Mind map
CPA 1987
Map content
CPA 1987
(1) Is the Item a PRODUCT under the CPA?
- Section 1(2): Any goods or electricity...and includes any product comprised in another product, whether as a component or raw material.
- Section 45: Goods include 'any substance', ship, or aircraft.
- Software: Where the software is part of a physical product such that it causes that product to fail, there can be liability under the CPA. But, where there is no tangible medium, unlikely to be liability.
- German Decision: BGH 16.6.2009, VI ZR 107/08: Airbag malfunctions owing to defective controlling software. Liability.
- Pure Information: ECJ Decision: VI v Krone. No strict liability under the Direct for misinforming article about a medical product.
- Computer Associates UK Ltd v The Software Incubator Ltd [2018]: software is not a ‘good’ under (NOT THE CPA) Commmercial Agents Regulations 1993
- Law Commission (2022): The CPA 1987 not 'written with software in mind' and not designed to cover. it.
- (2) Is C able to SUE under the CPA?
- Any person suffering damage. of the kind recoverable under the CPA is entitled. to sue under it. See "Recoverable Damage"
- Section 5: (1) Death or personal injury, or any property damage/loss, subject to remaining provision.
- (3) Can D be sued under the CPA?
- Section 2(1): Where any damage is caused in part or wholly by a defect in a product, EVERY person to whom Section 2(2) applies shall be liable.
- Section 2(2): (a) The PRODUCER of the product; (b) Any person who, by putting their name on the product or using any distinguishing mark, has HELD HIMSELF OUT to be the producer; (c) any person who has IMPORTED the product into the UK in order to SUPPLY it to another in the COURSE OF BUSINESS
- Section 3(3): ANY person who SUPPLIED (not necessarily to the claimant) the product shall be liable IF - (a) the person who suffers damage requests them to identify somebody under Section 2(2) AND that request is made within a reasonable period of time AND (c) the supplier fails to, within a reasonable period, identify the person who supplied them.
- Section 1(2): Defines Producer: (a) Manufacturer; (b) Person who extracted the substance;...
- Includes the manufacture of a component as well as the full product. So if brakes manufactured by X are installed in a car manufactured by Y and they fail, both X and Y will be liable: X because the brakes were defective, Y because the car as a whole was sub-standard.
- e.g. Section 2(2)(b): Busby v Berkshire Bed Co [2018]: Outsourcing to South Korea meant European company 'holding themselves out as producer' liable under
- e.g. Section 2(2)(b): Pollard v Tesco Stores [2006]: Does an 'own-brand' product incur liability under 2(1)(b)? Clerk & Lindell say often assumed to BUT really, do Tesco hold themselves out as producers? Interesting Q.
- Section 2(2): (a) The PRODUCER of the product; (b) Any person who, by putting their name on the product or using any distinguishing mark, has HELD HIMSELF OUT to be the producer; (c) any person who has IMPORTED the product into the UK in order to SUPPLY it to another in the COURSE OF BUSINESS
- Section 4(1)(c): If the person otherwise liable under Section 2(2) or Section 2(3) ONLY acted WITHOUT a view to profit. So BUSINESS only.
- (4) Is the Product DEFECTIVE?
- Section 3(1): The product is 'defective' if the safety of the product is not such as persons generally are ENTITLED TO EXPECT....including the safety of any products comprised in that product
- Section 3(2): In considering defectiveness, "all the circumstances" are to be included. This includes:
- (a) The manner in which, and purposes for which, the product has been marketed...any warnings or marks
- (b) What might reasonably be expected to be done with the product or in relation to the product.
- Sale of Good case of Wormed v RHM [1987]: Use of weedkiller to wash hands in plain disregard of risk; no liability for failure to warn.
- (c) The time when the product was supplied by the producer to another
- Warnings/Instructions for use (Section 3(2)(a))
- Worsley v Tambrands [2000]: Explicit warning on tampons with regard to toxic shock syndrome sufficient to prevent finding of defectiveness.
