Question 1
Question
Authorised guarantee agreements (AGAs)
Question 2
Question
Authorised guarantee agreements (AGAs)
Answer
-
AGA = agreement between L and assigning T under which assigning T guarantees that the assignee will perform the lease covenants
-
If assignee does not perform lease covenants then L can take action against assigning T
-
If assignee does not perform lease covenants then L cannot take action against assigning T
-
AGA = agreement between L and assigning T under which assigning T guarantees that the assignee will not perform the lease covenants
Question 3
Question
If AGA entered into by assigning tenant
Answer
-
When T1 assigns to T2 the lease covenants pass to T2 (section 3) and T1 is automatically released from any liability under the lease (section 5)
-
If T2 then defaults, L1 can bring an action against T2 due to section 3 or against T1 due to AGA
Question 4
Question
If T2 assigns to T3 the lease covenants pass to T3 (section 3) and T2 is automatically released from any liability under the lease (section 5)
Answer
-
T1’s AGA will no longer be enforceable
-
L might request AGA from T2 instead to guarantee T3’s performance
-
T1’s AGA will still be enforceable
Question 5
Question
enables L to require assigning T to enter AGA only in certain circumstances
Answer
-
Section 16 LT(C)A 1995
-
Section 15 LT(C)A 1995
-
Section 17 LT(C)A 1995
-
Section 18 LT(C)A 1995
Question 6
Question
Section 16 enables L to require assigning T to enter AGA only in certain circumstances:
Question 7
Question
L and T can agree that L may grant consent to assignment subject to condition that assignor enters into an AGA on assignment
Question 8
Question
LTA 1927 section 19(1A)
Answer
-
Will then be automatically reasonable for L to impose condition that assignor enters into an AGA on assignment
-
Remember that section 19(1A) only applies to leases of commercial premises granted on or after 1st January 1996 and it affects only assignments (not sublettings)
-
Remember that section 19(1A) does not apply to leases of commercial premises granted on or after 1st January 1996 and it affects only assignments (not sublettings)
Question 9
Question
Terms of the AGA
Answer
-
Can only require assignor to guarantee performance of the lease covenants by immediate assignee
-
Can make assignor liable as principal debtor
-
Cannot make assignor liable as principal debtor
-
Cannot require assignor to guarantee performance of the lease covenants by immediate assignee
Question 10
Question
Terms of the AGA
Answer
-
Can require assignor to enter new lease if assignee is declared bankrupt and lease is disclaimed by trustee in bankruptcy
-
New lease will be for remainder of term of disclaimed lease and covenants must be no more onerous than in disclaimed lease
-
Can't require assignor to enter new lease if assignee is declared bankrupt and lease is disclaimed by trustee in bankruptcy
Question 11
Question
The position of the landlord
Question 12
Question
The position of the landlord steps
Answer
-
1) L may apply to be released
-
2) Must serve written notice on current T requesting release
-
3) Must do so before or within 4 weeks after assignment
-
2) Must do so before or within 4 weeks after assignment
-
1) Must serve written notice on current T requesting release
-
3) L may apply to be released
Question 13
Question
T can serve written notice of refusal on L within further 4 weeks
Answer
-
If T does not then L automatically released
-
If T does not then L is not automatically released
-
If T does so then L must apply to court
Question 14
Question
Former T who suffers loss due to liability under AGA for default of assignee may:
Answer
-
Bring action against defaulting assignee under general law of guarantees
-
Take action against his assignee on indemnity covenant
(note that indemnity covenant will not be implied into a new lease)
-
Take no action against his assignee on indemnity covenant
(note that indemnity covenant will not be implied into a new lease)
Question 15
Question
Sections 17, 18 and 19 Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995
Answer
-
Apply to both old and new leases – retrospective
-
Improve position of former T who remains liable either due to privity of contract (if old lease) or due to having entered AGA (if new lease)
-
Do not improve position of former T who remains liable either due to privity of contract (if old lease) or due to having entered AGA (if new lease)
Question 16
Question
Only applies if original lease does not provide for variation which has taken place
Answer
-
Section 18
-
Section 17
-
Section 19
Question 17
Question
This section applies when a Landlord wishes to recover a fixed charge from a former tenant?
Answer
-
Section 17
-
Section 18
-
Section 19
Question 18
Answer
-
To recover fixed charge from former T, L must serve default notice on former T within 6 months of charge becoming due
-
To recover fixed charge from T, L must serve default notice on T within 4 months of charge becoming due
Question 19
Question
Fixed charges are sums capable of definition or ascertainment in the lease for example:
Question 20
Question 21
Question
Former T will not be liable to extent that covenants have been made more onerous by variation
Answer
-
Section 17
-
Section 18
-
Section 19
Question 22
Question
Former T will not be liable to extent that covenants have been made more onerous by variation
Answer
-
Section 18
-
Section 17
-
Section 19
Question 23
Question
Overriding lease = lease which slots in above lease to defaulting assignee
Answer
-
Section 17
-
Section 18
-
Section 19
Question 24
Question
Section 19 results in two leases
Question 25
Question
Section 19 results in two leases
Question 26
Answer
-
Duration of overriding lease = 3 days longer than term of lease being overridden
-
Duration of overriding lease = 4 days longer than term of lease being overridden
-
Other terms = different terms to lease being overridden
-
Other terms = same as terms of lease being overridden
-
Former T becomes immediate landlord of defaulting assignee which gives former T more control over defaulting assignee
Question 27
Answer
-
Privity of contract between L1 and T1 and between T1 and S1
-
Privity of estate between L1 and T1 and between T1 and S1
-
No privity of contract or privity of estate between L1 and S1
(no contract and no direct landlord and tenant relationship)
-
L1 cannot therefore enforce covenants in headlease or in sublease against S1
-
L1 therefore can enforce covenants in headlease or in sublease against S1
Question 28
Question
Likely that headlease and sublease will be on same terms so if S1 is in breach of sublease then T1 will also be in breach of headlease
Answer
-
L1 then has right of action against T1 (headlease)
-
L1 then has right of action against S1 (headlease)
-
T1 has a right of action against S1 (sublease)
Question 29
Question 30
Question
The restrictive covenant exception
Answer
-
Restrictive covenant = covenant which is negative in substance and which prevents occupier from doing something on land
-
Restrictive covenant = covenant which is negative in substance and which does not prevent occupier from doing something on land
Question 31
Question
If dealing with unregistered title:
Question 32
Question
If dealing with registered title