Needs Versus Desires: Traveling Light & Arriving Heavy.
We tend to accumulate
more than we need/use.
The brands of the objects you
have have a major significance in
the analysis of material culture.
We often develop strong emotional
attachments to our possessions.
Marxist Theory & Alienation.
Marx developed a number of economic &
psychological theories to explain the role
of capitalism in the modern world.
Alienation by Marx meant a
separation or estrangement of man's
true nature from his sense of self.
The more artifacts we feel we need to have, the more we
are signifying our alienation & the more alienated we are.
Class Conflict.
Rich vs. Poor
The ruling classes also avoid class conflict by making it possible for the
poor to purchase goods & services that distract their attention from the
class makeup of society & the unequal distribution of wealth.
The Role of Advertising.
The main engine of consumer culture in capitalist societies.
Henri Lefebvre argues that it
is advertising that gives all
objects their valuation.
Lefebvre believes that advertising transforms itself from
an industry inducing people to buy objects & products to
one that gives them value & status in people's eyes.
Thorstein Veblen &
Conspicuous Consumption.
Thorstein Veblen was a
"radical" American
economist who offered
a different perspective
on the role of
consumption in the US.
Veblen believes that the ultimate goal of
conspicuous consumption is to enhance self of self.
It is necessary to look for the hidden or
latent function of objects to fully
understand the role they play in our lives.
We are locked into a situation in
which we can never stop yearning
for new & better things, because
we are always comparing
ourselves with others.
Max Weber & Calvanist-Protestant Thought
Weber is a German sociologist & argues that Calvinist
theology is behind the development of capitalism & the
attitudes people have towards their possessions.
Calvin argues that people should discard the
catholic medieval ascetic perspective on life.
Protestant ethic is behind the
development of capitalism.
The belief that there is Divine Providence that
justifies the unequal distribution of wealth is a
great comfort to those who form the ruling class.
Georg Simmel on Fashion
Fashion can be considered more broadly & understood to
deal not only with new clothing styles but also with the
development of the new models of artifacts we use.
As soon as the exclusivity of a fashion becomes
tainted by mass adoption, fashionistas & new
adopters have to move on to something new.
Says women pay attention to fashion because
of their social & political subservience.
Walter Benjamin & the Work of Art in
the Age of Mechanical Reproduction.
Benjamin was a German Marxist critic
who was interested in the impact of
mass products on objects.
Once authenticity becomes irrelevant, he suggests,
art no longer is based on ritual with its focus on the
creative artist & the creative process.
"aura"- the authenticity, heart of it.
Authenticity & Postmodern Thought
One of the reasons for the lack of concern about
authenticity is because the concept is largely
irrelevant in postmodern times.
Postmodernism, according to Jean-Francois Lyotard, is
characterized by "incredulity toward metanarratives"
It also dissolves the boundaries between elite culture & popular
culture & between original works of art & reproductions or imitations.
John Berger on Advertising & Material Culture.
Berger makes the point that publicity is about social
relations, he argues that the objects we puchase
play an imporant role in our social relations & that
advertising is the engine that gives the objects we
purchase their significance to us.