Flashcards
Biogeography

Cards in this deck (200)
- 1What are the central questions of biogeography?1. What organisms are found where?
2. How are these organisms adapted to the local environment?
3. How have their distributions changed through time? - 2What is the fundamental unit of biogeography?The geographic range of a species
- 3Questions biogeographers ask 1: Why are there so many species in the tropics?a. Many theories, but none agreed. There’s a belt around the equator where most species are found. Boreal and Arctic zones don’t have many species.
b. Why do we need to conserve the tropics…? Lots of interacting processes etc. that need to be protected - 4Questions biogeographers ask 2: Why Penguins only occur in the South Pole?a. Galapagos even have penguins, penguins going up to the equator. But very few species in higher latitudes
b. Penguins are birds that can’t fly – limitations to dispersal. Range expansion of the species is hugely limited. The penguins adapted to the cold environments. - 5Questions biogeographers ask 3: Which are the ancestors of modern life forms on Earth?a. Burgess shale, Rocky Mountains - Discovered by palaeontologist Charles Walcott in 1909. Found incredible amount of biodiversity in this period.
b. The Cambrian (505 million years ago) explosion Astonishing burst of biodiversity occurred in the ancient oceans.
c. Famous for the exceptional preservation of the soft parts of its fossils
d. Questions as to why we do not have the species now – evolution/ extinction
e. Most ‘lost’ species in current phenogenic traits – evidence for evolution - 6Who is Alexander Von Humboltd, (1769-1859)?• Father of phytogeography
• Expanded latitudinal biodiversity gradients into elevational gradients. Visited Tenerife in 1799!
• Plants are distributed in elevation zones (or floristic belts).
• He travelled to the tropics (New World) and inspired a generation pf scientist (Darwin, Wallace, etc.)
• He visited Tenerife in 1799 for a week during which he climbed the Teide peak and made the first known account of the variation of the vegetation along an elevation gradient, recognizing different altitudinal belts, a scheme that is still essentially valid.
• Put latitudinal gradients into context and a map
• Questioned why there is these boundaries
• On top of mountains lots of endemic species - 7Who is Charles Darwin (1809-1882)?• Emphasized importance of long- distance dispersal in biogeographic distribution of species.
• 1831: 5-year voyage on the Beagle to South America.
• Collected samples of rocks, plants, animals, fossils.
• Developed the theory of evolution by natural selection; The Origin of Species (1859).
• The voyage on the Beagle to South America
- Theory developed only once he came back and analysed the species he brought back and tried to explain where they came from
- Galapagos island used for many theories - 8Who is Alfred Russel Wallace, (1823-1913)?• Father of zoogeography.
• The fossil record provides positive evidence for past migrations of organisms.
• Geological and ocean floor studies
• Physical and geological techniques used
* The Wallace line (Asiatic species split from species of a mixture of Asian and Australian origin) - 9Who is Alfred Wegener, (1880-1930)?• The theory of plate tectonics and continental drift.
• Composition of species found seemed similar in very different places
• Dispersal of species showing a strange pattern
• This theory was rejected! And not accepted until 1960! - 10Who are McArthur and Wilson?• Island biogeography! The field was started in the 1960s.
• The theory of Island Biogeography: attempted to predict the number of species that would exist on a newly created island.
• Islands very good for biogeographers
o Many can be dated
o Can see colonisation/ extinction events
o Lots of endemic species - 11How has biodiversity built on Earth over time?- Evidence in rocks that sun was 75% less bright than now in the Precambrian
- Paleozoic – fern trees
- Mesozoic – gymnosperms and dinosaurs
- 12How is the changing distribution of land and ocean over deep time linking Earth history and biogeography?1. Changes in sea level and global climate
2. Appearance and disappearance of dispersal barriers and corridors
3. Continental 'rafting' of biotas
4. Evolution - appearance of novel species and species extinction over time
(the patterns in the changes in Earth history, changes in the onsets (sea level and climate) and evolutionary timescales show how everything links in Earth history) - 13What is the geologic timescale?- Mainly use the Cenozoic, Mesozoic, Palaeozoic and pre Cambrian for biogeography
- Tend to concentrate on epochs in biodiversity (not periods etc.)
- 14What does the sub sections of the geologic timescale look like?1. On the left are ages, which are based on an average timescale.
2. The original geological boundaries are based on BIOSTRATIGRAPHIC data – fossil assemblages that could be correlated and established as belonging to the same period of time. Typically, these are marine fossil assemblages.
- 15What is the - Biogeographical way of looking at historic timescales over millions of years?- Shows changes to life and the earth supporting life
- Primitive life flowering plants humans over time
- Precambrian – where everything started - 16What are Stromatolites and their significance?- Stromatalites earliest microbes/ bioherms in the world which can still be seen
- For new thinking about why the Cambrian explosion (adaptive radiation) occurred, see Nature article by Fox (see last slide)
- For a great read on the Cambrian Explosion, see Wonderful Life by Stephen Jay Gould
- The next major event was the emergence of life on land - 17What is the difference between the Precambrian and the Cambrian?- Evolutionary time shows jump from soft organisms to species with hard parts
- Fossil of a turtle that only had one shell (not one underneath, one on top)
- Explosion of biodiversity in the Cambrian
- Thousands of years not considered over evolutionary terms – just millions of years - 18When was the evolution of wings?- The Devonian comprised of up to 10 million living species, which were present in all 7 continents and inhabit every terrestrial niche
- According to the fossil record, they were scarce before about 325 million years ago outnumbered by their arachnids and myriapods (centipeds and millipedes)
- Why insects weren’t abundant at the time of the Devonian. Scientists puzzled to why this the case. - 19What are the 4 stages in insect evolution (linking geological time with evolution)?1. Appearance of primitive wingless insects
2. Development of wings
3. Development of wing flexion
4. Development of metamorphosis - 20What are the 2 hypothesis for why there was no wingless insects in the Devonian?1. Hypothesis 1: insect size and abundance were limited by the amount of oxygen available in Earth's atmosphere during the late Devonian period.
a. The atmospheric oxygen level about 385 million years ago was below 15%, For comparison, today's atmospheric oxygen concentration is about 21%.
2. Hypothesis 2: insects were abundant before, but don't show up in the fossil record.
a. The fossil record looks just how you would expect if insects were rare until they evolved wings, at which point they very rapidly increased in diversity and abundance (Schachat et al, 2018).
- Environmental conditions may not have been good enough. Found the fossils weren’t abundant enough to have been preserved and the rocks couldn’t preserve wings. Not to do with lack of oxygen.
- During Devonian there were lots of insects
- Metamorphosis in the Carboniferous - 21What was the consequence of the evolution of wings?* In the Devonian, dragonflies had evolved. But some species had >0.5 m wingspans
- The large species now extinct thought to be because of a competition of the niche, climatic changes or predation
- Evolution of wings triggered a great explosion of species of insects with wings, may of which may have evolved to the ones we know today - 22What is the significance of the turn in the Carboniferous?By the Carboniferous, there were plant groups with modern descendants – e.g., horsetails (Equisetum)
- Plasticity, adaptation and potentially the internal structure has meant these species are still existing today - 23What is the significance of Gondwana and modern day Madagascar?• Madagascar: flowering plant species endemism 92%; land vertebrates 84% (Goodman and Benstead, 2005)
• Spatial changes in Earth has impacted the biodiversity of many areas
• We need to understand the history of the Earth to understand the biodiversity of Madagascar
• 88 million years without being connected by other land masses
• Understanding where all of Madagascar's species came from require the understanding of the geological history
• Madagascar was landlocked in the middle of the supercontinent Gondwana.
• Through movements of the Earth's crust, Madagascar, along with India, first split from Africa and South America and then from Australia and Antarctica and started heading north.
• Madagascar has been on its own for the past 88 million years. If it had been connected it may have been a different story. - 24What is meant by the changing Earth (continental drift)?• Continental drift: a model, first proposed by Wegener, stating that the continents were once united and have since become independent structures that have been displaced over the surface of the globe. Found in more modern science when looking at the magnetics in geology of the rocks. The plate tectonics does not just refer to land mass, but oceans moving at the same time.
• Lack of mechanism for moving continents Wegener said that continents broke through the ocean crust.
• Plate Tectonics (1965): the study of the origin, movement, and destruction of plates and how these events have been involved in the evolution of Earth’s crust. Provided the missing pieces thanks to palaeomagnatis: If continents had never moved the particles should all point to the present magnetic poles
• Tectonic plates that may contain continents and parts of oceans, or only ocean floor. Their movement I known as plate tectonics (rather than continental drift) - 25How has the idea for plate tectonics been supported?* By the floor of the oceans.
• Plate tectonics are driven by the earth’s energy. Blocks of continental crust area advected around the planet, sometimes splitting, sometimes colliding. See both texts and many other great sources (e.g. USGS URL)
• Tectonics has been supported by the magnetic changes of the floor - 26What is Pangea?• The Permian supercontinent of Pangaea saw both huge desert form and an ice age come and go, and greatly reduced shallow shelf areas. While there is some evidence for a meteorite impact, there was also massive volcanism, probably leading to major changes in atmospheric and ocean chemistry.
• All these stressor may have led to the unfolding of a mass extinction (more in lecture 25!). - 27What happened when Pangea split?- Massive mass extinction at the end of the Permian as Pangea split – the environmental and climatic factors in the area would start changing
- 28What is the significance for biodiversity of Earth history/ land mass splitting?- Biodiversity very linked to Earth history and the evolutionary changes in the changes to river openings, connection to other land masses, oceans etc. There is changes to niche.
• Plate tectonics has been the most important factor in causing major long term changes in the patterns of distribution of organisms
• Change of latitude (one of most important parts to understanding biodiversity) occurs when the continents move - 29What evidence that contributed to the acceptance of the Theory of Continental Drift?1. Stratigraphic evidence - Distribution of Precambrian shields and flood basalts.
a. Investigation of the ocean floor adjacent to oceanic ridges showed that the sea floor was spreading (ridges are spreading centres). Used palaeomagnetism to show this—the same patterns that show time in the geologic column.
2. Evidences that contributed to the acceptance of the Theory of Continental Drift: “Ring of Fire”
a. About 90% of the world's earthquakes and 81% of the world's largest earthquakes occur along the Ring of Fire (USGS)
b. Evidences that contributed to the acceptance of the Theory of Continental Drift
3. Palaeoeclimatic evidence
a. Map the same in the areas.
b. Arrows show direction of earth movement
c. Glacial deposits and glacial movement
d. Scouring on rocks indicate the direction
4. Palaentological evidence
a. Bones of the mammal found in many different areas - 30What have disjunct distributions of some living taxa often been taken as evidence for?* That their ancestral forms radiated across Gondwana
1. Southern temperate beetle
2. Nontropical freshwater fishes
3. plants Proteacea family
4. Aquatic frogs (Pipidae)
• Beetle in Australia, New Zealand and the other side of the ocean in Argentina and Brazil
• Occurs with fish too, not just terrestrial species
• How can this be explained? (Could be an exam question….!)
a. Dispersal or plate tectonics
• Takes a long time for scientists to work all this out - 31Wallace’s line: why the biota different between E and W Indonesia?• Wallace discovered that the faunas on the two sides of this line very different.
