Foundations of liberalism: origins and key beliefs
Slides in this set (34)
-
- it emerged in the 19th century, arising from the enlightenment and the collapse of feudalism
- liberal views were popular amongst the middle classes, as they stated that people should have freedoms, i.e. they could open more factories
- they challenged the divine right of monarchs and the authority of the church
- they criticised the economic and political privileges of the wealthy, and supported the movement towards freedom of conscience in religion
- During the 19th century liberal ideas triumphed, as industrialisation spread, and spread the idea of industrial capitalism that spread from Europe to America.

-
Ideas about Liberty and Freedom?
- under a feudal society, the individual wasn't important
- early liberals believed in an atomistic individualism, which is the belief that society itself doesn't exist, it's merely a collection of self-sufficient individuals
- classical liberals argued that people were egotistical and possessive
- the enlightenment emphasised that individuals were in fact rational and capable of decision making
- however, many saw the French Revolution as contradicting this, as it was so violent
- Kant and Bentham cautioned against paternalism, and encourage progress through education and critical enquiry rather than empiricism.
-
- ' a willingness to accept views or actions with which one is in disagreement'
- toleration is an ethical ideal and social principle, as it represents the goal of personal autonomy, and establishes a set of rules about how humans should behave towards one another
- first emerged with John Milton and John Locke, who wrote to defend religious freedom. Locke argued that since the proper position of government is to protect life, liberty and property, it has no right to meddle in the 'care of men's souls'
- it should be extended to all 'private' matters, on the grounds that they concern moral questions that should be left to the individual
- Mill developed a wider justification of toleration, highlighting its importance to society. This is because it's needed to secure the vigour and health of society
- only with a free market will 'truth' emerge as good ideas displace bad ones, and so ignorance is banished
- sympathy for toleration is linked to the liberal belief in a balanced society, one not riven by fundamental conflict. Although individuals pursue different interests, liberals hold that there is a deeper harmony or balance among these competing interests
- but, such competing interests complement each other
- individuals may pursue self interest, but a natural equilibrium will assert itself.
- limits to toleration: security of the state etc. Mill 'we are free to the extent that our actions don't harm others'
- liberals are sympathetic to being influenced by social and economic circumstances, and so should be offered help
-
- 'the principle that human beings are of identical worth or are entitled to be treated in the same way; equality can have widely differing applications'
- liberals disagree with the existence of natural rights. Locke/Paine based their belief system on these. Mill/Bentham reject natural theory, freedom consists of natural inclination of humankind to pursue own selfish interests
- however, everyone is still entitled to equal rights. If natural rights exist and are conferred to mankind by God/nature then they must be given on an equal basis.
- other liberals accept a rational proposition-no reason for inequality. That would be unnatural.
- a belief in equal rights is different from a belief in inequality. Most liberals accept the fact that we have different abilities and potentials when we are born, they want an equal right to reach our full potential.
- all groups entitled to the same rights, and should be equality of opportunity
-
- ' a moral standard of fairness and impartiality; social justice is the notion of a fair or justifiable distribution of wealth and rewards in society'
- consists of the equal application of the law to all citizens.
- liberals accept that a degree of inequality is natural and that social outcomes are all just
- this position has been challenged by Beveridge because deprivation curtails freedom as much as government and laws. Excessive inequalities from a market system can't be considered just
- many liberals and socialists agree that wealth should be redistributed from rich to poor
- Rawls suggested that some inequalities can't be tolerated and that the state is therefore justified in intervening
- modern liberals would argue that inequalities are justified in the free market as they're the result of each individual's own efforts and abilities
-
Key Beliefs: Equality of Opportunity
- 'a moral principle that suggests that all are entitled to equal life chances'
- classical liberals proposed a society in which individuals were free to succeed or fail, however this conflicted with individual liberty as some individuals, due to circumstances, did not have equal opportunity to benefit from a free society
- Booth 'cycle of deprivation', this cycle was hard to break
- Mill accepted that there were flaws in his theory, so the Liberal Party pushed equality of opportunity-access to education
- Beverage-welfare for all
- Labour Party from 1960s onwards pushed development of comprehensive education
- discrimination towards women and minorities was outlawed, and equality of opportunity became part of the British consensus
- USA is based on equality of opportunity, and strong safeguards against discrimination
-
- 'relates to a modern conception of the truly liberal society. It's characterised by a flourishing collection of groups to which people owed allegiance and in which they could freely participate'
- Tocqueville regarded Pluralism as an essential part of democracy.
