Mind map
When are evidence sufficient and appropriate?

Mind map: Sufficient and appropriate audit evidence
Map content
When are evidence sufficient and appropriate?
1. Sufficiency
- 2. Is the MEASURE of the QUANTITY of audit evidence
- 3. What affect the QTY?
- 3.1 RMM
- ^ RMM ^ QTY
- Inverse relationship
- Btw Sufficiency and Appropriateness
- Inverse relationship
- ^ RMM ^ QTY
- 3.2 QUALITY of the audit evidence
- ^ Quality ↓ QTY
- Note that increasing the QTY may not really improve the quality
- ^ Quality ↓ QTY
- 3.1 RMM
- 3. What affect the QTY?
- 2. Is the MEASURE of the QUANTITY of audit evidence
2. Appropriateness
- Is the MEASURE of the QUALITY of audit evidence;
- Quality?
- How relevant and reliable is the audit evidence is in providing support for the conclusions on which the auditor’s opinion is based?
- 0.1 What influenced the reliability of evidence?
- 1. Its source
- 1.1 Is it independent of the entity ?
- EXAMPLES
- confirmations from 3RD parties
- Analysts’ reports,
- Comparable data about competitors (benchmarking data).
- Analysts’ reports,
- confirmations from 3RD parties
- APPLICATION
- Yes, more reliable
- External confirmation of entity's bank balance received directly by auditor
- No, less reilable
- Examine cash balance recorded in GL
- Yes, more reliable
- EXAMPLES
- 1. 2 Has evidence from the entity being verified by an independent source?
- APPLICATION
- Yes, more reliable
- Cheque is cleared through the bank and returned back
- No, less reilable
- Duplicate copy of chq
- Indicate cancelled chq
- Duplicate copy of chq
- Yes, more reliable
- APPLICATION
- 1.1 Is it independent of the entity ?
- 2. Its nature
- 2.1 Is the document original?
- APPLICATION
- Yes, more reliable
- when auditor examine signed, original copy of a lease agreement
- No, less reilable
- Photocopy
- Fax
- Electronic copies
- Fax
- Photocopy
- Yes, more reliable
- APPLICATION
- 2.2 How effective is the internal control?
- EG: Accounting system
- Low CR / Effective
- Evidence is reliable
- High CR / Ineffective
- Evidence is reliable
- Low CR / Effective
- EG: Accounting system
- 2.1 Is the document original?
- 3. The individual circumstances which the evidence is obtained.
- Is it obtained In documentary form, whether paper, electronic, or other medium?
- APPLICATION
- Yes, more reliable
- written record of
- a meeting
- written record of
- No, less reilable
- subsequent oral representation of the matters discussed
- Yes, more reliable
- APPLICATION
- Is it obtained directly by the auditor?
- APPLICATION
- No, less reilable
- inquiry about the
- Yes, more reliable
- observation of the
- application of a control
- observation of the
- No, less reilable
- EXAMPLE
- physical inspection of entity's inventory
- EXECEPTION
- If Invty is diamonds or computer chips?
- Lack expertise to appropriately assess the validity and valuation of the items
- Solution: Hire experts to help with the invty audit
- Lack expertise to appropriately assess the validity and valuation of the items
- If Invty is diamonds or computer chips?
- EXECEPTION
- physical inspection of entity's inventory
- APPLICATION
- Is it obtained In documentary form, whether paper, electronic, or other medium?
- 1. Its source
- 0.2 How relevant/related is the evidence to the assertion tested?
- APPLICATION
- Test for Understatement
- Testing subsequent disbursements, unpaid invoices, suppliers’ statements, and unmatched receiving reports may be relevant
- Existence or Valuation of A/P
- Test for Overstatement
- Test the recorded A/P may be a relevant audit procedure
- Test for Overstatement
- Test for Understatement
- APPLICATION
- 0.1 What influenced the reliability of evidence?
- How relevant and reliable is the audit evidence is in providing support for the conclusions on which the auditor’s opinion is based?
- Quality?
- Is the MEASURE of the QUALITY of audit evidence;
Information
- Description
- Mind Map on When are evidence sufficient and appropriate?, created by sue san on 17/11/2016.
- Created by
- sue san
- Views
- 0
- Rating
More on Audit Evidence and Documentation