• The line marks a highly dynamic plate boundary (Asian, Australian, Pacific)- reflecting differences in geological history. - 32What is the significance of the recent discovery of Zealandia and Mauritia?Earth’s Hidden Continent
• Recently found Mauritia and Zealandia are both under the ocean – theories changing and having to think again about connection and disconnection of many different areas - 33What is Taxonomy, systematics, ecology and trophic?1. Taxonomy: classification & naming of organisms.
2. Systematics: includes evolutionary relationships of organisms.
3. Ecology: how organisms interact and are affected by their environment.
4. Trophic: how energy flows in an ecological community. Energy is exchanged through the food chain. Plant to predators (the top of the food chain). - 34What are the levels of organisation for species?***Species --> populations --> communities --> ecosystems ---> the biosphere***
• Species are one species
• Population – of a particular species
• Communities – Many populations living in the same area
• Ecosystems – A collection of communities - 35How many species currently exist?• 3 million species have been already described.
• Only about 1.5 million in any detail
• Lots of room for science and research
• There can be lots of surprises found with new research techniques - 36How are species classed through Linnean taxonomy?E.g. for the Gentoo penguin:
1. Kingdom: Animalia
2. Phylum: Chordata
3. Class: Aves
4. Order: Sphenisciformes
5. Family: Spheniscidae
6. Genus: Pygoscelis
7. Species: Pygoscelis papua (there can even be a third word here to describe a species) - 37What are the Cichlids and their importance in defining species?• Fish diversity reaches its high in tropical rift valley lake ecosystems.
• Lake Malawi (Africa) harbours more than 850 species of cichlids that are thought to have diverged from a common ancestor (Moyle and Cech 2003)
• Different morphologies and colours, but just the same specie
• The conditions in the lake mean they evolve differently to the different niches in the lakes – can be different pH, temperature, predators, surrounding organisms in the lake - 38What is the Morphological species concept?* Also known as the classical species concept. Since the beginning of taxonomy has been the main operational criterion used to delineate different species.
* Main assumption: morphological differences between species have an underlying genetic basis that is heritable.
* Challenge: Cryptic species: species within a genus that are morphologically so similar that they cannot be distinguished by superficial features (sibling sp.). E.g. animals that appear identical but are genetically quite distinct.
* Cryptic species: Species within genus that are morphologically so similar that there cannot be visually distinguished by superficial features
* These species are gene8cally dis8nct but extremely similar in their morphology and ecology
•Butterflies and the bees look so similar in the field they would be classed as the same species, but genetically these can be very different - 39What is the Biological species concept?a. Ernst Mayr (1893-1969) Group of populations that can reproduce among themselves and not with other groups. Offsprings are fully fertile.
b. Challenge: Difficult to identify reproductive isolation - 40What is the Ecological species concept?a. Arises from the organism’s need to find its own place in the natural world. In the face of competition from other organisms, it must develop a set of characteristics (morphological, behavioural, physiological, etc.) that give it an advantage over the competitors. These specializations define its ecological niche.
b. Challenge: Can miss cryptic species. Many taxa exploit overlapping resources, this is not a very robust species concept. - 41What are subspecies?• A taxonomic category used by systematists. A well differentiated population of genetically or morphologically distinct set of populations of a species, confined in a particular area
• ... Adding complexity...
• Linnean classification!
o Pygoscelis papua papua and the smaller Pygoscelis papua ellsworthii
o Found different populations were smaller and genetics proved them to be a sub specie - 42What are polytypic and monotypic species?1. Polytypic species
a. a specie that have a series of subspecies. Most of the widespread species (species occurring in different niches over the world) are Polytypic.
2. Monotypic species
a. a specie that exist in just one form (and in one place). Without any subspecies. Specialized species (host-plant specific insects). Do not form polytypic species - 43What is Heliconius cydno?Is a polytypic species ranging from southern Mexico to western Ecuador. Butterflies have been very well studied for migrations and genetics. Increasing a gradient in latitude means different environmental conditions. There are found to be many subspecies as you follow the latitude down.
- 44What is Cephalotus folliularis?A monotypic relict family of carnivorous plants endemic to the high rainfall swamps of the Southwest Australian Floristic Region. Only occur here. No subspecies anywhere else
- 45What is a population?• Krebs (1972). A group of organisms of the same species occupying a particular space at a particular time.
• Another specie added in this environment would make a community - 46What is meant by population growth and demography?• The size of a range, location of its boundaries, and shrinking patterns of abundance reflect the influence of environmental conditions on the survival, reproduction, and dispersal of organisms and the dynamics of populations.
• Malthus (1978) showed that: All organisms have the inherent potential to increase their numbers exponentially.
* Human population growth at nearly exponential rate
• However, because resources limit growth, and many environments are unsuitable, no organisms actually increase indefinitely.
• There is a limit to exponential growth – there are limitations to growth (food, space, climate) - 47What is the rate of change in a population?l
- 48How are these species and populations distributed in space and time?• The area of distribution is an essential concept in biogeography Several mapping systems... any example?
• Mapping rather than a graph with time and growth
• Can use GPS to locate the species and clickers and (now) cameras to count - 49What is an example for effects of the spatial scale of analysis on the perceived distribution of a species?• Clematis fremontii in Missouri
• On different spatial scales. Note that at all scales the population is patchy.
• Larger scale: Geographic range based on known collecting localities.
• The most local scale: shows dispersion of individual plants within a single local population. - 50What are environmental gradients and organism responses?-Environmental gradient of the climate etc.
-Zones of intolerance – species cannot possibly survive (temperature is way too high or low ect.)
- Very important in shaping biodiversity
- Gaussian distribution – limiting the distribution of species
- Optimal conditions allow strong growth of populations - 51What are limits to distributions?1. Climatic barriers: temperature and precipitation
a. Saguaro cactus (Sonoran Desert in Arizona and NW Mexico) in relation to winter temperature regime. Distribution limited by low temperatures (sensitive to temperatures below -7°C).
2. Physical barriers: high mountains, arid deserts, etc..
3. Geological barriers: soil chemistry and structure.
4. Historical factors: changes in the pattern of land masses over the surface of the Earth. Or the past expansion of ice masses. Much longer in time and more difficult to put in a map!
5. Chance! The arrival of wind-borne insect or seeds can find the niche and then can increase in their population – exponentially… (important for understanding invasive species)
6. Biological barriers: when an organism is subjected to increased predation, etc. promotes completion limits geographic ranges. - 52What is the definitions for niche?Niche: The total requirements of a population or species for resources and physical conditions.
• Grinnell (1917)
o Habitat concept (physical space used by a population). Emphasis on where the species lives. Not of its occupant!
• Hutchinson (1957)
o Most accepted definition of niche now
o Includes habitat, climate, behaviour, etc. Multidimensional ecological niche.
o hyper volume
- With salinity vs. temperature shown, it can be seen where the boundaries of the niche are
- We do need to include population growth though
- The salinity is shown to have a more defined boundary, so is more important to get right
- It is best that the niche is in the middle of each parameter to be best suited to the specie - 53What is the ecological niche?• Environmental conditions where populations of a species can survive without the need to immigrate.
• Describes the “ecological space” occupied by an organism
• Kestrels and owls overlap in their food requirements (Small mammals)
• But they obtain their food under different conditions – competition in reality at a minimum – we need to look at where, when and how to say whether species are in competition or not
(The ecological niche could be in one dimension (Species with different but overlapping requirements for a critical resource or habitat), but the actual niche a ‘hypervolume’ of many dimensions - 54What is the Fundamental niche?• The niche a species could occupy if only limited by the environment, and not by interactions with other species. Absence of any interspecific competition and predation
- 55What is the realized niche?• The observed ecological space a species uses – subset of entire fundamental niche.
(thinking of overlapping A and B venn diagram;)
• If A and B fundamental niches overlap and B is the stronger compe8tor, A’s realised niche shrinks.
• Sharing the niche.
• A kestrel and owl will not have any overlap in terms of food as they do not share the same niche - 56How does (inter and intra) species competition happen?1. Inter-specific competition (DIFFERENT SPECIES) - Different species share the same resource—unless they can partition its use, one species may eventually out-compete the other. Example, grey squirrels and red squirrels in Britain. The realized niche of red squirrels is reduced—and so are red squirrel numbers. Inter-specific competition is a factor affecting species diversity.
2. Intra-specific competition (THE SAME SPECIE) - Individuals of the same species directly share the same resources leads to limitation of population size: seedlings may fail to grow under parent tree if deprived of light; plants in the desert are spaced apart as water is limiting; there may be competition for reproductive opportunities (rut in deer) - 57What is the definition of vegetation and flora, fauna and biota?4. Vegetation
a. Contains species but also describes STRUCTURE
b. Forest, grassland, woodland
c. Particular 3D structure and way of life made up of species
d. Also includes functional properties
5. Flora, fauna and biota (flora and fauna)
a. Species: building blocks of biodiversity – species have names (finding more now that are needing to be given names…)
b. The planet’s inhabitants
c. Identifiable by looks, sounds, structure, genetics - 58What is the definition of Autecology, community ecology and ecosystem ecology?7. Community ecology
a. Focus on a community or communities – suitable habitats, role of habitat in species composition, interactions among species, species replacement and community change – competition, disturbance, succession, predation, mutualism
b. Habitat defined in space, but many communities can live in pockets in the habitats
c. Interactions provide competition and sucsession
8. Ecosystem ecology
a. Ecosystems have a place (physical location) and the interactions of the species – how the species then process and affect planetary flows (ecosystems an accounting system for earth system functions)
b. Energetics and nutrients, species interacting with their physical environment
c. A systems approach
d. e.g. the role of vegetation in the carbon cycle or plant productivity – productivity a product of how much photosynthesis there is and how many species can live off this
- Ecologists will choose what they observe - 59What is the community concept?• A human construct (humans like to put things in lists) – when we look at plants, animals, bacteria, etc. as assemblages of species in a specified area/place (raised bog, benthic stream invertebrates, your intestinal tract)
• Scope of a community varies with scale of organisms and types of interactions being studied
• Typically spatially defined by habitats—local conditions of soil, geology, drainage, topography, etc. (Peat only in specific areas etc.)
• May be characterized by taxa that are specially adapted to the conditions
• Typified by the physical properties of that area of the landscape
(- Bogs very unusual places.
- Sphagnum - creates the habitat through the bogs. Water all the way through it, but not much else (a very unique pore size)
- Sundews insectivorous plants that live in bogs – well adapted to the wet conditions. The insects can provide nutrients to the bog) - 60What is the ecosystem concept?• Another human construct
• Communities envisioned with respect to roles such as nutrient cycling, energy capture, regulation of other processes (such as hydrology) – depicted as components and flows and amenable to modelling
• Communities well defined for their own conditions
• The bog as an example: Community of species adapted to unusual hydrology and low nutrients
o Insectivorous plants, bog moss
o Ecosystem – low productivity BUT high carbon storage (peat bogs storing carbon to take CO2 out – we don’t want to mine them/ dry them out and let them oxidise) - 61What are biomes?• Biomes the big scale
• Boreal forest for example have similar biota, but occur in different places over the globe
• Biota will adapt to the landscapes
• Identified with climatic zones (that big! – reflecting back what it takes to survive in particular climatic conditions))
• Large biotas
• But may be mostly lost to anthropogenic land‐cover change (e.g., prairie)
• Humans now changing the biomes (especially those ones that are useful for carbon)
• (Covered in 1001 – see Lomolino or Cox) - 62What are the important emergent properties?1.Diversity – numbers of different species
2.Resilience – qualities of resistance in recovery to perturbations
3.Persistence – timescales coming very important (millions of years ago to more contemporary) - 63What kinds of features underlie the important emergent properties, and why are the properties important for biological conservation?• Definitions of resilience – integrate concept of vulnerability (in face of environmental stress, biotic invasion, etc) and ability to retain original composition (resistant) or absorb invading species with no great disruption (flexible resilience). Can cope with perturbations. There may be a tipping point as the stress or invasion progresses, however.