- civil society would prevent that state from becoming too powerful, and so would act as a balance against tyranny of the majority
- modern conception of pluralism: diversity of cultures and rights of groups are protected, state tolerates expression of variety of beliefs as long as they don't threaten peace
- groups also have access to the political system and so can influence policy making, and the existence of different cultures can help domination of society by any single section
-
Key Beliefs: Liberty and Freedom
- 'all people should be independent, determine own government and masters of their own destiny'
- early liberals: political freedom implied the freedom of the people to determine their own form of government and not be ruled by an external power
- individual liberty: Benjamin Constant individual liberty was a practical aspiration. Political liberty will help guarantee this.
- over-powerful governments were its main enemies, they are paternalistic and regulate behaviour without cause
- utilitarianism and liberalism- individual is the best judge of their own interests. Bentham- individuals are motivated to pursue pleasure and avoid pain. Making such decisions ourselves is the essence of freedom
- role of government shouldn't be to make these decisions for us, government shouldn't prevent us from following our own self-interest unless we prevent others following theirs
- Mill- self regulating actions and other regarding actions
-
Key Beliefs: Negative and Positive Liberty
- Isaiah Berlin- negative freedom refers to the absence of restraint, you can act unobstructed by others
- positive liberty is where individuals fulfil their own potential
- Green- sees society as organic with citizens being inter-dependant ad so not motivated by self-interests, but by a desire to promote a common good
- individuals achieve self-fulfilment by pursuing social goods such as welfare of others
- modern conception of positive liberty is the widest choice and opportunity for everyone. Freedom and choice encourage social responsibility by pursuing common good.
- this doesn't make Green a socialist, rather the state should provide individual liberty and that we pursue self-interest, freedom can be individual and social in nature
-
Key Beliefs: Government by Consent
- before rational thought, divine right of kings, sanctity of obedience and acceptance of traditional basis or authority were used to explain the legitimacy of government
- Hobbes and Locke: developed the concept of government by consent. Hobbes- people would come together in a free compact or agreement to set up a great power over them; this would bring peace and security
- Locke- contract was real and had to be constantly confirmed. Original consent was assumed to be constantly renewed as long as future generations didn't dissolve a government. Liberals mean that the people should have regular opportunities to express their consent, or withhold it
- this implies the use of referendums for major changes to the system of government. State must tolerate free expression of public opinion even if it challenges basis of government
- governments are only legitimate if people have freely given their consent
-
Key Beliefs: Limited Government
- government must operate between strict boundaries. If government isn't limited it will encroach upon peoples' freedoms and private lives
- Liberals fear 3 potential consequences of government:
- exercise of arbitrary power (power without legitimacy)
- tendency for power to become concentrated in too few hands
- democratic systems may become tyranny of the majority
-
Key Beliefs: Limited Constitution
- constitution would be sovereign. Governments would adhere to its terms except in times of an emergency
- the constitution would define the limits to the jurisdiction of government. Prevent arbitrary power and increased drift to state power.
- defines the rights of citizens which safeguards against the encroachments of governments
- power is distributed evenly amongst different insititutions
-
Types of Liberalism: Early Forms
- EARLY LIBERALISM:
- include John Locke, Rousseau and Jefferson. Their emphasis on natural rights gave rise to practical developments:
- a gov. has no authority to encroach upon the rights of its people, unless the people consent to sacrifice some of their rights. They must still have the option to dissolve government
- all are born with equal rights. Governments should respect and promote equal rights
- individuals have the right to pursue own interests , and governments must respect this, and protect individual's freedoms
- the exercise of power without the expressed authority of the people cannot be justified as it denies fundamental rights
-
Types of Liberalism: Early Forms
- UTILITARIANISM:
- 'greatest happiness for the greatest number'
- Bentham wanted an alternative to the 'nonsense' of natural rights
- he believed individuals were purely motivated by self-interest- seek pleasure and avoid pain
- only individuals can be the best judge of their own interests
- BUT
- majoritarian implications of the greatest number-tyranny of the majority
- pain and pleasure is too simple
- gov. pursuing pleasure for the greatest number could lead to excessive interference
- criticised by liberals for having too simplistic view of pleasure, as it's seen only in terms of consumption, rather than higher pleasures
-
Types of Liberalism: Classical Liberalism
- CLASSICAL LIBERALISM:
- inspired by the philosophy of John Stuart Mill
- early liberals derived freedom from natural rights; utilitarians saw freedom in terms of being able to pursue their own self-interest, Mill's individual liberty was higher than this
- he believed that freedom would maximise human progress by promoting innovation, creativity and self-fulfilment
- it went hand-in-hand with entrepreneurial spirit.