- B v McDonalds [2002]: No duty to warn in relation to hot coffee; obvious danger.
- A warning might not be sufficient though, either because it does not sufficiently alert the consumer OR because the product is so dangerous: Consorts X [2018] (ECC - French decision)
- Worsley v Tambrands [2000]: Explicit warning on tampons with regard to toxic shock syndrome sufficient to prevent finding of defectiveness.
- Compliance with regulatory standards: Not conclusive either way, but compliance good indication of sufficient safety.
- Wilkes v DePuy International [2016]; Gee v DePuy Ltd [2018]
- Standard v Non-Standard Product: i.e. where some manufacturing problem has occurred, or where the design itself is flawed.
- Where standard, compared with other relevant products available on the market.
- Hastings v Finsbury Orthopaedics [2021]
- Guy v DePuy [2018]
- The Risk-Benefit test might be sneaking in via the backdoor here, as well.
- Wilkes v DePuy [2016]: Hickinbottom J [66]-[67] expresses scepticism about the irrelevance (A v National Blood Authority) of risk-benefit, at least in standard cases and in the context of medicine; also Andrews J did in Gee v DePuy [2018] at [144]-[167]
- Nolan (2018) and Eisler (2017)
- Eisler (2017): Such analysis is especially relevant where the product can only produce certain benefits if it also produces certain risks e.g. medicines
- Wilkes v DePuy [2016]: Hickinbottom J [66]-[67] expresses scepticism about the irrelevance (A v National Blood Authority) of risk-benefit, at least in standard cases and in the context of medicine; also Andrews J did in Gee v DePuy [2018] at [144]-[167]
- Hastings v Finsbury Orthopaedics [2021]
- Where non-standard, compared with standard versions of the product.
- A v National Blood Authority [2002], though Burton J declined to use the standard/non-standard distinction.
- Where standard, compared with other relevant products available on the market.
- The Public's Legitimate Expectation of safety is the key: A v National Blood Authority; Guy v DePuty Ltd [2018]
- Hastings v Finsbury Orthopaedics [2022]: In the case e.g. involving an artificial. hip, the public cannot legitimately expect 100% safety. Product dependent. Condom: Richardson v London Rubber (not 100% e.g.)
- (5) Does C suffer damage of a recoverable kind?
- Section 5(1): Death, personal injury, or any loss of or damage to property subject to the restrictions below.
- Section 5(3): No liability for property damage if the property is NOT: (a) Of a description of property ORDINARILY INTENDED FOR PRIVATE USE, occupation, or consumption; AND (b) intended by the person suffering damage mainly for his own private use.
- Renfrew Gold Club v Motocaddy Ltd [2016], C failed to recover for property damage done to a golf clubhouse. The golf trolley supplied by D was left ‘on’ overnight and caught fire, damaging the property. However, because of Section 5(3), C failed to recover under CPA. The clubhouse is not ordinarily intended for private use (a) and was not intended so by C (b).
- Section 5(4): No damages are claimable in respect of property loss UNLESS the claimant's TOTAL damage exceeds £275
- Section 5(2): A person shall not be liable under section 2 above in respect of any defect in a product for the loss of or any damage to the product itself or for the loss of or any damage to the whole or any part of any product which has been supplied with the product in question comprised in it.
- Article 9(d) of Directive suggest limitation applies to EACH property but Clerk & Lindell say cumulative. Not either way in PQ.
- Section 5(3): No liability for property damage if the property is NOT: (a) Of a description of property ORDINARILY INTENDED FOR PRIVATE USE, occupation, or consumption; AND (b) intended by the person suffering damage mainly for his own private use.
- (6) Does the defect CAUSE the damage?
- Busby v Berkshire Bed Co Ltd [2018] C failed in a PI claim because the defect (the absence of two ‘feet’) to her bed was not responsible causally for her falling off it during sex and breaking her spine. The sex caused that. Likeiwse in Howmet (negligence case), the ‘defect’ was not the cause of the fire.
- (7) Does D have a full or partial defence?