• Some plants/ animals may be more resistant to changes via climate or human impacts
• Persistence – how long do we observe a community or a biome to be in place – with variation over time, some loss or addition of species, but no clear trajectory of change
o In biogeography, this can be a question asked about recognizable communities that exist for thousands to millions of years (same functional types, same genera, mostly same species) – e.g., the so‐called “Tertiary forest” of eastern North America, Europe and China. The deciduous forests in eastern North America have 30-40 species in a square mile. Same in China, but of different species. In Europe there are less species but are similar to American ones. Narrowing the time scale - 64What is meant by species richness?• Count of species, often is one group eg birds, bryophytes
• Usually for a community - 65What is meant by and what are the 4 types of diversity?• Accounting for evenness or dominance
o 1. Alpha(α) local diversity, eg a vegetation plot or a plankton scoop, number of birds on campus
o 2. Gamma (γ) regional diversity (bigger picture) ‐‐‐ estimated from many observations of local diversity – this key to defining diversity hotspots on a geographic scale (e.g. all the birds in the Hampshire basin/ southern England)
o 3. Beta (β) is about gradients in the environment (biotic but often dominated by abiotic features, e.g., elevation, soil catenas etc) and how rapidly species composition changes along the gradient. Can be applied in other ways, but this easy to grasp. (How many species we can pack into an environment). Beta diversity high where species turnover a lot over an environmental gradient. Different species may be found in different patches (gradient deterred by a lot of different patches, not just a linear gradient)
o 4. Delta (δ) measure of dissimilarity between large geographic areas - 66What are key diversity indicies?• Larger diversity index, more species. In Shannon index, a higher number shows a more even distribution of species.
• Species richness is an important biogeographic measure – the number of species in an area/region (defining species‐rich areas etc)
• Alpha and Gamma are estimated in a similar way: a function of species present and their abundances
• Shannon’s diversity (H’) ‐ΣPi ln(Pi) [log function downplays high abundances] (Minimises dominance – as in the first square in example)
• Simpson’s diversity (D) 1 ‐ ΣPi2 [square function emphasizes dominant species] (big numbers stay big – indicates the dominance of a species)
• Pi is the abundance of species i, when there are i species in the species pool [index sums all abundances] - 67What is meant by Evenness, dominance and rarity?• Controlled by species traits, interactions and environment—vary with scale
• Plants: Small‐scale (plot) dominance – even physical environment– traits about size, growth rates, and competition. Meadows will have lots of one thing, but there can be rare species hiding – lots of competition to reach the light.
• Multi‐layered plant communities (e.g. forests) can include plants with a range of traits, and not all compete. Deciduous woodland with spring‐flowering understory. Trees will cut the light out, so temporal separation of plants (spring ephemerals (e.g. bluebells) and then trees over the rest of summer)
• Rarity: rare species more susceptible to chance elimination of local populations
o In animal communities, the energy pyramid means predators are rare
o At larger geographic scales, there is always rarity—why?
1.Habitat heterogeneity
2.Food preferences
3.Fugitives and poor competitors – species hiding in corners. Bog species (there are less competitors as not nice place to be)
4. Succession
5. Time you are sampling – just after a disturbance, there will be les - 68What is beta diversity?• Change in species composition on a gradient
• Often depicted as length of an ordination axis (see Tenerife field course field courses) (graph on left) – serpentine soils across a gradient
• Whittaker and Niering –Santa Catalinas Right Hand diagram shows change with elevation on Y‐axis and aspect on X‐axis: NNE SSW
o Local climate changes
o Can change from conifer woodland to alpine nearer the top
o Function of different solar radiation (in Northern Hemisphere it is cooler on the North side of a mountain)
- Running down through California and the Rockies- mountain areas have greater beta diversity
- Mountain areas harder to live in/ transform – so a big focus on national parks for conservation - 69What are examples showing the statement changes in the controls over processes that structure communities and ecosystems will in turn affect which species are present and levels of diversityo Habitat heterogeneity‐‐mountains (Whittaker)
o Intermediate disturbance hypothesis (Connell)
o Suppression of dominance via biotic interactions (chalk downland)
o Tipping points and multiple drivers of change (fire dynamics)
o Habitat heterogeneity in tundra and response to climate change - 70What was the study undertaken by Robert Whittaker?• Ground-breaking study in ecology – greater species going around the mountains and up and down the mountains
• Describes how species are strcutred
• Underpins who lives in a particular area show lots of change – species found in habitats can actually be quite different (due to the hugely large historic timescales – species will interact to different challenges individually)
• The great Smoky Mountains are highly diverse.
• He described the great range of habitat heterogeneity in 3 dimensions, discussing diversity, turnover, species autecology, and assembly rules.
• At the time, there was a debate about how communities were structured: i) as predicable, repeatable units or ii) as individualistic responses, governed by chance and opportunity (new idea). His familiarity via years of fieldwork showed him that although communities in similar habitats looked superficially similar, it was the latter – this paradigm shift underpins much of modern plant community ecology. - 71What was the study undertaken by Margret Davis?• A paleoecologist, mapped the migration history of eastern North American tree species using pollen data. She showed as trees returned northward after glacial retreat and warming over thousands of years, they indeed showed individualistic patterns of recolonization and that various forest communities were geologically and ecologically “young”.
• The consituants of the tertiary forest coming together only really quite recently as the grouping of the forests in America seen today
• Moved at different times – adaptations and readjustments over times (particularly in the ice ages).
• Not much equilibrium – things always changing
• In years since, people have questioned how broadly applicable the hypothesis is, but it still stands as a useful guideline for understanding why diversity may be changing, especially in relation to fire. See Johnstone et al 2016 and Enright et al 2015 in Frontiers* - 72What scales do disturbances occur over?frequency and intensity
Organisms are damaged or killed. Succession occurs, beginning with low species numbers, and then numbers rise with time. After long periods of no disturbance, competitive exclusion leads to species loss and establishment of dominants. Thus the “non‐equilibrium” state in which communities are knocked back by disturbance is likely to have the greatest species richness. Supported by data from reefs and rainforests.
• Lots of big disturbances are hard on species – species will go extinct
• A middle ground of disturbances (in time and intensity) will give the largest number of species when looking at a large historical time range
• Ecology to unpredictable and uncertain, complex systems, so the theories cannot be set in stone - 73What is the significance of Chalk grasslands for diversity?• Creating diversity by interfering with the competitive balances
• See South Downs National Park Publication Chalk Grassland: the European equivalent to tropical rainforest
• Formed over millennia from clearance and stock grazing
• As soon as the animals are taken off, the grasslands will return to shrub
• Humans are the influencers
• Nutritious chalk turf supports many plant species, which in turn support a high diversity of insects, especially butterflies
• Up to 45 species per square metre
• But needs grazing/mowing to survive
• Grazing keeps all plants cut back – potential dominants are suppressed
• Rainforests, reefs, mountain regions, chalk grasslands... all high‐diversity systems and of great conservation value - 74What are mutualisms?1. Pollination – plant-animal mutalism linked to adaptive radiation of the flowering plants
2. Mycorrhizae – associations of plants and fungi – may influence plant establishment in new habitats (fungus gets carbohydrates, plants get more nutrients from the fungi) – would need to bring both parts to migrate, as otherwise wouldn’t survive as well (dependent - 75What are tipping points?• More recently, focus as moved to multiple drivers of change and “surprises”. Critical transitions, safe operating spaces for forests, climate change; see Johnstone et al. 2016
• Interactions between disease transmission, host mortality, and subsequent fire behaviour and mortality that may feedback to influence changes in forest states. Johnstone et al. 2016 - 76What is an example of a cycle that can move the ecosystem/ community into a different state/ place?1. (a) The pathogen Phytophthora ramorum alters forest structure by selectively killing host species, as in this landscape near Big Sur, CA.
2. (b) Structural changes may then alter fire behaviour across the forest landscape, such as in (c) when injured host species, such as tanoaks (Notholithocarpus densiflorus), carry flames into the forest crowns, increasing the mortality of redwood (Sequoia sempervirens) trees.
3. (d) Hosts vary in susceptibility to the pathogen: for example, cellular processes influence the spread of P ramorum hyphae
4. (e) Spread of the pathogen is shaped by the distribution and connectivity of potential hosts, such as these infested leaves of California bay laurel (Umbellularia californica); the pathogen may return to influence forest structure and future - 77What is the case study of Finse, Norway about?(Opedal et al 2014)
* Small scale complexity in the landscape (beta diversity)
• Habitat heterogeneity on a small scale (10s of m)
• More microclimatic variation in rough than flat terrain
• Turnover (Beta diversity) estimated as a dissimilarity measure between plots
• Niche size estimated by observed climate envelope and co‐ occurring species
• Species richer in rough habitats
• More turnover, more species in rough terrain
• Complex (heterogeneous) habitats may allow species re‐ shuffling on local landscapes in response to climate change (alternative to long‐distance migration)
• A stress/ pressure (climate change) – complicated places better, as could allow the survival of species who can move to other areas over a short scale rather than over a long timescale - 78What is meant by species richness, endemic species and cosmopolitan (widespread) species?o 1. Species richness: number of species per unit area (i.e. human + spider = 2)
o 2. Endemic species: Pertaining to a taxon that is restricted to the geographic area specified, such as continent, lake, biome, or island. Meaning of continental endemic specie will be slightly different. Always have to state where the endemic specie is from.
o 3. Cosmopolitan (or widespread species): occurring essentially worldwide, as on all habitable landmasses or in all major oceanic regions. (Rats or pigeons – can have different conservation/ biological issues – invasive etc..). (Polytypic species are cosmopolitan). - 79What are meant by biogeographic kingdoms (at top of hierarchy of distribution areas)- Huge scope of the map
- Many different ways to classify biodiversity on earth
- Kingdoms trying to group species under the same evolutionary processes
- Oriental cut off at the Himalayas, Ethiopian at the Sahara
- Limited by distribution of physical traits - 80What is Sclater’s classification of marine biogeographic regions?(see image)
- Marine distributions over the oceans
- Arctiernia – particular species of seal only occurring in one particular area of the ocean - 81How is complexity added to where species are found?- Increasing latitude
- Increasing aridity (environmental gradient)
- Triangle – the base much bigger. At the equator there is the biggest gradient of aridity (elevation 0). At the poles, there is just tundra and not much change in aridity
- More biodiversity at lower latitude - 82What is a climograph?• Diagram quantifying some aspects of the relationship between climate and vegetation types
*****(See notes)*****
- Just temperature and precipitation (climograph)
- Can find the expected vegetation at specific precipitation/ temperature
- Links environmental gradients, limits to distribution (can then see how species sit and what the set of traits are that the specie possesses to be able to survive in the area) - 83How does it come that in very different flora region plants occur with a quite predictable spectrum in life forms?• Most important forms according to Raunkiær, 1934
• Plants classification according to the place where the growth point is located during the less favorable seasons, provided the plant maintains the capability to survive these difficult condition
- Looks into the mechanism of how these plants survive (even though all do) – where the habitats
- There are different growing strategies depending on where they live - 84What is the significance of each climatic zone having its own spectrum of life forms?• In the tropics relatively many Phanerophytes (trees) occur.
