Help shape GoConqr. What should we add next?

Notes

The Patents Act 1970

saili rane Intellectual Property Rights Law LLb English 1 page

Content of the notes (1)

Page 1

PATENTS ACT

PATENTS ACT

1. Discuss in detail the procedure for grant of patents? ***

2. Define invention. Which inventions are patenable and which are not. *****

3. What are the legal provisions relating to revocation and surrender of patents? ***

4. What is the meaning of infringement of patents? What are the remedies in case of its infringement? ****

5. What is patent? What are the rights and obligations of patentee? Are there any limitations on his rights? ****

6. Notes : 1. Product patents and process patents **

2. Assignment and license of patent. *

3. Patent agents *

7. What are the objects of The Patents Act, 1970.

8. What are the rights of the inventors.

12.Define ‘Patent’ and ‘invention’

The law of patents in India is governed by the Patents Act 1970 as amended by the Patents (Amendment) Act 1999. A bill named Patents (Second Amendment) Bill 1999 which had proposed substantial changes in the law was introduced in the Parliament in December 1999, and was passed as the Patents (Amendment) Act 2002. This Act was further amended by the Patents (Amendment) Act 2005.

12.1. Patent

A patent is an exclusive right granted to a person who has invented a new and useful article or an improvement of an existing article or a new process of making an article. It consists of an exclusive right to manufacture the new article invented or manufacture an article according to the invented process for a limited period. After the expiry of the duration of patent, anybody can make use of the invention.

The concept of patent and its essential ingredients like novelty, inventive step, lack of obviousness and sufficiency of description have remained the same ever since it was conceived over four hundred years ago.

A patent is a form of industrial property or as it is now called intellectual property. The owner of the patent can sell this property. He can also grant licences to others to exploit the patent. The property in a patent is similar in many respects to other forms of property.

A patent being a creation of statute is territorial in extent. A patent granted in one state cannot be enforced in another state unless the invention concerned is also patented in that state.

A patent is not granted for an idea or principle as such, but for some article or the process of making some article applying the idea.

12.2.Invention

To invent literally means to find out something, to discover something not found or discovered by anyone before. It is the production or introduction of a new thing for the first time by exercising one’s own mind, skill and labour. It must not be known to the public prior to the claim made by the inventor.

12.2.1.Definition-Under S. 1(1)(j) of the Patents Act, 1970 (as amended in 2002) an invention is defined as follows: ‘Invention means a new product or process involving an inventive step and

capable of industrial application.

The Patent (Amendment) Act 2005 defines ‘new invention’ to mean any invention or technology which has not been anticipated by publication in any document or used in the country or elsewhere in the world before the date of filing patent application with complete specification i.e. the subject matter has not fallen in the public domain or that it does not form part of the state of the art. Patent can be granted for either products or processes. In the case of product patent, the product itself is patented by the inventor. For example, say if the inventor invents a new drug which can itself prevent the occurrence of influenza he would get a patent over the product i.e. the drug itself. This means that the exclusive right to manufacture that drug vests with the inventor. Consequently, none apart from the one who holds the patent in the product can manufacture the product

irrespective of the fact that the new manufacturer uses a process completely different from the patent holder.

It has been held that a method or process is a manufacture if it

• results in the production of some vendible product, or

• improves, or restores to its former condition a vendible product or

• has the effect of preserving from deterioration some vendible products to which it is applied.

A patent can be obtained only for an invention which is new and useful. The invention must relate to a machine, article or substance produced by manufacture, or the process of manufacture of an article. A patent may also be obtained for an improvement of an article or of a process of manufacture. In regard to medicine or drug and certain classes of chemicals no patent is granted for the substance itself even if new, but a process of manufacturing the substance is patentable.

The applicant for a patent must be the true and first inventor or a person who has derived title from him, the right to apply for a patent being assignable. He must give a full and sufficient disclosure of the invention and specify the precise limits of the monopoly claimed. The invention claimed must be novel and must not be obvious to those who are skilled in the art to which it relates.

The three essential requirements of a patentable invention are novelty, inventiveness (i.e. inventive step or lack of obviousness) and utility. There are some inventions which may satisfy the above criteria but are still not patentable.

13.Explain the various things which are excluded from patentability.

13.1.What is a Patent

A patent is an exclusive right granted to a person who has invented a new and useful article or an improvement of an existing article or a new process of making an article. It consists of an exclusive right to manufacture the new article invented or manufacture an article according to the invented process for a limited period. After the expiry of the duration of patent, anybody can make use of the invention.

