Leadership Research
Slides in this set (10)
-
- Much effort placed upon research of leadership - with little known and much still a mystery
- Several Major Theoretical approachs assigned to study leadership
- Trait Approach
- Style/Behavioral Approach
- Contingency/Situational Approach
-
- One of earliest approaches employed to study leadership
- Suggests that good leaders are born - "natural leaders"
- Leaders aren't made and individuals possess certain qualities and attributes which set them apart
- Psychological inventories and tests made to assess and analyse desired qualities
- Most frequently examined qualities
- Physical characteristics - Height
- Intellectual Attributes - Intelligence
- Personality features - Sensitivity
- Stogdill (1948) found some differences between leaders and non-leaders
- situational demands dictated requiste leadership skills
- Possesion of leadership traits was no guarantee of success
- Assumption: Possession certain perceived leadership traits can increase likelihood of leader being successful in certain situations
- Kirkpatrick & Locke (1991)
- Essential traits desired:
- Drive
- Honesty
- Cognitive Ability
- Desire to Lead
- Self Confidence
- Integrity
-
- Extension of Trait Approach
- The use of tests indicate traits that predict management potential
- Projective and situational tests comprised of perceived advancement traits
- Resistance to stress
- Tolerance of uncertainty
- Candidates level of activity
- Weakness: Potential gender bias
-
- 1950s Research
- Research sites at Ohio State and Michigan
- Tried to identify leadership style through primarily psychological research - Psychologists researched
- OSU studies sought to determine behaviors associated with leaders attempt to identify leadership type behaviors
- Leadership Behaviour Description Questionnaire (LBDQ)
- Mixed reactions to is viability
- Major modifications made over years with some shortcoming persisting:
- Inconsistent & statistically insignificant
- Situational factors are not accounted for
- Direction of the cause is unknown
- Informal leadership is not addressed
- Validity of studies in question
- *Used despite the shortcomings*
-
- Snyder (1990) : results suggested personal style is important in understanding a leader's decision making behavior
- Michigan Studies: found certain qualities among leaders in high performance organisations - role-differentation, macro-management (leader autonomy), developed group cohesiveness, employee-centred approach. One of the shortcomings is that situational variables are not considered
- OSU & Michigan Results:
- 4 dimensions of leadership emerged
- Support
- Interaction facilitation
- Goal Emphasis
- Work Facilitation
- Bowers & Seashore
- Coined the terms managerial leadership and peer leadership which gave rise to informal leadership and participative leadership
-
- Similarities exist between OSU and Michigan studies
- Both addressed behavior or style
- Both addressed two dimensions of style - Organisational Tasks & Employee Relations
- Both had similar problems with their research
-
Contingency/Situational Approach
- Assumes no universally appropriate style of leadership and impact of style is based upon situational factors
- Most common contigency theories:
- Path-goal theory (robert house)
- Situational Theory
- Fiedler's LPC Approach
-
Path Goal Theory - Contingency Approach
- Attempts to understand how leader behavior influences the satisfaction and effort of their employees
- Seeks to explain what effects different types of leaders will have under certain conditions
- Diverse leadership styles:
- Supportive
- Instrumental
- Participative
- Achievement
- Aided researchers to identify situational variables which can impact leaders and their staff
- Chelladurai and Saleh (1978 & 1980 - Identified 5 types of leader behaviors in sport. Found that leadership style correlated strongly with athlete satisfaction and desire to maximise performance
- Two dimensions make up concept:
- Job Maturity
- Psychological Maturity
-
- Herset & Blanchard
- Based on premise that two leader behaviors exist:
- Task Behavior - initiating structure
- Relationship Behavior - Support & open communication
- Concept suggests that you have task-related leadership behaviors and maintanence-related leadership behaviors
- Strengths:
- Draws attention to a leader's need to treat employees differently
- Draws attention to ways leaders can facilitate employee's abilities & confidence levels
- Weaknesses:
- Few Studies utilise approach
- Few attempts to emprically test concepts
-
- Considered oldest approach in contingency theory leadership research
- Paradigm pertains to how situational variables moderate the relationship between leader traits and organisational effectiveness
- Least-Preffered Coworker (LPC)
- Instrument used to determine leader's traits
- Scores reflect task-orientation or relationship-orientation leaders
- Limitations:
- Few supporters and major criticisms
- Limited research
Information
- Description
- M.A Sport Administration Slide Set on Leadership Research, created by Jacob Lloyd on 21/11/2018.
- Created by
- Jacob Lloyd · Nov 2018
- Updated
- Nov 21, 2018
- Views
- 12
- Rating