• In an arid climate (desert) relatively numerous annuals (Therophytes).
• In a more temperate zone Cryptophytes and Hemicryptophytes (rosette plants, plants with rhizoids, bulbs, turnips) are relatively abundant.
• Not all strategies for surviving happen over the world – limited to climate
• Raunkiær (1934) - 85What traits are seen in species depending on where their habitat is?1. Body size
2. Dispersal capacity
3. Color
Etc... - 86What is meant by body size and Bergmann’s rule?• Bergmann’s Rule (1847):
o Body size increases with latitude.
o Within a given group of organisms, those with larger body sizes will be found at higher latitudes.
• Therefore, animals tend to be larger in cold areas than in tropical ones.
• Tested across different species and different regions - 87What is Allen’s rule?• Animals in colder climates have shorter appendages than their close relatives in warmer climates.
• Lepus in north America show a decline in the length of their ears with decreasing temperature
o Species on the left occur in hot deserts
o Species on the right in cold tundra.
o Species In the middle in intermediate temperate environments
• In endothermic animals from cold environments tend to have shorter ears, tail, and legs.
• Endotherms – bodies control the temperature (frogs/ reptiles have bodies that don’t control temperature – so surroundings are very important) - 88What is Gloger’s rule?• More darker forms tend to be found in more humid environments,
o e.g. near the equator to avoid UV
• In cold environments the colour of the species tend to be lighter.
o Easy to hide in snow.
• Floral pigmentation patterns provide an example of Gloger's rule in plants (Koski, 2015)
• Gloger's rule explains patterns of variation in UV-absorbing floral pigmentation in a widespread plant, Argentina anserina (Rosaceae).
• Associated with higher UVB incidence (Equator) - 89What is the importance of latitudinal gradients?- Important in biogeography to look at the patterns
- In the equator, there are higher levels of biodiversity
- Nearer the poles there are very few species
• Species diversity decreases with increasing latitude.
• Increasing species diversity from the poles to the Equator (less at the poles)
- More species of butterfly at the equator, not nearer the poles
- In equator zone there is much of the biodiversity of habitat types
• One of the most widely recognized (and studied) patterns in biogeography!
• Lots of research aimed at explaining this pattern - 90what is the significance of the Guayana Highlands?- Table mountains surrounded by Amazonia on one side, savannah on the other
- Amount of biodiversity on the top of the tepui similar to that on islands
- There are endemic genus on top of the mountains (42% of the species on the mountains are endemic to the mountain top and not found below on the flat)
• GAM analysis included: elevation, area, MDE, species richness for 8 tepuis (the flat mountain tops in the area).
• In non-endemics there is a complete decline with elevation - 91What is endemism?- Australia has highest amount of endemic species of mammal (extinctions will be very important – the genetic biodiversity has to be conserved
- 92What is the importance of elevation?• Decrease in species diversity with increase in elevation.
- Himalayas one of highest elevation gradients in the world 0-9000m
- Most biodiversity happening at the mid elevations (species of plants)
• Hump-shaped pattern: described as the most common in a review of 304 data sets (Rahbek, 2005)
- 2000 – 4000m show a big peak in species
- Limits to distribution due to climatic factors however
- Pattern the same in Costa Rica – hump shaped pattern the same - 93What are the main conditions to the changing elevation?1. Moisture
2. Pressure
3. Temperature
• Causes vary depending on the species Environmental factors - 94What is the case study for single-island endemics in the Canaries?• Observed relationships between the percentage of Single Island Endemics and elevation.
• Endemic species increasing with elevation
• Ecological insulation
• The ecological isolation of the high elevation habitats occurring at high altitude ecosystems would promote in situ speciation leading to a higher percentage of endemic species
• (Kessler,2002; Steinbauer et al, 2012; Nogué et al, 2013).
- Some variation, but at the world level, endemic species increasing with elevation - 95What are the main processes that shape the pattern of non- endemic species richness?• Main processes in shaping this pattern of NE species richness:
o 1. Dispersal, climatic filtering along elevational gradients
o 2. Human land-use are the involved
• NE species tend to decline with elevation - 96What is meant by a discontinuous range of taxon?• In which at least two closely related populations are separated by a wide geographic distance...??
- 97What is dispersal?• Dispersal is the movement of organisms away from their point of origin.
• There are 3 fundamental processes in biogeography:
o 1. Speciation (lecture 8) (SEE for revision: https://evolution.berkeley.edu/evolibrary/article/_0_0/speciationmodes_03)
o 2.Extinction (lecture 25 and 26)
o 3. Dispersal
• All the biogeographical patterns that we study derived from the effects of these processes - 98Want creates successful dispersal and Range Expansion?• To expand its range, a species must be able to:
o 1.Travel to a new area
o 2. Withstand potentially unfavourable conditions during its passage
Lots of species currently arriving through tourists/ transport, but these don’t often survive
o 3. Establish a viable population upon arrival.
• Dispersal is not dispersion! - 99What types of dispersal are there?1. Jump dispersal (or long-distant dispersal): dispersal that is accomplished by movement of individuals within relatively short period.
2. Diffusion: a form of range expansion that is accomplished over generations by individuals spreading out from the margins of the species range.
3. Secular migration: geographic range expansion, which is so slow (e.g. many generations!) that it is often accompanied by substantial evolutionary changes in the population en route. They expand to colonize new regions. Similar to diffusion. - 100What is jump dispersal?1. Jump dispersal (or long-distant dispersal): dispersal that is accomplished by movement of individuals within relatively short period.
a. Happens very fast
• An example can be seen in the rapid colonization of Krakatau islands after a volcanic eruption (1883) removed two- thirds of the largest island (Rakata) and buried all three islands in a blanket of volcanic ash, eliminating life from their land surfaces.
• All life on the island and other islands around it completely eradicated
• What will happen now there is no species on the island?...
•Study found that between 1883 and 1940, there was a big increase in number of species arriving and settling in the islands
•In 50 years, the dense tropical forest re-established
•Rapid new populations established in Krakatau
•It has been documented both active and passive transport
•Jump dispersal from Java (40km) and Sumatra (30km)
•Jump dispersal normally after an eruption or where species travel and invade
• To explain the wide, and often discontinuous, distribution of many taxa.
• To account for similarities and diffenc - 101What is diffusion?2. Diffusion: a form of range expansion that is accomplished over generations by individuals spreading out from the margins of the species range.
• Normally happens after jump dispersal
• Much slower than jump dispersal! Over generations by populations gradually spreading out from the margins of a species’ range.
• But often follows jump dispersal.
• Range expansion of the starlings after their intentional introduction into North America.
• Humans introducing birds into North America
• Different boundaries showing time periods diffusing from the East coast (1890- 1970 managed to diffuse over the whole US)
- European rabbit in Australia
- Rabbits introduced by jump dispersal by humans in 1860 in Victoria and then diffused over the rest of the country, by the 1980s, managed to make it to the Norther Territories
- The red fox also diffused through Australia over numerous genertions - 102What is secular migration?3. Secular migration: geographic range expansion, which is so slow (e.g. many generations!) that it is often accompanied by substantial evolutionary changes in the population en route. They expand to colonize new regions. Similar to diffusion.
a. Occurs over longer terms (1000s of years/ evolutionary time)
b. Animals that look as if they should be close together, but are in different areas
- Fossil evidences for the species in central Europe shows some crossed a bridge into North American and then into South America - 103What types of mechanism of movement can occur?- Active dispersal vs. Passive dispersal
1. Active: movement of an organism from one location to another by its own means.
2. Passive: movement of an organism from one place to another by means of a stronger force, such as water flow, wind or another organism.
- Mainland’s islands give different mechanisms of arrival
- Either by aeolian or aquatic movements - 104What is an example of Active Dispersal by Air?• Flight-migratory routes
• Effective active dispersal - 105What is the annual migration of North America’s monarch butterfly and the Sahara butterfly?- Monarch butterfly uses a two – way migration (like birds) and travels south when it is cold
• Painted lady butterflies are able to cross the Sahara Desert and it breeds in the African Savannah
• Winds from the North are the trigger
• Able to withstand 0’C as they go over the alps
• After 3 or 4 days, arrives in Barcelona
• Has a massive temperature range (The Sahara, the alps etc). - 106What examples of Active Dispersal are there?1. Water:
• Non-Volant animals
• Less effective (forced to swim through unfavourable habitats)
- Animals that disperse via water travel shorter distances than those travelling
2. In plants: explosive seeds (bursting)!
• E.g. the squirting cucumber - 107What is an example of Passive dispersal?• Vast majority of organisms disperse largely by passive dispersal.
• E.g. Diaspores (Seeds, spores, fruits, or other plant propagules)
o Consists of seed plus additional tissues adapted for dispersal
- Coconuts, turtles rafting across the oceans, planktonic microorganisms float on the oceans and move according to wind patterns and movement of water - 108What are barriers?• Any abiotic or biotic feature that totally or partially restricts the movement of genes or individuals from one population or locality to another
• Barriers are species-specific phenomena
• Abiotic or biotic feature that restricts movement of genes or individuals from one place to another. - 109What is one of the main barriers to dispersal in the tropics?- Elevation trends one of the main barriers in the tropics (due to changes in temperature)
- Given a change in elevation there is a barrier in the tropics (Costa Rica sees no crossover, Colorado shows a crossover in the elevations when comparing mountains) - 110What are the barriers and dispersal routes?(in increasing likelihood of being traversed)
1. Corridors
2. Filters
3. Sweepstake routes
(See notes for images) - 111What is a corridor as a barrier to dispersal routes?a. Corridors easiest to transverse (compared to filters and sweepstake routes)
b. Dispersal route that permits the movement of many (or most) species of a taxon from one region to another. No selectively discriminate against any form.
c. Biota from both sites of the corridor share the same taxonomic or functional groups. Free communication. - 112What is the example of a corridor?Beringia (Pleistocene)
o Species composition the same (in terms of taxanomical resolution) as Siberia and Alaska
o A great diversity of terrestrial plants and animals dispersed across the land bridges of Beringia in both directions between Alaska and Siberia. - 113What are filters?Filters –
a. Dispersal route that is more restrictive than a corridor. It selectively blocks the passage of certain forms while allowing those able to tolerate the conditions of the barrier to migrate freely.
b. Biota from both sites of the filter share many of the same taxonomic or functional groups. (But not all….!) - 114What is the example for filters?• E.g. - Filters across archipelagos that connect different Biogeographic kingdoms (Brown & Lomolino, 1998)
• Java to the south shows a decrease of the ‘western species’, Aru Island to the north shows a decrease of the ‘eastern species’
• Shows a crossover where the species are either more western or more eastern - 115What are sweepstake routes?a. A sever barrier that results in the partly stochastic dispersal of some elements of a biota, and the establishment of a disharmonic biota.
b. Unpredictable - 116What is the rafting lizards case study?• Rafting lizards! Rare events. Distribution of the green and Lesser Antillean iguanas (Iguana iguana and I. delicatissima) influenced by rare events, including being washed offshore by landslides caused by hurricanes.