The concept of patent and its essential ingredients like novelty, inventive step, lack of obviousness and sufficiency of description have remained the same ever since it was conceived over four hundred years ago.

A patent is a form of industrial property or as it is now called intellectual property. The owner of the patent can sell this property. He can also grant licences to others to exploit the patent. The property in a patent is similar in many respects to other forms of property.

A patent being a creation of statute is territorial in extent. A patent granted in one state cannot be enforced in another state unless the invention concerned is also patented in that state.

A patent is not granted for an idea or principle as such, but for some article or the process

of making some article applying the idea.

13.2.Inventions not Patentable [Ss. 3-4]

The following inventions are not patentable:

1. An invention which is frivolous or which claims anything obviously or contrary to well-established natural laws.

2. An invention the primary or intended use of which would be contrary to law or morality or injurious to public health.

3. The mere discovery of a scientific principle or the formulation of an abstract theory or discovery of any living or non -living substances occurring in nature(for example, the theory of relativity is not patentable).

4. The mere discovery of any new from of a known substance which does not result in the enhancement of the known efficacy of that substance or the mare discovery of any new property or new use for a known substance or of the mere use of a known process, machine or apparatus unless such process result in a new product or employs at least one new reactant.

5. A substance obtained by a mere admixture resulting only in the aggregation of the properties of the components thereof or a process for producing such substance.

6. The mere arrangement or rearrangement or duplication of known devices each functioning independently of one another in a known way.

7. A method of agriculture or horticulture.

8. A process for the medical, surgical, curative, prophylactic diagnostic, therapeutic or other treatment of human beings or any process for a similar treatment of animals to render them free of disease or to increase their economic value or that of their products.

9. Plants and animals in whole or any part thereof other than micro-organisms but including seeds, varieties and species and essentially biological processes for production or propagation of plants and animals.

10. A mathematical or business method or a computer programe per se or algorithms.

11. A literary, dramatic, musical or artistic work or any other aesthetic creation whatsoever including cinematographic works and television productions.

12. A mere scheme or rule or method of performing mental act or method of playing game.

13. A presentation of information.

14. Topography of integrated circuits.

15. An invention which in effect, is traditional knowledge or which is an aggregation or duplication of known properties of traditionally known component or components.

16. An invention relating to atomic energy.

14.How is infringement of patent determined?

What constitutes infringement of Patent is not defined in the Patents Act.

But obviously infringement of a patent is the violation of the monopoly rights conferred

by the grant. The right conferred by the Patent is the exclusive right to make, use,exercise, sell or distribute the invention in India. Hence infringement consists in the violation of any of these rights.

Where the invention claimed is not a process but a substance irrespective of the means by which it is produced, the rights of the patentee are infringed by anyone who makes or supplies that substance commercially for use by others even though he does not know that it is that substance he is making or supplying. In the case of a patent for a process the rights of the patentee are infringed by one who uses or exercises the method or process in India. Since the patentee's rights are subject to various condition under the Act, the scope of infringement must be considered in the background of these statutory conditions.

14.1.In determining whether what the alleged infringer is doing amounts to an infringement of a particular patent three questions are involved:

1. the extent of monopoly right conferred by the patent which has to be ascertained by a construction of the specification, particularly the claims. Construction

2. whether the alleged acts amount to making, using, exercising, selling or distributing a product or using or exercising a method or process in the case of a process patent, and

3. whether what the alleged infringer is doing amounts to an infringement of the monopoly conferred by the patent grant.

First, in order to ascertain the scope of the claims made in the patentee’s specification, the court must ascertain the essential integers of the claim. This is a question of construction and no general rule can be laid down. The claim must be construed as a document without having in mind the alleged infringement. Secondly, the essential integers having been ascertained, the infringing article must be considered. To constitute infringement the article must take each and every one of the essential integers of the claim. Non-essential integers may be omitted or replaced by mechanical equivalents;there will still be infringement. Where the invention resides in a new combination of known integers, or merely in a new arrangement and interaction of ordinary working parts, it is not sufficient to show that the same result is reached; the working parts must act on one another in the way claimed in the claim of the patent.

If the patentee has in his specification limited the essential features of his claim in a manner that may appear to be unnecessary, it may be that the copier can escape infringement by adopting some simple mechanical equivalents so that it cannot be said that every essential integer of the claim has been taken.