- Bentham saw human progress in terms of consumption of goods, Mill saw it was human progress, and that freedom was a matter of principle, rather than Bentham who saw it as a matter of economic wellbeing
- believed that our own freedom depends upon all people enjoying the same freedom, we must respect others if we expect respect
- Mill accepted that there were limits to free speech, words must not be used to harm others
- individuals and the law must respect people's right to chose their own beliefs and values
- according to liberals, there's no reason why such freedoms shouldn't be tolerated by the state
- 19th century liberals were concerned with the dangers of ruler accumulating too much power-didn't see democracy as a cure for this
- it meant majority rule, and they believed that universal suffrage was dangerous, as the majority formed by the working classes would suppress minority groups
- liberals therefore supported the retention of the property qualification for voting in order to counterbalance the power of the majority
- they argued for a minimal state. It had responsibility to maintain order, security and peace in order to protect individual liberties
-
Classical Liberalism: A Summary
- individual freedoms should flourish and be respected
- the state should be limited to a min. number of functions, confined to:
- protecting people from each other
- defending the nation
- preventing the accumulation of economic and political power
- there should be a tolerant society in which behaviour that was not harmful to others would be uncontrolled
- the economy should be based on completely free markets, except where monopolies developed
- the state should be placed in the hands of a representative democracy
-
Classical Liberalism: Neo-Liberalism
- THATCHER: privatisation, deregulation etc.
- it was a counter reactionary idea in the 1970s to reverse big government and state intervention
- encompassed conservative social philosophy and laissez-faire because market fundamentalism which went further than laissez-faire which recognised the limits of the market
- emphasised the free market
- intervene in lives to maintain order and enforce a kind of private morality
- minimal state in economics-not in social issues
-
Classical Liberalism: Social Darwinism
- 1809-82, The Origin of the species a theory of survival of the fittest
- Samuel Smiles book of 'self-help', explained the concept of helping yourself rather than the state
- inequalities of wealth, social position and political power are natural and the government have no right to interfere with them
- US Sumner 'drunkard in the gutter is where he ought to be'
- revived in the New Right
- belief that the dependency culture had gone too far, and this excessive welfare sapped dynamism and motivation
-
Classical Liberalism: Economic Liberalism
- Smith and Ricard attacked mercantilism as allowing the state to have too much involvement in the economy
- economy to be viewed as a market with freedom of choice to assist the utilitarianism of the 'economic man'
- the economy has market forces which naturally promote economic prosperity
- INVISIBLE HAND
- self-interest, that drives this
-
Classical Liberalism: Manchester School
- Richard Cobden and John Bright, advocatd suffrage and focus on the views of the workers
- believed that workers success should be through their 'own efforts' and self-reliance rather than from the law
- no suggestion that the workers should have a welfare state
- if workers are to be successful, they should do so themselves
- NEGATIVE FREEDOM
-
Classical Liberalism: Libertarianism
- 'freedom is the most important thing'
- more extreme idea of negative freedom
- linked to conservatism as part of their focus on the state as being overly restrictive on freedom
- belief that the state shouldn't interfere in social and moral affairs that can't be solved by the free market
- egotistical individualism 'atomistic society'
- similar to anarchism, but they still want the state
- state shouldn't protect us against other individuals
- see social problems as being able to be solved by the free market, even law and order
- the state should do little than defend the nation
-
- self interest didn't produce a socially just society and we can't be free to pursue our own interests without having a social obligation to the welfare of others
- classical liberals accused modern liberals of abandoning individualism, so it resembles a society that isn't liberal
- BUT the state can't just give negative freedom, it has to have a bigger role
- modern liberals argue that the proper role of the state has been considered
- it was proposed by Green as an alternative to classical liberalism
- developed positive liberty
- couldn't allow unregulated capitalism to continue, and believed that the poorest in society were not equally able to benefit from this free society
- allowing the poorest to advance would allow society to progress collectively and fulfil potential
- viewed the state as a vehicle for enhancing liberty, rather than threatening it
-
Modern Liberalism: Welfare Liberalism
