Notes
International Research Ethics
Content of the notes (1)
Page 1
Biomedical Research
Uses systematic
scientific methods to develop new preventative, diagnostic, therapeutic and
palliative interventions
It has important
social value
Precondition for safe and
effective treatments
Precondition for medical
progress
Research interventions
expose study participants to risks primarily to generate generalisable
knowledge
Ethical conflict
between promoting valuable research, and protecting participants' rights and
interests
Ethical Principles and How to Apply Them
General ethical
principles
Respect for persons -->
informed consent or surrogate consent
Capacity to make decisions
Disclosure of relevant
information
Understanding of relevant
information
Voluntariness of agreement
Agreement given
Beneficence and non-maleficence
--> risk-benefit evaluation
Ensure minimum social value
Minimise risks to participants
Ensure reasonable relation of
risks and potential individual benefits/social value
Limit risks when participants
cannot or do not consent: minimal risk threshold for 'non-beneficial'
research procedures
Justice --> fair selection
of participants
Enrol participants (or not)
for scientific reasons, not convenience
Include vulnerable groups with
appropriate 'special protections', such as:
Risk limits
Group benefit
Surrogate consent or consent
advocate
Community consultation
What Makes Research Ethical?
At least (in
chronological order):
Socially valuable research
question
Scientific validity
Fair subject selection
Acceptable risk-benefit ratio
Informed consent
Annual research and
development expenditures
$268.4 billion in North
America/Europe/Asia-Oceania (45% in US)
Largest growth in spending in
Asia-Oceania
37% public, 63% private
Research in LMICs
Many sponsors
Public: external/internal,
governments/international organisations
Private: external/internal,
NGOs/industry
Many goals
Understand or improve local
health problems
Build research capacity &
infrastructure
'Outsourcing' of research
Culture and power
Cultural differences: different
habits, beliefs or systems of value
Differences are dynamic and
often unexamined
All cultures are heterogeneous
Power differentials: asymmetry
in the ability to 'impose one's will on others' due to social, economic or
political factors
Background injustices
Individuals have a right to
basic infrastructure (e.g. health care, sanitation), but in many LMICs
this right is not fully realised
Due to these background
injustices, there are many unmet needs in LMICs, both on the individual
and population
It is often unclear or
controversial what the general ethical principles for research imply when
studies are conducted in LMICs (especially when they are conducted by external
researchers)
Area of ongoing debate
in research ethics
Respect for Autonomy
Who should make
decisions?
Different conceptions of
autonomy - spousal consent, community consent
When are decisions
voluntary?
Power differentials, unmet
needs
Example: community
consent
Must individual informed
consent always be obtained? (Yes)
Should community consent be
obtained where it is the cultural norm?
Communities can limit options
for individuals
Community decisions can unduly
influence individual decision making
If so, who speaks for the
community?
Beneficence and Non-Maleficence
What is the
appropriate standard of care in clinical trials?
E.g. what's locally available
or medically best
Should sponsors and
investigators provide ancillary care for conditions that are not the focus of
the research?
What are participants
owed when the research is over (post-trial benefits)
Example: ancillary
care
What grounds the obligation to
provide ancillary care?
Therapeutic obligations of
clinician-investigators
Duties of non-maleficence of
investigators
Natural duties of all persons
(e.g. duty to rescue)
Entitlements as a matter of
justice
What are the limits to this
obligation?
Fair Participant Selection
Must the research be
responsive to local health needs (responsiveness requirement)?
Should the benefits of
the research (e.g. new intervention) be made available to the community
(reasonable available requirement)?
If so, who is the
community?
Example: reasonable
availability
What grounds the obligation to
make new interventions available?
Duties of non-exploitation
Duties of reciprocity
Entitlements as a matter of
justice
What are the limits to this
obligation?
Information
- Description
- Global Health (International Research Ethics) Note on International Research Ethics, created by Eleanor Farenden on 15/03/2017.
- Created by
- Eleanor Farenden · Mar 2017
- Updated
- Mar 15, 2017
- Views
- 1
- Rating