Flashcards
Step 2 - Must involve an inventive step
Cards in this deck (15)
- 1What section covers this?s3 of the Patents Act 1977
s1(b) also requires an invention to involve an inventive step to be patentable - 2What does this section prevent?It prevents inventions which would be discovered by routine investigation and development by people of that art.
We only want to give patents to people who have gone beyond this.
A patent can be challenged through this step at the start of the patents life, and during it. - 3What does s3 Patent Act 1977 state?An invention shall be taken to involve an inventive step if the invention:
"is not obvious to a person skilled in the art having regard to any matter which forms part of the state of art at the priority date of the invention".
If a patent does not meet this criteria, then it would be viewed as obvious, and not patentable. - 4How do we assess whether the invention is the nest inventive step?A comparison between the invention and the state of art through the eyes of the hypothetical skilled technician.
A judgement needs to be made to assess whether the invention shows a sufficiently innovative step forward in the art.
This can be difficult, as this judgement has to be made with hindsight, ignoring all the developments since the priority date. - 5Preliminary stepWhat is the scope of the invention for which a patent is being sought? Important issue in relation to inventions with multiple features:
(MFI case) - 6Sabaf v MFI Furniture centres [2004]You need to look at what invention is patented. Tesla won't patent their cars, but they will protect certain parts of their cars with patents. This will determine the state for the art
Need to look into more? - 7EPO Guidelines: Combination v Juxtaposition?
- 8What does obviousness mean?Test outlined by Oliver LJ in Windsurfing International Inc v Tabur Marine Ltd [1985] with four steps.
These are an objective test, concerned with whether the step would be obvious to the reasonable person in the art - 9Windsurfing International Inc v Tabur Marine Ltd [1985] Step 1Identify the inventive concept incorporated in the patent
- 10Windsurfing International Inc v Tabur Marine Ltd [1985] Step 2"Assume the mantle of the normally skilled but unimaginative person in the art at the priority date and impute to him what was, at that date, common general knowledge in the art in question;"
We are not looking at James Dyson, we are looking at the person who knows the product upside down, so the person who would come round to fix your Dyson, do these people think it is obvious. - 11Windsurfing International Inc v Tabur Marine Ltd [1985] Step 3"Identify what, if any, differences exist between the matters cited as being known or used and the alleged invention"
- 12Windsurfing International Inc v Tabur Marine Ltd [1985] Step 4"Ask whether, viewed without any knowledge of the alleged invention, those differences constituted steps which would have been obvious to the skilled man or whether they required any degree of invention".
- 13Key part to remember about the state of the art?We are looking at whether can you invention be put together with the knowledge which already exists at the time.
- 14The hypothetical technicianThe reasonable person within that field of art
- 15Relevant fieldOnly concerned with whether it is obvious within the field of research in which the invention lies in.
Information
- Description
- Intellectual Property (Patents) Flashcards on Step 2 - Must involve an inventive step, created by James Dolton on 18/02/2018.
- Created by
- James Dolton
- Views
- 1
- Rating