- response to popular support for socialism
- Beveridge recognised that deprivation was as much a curtailment of freedom as overbearing government
- liberty enhanced by relieving these issues by intervention, greater equality of opportunity and positive liberty
- Keynes justified state's role on the grounds that it provided economic stability, people felt more confident to pursue future careers, knowing there would be support
-
Modern Liberalism:Contemporary
- decentralisation of government
- stronger constitutional safeguards
- increased use of referendums to promote popular democracy
- strengthen local safeguards for individual rights and minority rights
- support multiculturalism as part of pluralism
- more social justice to counteract neo-liberal economics
- hope to tackle the causes of crime, not just punish offenders
- focus on equality of opportunity to improve social mobility
-
Issues within Liberalism: Democracy
- Rousseau distinguished between the 'will of the people' (self-interest=negative) and the 'general will' (consensus) and he therefore rejected democracy as being majority rule
- Rousseau believed that even if 99% of people supported one course of action, it wouldn't be for the common benefit as it was just the sum of the self-interested motives of those who formed the majority, so he preferred consensus politics
- for liberals it's acceptable to pursue self-interest and that they should use their participation in the political system to pursue that, what's not acceptable is the majority ruling at the expense of the minority. Such as N.Ireland and the 2005 ban on hunting with dogs- persecute a minority's private pastime
- democracy= a means where people could be liberated, but excessive amount can result in oppression of individuals. This is the PARADOX OF DEMOCRACY. This is where there is no guarantee that the majority is right, or that the outcome of majority rule will be just
- 19th century liberals were concerned with tyranny of the majority, and so had remedies. These include having the property qualification in order to vote, so that the irresponsible majority would be denied political rights
- modern liberals couldn't accept this denial of voting rights to the majority, and so have been forced to accept extensions on the role and power of the state in the last century
- although democracy was essential to control state power, simple democracy remained dangerous, the solution was found by looking at the USA:
- sovereign constitution protects people against the power of the state. It places controls on state power, divides power and guarantees rights. Therefore all modern liberals support a constitution and limited government
- the political structure of USA is a pluralist structure. All groups have access to decision making and legal safegaurds to protect their rights.
-
Issues within Liberalism: Democracy
- By using these American experiences, it can be summarised how modern liberals have been able to offer solutions to the paradoxes of democracy:
- the basis of democracy must be government by consent
- government should be limited by a sovereign constitution
- individual and group rights must be protected
- the political system should allow full access to all legal groups
- there must be freedom of expression
- only where there is a fundamental issue concerning the jurisdiction and system of government arises should there be direct democracy
- representative and responsible government is essential in ensuring moderate politics that will mediate interests
- PEOPLE:
- Alexis de Tocqueville (1805-59)
- Democracy is the enemy of individual liberty as the people are a collection of individuals and rule by majority will harm minority rights and individual liberty
- James Maddision
- Advocated checks and balances to avoid majoritarianism, and viewed protective democracy as a solution to government taxation and during the American Revolution 'no taxation without representation'
- Mill
- Argued that political wisdom was unequally distributed and related to education. Developmental democracy to allow personal development
- Ortega y Gasset
- Argued that mass democracy allowed authoritarian rulers to emerge by crude appeals to the masses
- Bentham
- Utilitarianism promoted universal suffrage
-
Issues within Liberalism: The State
- Liberalism has often seen that state as a threat to individual liberty.
- Mill: believed that it might seek to interfere with private parts of people's lives, and that intervention in economic markets would inhibit innovation
- Utilitarians: concerned that gov. intervention should always consider the best interests of society as a whole
- Classical Liberals: considered only the interests of the individual. If individuals could flourish without state interference- automatically create social progress
- 19th century, social Darwinists, emphasised the dangers of the state providing too much support. In the 1980s Neo-liberals believed that the excessive provision of social welfare was creating a dependency culture, so the state was rolled back.
