Help shape GoConqr. What should we add next?

Mind map

Philosophy AS - epistemology

khudoon96 English

Philosophy AS - epistemology

Map content

Philosophy AS - epistemology

  1. 1. Perception

    • What is perception?
      • . Locke - primary (PQ) and secondary qualities (SQ)
        • PQ
          • Primary qualities are the properties an object holds mind -independently of perception, qualities that exist despite our presence. (I.e. Size, shape, motion - including rest, solidity and many more.)
            • Whereas a primary quality exists irrespective of any changes made - the primary qualities hold these properties ‘in and of itself’.
        • SQ
          • Secondary qualities exist due to sense-data being perceived to create sensation of smell,taste etc.
            • Locke states that secondary qualities are ‘powers to produce various sensations in us by their primary qualities.’
      • Russell - sense-data and perception
        • "...Sense data are mind-dependent representations of the physical world: they only exist in our minds and therefore are entirely subjective and relative to the particular circumstance of our perception."
          • The table:
            • 1. Walking around the table, he discerns different colors from different points of view: in places seeming to reflect more light, a brighter shade of brown appears. In reality we assume that there is only one color of the table, yet the appearance of many colors contradicts our assumption.
              • The color seems to be a relation depending on the observer, his point of view, and conditions like "the way the light falls on the table."
                • perceptual variation
      • Berkeley - idealism
        • 1. Something like a tree exists, according to Berkeley, because someone perceives it.
          • 2. What is real about a tree exists in its perception
            • But what if no human perceives the tree?
              • 1. Berkeley admitted belief in an external world independent of humans.
                • 2.a His philosophy held that the world and everything in it was an idea in the mind of God.
                  • 2.b What we call a real thing is the continuing "physical" object or permanent idea in God's mind.
                    • 3. Our minds participate in God's perceptions, and thus different people's differing perceptions of the same object are variable but similar because each is of a piece with the same thing.
                      • Berkeley takes the mind-dependent state of the SQ and applies them to the PQ
      • (DR) Direct realist
        • 1. Direct realism claims that objects are composed of matter; they occupy space.
          • Direct realists might claim that indirect realists are confused about conventional idioms that may refer to perception. Perception exemplifies unmediated contact with the external world; examples of indirect perception might be seeing a photograph, or hearing a recorded voice.
          • 2. These properties are perceived directly, they have properties we perceive with no intermediary links.
            • 3. Direct realists claim that we perceive the physical objects themselves, they exist in a mind-independent state.
              • 4. Direct realism claims that the immediate object of perception is the physical object itself. We don’t perceive it in virtue of perceiving something else that ‘mediates’ between our minds and the physical object
      • Knowledge
        • Definition of Knowledge is concerned with:
          • Justified True Belief
            • There are three components to the traditional (“tripartite”) analysis of knowledge. According to this analysis, justified, true belief is necessary and sufficient for knowledge.
              • The Tripartite Analysis of Knowledge:
                • S knows that p iff
                  • i. p is true;
                    • ii. S believes that p;
                      • iii. S is justified in believing that p.
              • But is it always sufficiant for knowledge ?
                • Edmund Gettier - 'a Gettier case': challenging the tripartite theory of knowledge
                  • Where one has JTB but fails to have knowledge
                    • Case study one:
                      • The case’s protagonist is Smith. He and Jones have applied for a particular job. But Smith has been told by the company president that Jones will win the job.
                        • Smith combines that testimony with his observational evidence of there being ten coins in Jones’s pocket. (He had counted them himself — an odd but imaginable circumstance.) And he proceeds to infer that whoever will get the job has ten coins in their pocket.
                          • Notice that Smith is not thereby guessing. On the contrary; his belief b enjoys a reasonable amount of justificatory support. There is the company president’s testimony; there is Smith’s observation of the coins in Jones’s pocket; and there is Smith’s proceeding to infer belief b carefully and sensibly from that other evidence. Belief b is thereby at least fairly well justified — supported by evidence which is good in a reasonably normal way. As it happens, too, belief b is true — although not in the way in which Smith was expecting it to be true. For it is Smith who will get the job, and Smith himself has ten coins in his pocket.
                            • These two facts combine to make his belief b true. Nevertheless, neither of those facts is something that, on its own, was known by Smith. Is his belief b therefore not knowledge? In other words, does Smith fail to know that the person who will get the job has ten coins in his pocket? Surely so (thought Gettier).
                              • It contains a belief which is true and justified — but which is not knowledge. And if that is an accurate reading of the case, then JTB is false. Case I would show that it is possible for a belief to be true and justified without being knowledge. Case I would have established that the combination of truth, belief, and justification does not entail the presence of knowledge. In that sense, a belief’s being true and justified would not be sufficient for its being knowledge.
                                • Rejecting Gettier:
                                  • Virtue epistemology
                                    • You know p is true if;