14.2.What Constitutes Infringement

In order to constitute infringement the defendant must be shown to have taken the invention claimed in substance. As to what is the real substance of the invention, whether it be a combination or a process must be decided on the evidence, that is to say, it is a question of fact. It is seldom that an infringer takes the whole of the invention, he may omit some unessential part or step, and substitute another step or part. But if he takes all the essential features of the invention he cannot avoid infringement. This leads to the question what are the essential features of the invention claimed.

The patentee himself specifies in his claims with particularity those elements or integers of his invention which he claims to be essential. If the language which the patentee has used in the claims specifies a number of elements or integers acting in a particular relation to one another as constituting the essential features of his claim, the monopoly which he obtains is for that specified combination of elements or integers so acting in relation to one another and for nothing else. There is no infringement of his monopoly unless each and every one of such elements is present and such elements also act in relation to one another in the manner claimed. Non-essential integers may be omitted or replaced by mechanical equivalents; there will still be infringement. The question whether the infringing apparatus is substantially the same means ‘in all essential respects the same.’

Where the infringer has taken all the essential features claimed in the patent but has altered one or more unessential feature or has added some additional feature which may or may not itself involves a new inventive step, it is called a ‘colourable imitation’. A process or an article which makes use of the same principle as the patented invention or achieves the same result or makes use of some only of the essential features is not a ‘colourable imitation’ in any sense relevant to patent law unless it does adopt all the essential features which the patentee has specified in his claim. Copying the ‘essential features’ of the invention is sometimes referred to as taking the ‘pith and marrow’ of the invention.

A person is guilty of infringement if he makes what is in substance the equivalent of the patented article. He cannot get out of it by some trifling or unessential variation. One cannot avoid infringement by substituting an obvious equivalent for an unessential integer. On the other hand, one cannot be held to have taken the substance of an invention if one omits some essential integer or substitutes something else for an essential integer.

14.3.Who can Sue for Infringement

The right to sue for infringement belongs to the patentee. The exclusive licensee, if the licence is registered, may file a suit. If the patentee is not joined as a plaintiff he must be added as a defendant to the suit. A compulsory licensee may also file a suit for infringement under certain circumstances. An assignee is entitled to file a suit if the application for registration of the assignment has been filed before the date of filing the suit. A co-owner may also bring a suit for infringement.

Any person who infringes the patent, that is to say, who exercises without authority any of the monopoly rights conferred by the grant may be sued for infringement. Thus manufacturers, importers and dealers, their servants and agents and sometimes even users of the patented articles may be made defendants in a suit for infringement. A person who threatens to infringe may also be sued. The consignees of the alleged infringing articles could be made a party to the action, but mere carrier or warehouseman is not an infringer.

The directors of a company cannot be personally sued for infringement unless they had authorized the wrongful acts or unless the evidence established the relationship of principal and agent between the directors and the company. Action may also be taken against agents and servants of the infringer either individually or collectively and with their employer or principal.

14.4.Defences for the Defendant

The defendant in a suit for infringement of a patent may plead one or more of the following defences:

1. plaintiff not entitled to sue for infringement,

2. denial of infringement or of any threat or intention to infringe,

3. leave or licence express or implied to use the invention,

4. estoppel or res judicata,

5. claims alleged to be infringed are invalid on certain grounds,

6. the acts complained of are in accordance with the conditions specified in S. 47(Government use, experiment, research and education),

7. existence of a restrictive contract declared unlawful,

8. Acts complained of come within the scope of innocent infringement, or done after failure to pay renewal fee, or done before the date of amendment of the specification (available only against a claim for damages or account of profits,

9. alleged infringement not novel or is obvious (Lord Moulton's defence or Gillette defence).

Counter - claim for revocation may be made by the defendant in his written statement

instead of a separate petition for revocation.

14.5.Reliefs

The reliefs available to a successful plaintiff in a suit for infringement include:

1. an injunction, and

2. either damages or account of profits.

The power to grant reliefs is subject to certain restrictions. Thus where the patent is endorsed ‘licences of right’, and the infringing defendant is ready and willing to take a compulsory licence no injunction will be granted. In the case of innocent infringement no, damages or account of profits will be granted. Damages or account of profits may be refused in respect of infringement committed after a failure to pay the renewal fee within the prescribed period. In certain circumstances damn or account of profits will not be granted in respect of the use of the invention before the date of amendment where the specification has been amended after its publication. If the patent is held to be only partially valid, reliefs may be granted in respect of the valid claims which is infringed,provided the plaintiff proves that the invalid claim was framed in good faith and with reasonable skill and knowledge.