• Iguanas eventually made it to Guadeloupe
• If it wasn’t for this very specific rare event, the Iguanas wouldn’t be populated properly - 117What is Vicariance?• Attempts to reconstruct the historical events that led to observed distributional pattern based largely on the assumption that these patterns resulted from the splitting (vicariance) of areas and not long-distance dispersal.
• Starting point the same – two disjunct populations
• Geographical range of a taxa is split into parts by the formation of a barrier –no dispersal!
• Geological/ climatic events - 118What are the facts for evolution?- Direct lineage of dinosaurs from the Mesozoic and todays birds
- Darwin noticed animals that were clearly different species showed adaptations that were hugely similar (rabbits and capybaras/ kangaroos and deer’s (both graze on grass, but hugely different) etc.)
- Darwin – why do current species not live on the same continents, but developed the same solutions to doing things - 119What is the significance of Darwin?• Darwin initially went for a geological voyage, then went into animals
• Darwin observed and collected lots of material, but it was only after many years of thinking and discussion he came up with his ideas about evolution.
• The huge range of species he encountered across the globe and Lyell’s realization that geological time was much greater than previously thought gave Darwin a completely different perspective on what mechanisms might work to drive species change and diversification. (Leyll looking at the huge time frame for geological time)
• Looks at why there is so many species in different areas
• Moorhead’s book is an excellent and readable account of Darwin’s adventures - 120What is the significance of Wallace?• Around the same time as Darwin
• Alfred Russel Wallace—explorer extraordinaire– began thinking about evolution after Darwin did but wrote a paper on natural selection before Darwin had written his ideas down fully
• Looked at the difference between Eastern Islands and Western Islands (difficult for animals to cross this area – related to sea levels)
• 1958‐sends letter to Darwin—upshot is that both their papers were read at the same time in London at the Linnean Society (realised they were thinking very similar things) - 121What is the Darwin Orchid case study?• Things have very similar features
• Darwin fascinated by pollination and their mutualisms (plants and pollinators)
• Angraecum sesquipedale and its pollinator, a long‐ tongued moth
• Darwin did not stop in Madagascar (unfortunately – Madagascar has one of the most unique and varied faunas on earth), but on seeing this orchid in a collection (the orchid had a very long spur where the pollen was kept), he predicted the existence of a very long‐tongued moth, which was later observed
• Did pollinators start like this or was their a development of the mutual relationships (of pollinator and plant)
• Darwin was familiar with animal breeding for domestic and agricultural purposes.
• Recognized that humans selected for specific traits – desirable traits put together (genetics of wolf and dogs similar, but bred for differences)
• See Arditti et al 2012 - 122What is the fox experiment?• Dmitri Belyaev bred foxes in Siberia during the time of Lysenko in the 1950s (hard in Russia in the 1950s for scientific experiments – Stalin didn’t believe in evolution)
• Pretended he was interested in breeding for fur
• Domesticated foxes for tame characteristics (then saw other features – ears went floppy, tails waggily and curly)
• His amazing finds on how dog domestication probably happened were lost to science for a decade, and to the West for longer - 123What were Darwins observations?• There is a huge variety of species, and species on different continents have “solved” the same problems in similar ways
• Finch species on the Galapagos probably derived from single ancestor (possibly tiny flock), so how did they become so different? Population variations
• Surplus of production of organisms in the wild – many die very young – the ones that survive through maturity are more likely to breed and produce better offspring
• Artificial breeding – humans SELECT animals and offspring INHERIT traits
• When you look at individuals in a species, they usually show variation
• Most species produce more offspring than survive to breed
• Therefore, given enough time, maybe nature (natural pressures and stresses) can also exert selection = NATURAL SELECTION
• No Mechanism of inheritance - The variants most well suited to their environment survive to breed, and their traits carry on in the population (this is until Mendel produced a mathematical description of the passing on of attributes – the mother and father passing on elements of variation occurring together as the same of d - 124What was the puzzle surrounding evolution?• What is the mechanism of inheritance, and how does variation arise in a population?
• Neither Wallace nor Darwin knew about the idea of genes as a mechanism for inheritance
• Gregor Mendel studied pea colour inheritance – he showed that one could predict the inheritance of traits quantitatively and developed the idea of GENES
• Reproductive cells of organisms contains chromosomes – these distributed in reproduction
• We now know genes are made of DNA, which carries messages about how to make an organism. Incorporated into sets of paired chromosomes, one inherited from each parent.
• Genes occur in slightly different forms, alleles. The long strings of bases that make up a gene can sometimes change – MUTATION. While many mutations are quickly lost, some are beneficial and individuals with the mutation are selected [as with superbugs—beneficial to them!]
• Strings of DNA in genes have the capacity for change through alleles, as mutations or chance - 125What is the process of evolution?• The 4 bases code unique sequences for all the amino acids, which form proteins and line up as a double helix
• Genes contain codes for proteins to build organisms
• Typically, organisms have two pairs of chromosomes. Prior to gamete formation, pairs may swap material (genes) – mixes up the allelic composition of gametes. Source of variations through gametes.
• During chromosome splicing - If genes are on the same chromosome, especially close together, they tend to be inherited together – linkage.
• Example of mutation – caused by changes in the base sequence. Normally changes a protein and means the organisms won’t survive, but sometimes is a good thing - 126What is the simple case of evolution? One allele from each parent—two forms—dominant and recessiveOne allele from each parent—two forms—dominant and recessive
- Large A – the dominant allele. Little a, the recessive – characteristic only in phenotype if recessive allele passed from both parents
• BUT the a‐form can persist in the population (here expressed 25% of the time)
• KEY POINT: selection acts on the individual phenotype
• Classic example of natural selection and change of gene frequencies in a population.
• Industrial melanism (darkening) in the moth Biston betularia in the UK.
• Story probably a bit more complicated – but still stands See blog at UCL.
• Natural selection can overcome the dominant/ recessive alleles to better chance of survival - 127What is the significance of the appearance of antibiotic resistance?It is an evolutionary phenomenon.
• See Palumbo 2001 for a review of the ways that humans have (often inadvertently) speeded up evolution.
• Example: new strains of bacteria appear with physiologies that are not affected by drugs designed to kill them
• Some variations allow the bacteria’s to fight back from the antibiotics – this is then quickly passed through the genetics
• Return of TB an issue of this – wasn’t an issue when antibiotics were working well
• A case of microevolution (happening below the organism level) – changes in the gene make up - 128What is the case of the foxes for evolution?• Gene Linkage
• The trait selected for is tameness
• Linked genes related to pelage, ears, tails
• Tameness and genes related to the tails/ears etc. close on the same chromosome, so are inherited together
• A frequency of genes can change: A shift in gene frequencies (read: allele frequencies) in a population is the phenomenon of microevolution
• Not speciation, but variation among populations. Can be quite distinct, but if populations come together they are inter‐fertile.
• Gene frequencies can also change without natural selection: genetic drift and gene flow - 129What is genetic drift?• In a small population, some alleles are rare, subject to random loss. Different to the alleles in larger populations
• Can lose alleles completely in small populations
• Reduced genetic diversity in isolated populations. Less resilience in the face of environmental stress.
• Unusual genetic composition of small “founder” populations (where organisms don’t have the full genetic extent), potential for genetic divergence – think about islands. But also bottlenecks.
• Small populations with small number of genes can see collapse if there is no chance of change - 130What is gene flow?GENE FLOW counters genetic drift
• A founder population may be a vanguard of a larger migration, e.g. Tree species returning to Britain after the ice age, or species from Europe expanding their ranges into Britain with climate warming
o Seeds etc. taken ahead of time and begin to develop (a founder population)
• Once the main population catches up with the vanguard, there can be widespread gene mixing and founder‐effect gene patterns are lost
• Widespread pollen dispersal by plants is an important source of gene flow
• See Davis et al 2005 and Davis and Shaw 2001 for a Quaternary palaeoecological view of climate change and the genetics of tree species - 131What is the case study of terrestrial fishes having rivers as a barrier to gene flow?Terrestrial fishes: rivers are barriers to gene flow in annual fishes from the African savanna (Bartakova et al 2015)
• Cladogram – diagram of genetic relationships of collected specimens
• One or more positions on certain genes that tend to have high variability are looked at
• The more differences there is, the more likely the species considered divergent
• 3 species in the small river fish – work on genetics creates the family tree seen. Long genetic differences seen initially, as the species get closer, there are less genetic differences
• A story of evolutionary history – time is involved (genetic makeup in populations shown) - 132What is the significance of haplotite?- Haplotitie – a genetic composition unique to other species
- Can be plotted geographically, as seen in the maps
- Those with different alleles cluster due to the geography (shown by different colours and the size of dots show the numbers contributing to the data – lots of offshoots with few individuals, but main base has many individuals)
- Modern geography of the organisms map onto the modern geography of the rivers, which cut off the gene flow (the species limited by the rivers as a boundary) - 133What is the legacy of the Quaternary ice ages in terms of genetics (Hewitt 2000)?climate change
• Species coming back into Europe after the ice age
• Genetic makeup thought to be different as they spread
• Should show locations of refugia (places where species survived the last glacial maximum) and migration routes (least diversity and founder/ genetic drift effects at range migration limits)
• At the edge of the range, organisms may have different genetic make-up to those that didn’t travel far out of the refuge area during the ice age - 134What is the legacy of the Quaternary ice ages in terms of genetics (Hewitt 2000)? Larger time and space scales – spruce (Picea) in Europe-Would have been covered by Scandinavian ice sheet
- When looking at chosen genes and the alleles present, saw a large difference between those in the North and the South (Northern group in blue). Shows may have different history between each other
- Shows when spruce trees may have been in the landscape – spruce migration route map. Russian plain to Scandinavia takes quite a while and the two populations don’t see any mixing (Russian plain and the South Central Europe mountainous regions)
- Hewett suggested there should be greater genetic diversity in the refugia area
• After the last glacial period, Picea spread across Europe from refugia
• Smoothed map of pollen values above a threshold (= present locally)
• E W in North
• Complex patterns in the European mountains- Haplotites merged on the migration routes
- Only a few light blue types in Scandinavia
- A wide mix in the Baltic region
- In the alps there are varied haplotites – some in their own area
- Alps had glaciers, but not an ice cap – areas exposed probably good for the trees
• Haplotypes mapped on to
(SEE IMAGES) - 135What are the patterns of within- population genetic diversity?• Patterns of within- population genetic diversity
• In alpine areas, there are big dots – high variability
• Most variation up North in the East
• Complicated theories…!
