Paul Schrader, 'Notes on Film Noir'

    • Noirs look at 'underside of the American character
      • The hard-boiled tradition
        • Thirties authors such as Hemingway, Raymond Chandler (script for Double Indemnity) created 'tough', cynical way of thinking separating one from everyday emotions - 'romanticism with a protective shell'. Roots in pulp fiction/journalism,  protagonists live out 'narcissistic, defeatist code'.  R. Chandler/D Indemnity 'first film showing Noir as: small-time, unredeemed, unheroic, a break from Romantic noir of The Big Sleep There is a constant encounter with a regular person with the absurd world around them. Existentialist. 
    • FN not a genre as not defined by setting and conflict, but rather tone and mood, also a period of film like Expressionism or FNW.
      • Schr. argues reduce FN to its primary colour, 'black', and cultural/stylistic elements
      • Noir tonality draws from -
        • War/post-war disillusionment
          • During Great Depression, cinema kept up spirits.  Dark crime films began appearing after, though interupted by WWII which increased need for Allied propaganda and patriotism Following WWII, films became more sardonic w/ boom in crime film
          • Post-war realism
            • de Rochemont-Hathaway 'Kiss of Death' 1947 all shot on location Deals at beginning with voiceover narration about on screen Nick (Victor Mature - Noir star) who during Christmas cannot afford anything due to unemployment for his criminal record, repeating cycle of crime (Nick saw same pattern and eventual downfall of his father, again, repeating cycles a major them - never ending corruption, failure).  Scene w/ elevator a claustric atmosphere, trapped. Entrapment a major Noir theme as are financial struggles so characters must resort to crime - however, this is more than anything SOCIETAL rather than invididual failure - invididuals as VICTIMS of society.  Chiaroscuro style emphasising light/shadow illuminates Western moral binaries. 
            • public demands honest/harsh view of America, which would repeat in the 70s w/Vietnam, Watergate
              • moves away from high-class melodrama
        • The German influence
          • Expressionist lighting
            • G expatriates Lang, Wilder, Douglas Sirk etc
              • Noir contradictory - realism w/ reliance on artificial studio lighting
                • noir technicians weld contradictory elements
                  • directing unnatural/Expressionist lighting onto realistic settings
    • 1
  2. Stylistics

    • recurring techniques identified by Schrader
      • Majority of scenes lit for night.  Gangsters sit in offices at midday with shades pulled/lights off. 'They Live By Night' (1948, Ray).  As w/ Germ. Expressionism - oblique/vertical lines preferred to horizontal. Obliquity in choreography of city opposed directly to horizontal American Western tradition of Ford. 'Crooked'.  Actors/setting given equal lighting emphasis. Unlike famous Warner Brothers lighting of Thirties, in which protagonist accentuated by heavy shadow - in film noir, protagonist is shrouded IN the shadow.  Dominance of setting over protagonist illuminates central themes of Noir such as the individual's futility in the face of society's stranglehold and power over them - creates hopeless, fatalistic mood. The protagonist is powerless, will be outlasted and negated by the city.  Compositional tension preferred to physical action. Measured pacing, restrained anger and oppressive compositions. Scenes cinematographically move around the actor rather than the actor controlling scene by physical action. Entrapment. Streets almost always glistening with rain and rainfall increases with direct proportion to the drama. Docks and piers second only to alleyways as popular rendezvous points. Love of romantic, nostalgic narrations - an irretrievable past, a predetermined fate and an all-enveloping hopelessness. Complex chronological order reinforce feelings of hopelessness and lost time. Films use convoluted time sequences to immerse the viewer in a time-disoriented but highly stylised world.  
  3. Themes

    • Raymond Durgnat, 11 themes
    • hwvr, overriding theme of noir is
      • a passion for the past and present, but a fear of the future. The noir hero dreads looking ahead, survives by the day, and failing this, retreats to the past (Double Indemnity).  Film noir's techniques emphasise loss, nostalgia, lack of clear priorities, insecurity: then submerge these self-doubts in mannerism and style.  Style becomes paramount as it is - all that separates one from meaninglessness. 
  4. FN can be subdivided into three broad phases