14.5.1.Interlocutory Injunction

The plaintiff may at the commencement of the action move for an interim injunction to restrain the defendant from committing the acts complained of until the hearing of the action or further orders.

The principles upon which an interlocutory injunction may be granted in a patent action are the same as in any other action, namely, that the plaintiff should make out a prima facie case and also that the balance of convenience lies in his favour. In patent actions it may frequently happen that the defendant is able to show that there are substantial grounds for disputing the validity of the patent and often also that there are good reasons for saying that his apparatus does not infringe the plaintiff's claim. If either of those circumstances are shown to be present, the court may not grant an interlocutory injunction. The onus of showing a prima facie case which lies on the plaintiff is a heavy one and that it is comparatively easy for the defendant to establish a defence sufficient to prevent the grant of such an injunction. The remedy by interlocutory injunction is kept flexible and discretionary and is not made the subject of strict rules.The object of an interlocutory injunction is to protect the plaintiff against injury by violation of his rights for which he could not be adequately compensated in damages recoverable in the action if he succeeds at the trial. The court must weigh one need against another and determine where the balance of convenience lies. In granting the injunction the court must be satisfied that the claim is not frivolous or vexatious; in other words, that there is a serious question to be tried.

Various factors are taken into consideration in deciding the balance of convenience, such as whether the patent is a new one or an old one, whether the defendant's trade is a new one or an old established one and so on. If a patent is a new one, challenging its validity may be sufficient for a refusal of an injunction, but if the patent is sufficiently old and has been worked, the court would, for the purpose of temporary injunction presume the patent to be a valid one. Even if a likelihood of infringement is established, interlocutory injunction will be refused if there is a serious attack on the validity of the patent. If the patent relied on will expire before the action can be heard, the balance of convenience can be considered against the grant of an interlocutory injunction.

14.5.2.Damages or Account of Profits

A successful plaintiff in a suit for infringement is entitled to the relief of damages or an account of profits with certain exceptions. The exceptions are:

1. infringement was innocent,

2. the infringement was committed after a failure to pay the renewal fee within the prescribed time and before any extension of the period

3. where the specification has been amended, the infringement was committed before the date of amendment unless it was shown that the original specification was framed in good faith and with reasonable skill and knowledge, and

4. where the patent was held partially valid, damages or account of profits in respect of the valid claims will be granted only under certain circumstances.

14.5.3.Assessment of damages

In assessing damages the sole question is what is the loss sustained by the patentee by reason of the unlawful sale of the defendant’s goods. The loss must be the natural and direct consequence of the defendants' acts. The object of damages is to compensate for loss or injury. The general rule is that the measure of damages is to be, so far as possible, that sum of money which will put the injured party in the same position as he would have been in, if he had not sustained the wrong. There are two essential principles in valuing the damages, first, that the plaintiffs have the burden of proving their loss; second, that defendants being wrongdoers, damages should be liberally assessed but the object of this is to compensate the plaintiffs and not to punish the defendants.

The measure of damages may be estimated by applying the following principles:

1. Where the patentee manufactures the product and does not grant licences, the measure of damages will be the profit which would have been realized by the owner of the patent if the sales of the infringing articles had been made by him.

2. Where the patent is exploited through the granting of licences for royalty payments, the measure of damages which the infringer must pay will be the sums which he would have paid by way of royalty, if instead of acting illegally, he had acted legally. The solution to this problem will depend upon the evidence as the rates of royalty may vary from time to time.

3. The pecuniary equivalent of the injury resulting from the natural consequences of the acts done by the defendants. An estimate should be made of the number of articles the plaintiff did sell less by reason of the acts of the defendants. Then find the profit that they would have made upon each article.

4. Where only a part of a complex machine is protected by a patent the importance of the patented part to the whole machine should be considered. If it forms the very essence of the machine damages may be measured by the profit on the whole machine; otherwise account should be taken only of the patented part.

Information

Description
Law LLb Intellectual Property Rights Note on The Patents Act 1970, created by saili rane on 05/03/2015.
Created by
saili rane
Views
0
Rating

Feedback

What is it about?

What should we add next?