- Full Defence 1: Compliance with Legal Requirement
- Section 4(1)(a): If the defect is attributable to compliance with a legal requirement, no liability.
- Full Defence 2: Uncirculated Product
- Section 4(1)(b): If D did not, at any time, circulate the product, that is a whole defence.
- Full Defence 3: Subsequent Defect
- Section 4(1)(d): If the defect did not exist in the product at the relevant time...e.g. after parting with it...
- Piper v JRI Ltd [2006]: Failure of prosthesis AFTER fitting
- Section 4(1)(d): If the defect did not exist in the product at the relevant time...e.g. after parting with it...
- Full Defence 4: Non-Profit Activities
- Section 4(1)(c): Where a supply does not supply in the course of business, no liability. Producers and those under Section 2(2) also not liable IF they do not supply with ANY view to profit. So not going to cover professional charities?
- Full Defence 6: DEVELOPMENT RISKS***
- Section 4(1)(e): “that the state of scientific and technical knowledge at the relevant time was not such that a producer of products of the same description as the product in question might be expected to have discovered the defect if it had existed in his products while they were under his control.”
- BUT Directive Article 7(e): ‘The producer shall not be liable…if he proves: (e) that the state of scientific and technical knowledge at the time when he put the product into circulation was not such as to enable the existence of the defect to be discovered.’ I.E by ANYONE
- A v NBA [2001]: The strict wording of the Directive should prevail. Therefore, only if the knowledge is INACCESSIBLE TO ANYBODY i.e. because unpublished, locked away.
- assuming the wording of the Directive is taken, the requirement that the state of knowledge “was not such as to enable the existence of the defect to be discovered” is also strictly construed. If any hypothetical researcher could have discovered the possibility of the defect, however obscure the source of the information, the defence will not apply. Indeed, in A v National Blood Authority Burton J seemingly thought that existing knowledge could be discounted only where in the form of “an unpublished document or unpublished research not available to the general public, retained within the laboratory or research department of a particular company”.318
- A v NBA [2001]: The strict wording of the Directive should prevail. Therefore, only if the knowledge is INACCESSIBLE TO ANYBODY i.e. because unpublished, locked away.
- BUT Directive Article 7(e): ‘The producer shall not be liable…if he proves: (e) that the state of scientific and technical knowledge at the time when he put the product into circulation was not such as to enable the existence of the defect to be discovered.’ I.E by ANYONE
- Section 4(1)(e): “that the state of scientific and technical knowledge at the relevant time was not such that a producer of products of the same description as the product in question might be expected to have discovered the defect if it had existed in his products while they were under his control.”
- Full Defence 5: Components
- Section 4(1)(f): Component manufacturer has defence if he can show the defect in the subsequent product is WHOLLY due to the design of the subsequent product, OR to compliance with manufacturer instructions.
- Partial Defence 1: Contributory Negligence of C
- Section 6(4): Ordinary principles apply.
- Section 7: Liability cannot be excluded but (Section 11(3)) a ten-year long stop post-circulation operates.
- Full Defence 1: Compliance with Legal Requirement
- Section 5(1): Death, personal injury, or any loss of or damage to property subject to the restrictions below.
- Section 3(2): In considering defectiveness, "all the circumstances" are to be included. This includes:
- Section 3(1): The product is 'defective' if the safety of the product is not such as persons generally are ENTITLED TO EXPECT....including the safety of any products comprised in that product
- Section 2(1): Where any damage is caused in part or wholly by a defect in a product, EVERY person to whom Section 2(2) applies shall be liable.
- Any person suffering damage. of the kind recoverable under the CPA is entitled. to sue under it. See "Recoverable Damage"
- Section 1(2): Any goods or electricity...and includes any product comprised in another product, whether as a component or raw material.
Information
- Description
- Mind Map on CPA 1987, created by Alex Scoby on 31/05/2023.
- Created by
- Alex Scoby · May 2023
- Updated
- May 31, 2023
- Views
- 1
- Rating