                                      • p is true;
                                        • s believes in p;
                                          • and s's true belief is the result of them exercising their intellectual virtue.
                                            • If you use your intellectual virtues to find knowledge then that knowledge is a cognitive achievement
                                              • Sosa
                                                • Invented virtue epistemology
                                                  • If you imagine an archer aiming at a target, it is like a person aiming to know something about the world
                                                    • AAA structure are both necessary and jointly sufficient for Knowledge
                                                      • 1A. Accurate
                                                        • Do you hit the target? Do you have the right beliefs about the right thing? Is what you're thinking true?
                                                      • 2A. Adroitness
                                                        • Did you aim and shoot well? Did you do it right - as an exercise of intellectual faculty? As the name suggests, did you use the right skill?
                                                      • 3A. Aptness
                                                        • Did you form your conclusion from 1A and 2A? Or was it just fluke K (Gettier)? It is accurate due to your adroitness.
                                                  • This defeated Gettier as his 'cases' held only A1 and A2, they were fluke K
                                              • How do we know anything?
                                                • Knowledge innateism
                                                  • Plato.
                                                • Knowledge empiricism
                                                  • Locke.
                                                • Concept innateism
                                                  • Leibnitz
                                                • Concept empiricism
                                                • Necessary and contingent
                                  • Infallibilism
                                    • Instead of destroying JTB, it attempts to preserve it by improving the J.
                                      • It does this by:
                                        • s believes p;
                                          • p is true;
                                            • s is justified in believing p IFF s can't be mistaken, thus your J results in certainty.
                                              • Flaws in infallibilism:
                                                • 1. It ends in very little knowledge
                                                  • To say you know something you have to be ultimately certain, which results in little 'knowledge'
                                                • 2. If you think you know something you also believe you are certian
                                                • 3. People want to say 'I know' but can't with this theory.
                                                  • So, humans want to be able to say they know something but this theory leave very little to know.
                                                • 4. Only super human epistemology works, as only superhuman knowledge (beings) can be certain.
                                  • Reliabilism
                                    • Reliabilism claims that you know that p if
                                      • p is true;
                                        • you believe that p;
                                          • your belief is caused by a reliable cognitive process.
                                      • Disadvantages: 1. Reliable methods can easily lead to falsehoods. (ie: 'I saw a dragon, therefore it's real')
                                        • Advantage: of reliabilism is that it 1. allows young children and animals to have knowledge.
                                          • 2. It allows for knowledge to become broad in terms of how much we can be certain of knowledge
                                        • 2. Justification can often be explanatory, it destroys JTB by taking out the justification, but reliable methods don't always tell you why, how or when something works.
                                          • 3. You can just as easily believe a false proposition as a true one, due to the lack of certian justification
          • 2. The elements of knowledge
          • 1. Knowledge vs. other cognitive states 
            • opinion, misunderstanding, guessing, etc.
          • 3.Philosophical Skill: Necessary and Sufficient Conditions
            • Necessary and sufficient conditions
              • Necessary Conditions
                • - What you have to have to make something something
                  • - It is necessary for a bachelor to be male
              • Sufficient Conditions
                • - If you have them, you’ve got it
                  • - Being a male is necessary but not sufficient for being a bachelor
              • necessary, sufficient, both or neither
                • To be 18 (S and N) to vote in the UK
      • (IR) Indirect realist
        • 1. Indirect realism claims that we perceive physical objects which are mind-independent, but we do so via, or in virtue of, perceiving mind-dependent sense-data that are caused by and represent physical objects.
          • 2. We perceive sense-data immediately, and physical objects indirectly.
            • 3. An indirect realist would state that a direct realist
      • N.B. Look at the arguements for DR and IR

Images and files in the map

  • Philosophy AS - epistemology
  • Philosophy AS - epistemology
  • Philosophy AS - epistemology
  • Philosophy AS - epistemology
  • Philosophy AS - epistemology

Information

Description
Mind Map on Philosophy AS - epistemology, created by khudoon96 on 23/04/2015.
Created by
khudoon96
Views
18
History
  • Created by slatter.e07 · Apr 23, 2015
  • Copied by khudoon96 · Apr 23, 2015
Rating

More on Theories of Perception: Direct and Indirect Realism

Feedback

What is it about?

What should we add next?