• Migration leading to lower genetic variation probable
• Generally lower where trees have migrated recently
• High diversity in mountains, and separation of some populations suggests multiple refugia. If refugial populations large enough, variation accumulates. If too small, genetic drift, loss of alleles possible (population bottlenecks – loose genetic variation, could go extinct or gene flow may allow the building up of variation) - 136What concepts are needed to understand evolution?1. Phylogenies (within and among species)
2. Haplotypes – marker alleles that show up and pinpoint a population different from others
3. Phylogeography – puts the phynology into the geography. Genetic patterns across space (and temporal change)
4. Temporal and spatial change in gene frequencies among populations within species
5. Bottlenecks
6. Refugia
7. Migration
8. Evolutionary responses to climate change (along with migration, refugia and temporal changes there are responses to the pressures of climate change. Organisms still today seeing evolution at the micro level for climate change) - 137What is vicariance and dispersal?1. Vicariance: species existed - then were separated and underwent allopatric speciation.
2. Dispersal: species disperses across an EXISTING barrier- e.g. islands already exist - some individuals made it to the next island, underwent allopatric speciation. - 138What is Speciation?• The process in which two or more contemporaneous species evolve from a singles ancestral population (Lomolino et al, 2010)
• Ancestral popualtions and the way the split
- How one species changes over time to have many species
- One ancestral species of butterfly produces three species - 139What are the mechanisms of genetic differentiation?• 1. Mutation: changes in DNA
• 2.Genetic drift: changes in gene frequency within a population caused by chance! Non-influence of natural selection.
• 3. Natural selection: change in a population that occurs because individuals express genetic traits that alter their interaction with their environment so as to enhance their survival and reproduction.
• 4. Gene flow: impede genetic divergence. There is a limitation in gene flows by barriers. - 140What can happen with barriers in terms of genetic differentiation?- Genes in a population that can disperse without a barrier initially. Then with a barrier (black line) can isolate populations
• In a population of organisms, gene flow maintains an interbreeding group.
• Disruption of gene flow, physically or through a behaviour change, can isolate a population.
• Population becomes so distinct that it becomes reproductively isolated.
• Even if populations are rejoined, individuals no longer interbreed.
• As we go through time, populations become distinct (when populations rejoin (after millions of years) they can then not interbreed. - 141What types of speciation are there?- There are different types of speciation
1. Allopatric (Vicariance) – Two populations where if there is range expansion, there may be overlapping ranges (which could become sympatric)
2. Allopatric (Peripatric)- population with subset that with time the population becomes a new species through dispersal
3. Parapetric – Populations have very close ranges and then there is an interchange
4. Sympatric – Species occurring in the same space share populations - 142What is Allopatric speciation?• Allopatric (or geographically isolated) speciation: formation of new species that occurs when populations are geographical separated (Lomolino et al, 2010)
• There are two modes of allopatric speciation:
o 1) Vicariance: environmental change can create a barrier to dispersal within a species range. Such events are called vicariant events. E.g. Isthmus of Panama in the Pliocene divided many marine organisms.
o 2) Peripheral isolates or founder events (Peripatric speciation): individuals may disperse across an existing barrier to colonize a previously uninhabited region (Mayr 1954). (Islands). Kingfisher (Tanysiptera galeata), which shows geographic variation in plumage throughout climatically very different regions of New Guinea – populations arise in one place and disperse across different islands. Kingfishers can fly across to different islands. A dispersal process - 143What are ways to separate populations?- Population that can fly across the barrier (mountain) – dispersal (paripatric)
- The bottom rectangle could split in a Vicariance event
- Processes can take millions of years
• Vicariance events e.g., flooding of a land bridge, separation of continents, habitat change, emplacement of an isthmus, growth of an ice sheet. - 144What is the Allopatric speciation mode I: Vicariance?- Species a has a population
- A barrier forms and prevents gene flow from species a to speices b and c, which develop on their own
- There can be further barriers to prevent gene flow again
- Species c then diverges to d and e
- a is then ancestral to c and b in the first instance and c going to to d and e
(SEE IMAGE) - 145What is the case study for the Vicariant event: Closure of the Isthmus of Panama ( 2.7 to 3.5 Myr)?- The snapping shrimp and butterfly fish
- As isthmus closes, it isolates different populations of the animals
- If we just looked at moropology, they look different
- If we look at genetics, there is a ancestral divergence as the Isthmus closes (2-4 millions years ago)
- Species at shallower waters more related to each other than those in the deeper species (Snapping Shrimp)
- Butterfly fish different morphologically – takes 2-4 million years for them to look so different!
- The Great American Biotic Interchange – the isolating of populations on both sides of the oceans that were previously connected - 146What is the allopatric speciation mode II: Peripheral isolates, or founder events or Peripatric speciation?• Individuals may disperse across an existing barrier. In oceanic islands and isolated patches.
• Important in population bottleneck, genetic drift and is often seen on-islands
- Species a has random dispersal to peripheric areas
- In (A) there is a rapid speciation to make b, c and d
- In (B) there is a slow speciation to make b, c and d (a to be to b to c to c to d)
(SEE IMAGES) - 147What is the cases studies for allopatric speciation mode II: Peripheral isolates, or founder events or Peripatric speciation?- Kingfishers in New Guinea found the species occurring in the main island in a very large climatic range are very similar (only 1-3 species), however in the small islands, there’s many different species (4-8)
- Researchers don’t know whether there are natural variations or human introductions (so ignore the dashed lines)
- It has been measured the ancestral populations come from south America
- The oldest islands of the Galapagos are where the species first begin to diverge (Espanola and San Cristobel), the younger are then diverged to later
- Colonisation and divergence is congruent with the geological ages of the islands
- Santa Cruz island had two independent colonisations – one from San Cristobel, one from Espanola
- A very fast diversification process
- Islands colonised and there are many species on the islands (much like the Darwin Finches) - 148What other ways are there to speciate: without physical separation?Sympatric Speciation
• Difficult to demonstrate this type of speciation
• Differentiation of two isolated species from one initial population within the same local area.
• Gene flow potentially could occur!
• Factors such as: chromosomal changes (common in plants “polyploidy”) and non-random mating (in animals) alter gene flow.
- Two species speciating in the same place, potentially at the same time… - 149What is the case study for Sympatric Speciation in Tropical vine?• Tropical vine (over 100 species across tropics)
• Reward is often resin
• Advertisements include
o Showy bracts
o Fragrances
• Behavioural as well as physical changes
• D. brownsbergensis and D. fragrans co-occur in Suriname, and both are pollinated by fragrance-collecting male euglossine bees.
• D. Brownsbergensi: bloom year-round. Pollinated by few species of bees, including Euglossa tridentata and E. gaianii.
• D. fragrans: Bloom October-December. Pollinated by 13 sps
• EXPERIMENT:
o D. fragrans were "transplanted" into a population of D. brownsbergensis. (Planted together)
o Ambruster et al, (1992)
o Species can simultaneously occur
o Pollination of most species is by resin-collecting bees
o Pollinator of D. brownsbergensis also visited the flowers of D. fragrans.
o Pollinators of D. fragrans, however, did not visit the flowers of D. brownsbergensis.
o Partial sharing of pollinators may have only a small negative impact on the two sympatric plant species.
o Species flower simultaneously only part of the year, and they are often spatially separated from one anothe - 150What is the case study for sympatric speciation in plants: Polyploidy?• Sympatric speciation (also parapatric) can also occur though chromosomal change!
• During meiosis (gamete formation) chromosomes do not segregate normally but double up in various combinations, often fatal but sometimes viable.After the change, only that group of polyploids successfully interbreeds.
• If there is variation in the same number of chromosomes, species can’t breed
• Common in plants, because many plants self-pollinate. - 151Why is sympatric speciation sometimes difficult to demonstrate?1. Current overlap between 2 species does not necessary mean that their ranges overlapped at the time of speciation. – difficult to see in the past if species overlapped
2. Which scale? Sympatric at regional scale but perhaps not at local scale? Researchers needs to determine that home ranges of breeding members of the ancestral population did indeed overlap.
3. Closely related species that have not had the time (yet) to experience appreciable range shifts. May speciate later.
- Symatic speciation not got many easy to understand papers - 152What is Parapatric speciation?• Parapatric speciation is a mode of speciation in which differentiation occurs when two populations have contiguous but narrowly overlapping ranges, often representing two distinct habitats
- Looks similar to sympatic diagram – but overlapping only in a narrow zone of contact (not in the middle of overlapping extent!) - 153What is the example of parametric speciation in Anthoxanthum odoratum?SEE IMAGE
- Contaminated zones (shaded) with lead and zinc. Plants growing in the contaminated soil are tolerant to metals.
- (b) Flowering time: earlier flowering time from the contaminated area reduces gene flow from non-tolerant plans in the uncontaminated areas
- (c) Capacity to produce seed by self-fertilization was higher in plants from contaminated areas.
- There are therefore two different populations of species in the area
- Gradient of 8 different sample sites – if area is blue, there is contamination of soil
- Later on, by sample site 5, there is no contamination
- Stigma emergence – a proxy for flowering
- A decline at site 5, at the edge of the two populations - 154What is adaptive radiation as a form of diversification?• Adaptive radiation is the diversification of species to fill a wide variety of ecological niches.
• A radiation refers to the process by which one species rapidly speciate into a number of different species.
• Diversification of the major mammals: differentiated during the Paleocene in relatively short period of time (10 million years)
• Variety of head shapes and feeding habits resulting from adaptive radiation of cichlid fishes in Lake Malawi.
• The mechanism of sympatric speciation: when a population uses resources that are different from the original population. Lomolino et al, 2010
• Happened very fast in terms of geological time - 155What is the case study of Darwins finches for adaptive radiation?SEE IMAGE
- Single ancestor and then radiated to all the different species
- First there is allopatric speciation among different islands
- Later if the range keeps growing, there is more - 156What is a species’ distribution model?1. Models that predict distributions of species by combining known occurrence records (where species are) with digital layers of environmental variables (Modelling the niche. Can change the layers to predict what could happen in the future).
2. The most common strategy for estimating the actual or potential geographic distribution of a species is to characterize the environmental conditions that are suitable for the species, and to then identify where suitable environments are distributed in space (Guisan & Thuiller 2005). - 157What is a niche?• The total requirements of a population or species for resources and physical conditions.
* Niche can be visualised in one or two dimensions, but is in face a 'hyper volume' of many dimensions - 158What is the fundamental niche and the realised niche?1. Fundamental niche
a. The niche a species could occupy if only limited by the environment, and not by interactions with other species. Absence of any interspecific competition and predation
2. Realized niche
a. The observed ecological space a species uses – subset of ensure fundamental niche.
• If A and B fundamental niches overlap and B is the stronger competitor, A’s realised niche shrinks.
- In modelling ways of modelling the different niches still being developed - 159What assumptions are there in species distribution modelling?1. Are highly sensitive to the assumptions, algorithms and parameterizations of different methods (Araújo et al, 2005) – outputs could be different in using different models.
2. Assume equilibrium between species and their environment
o “A species is at equilibrium with the physical environment if it occurs in all suitable areas, while being absent from all unsuitable areas.”