- however, traditional liberals were more concerned with social justice and so became more tolerant of state activism
- liberals seek to protect rights from the power of the state, but the state should also be allowed to pursue liberal objectives
- equality of opportunity requires state intervention i.e. education. The pursuit of social justice has also implied the redistribution of income and wealth via state policies
- the demand for economic stability has meant that the state must intervene where the forces of the free market fail to ensure favourable conditions for that individualism
- during the 19th and 20th centuries many liberals turned to supporting constitutionalism and the rule of law. Modern liberals have many ways to control the power of the state:
- gov. to operate within constitutional rule and principles
- rule of law to operate, ensuring that all are treated equally and gov. can't discriminate. Means also that the government must always operate within the law and not act in an arbitrary way
- these principles to be upheld by an independent judiciary
- there should be a system of internal checks and balances
- government should be decentralised to make it more democratic
- democratic control-ensure representation to be kept strong
- rights of all to be guaranteed by laws that are protected from encroachments by government
-
Issues within Liberalism: Tolerance
- J.S. Mill saw tolerance in terms of liberty, any beliefs could be tolerated as long as they didn't harm others. Also stated that tolerance of ideas would ensure that society would develop because no many different ideas would enrich social and intellectual life.
- 20th century brought challenges, including:
- political movements have challenged democratic principles, should extreme views be tolerate? Liberals would say no
- attitudes to sexuality and family life have changed, liberals are inclined to accept it, but also concerned that such tolerance may cause deep changes in the nature of society
- societies are becomming increasingly culturally varied. What degree of tolerance should be applied to different cultures norms? such as the marriage of young girls? Liberals tend to suggest that such multiculturalism should be tolerated, but on the basis that such groups won't threaten the integrity of British culture.
-
Liberalism has become consensus?
- LABOUR:
- has always had the liberal value of individual freedom-many other socialist disregard in favour of equality
- has become associated with pluralism-tolerates alternative doctrines, and different views of own members
- have championed minority causes and civil liberties
- Blair promoted individualism at the expense of collectivism
- constitutional reform is now a central part of policy making
- even came to accept inequality as an inevitable consequence of free market:
- justified in a society with equal opportunity
- imposition of equality left behind by social democrats
- even encourage utilitarianism pursuit of self interest
-
Liberalism has become consensus?
- CONSERVATISM:
- New Right and neo-liberal influences in economics
- US conservatives follow limited, decentralised government, constitutionalism and civil liberties
- Cameronian/social and liberal conservative principles:
- accept Green's notion of moral obligation to aid the less fortunate
- promote equality of opportunity and social justice
- tolerate alternative lifestyle and protect individual rights
- small nationalist parties (SNP) have embraced liberal value of self-determination
- Lib Dems have strong liberal links
- stress intervention to create social/economic equality
- liberty and tolerance are still their central principles
- divided between classical and welfare/social liberalism
-
- Although there is no codified constitution, political system has developed to be very liberal:
- largely in-corrupt elections, and virtually all adults can vote
- system operates open to all parties and groups
- permanent accountability through elections. Referendums used for constitutional issues
- national minorities granted large amounts of political independence
- rights guaranteed by the HRA
- Parliament acts as a mediator for majority and minority
- HOWEVER, some illiberal aspects:
- parliamentary soveriegnty threatens individual liberty as executive can dominate via legislature
- PM power is mostly unchecked
- Unjust legal system?
- some unelected institutions have a political role-monarchy, House of Lords and public officials
-
- economic globalisation is closely linked to neoliberalism
- governments have deregulated economies and tax levels to encourage transnational corporations
- commercial liberalism which emphasises the economic and international benefits of free trade, leading to 'bonds of eternal peace' according to Cobden
- this is because everyone will be inter-dependant
-
- collapse of communism led to theorists (Fukuyama) arguing that the western liberal democracy was the final form of government
- Claimed Africa etc. were showing liberal democratic processes which would lead to greater peace internationally rather than authoritarian states. Went wrong as a result of the rise of religious fundamentalism
- claimed it was the only democracy that would last
Information
- Description
- Slide Set on Untitled, created by carysjones98 on 25/10/2015.
- Created by
- carysjones98
- Views
- 35
- Rating