Flashcards
Critical Discourse Analysis and Positive Discourse Analysis
Cards in this deck (50)
- 1Origins of CDAEnd 1970s
Reaction against formal paradigms of 1960s an 1970s - 2CDA focuses on …Social power abuse, inequality and injustice
- 3CDA analytical approach is based on …Halliday’s functional grammar
- 42 premises of CDA analytical approachGrammar is an ideological instrument for categorizing things in the world
Sapir/Whorf Hypothesis : language influences how we think because every language has a different way of categorizing the world - 5Van Djijk’s definition of CDA and aimApproach to discourse that studies how social power abuse, dominance and inequality are enacted, reproduced and resisted by text and talk in the social and political context.
Its aim is to expose, understanding and resisting social inequality - 63 main representantes of CDANorman Fairclough
Ruth Wodak
Wetherell et al. - 7Norman Fairclough main conceptDiscourse is a three-dimensional concept
- 83-dimensions of text (Fairclough)Text (objet of the analysis)
Discourse practices (production, distribution and consumption of texts)
Social practices (ideologies and power relations are reproduced and challenged by text) - 9Ruth Wodak focuses on …Language behavior in natural speech situations of social relevance to expose inequality and injustice with emphasis on historical and social aspects
- 10Wetherell et al. main conceptSemiosis: material social processes include all forms of meaning-making (visual images, body and verbal language) and social life is an interconnected network of social practices each one with a semiotic element
- 116 main tenets of CDAFocus on social problems
Power relations are discursive
Society and culture are discursive
Discourse does ideological work
Discourse is historical
Discourse is a form of social action - 12Power is a multifaceted phenomenonSocial
Political
Military
Physical - 13Power is always associated to …Rank and status
- 14Social power is defined in terms of….Control: a social group has power if it can control the thoughts and the actions of other groups
- 15Power is seldom ….Absolute: groups may resist, accept or comply with such power
- 16Althusser’s 2 features of powerIt is discursive and ideological: discourse creates subjects’ position through rules, laws and habits which are often taken for granted and accepted as natural and unchangeable
- 173 CDA’s statements about relationship between power and discourseAccess to discourse is a source of power
If we can influence people minds, we can control their actions
Those groups who control the most influential discourse have more chances to control others’ minds and actions - 181 type of power abuseHegemony
- 19HegemonyA given group abuses its power and other gourds accept this abuse acting in the interest of the powerful
- 20Power elitesHegemonic groups
- 21CDA defines power elites in terms of their …Symbolic capital (Bourdieu)
- 223 Examples of forms of control illegal or morally unacceptableExclusion of women by men
Restrictions put on black people by white people
Every kind of communicative discrimination - 23Discourse is a segregated structure when …It becomes a form of censoring and devoicing the less powerful
- 24Manifestations of dominance in discourse can be found at 3 levels:…Syntactic
Morphological
Phonological - 255 examples of manifestation of dominance at various levelesDominating the floor (longer)
(Im)politeness strategies (irony)
Use of pauses, interruptions and laughter
Use of certain intonations
Choice of topic or topic changing - 263 key concepts of CDAIdeology
Social cognition
Discourse - 27IdeologySet of beliefs or principles on which is based an organization
- 28According to CDA ideology is …The link between discourse and society
- 29According to CDA ideology is essentially socialShared by members of a group
Used to coordinate interaction with members of other groups - 30According to Van Djik ideologies control ….Social groups and their discourse because they are at the basis of social representations shared by the members of a group and they have been developed but dominant groups to reproduce and legitimate their domination
- 31Ideologies are both …Social systems and mental representations
- 32Social cognitionAim of CDA: become aware of social an political issues reducing the gap between micro and macro levels of social order (specific situation of debate - legal system)
- 335 steps CDA (Whetherell et al.)Choose a social problem with semiotic aspects
Identify obstacles to its solution
Consider whether the social order needs the problem
Identify how to pass the obstacles
Reflect critically on the analysis - 34Schleghoff’s 2 critiques of CDAIt does not have a detailed and systematic analysis of discourse
(it presupposes contextualization but does not prove what social members actually say and do)
It method of analysis is not objective (critical analysts impose their own frame of reference on a words which is already interpreted and constructed by participants of discourse, turning themselves into the intellectual hegemony - 35Other critique to CDAIt is politically biased (left-oriented)
- 366 steps of Van Dijk ideological analysis (focused on ideological polarization)Topic selection
Schematic organization
Local meanings, coherence, implications, presuppositions
Lexicalization
Style
Rhetorical devices - 37Topic selectionInformation that the speaker finds more important in terms of ideology
- 38Schematic organizationOverall meaning that can be manipulated to achieve our goal
- 39Local meanings, coherence, implications, presuppositionsImplicit meanings, more difficult to be challenged
- 40LexicalizationVocabulary used to produce positive self-representation and negative other-representation
- 41StyleFrom formal to informal
- 425 stylesFrozen style
Formal style
Consultative style
Informal style
Intimate Style - 43Frozen styleTo be remembered
Used in very formal settings
complex grammatical structures
vocabulary used by expert
ritualized expressions (marriage vows) - 44Formal styleTo inform and to captivate audience
Formal settings with little feedback from the audience
(Announcements) - 45Consultative styleSemi-formal communication
Two ways participation
(Teacher-student, doctor-patient) - 46Informal styleAmong friends
Free participation of speakers and hearers
colloquial vocabulary and expressions (internet chat rooms) - 47Intimate styleBetween people very close
Free and easy participation
language used not in public
(Mother-child) - 48Positive Discourse Analysis according to Martin ad Rose focuses on 2 things:the positive aspects of power and on community
(How people get together in the world in ways that redistribute power without struggling against it)
Constructive social actions and researches
(Accounts of processes, not discouraging analysis of oppression) - 491 example of PDAInspirational writing by Mandela
- 504 steps of PDAChoosing the type of text analyzed
Defining the aim of the text
Describing how the aim is achieved
Describe the effects of the chosen text
Information
- Description
- B Discourse Analysis (10 Critical Discourse Analysis and Positive Discourse Analys) Flashcards on Critical Discourse Analysis and Positive Discourse Analysis, created by Gabriella Foresti on 11/08/2023.
- Created by
- Gabriella Foresti
- Views
- 2
- Rating
More on Critical Discourse Analysis