Species breed in favourable environmental conditions
o Species distribution models just assume they are at equilibrium – this causes lots of debates in the literature
• The degree of equilibrium depends both on biotic interactions (competitive exclusion from an area) and dispersal ability (organisms with higher dispersal ability are expected to be closer to equilibrium than organisms with lower dispersal ability) (Araújo and Pearson, 2005).
o Species with higher dispersal, closer to equilibrium as can disperse everywhere - 160How are SDMs built?- Map of data points (for the presence of the specie)
- For a niche, need the physical/ environmental layers, which can be helpful for SDM
o Temperature
o Precipitation
o Topography (elevation)
o More categorical variables now being developed and used (land use)
- MaxENT, statistically and probabilities of where the specie will be found in the landscape
* (Needs data points and layers to produce a map) - 161Where can data be found for species information for distribution modelling?- Data can be obtained by
1. in the field
2. Local maps
3. Online
For species’ distributions
- Instead of doing field studies, there is secondary data
- The GBIF (Global Biodiversity Information Facility) has occurrences of species/ Migrant species seen in the oceans/ Red shows higher density of species/ Can search for a species and it can show where the species is - 162What limitations are there to SDM data?1. Incorrect identification of the sp. or coordinate. (need to clean the data set before putting through the software)
2. Researchers uploading data might be biased towards easy access places (Graham et al., 2004). (Don’t have the whole breath of occurrence of a species)
3. Museum data is also used. Often biased towards rare sp. (People collecting the specimen notes the co-ordinate, will tend towards rare species)
- A co-ordinate that is wrong can start including the habitat and niche of that area and completely skew the data
- Need to check raw data as a species may not even exist there - 163Where can data be found for the environmental covariates used in the layers for SDM?• To describe the physical environment (the niche) where the sp. is present. (to be used in the model)
1. Climatic variables: Temperature, precipitation, etc.
2. Topographic variables: elevation, slopes. Etc.
3. Soil types and land cover.
• Some examples:
o WORLCLIM (www.worldclim.org) -climatic data - NASA (www.usgs.gov) – topographic data
o MODIS (NASA) (modis.gsfc.nasa.gov)
• In remote places, the quality of the data set is more likely to be low - 164What is MaxEnt?- Modelling software with statistical outputs and a continuous prediction (probability) of species
- Need to know the limitations of MaxEnt
o Need to always cut the map to a smaller location of interest, as otherwise will see the good environmental conditions for the species which may then show a suitable area on the other side of the world
- Outputs a map - 165What are model validation statistics and what are they?- Need to know the validation statistics to understand a final map
- Will occur in a folder in the production of the final map
1. ROC (Receiver Operating Characteristic) curve - Shows probability of map being correct or not.
2. Jackknife - To determine which environmental variables contribute most to the model prediction and are best and most important for prediction - 166What is ROC?ROC (Receiver Operating Characteristic) curve - Shows probability of map being correct or not. Upper curve (red) signifying superior predictive (better) ability than lower curve (blue). Dashed 1:1 line signifies random predictive ability, whereby there is no ability to distinguish occupied and unoccupied site. To know whether data included in the model works well or not)
- 167What is Jackknife?• To determine which environmental variables contribute most to the model prediction and are best and most important for prediction
• Environmental variables on the left and there is 3 columns
• Prcpseason: achieves almost no gain, so that variable is not (by itself) useful for estimating the distribution of Egretta.
• Meantemp: allows a reasonably good fit to the training data
• Lighter blue bars: it appears that no variable contains a substantial amount of useful information that is not already contained in the other variables, because omitting each variable in turn did not decrease the training gain considerably. - 168What is a case study for the outputs from an SDM?SEE IMAGE
Outputs: projected distribution (Nouge et al., 2016)
• Example of species distribution models, Apis mellifera (a) and Bombus terrestris (b) (Nouge et al., 2016)
- If we have this output and know the model is good, this could be useful for policy/ land management - 169How can SDMs be used for conservation?• Predicting species’ distributions has become an important component of conservation planning in recent years, and a wide variety of modelling techniques have been developed for this purpose (Guisan and Thuiller, 2005).
1. Identification of areas of endemism – why it is important to protect endemic species
2. Management of ecosystem services
3. Recovering distributional ranges of extinct species - 170How have SDMs helped Chameleons in Madagascar?Example 1: Chameleons in Madagascar Predicting distributions of known and unknown reptile species in Madagascar (Raxworthy et al, 2003)
• Madagascar a hotspot of biodiversity
• We can sometimes see the distribution of species out of the range – unknowns can be useful for conservation and exploration
Data:
• 29 modern data sets of environmental land coverage
• 621 chameleon occurrence localities from Madagascar (historical and recent)
- Occurrences in blue, projected distribution in red
- Red can be far away from where the chameleon has actually been found
o An error in the model?
• They then tested the areas where the SDM said the environmental conditions for the species would be good
• Red: poorly studied areas
• Green: Recently yielded several new locally endemic chameleon species – just from the potential of where the species may be directly from SDM
• These findings have valuable applications for identification of areas of endemism
• Now know more about distributions of chameleon in Madagascar - 171How have SDMs helped management of ecosystem services?•Highlighted the importance of biodiversity and ecosystems to human livelihoods.
•Where ecosystem services are “the set of ecosystem functions that are useful to humans” (Kremen, 2005) (most accepted definition)
•Biodiversity and ecosystems viewed as an economic commodity. and can include air quality in water
•The first book talking about ecosystem services was the millennium ecosystem assessment
-Used the online tool to find the bee distribution, Found the environmental layers, Asked the questions:
oWhere pollinators are
oIf they are delivering their service
•Subset of 8 bee species and Species distribution model (continuous probability of occurrence maps) for the 8 bee species used in the model
•Bees hard to model as in nests
Hotspot map showing species richness of bees delivering pollination services across Europe
•Use all the SDMs of the species to see where they are more present in Europe. Not much in Norway or Pyrenees (elevation limiting factors for bees?)
SEE IMAGEs - 172What are the conclusions for the use of SDMs in helping manage ecosystem services?1. In areas with low to intermediate pollination index, land management should be targeted to increase availability of suitable wild bee nesting habitat near and around pollinator-dependent crops to enhance pollination provisioning by wild bees.
2. Our hotspot map suggests that Nordic agricultural areas (e.g. Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway, and Sweden), are located outside the climatic range of many wild bee species, and here pollination service delivery may benefit from increasing the number of beehives to ensure high pollinator densities.
3. This model provides an approach that can quickly obtain a first approximation for land managers to identify potential regions to invest in actions to conserve or restore nesting habitats to enhance pollination service delivery. - 173How have SDMS helping in Recovering the distribtition and migratory patterns of the extinct Carolina parakeet?•Modelled distribution to understand why the species went extinct
•Took natural history data from museums and other historic data to map where the parakeet had been found in the past
•Neotropical parrot: native to the eastern, midwest and plains states of the United States.
•The final extinction (1904) of the species is somewhat of a mystery, as it happened so rapidly (distributional ranges and the size of populations – are populations likely to go extinct if they are small).
•Humans had at least a contributory role in the extinction of the Carolina parakeet: hunting, deforestation, poultry disease (?), and pet trade.
•Aim: informing modern conservation programs focused on threatened (extinction), closely related species. To understanding extinction as a process: the end, when species actually go extinct.
•How? Building a database with historical accounts with museum collections (e.g. Lewis and Clark expedition journal from the 1800s) and using Maxent - 174What are the conclusions for SDMS helping in Recovering the distribtition and migratory patterns of the extinct Carolina parakeet?• Found 2 super species of the bird – one in Florida, one in a further extent – red line what earlier researchers thought the range was
• Small populations can be more vulnerable to extinction (genetics)
• Evidence that the Carolina parakeet’s range was much smaller than previously believed
• Populations with smaller range sizes are more vulnerable to extinction (Payne & Finnegan, 2007). - 175What is the use in SDMs for comparing in the seasonal distribution models of the extinct Carolina parakeet?• Western subspecies may have moved between breeding and winter seasons, whereas the eastern subspecies appears to have no.
• These results also suggest that the subspecific taxonomy may be valid!
• Further genetic testing could be targeted to verify the validity of these subspecies, and to explore whether or not gene flow existed between the two subspecies in areas where they may have overlapped in the southeastern United States.
- Smaller ranges might have meant extinction happened faster – two super species could have separated, meaning gene flow doesn’t happen – speciation of different species
• Western subspecies may have moved between breeding and winter seasons, whereas the eastern subspecies appears to have no.
• These results also suggest that the subspecific taxonomy may be valid!
• Further genetic testing could be targeted to verify the validity of these subspecies, and to explore whether or not gene flow existed between the two subspecies in areas where they may have overlapped in the southeastern United States.
- Smaller ranges might have meant extinction happened - 176What is the issue with SDMs & Climate change?• Projected temperature increases 2080-2099 (IPCC)
• The poles (especially Arctic) predicted to warm most rapidly
SDMs & Climate change
• Modelling the potential impacts of Climate change on species’ distribution
1. Climate change has the potential to significantly impact the distribution of species (Example 4).
2. The general approach is to calibrate the models based on current distributions of species and then predict future distributions of those species across landscapes for which the environmental input variables have been perturbed to reflect expected changes (Example 4 and 6).
3. Also can model past distributions to e.g. understand how drivers of change influence in the past (Example 5). – could see why a specie that is now small in range used to be in large range e.g. Laurel forest of Tenerife used to be across Europe - 177How have SDMs been used for Climate warming and the decline of amphibians and reptiles in Europe (Araujo et al., 2006)?• Aim: Explore the relationship between current European distributions of amphibian and reptile species and observed climate, and project species potential distributions into the future.
• Which is the impact of increasing temperatures on amphibian and reptile species in Europe?
• Made a current species distribution model and then changed slightly different variables
• Used 3 different models for comparison
• Several factors contribute to the vulnerability of amphibians to the projected effects of climate change.
• 1/3 of amphibian species are already at risk of extinction.
• Habitat loss, disease, invasive species, overexploitation, and chemical pollution.
• Amphibian: Ectothermic ‘cold- blooded’: rely on external warmth and temperature to raise their body temperature and become active.
• Their ability to cope with lower temperatures is limited (most species are unable to live at temperatures below -4 ‘C). Better at coping with warming.
• More sensitive to climate cooling than warming? - 178What was found using SDMs for Climate warming and the decline of amphibians and reptiles in Europe (Araujo et al., 2006)?• If no dispersal is assumed, virtually all species in our study would be projected to lose range
• More accurate to use limited dispersal projections, but used dispersal unlimited to look at potential historic dispersals
• Amphibian species are projected to expand distributions if dispersal is unlimited.
• But assumptions of unlimited dispersal under changing climate are unrealistic
• The researchers interested in the gains and losses of dispersal
• Darker regions- major losses of frogs
• Major losses were projected to occur in the Iberian Peninsula, southern France, Italy and eastern European countries.
• Gains were projected to occur mainly in the northern fringes of central Europe for amphibians - 179What are conclusions for using SDMs for Climate warming and the decline of amphibians and reptiles in Europe (Araujo et al., 2006)?1. Unlimited dispersal: species expand! This is because warming in the cooler northern ranges of species creates new opportunities for colonization.
2. If species are unable to disperse, then most species are projected to lose range.
3. Loss of suitable climate space for species is projected to occur mainly in the south-west of Europe, including the Iberian Peninsula, whilst species in the south-east are projected to gain suitable climate. This is because dry conditions in the south-west are projected to increase.