    • 1. Wartime period, 1941-6 approximately
      • Phase of the private eye and the lone wolf. Studio sets and generally more talk than action. Bogart and Bacall. Curtiz.  The Maltese Falcon, Casablanca, The Big Sleep, Scarlett Street, To Have and To Have Not. 
    • 2. Post-war realistic period, 1945-9)
      • Double Indemnity begins phase. More focused on problems of crime in the streets, political corruption and police routine. Less romantic heroes (Burt Lancaster), and more proletarian directors like Hathaway and Elia Kazan.  realistic urban look Kiss of Death, Double Indemnity. 
    • 3. psychotic action and suicidal impulse, 1949-53
      • Noir hero goes crazy. Psychotic killer archetype who had previously been supporting/background enters foreground, as active protagonist. James Cagney makes return (Kiss Tomorrow Goodbye) - also Lee Marvin. Phase of 'B' Noir film, psychoanalytically inclined directors like Ray.  They Live By Night, Sunset Boulevard
    • summary of three
      • 1st period 'gray' melodramas, 2nd street films and 3rd most aesthetically, sociologically piercing. 3rd result of shedding romantic tendencies and conventions. 3rd dealt with loss of public honour, heroic conventions, personal integrity, and psychological stability - more self-aware.  Schrader argues fundamental reason for film noir's neglect is its dependence on choreography versus sociology - more stylistic than thematic.  Film Noir attacked and interpreted its sociological conditions, and created a new artistic world which went beyond a simple sociological reflection, a nightmarish world of American mannerism which was by far more a creation than a reflection. They Live By Night (1949, Ray) Sunset Boulevard (1950, Wilder) 
  5. further notes

    • Existentialism and film noir.  Fatalism in film noir and absurdity in Existentialism. Protagonist always seems doomed - plans fail, relationships flawed, society biased, conspires against protagonist. Protagonists fail to or refuse to accept given moral codes in society, often stubborn and individualistic - reflecting the inverse of the single-minded Western hero, the frontierism represented by this. Noir protagonist more attuned with absurd, embroiled in greater doubt and appear gradually crushed by weight of society. Nick disobeys police officer's rules in Kiss of Death, in favour of his own individualistic stand - mistrust of authority and society perpetually places protagonist in compromised positions which are hazardous and often fatal.  Existentialism stresses that strength of individual can rise above society's conspiracy against them, whereas the noir hero is invariably doomed, unable to find any hiding place in the world of shadows.
  6. Existentialism