NB - have to be very careful about the difference between unlimited and limited dispersal - 180How has the accuracy of SDMs for economically valuable species in Europe been tested? (Macias- Fauria and Willis, 2012)1. Devised a methodology to hindcast (go back in time) SDMs for 7 economically valuable European tree species
2. Three climatically distinct periods considered:
• 1. Medieval Warm Period (900-1300)
• 2. Little Ice Age (1600-1850)
• 3. 20th century warming
3. Modelled distribution compared against actual distribution as displayed in European fossil pollen database (there is an online site for when the species were around in Europe)
- Wanted to check if there was any difference in the range of these periods
Understanding how drivers of change influence in the past
- Olive tree and vines
- The vines during the medieval warm had distribution in the Mediterranean, during the little ice age, the range expanded north. In new warming, in contracted slightly
- Olives never occurred higher than the Pyrenees in any time period (as determined by model) - 181How has the Iberian Lynx and its relationship to climate change been found through SDMs? (Fordham et al., 2013)• Trying to link the prey of the Lynx into the model – also looked at different scenarios (if there was no climate change/ if conservation efforts succeeded, what would happen?) -a very complex model
• The Iberian lynx (Lynx pardinus) is the world’s most threatened cat, with recent counts estimating only 250 individuals surviving in the wild.
• Climate change threatens the Iberian Lynx (Lynx pardinus) despite conservation efforts
• Over €90 million has been spent since 1994 to mitigate the extinction risk of this charismatic animal, mainly through habitat management, reduction of human- caused mortality and, more recently, translocation (human mediated migration). But Araújo and his colleagues aren't convinced that those programs could work – aren’t taking climate change into account.
• Combined effects of climate change, prey availability (rabbit, 80% if Iberian lynx consumption) and management intervention on the persistence of the Iberian lynx.
• Also rabbit declined in the 20th century due to two diseases.
• This study provides one example when anticipating the effects of clima - 182What was found from the SDM about Iberian Lynx and its relationship to climate change? (Fordham et al., 2013)• Green - a high-CO2 concentration stabilizing reference scenario
• Orange - Policy scenario that assumes strong mitigation
• Blue - No change scenario’ where temperature and precipitation remains unchanged from the year 2000. High uncertainty around it however.
• Climate change is predicted to have a rapid and sever negative influence on lynx abundance. - Even with global cuts to anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions.
• By shifting reintroduction programs further north, Lynx could not only survive climate change, but rebound, the researchers found.
o More of a policy related paper
• Peninsula-wide strategy considers habitats in the northern half of Iberia as potential refugia from climate- induced shifts in physiological conditions, rabbit abundance and habitat availability.
• One geopolitical map, one peninsula- wide
• Had to be careful with the language used and showing all the maps, so it wasn’t just climate change being blamed outright - 183How are SDMs used for invasive species Managing biological invasions (Guisan et al., 2013)?- How species can be managed for biological invasions
- 184What is the case study of the Little Egret?•Current and future distribution of the Little Egret in UK and Ireland
•According to the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB) in the last decade Britain has suffered declines in many birds including the fieldfare (Turdus pilaris).
•The little egret (Egretta garzeta) has expanded! Why?
•Here we will use a maximum-entropy software (MaxEnt) to model the current and future distribution of the Little egret.
-Before doing any SDM have to understand the species (its habitat preferences etc.)
-Understand the biology of the species
* Taxonomy, Family: Ardeidae Genera: Egretta
Current status in UK and Ireland
o660-740 breeding pairs
oEspecially useful for conservation policiesHabitat
oCan help understand what variables might want to be included in models (topography/ water bodies?)
oLittle egrets inhabit the margins of coastal and inland water habitats, preferring open areas with shallow fresh water.They eat fis
•Behaviour
oColonial nesters, building near water, in trees and bushes or sometimes on rocks or cliffs.
o Colonies range from a few hundre nests up to a cou - 185What is The importance of natural history collections?* Accessibility of specimens sampled during biodiversity studies is problematic.
1. Limitation on systematically archive the samples of specimen.
2. Specimens are either discarded or only a small reference collection is saved.
3. Even if specimens are stored, material from separate plots or dates are often pooled to reduce storage space, rendering valuable information irretrievable.
- Potential solution: deposit of all specimens from a study in a natural history collection. Public natural history collections make the content of their collections databases available through the Global Biodiversity Information Facility (GBIF). (Schilthuizen et al, 2015) - 186What are botanical collections?1. Botanical collections originated in Europe in the 15th and 16th centuries (Renaissance expeditions) (Nualart et al, 2017).
2. 3000 herbaria worldwide preserving almost 350 million specimens (Thiers 2006).
3. Traditionally used as libraries for taxonomic purposes. Digitalization has facilitated access.
4. Funk (2004) lists a total of 72 uses of herbarium collections. - 187How many herbariums are there?• The Herbarium is a collection of preserved plants that are stored, catalogued, and arranged systematically for study.
• Index herbarium
Largest herbaria in Europe:
• Paris (P, PC) France 8,877,300
• Kew (K) United Kingdom 6,000,000
• (ACRONYM) Country Number of specimens
• Available for consultation by scientific community.
• Must have at least several thousand specimens and a person identified as a correspondent. - 188What are the Functions of herbaria (Funk (2004)?• Herbaria have one or more of the following functions or roles:
o 1. Conservatory of dried plant material.
o 2. Archival record of a local/regional flora.
o 3. Source of botanical information and diversity.
o 4. Recorder of plant names.
o 5. Training for botanists.
o 6. Research. - 189What is the case of the Hibiscus townsvillensis in a herbaria?• Part of Holotype specimen of Hibiscus townsvillensis (Craven 10469, CANB 875440) Single specimen taken as "the type" specimen (or reference specimen) Badry et al, 2017
1. Well-preserved.
2. Illustrate the maximum number of diagnostic features.
3. A permanent reference specimen (kept in a museum, etc.)
4. Isotype: Duplicate of the holotype - 190What is the importance of natural history collections for Biogeographical questions?Traditional
1. Identification of unknown species.
2. Compilation of biodiversity surveys.
3. Phylogenetic reconstructions.
Recent (mainly using data in digital form)
4. Phonological studies (including climate change)
a. Bee specimens (Bartomeus et al, 2010) and ancient photography (Penuelas et al, 2003)
5. Ecological modelling (altitudinal al latitudinal gradients & SDMs).
6. Other applications: Documenting the spread of invasive species - 191What are the challenges to evaluate phenological trends?1. A primary challenge in investigating long-term phenological shifts is obtaining reliable historical data
2. It requires long-term standardized monitoring schemes that could provide historical data. - 192How would you evaluate long-term phenological trends in wild bees from northeastern North America?- To examine a 130-y period
o Museum data from the contemporary period (2000–2010) in conjunction with data we recorded from museum specimens dating back to the 1880s.
o 10 bee species that emerge in early spring.
- The final analysis comprises 3,447 records. - 193What is the data capture protocol for herbariums?- Data Capture Protocol
o 1. Full-label data from all pinned specimens that could be accessed from: the American Museum of Natural History; the Illinois Natural History Survey; and the entomology collections maintained by the University of Connecticut, etc.
o 2. Only taxonomically verified specimens.
o 3. Verified location (coordinates). Google Earth to “virtually ground truth” localities when possible.
o Bartomeus et al, 2011 - 194What is the issue for bees decline in the USA?- Trends in species richness over time (A, B and C in diagram)
o A) All native bee species excluding Bombus
o B) Genus Bombus
o C) Exotic bee species
Conclusions
• The Northeastern US bee species persisted along the last 100 year
• However, community composi=on changed markedly
• Bumblebees (e.g. Bombus impa+ens) are doing great! - 195How can photography be used to show change?• Useful technique in the analysis of long term ecological and geological landscape changes
• First developed for the documentation of glacier changes but has now been adapted for other research, including recording changes in landscape and ecosystem processes (Webb et al. 2010).
• Photo ID: AFCEC_SOLER_C_0034. Historical: 1907, Repeat: 2015 (Marc Macias-Fauria) Loca+on: Aigüestortes & Estany de Sant Maurici Na+onal Park, Colomers - 196How can a global change-induced shift in the Montseny mountains (NE Spain)?• Montseny peaks:
o Turó de l'Home (1,712 m)
o Les Agudes (1,703 m) El Matagalls (1,697 m)
o Puig Drau (1,344 m).
Step-by-step methodology to monitor the upward shift of forests (Peñuelas et al 2003, 2007)
1. Historical records of vegetation at three peaks taken since 1940s by several researchers (Llobet, 1947; Bolos, 1983).
2. Photographs of these three main peaks and also from medium altitude taken since early 1940s.
3. Orto-rectified aerial photographs from the 1050s to current days (Cartographic Institute of Catalonia).
4. 1945 vegetation map and 1994 forest map.
5. Field visual examination of the Montseny mountains to confirm vegetation - 197How is a photographic diachronic analysis used in the Montseny mountains (NE Spain)?• Distributional change linked to climate change
• Progressive replacement of cold- temperate ecosystems by Mediterranean ecosystems.
• Beech (Fagus sylvatica) forest has shift attitudinally upwards by ca. 70 m at the highest altitudes (1600– 1700 m).
• Both the beech forests and the heather (Calluna vulgaris) heathlands are being replaced by holm oak (Quercus ilex) (800-1400 m). - 198How useful are collections?Traditional
1. Identification of unknown species
2. Compilation of biodiversity surveys
3. Phylogenetic reconstructions
Recent (using data in digital form)
4. Phenological studies (including climate change): Bee specimens (Bartomeus et al, 2010) and ancient photographies (Penuelas et al, 2003)
5. Ecological modelling (altitudinal al latitudinal gradients, SDMs- check the practical!): Introduced and native species (Wolf et al, 2016)
6. Other applications: Documenting the spread of invasive species - 199How are altitudinal and latitudinal changes supported by herbaria?• The distribution of a species is typically based on herbarium data (Applequist et al, 2007).
• The differential responses of plant species to climate change are of great interest and concern for scientists and conservationists (Wolf et al, 2016).
• One underexploited resource for better understanding these changes are the records held by herbaria - 200—• Wolf et al (2016) examine changes in the distribution of species through time in different altitudinal gradients in California.
• To estimate mean shifts in elevational and climatic space: 681,609 georeferenced herbarium of 4426 plant taxa from Consortium of California Herbaria.
• Aim: to compare mean altitudes during two periods (1895-1970 vs 1971-2009).
• But...missing environmental (altitudinal) information from specimen labels
• Climate and elevation: PRISM Climate group (Oregon state University).
• Monthly temperature grids at 2.5-arcmin resolution were recalculated into annual sums, means, and associated with each herbarium record for the year of its collection.
• Digital elevation model for the study area to infer such information
• Significant altitudinal increase in 15% of species.
• 17.9% of taxa show an increase in mean annual temperature across their niche.
• 18.5% of taxa experience a similar increase in precipitation.
• Altitudinal changes are mainly due to climate change!
Information
- Description
- Flashcards on Biogeography, created by Pippa Holman on 14/04/2018.
- Created by
- Pippa Holman
- Views
- 6
- Rating
More on Biogeography and biodiversity distribution