  7. 'Guess Work', Adrian Martin

    • Film Noir features - Sc St, Lang fond even in silent films of beginning scenes with an insert or detail, key Noir feature (create intrigue, and a kid of what Alain Masson cals poetic mystery because while seemingly direct and easily readable, they are in fact built on ‘intensity, uncertainty and dissimulation’ - creates an enigma as to the location or status of a gesture, intention behind it and the precise identify of who is performing it. Repeated patterns and motifs ‘Langian guesswork’ - noirs mysterious, plot convoluted and not all elements visible Maintained air of cinematic intrigue - to attend the ways and means of representation - creation and transformation of representational illusions (metamorphosis), and unravelling/cancellation/unmasking (enantiomorphosis) Noirs, like Lang’s and Hitchcock’s, can give appearance of a central character/viewpoint, however the film builds webs and conspiring subplots around this character which ensnare them, minimising their control and influence over situations - character loses freedom, becomes victim to a narrative which is too large for him to comprehend or at least control - also, reflects absurdity of the characters, and therefore through the identification process, the audience. We perceive the futility of so many of these characters’ efforts to control things around them, the frame. Character named ‘Criss Cross’ - while narrative is often mysterious or concealed, there is frequently in Noir a comic surface emphasising absurdity and self-awareness of the text. While many critics argue against the noir’s status as a genre, they are so easily mimicked and parodied, even by themselves within its prominent era, it is hard to justify not classifying them so, in spite of technicalities. Importance of irony, ‘taking the simple definition of irony as an aesthetic device’ Ross Gibson describes Lang’s noirs, ‘provocatively amoral’ films - a tradition continued by Lynch, De Palma, Coens (all prolific makers of neo-noir). Provocative in the sense that the film’s lack of values provokes ethical and moral and value debates. ‘pre-postmodern truth multiplies the passing opportunities for bluff, deception, scheming and evasion, creating a fleeting margin of freedom without ever guaranteeing ultimate survival, salvation or self-knowledge.’ - film noir
    • Scarlett Street notes
      • Scarlett Street (Lang, 1945) Noir features (2nd period) - Rain-glistening street What does rain symbolise? perhaps symbolic of the implicit corruption of the city - rain corrodes, is acidic. Also, suggests effect on environment, sense of unnatural. Symbol of 'concrete jungle' of city literalised in which a rain soaked forest is imitated by stacks of corroding concrete and streets filled with animalistic, violent creatures. Further, a sense of the city coming down on the characters, victimising and repelling them. -Chris minimised in frame by MES, larger characters -Chris minimised in frame, a frame balanced by large overhanging photographic portrait of Homer. -During a scene in which Chris sees Johnny and Kitty fighting in street, train passing overhead as unseen diegetic sound increases in volume as intensity of scene builds, drowning other noises out. -motif of straw hat -Lang teases - Chris runs off for a police officer as Johnny sits up looking confused as Kitty, unperturbed, first asks if Johnny is ok - implication that she and her attacker are intimate is clear for a second, yet the there is a cut as Chris flees this idea, literally and metaphorically. He covers his eyes, and idealises his world naively, avoiding reality, which is harsh and uncaring - summed up by his vehement dislike for the medium of photography in favour of the subjectivity and freedom painting allows. -musical motif of My Melancholy Baby -Chris Cross - comedic irony -Chris/Kitty cafe scene - Kitty controls the frame, when she stretches out her arms yawning, the camera zooms out to allow her space to remain fully in frame - Kitty controls the camera here and dominates frame. also, reverse shots of conversation show characters each separate in frames therefore emphasising different perspectives, and Kitty often framed with candlelight to left of her. This implies Chris sees their encounter far more romantically than she, while more frequently, he is framed up front, with less in the foreground - illuminating not only his more naive, surface identity than her covert nature, and her front. They both pretend to be something they are not, but Kitty we perceive is far more a natural at it. (limited perspectives are an inherent part of film noir) -motif of flower -Chris emasculated - doing dishes in frilled apron -Scenes frequently begin with an insert which then pans out to reveal the fuller scene, with often unsuspected or shocking reveals, or at least the opportunity for this - creating tension, an aura of suspense and guessing, enigma. -Once Kitty and Johnny's charade begins, Kitty ceases to dominate frame. One shot, three men - Dellarowe, Janeway and Johnny all stand foregrounded in a queue with their backs to the camera, pushing Kitty deep into the corner of the frame, reducing her presence, trapping her. The implication in noir is that whenever a character becomes embroiled in a plot, even if they believe they are in control, they are not. They are puny by comparison. -musical motifs - irony seeps throughout film, with the skipped record in the diegesis is repeated faithfully in both the score, Chris' hums towards the end of the film once Johnny has been convicted. -Expressionistic sequence of Chris' guilt manifesting, with voices echoing in his head represented in the non-diegetic audio, the lights of neon and lamps flashing on and off, symbolising much within the sequence and film, bringing toa technical fore that which is purely emotional - like Chris saw himself achieving through painting.
      • rel. to Women's/Feminism/Mulvey
        • 'Self Portrait' of Katherine March. and Laura Mulvey. The female as fetishised , as sex object of the male gaze, is flattened. Here literally, her facial features depicted as flatter and more two-dimensional, with 'something hidden' behind the surface as Janeway voices, 'mona lisa without the smile'. Her identity has been flattened by the true painter, Chris, and fetishised, flattening the representation therefore reducing the castration threat she poses. Also, the false attribution of identity of this flattened icon, merely an aspect of the refracted male gaze.

Information

Description
Mind Map on Schrader: FILM NOIRS, created by Jonny South on 14/04/2015.
Created by
Jonny South
Views
5
Rating

More on Film Genres and Conventions

Feedback

What is it about?

What should we add next?