Flashcards
The Beneficiary Principle
Cards in this deck (35)
- 1The beneficiary principleThe beneficiary principle states that a trust must have a human beneficiary who can enforce the trust.
- 2Morice v Bishop of Durham / Re AstorMorice - 'There must be somebody in whose favour the court can decree performance of the trust'.
Re Astor - Private purposes trusts are NOT valid because they have no human beneficiaries. - 3ExceptionsThere are notable exceptions to the fact that a private purpose trust will not be valid;
1. Anomalous exceptions, subject to the perpetuity rule
2. The trust satisfies the Re Denley rule
3. The trust is for a charitable purpose
4. The trust is for an unincorporated association. - 4Anomalous exceptionsThere are several anomalous exceptions to the beneficiary principle.
- 5AE - Trust made for a specific animalWhere a trust is made for the welfare of a specific animal, it will be a valid trust.
- 6Pettingall v Pettingall / Re Haines / Re Dean / Re Howard / Re KellyAll these cases are examples in which a trust has been made for the welfare of a specific animal and has therefore, been declared a valid trust.
- 7AE - Private massesA trust that is made for the saying of private masses will be held as a valid trust.
- 8Bourne v KeaneThe gift within the trust concerned a private mass for the dead. This was a valid trust.
- 9AE - Tombs and monumentsGifts made for the maintenance and erection of a tomb/monument will be held as valid.
- 10Pirbright v Salwey / Re Hooper / Re EndacottPirbright / Hooper - Gifts were for the erection of monuments and therefore, were held as valid.
Re Endacott - 'some useful memorial to myself' made the trust void. The phrase was too broad and could encompass things outside a tomb or monument. - 11AE - Fox hunting?Re Thompson - The court allowed a gift for the promotion of fox hunting. However, unlikely to still be the law due to the prohibition of fox hunting under the Hunting Act 2004.
- 12Anomalous exceptions are closed!Re Endacott highlighted that these anomalous exceptions are a closed list. They cannot be extended and new categories cannot be added.
- 13The perpetuity periodTrusts cannot last forever. Under s.18 of the Perpetuity and Accumulations Act 2009, funds can only be tied up for a life in being plus 21 years.
- 14Mussett v BingleExample of where a trust did not adhere to the perpetuity period and was therefore void.
- 15Re Khoo Cheng TeowThe 'life in being' can be anyone nominated within the trust instrument. This person does not need to be anyone connected to the trust or testator.
If no life in being is nominated, the period will be 21 years from the testator's death. - 16Excluding the perpetuity periodA testator may be able to exclude the perpetuity period by including a phrase of limitation within the trust.
- 17Re Hooper / Pirbright v SalweyRe Hooper - 'As far as trustees can legally do so' was a limitation clause and therefore, the perpetuity period was met.
Pirbright - 'For so long as the law allows' was likewise held valid. - 18The perpetuity period and animalsSometimes, the courts have been willing to look at the lifespan of an animal for which the trust has been made, in order to determine whether the trust goes beyond the perpetuity period.
- 19Re Holmes / Re KellyRe Holmes - Courts considered that cats do no live longer than 21 years.
Re Kelly - The correct law was given. The courts should not reference animal lives, only human lives. - 20Re Denley's trustA non-charitable trust can be valid if the purpose is recognised as directly or indirectly benefiting ascertained individuals.
- 21Re Denley's trust / Re LipinskiThe courts held that where;
1. A trust is made for a purpose which is 'inward looking' (benefits ascertained individuals, not public).
2. There are ascertainable human individuals (who are not strictly beneficiaries) who can enforce the trust
3. The trust is limited in perpetuity
This will be a valid trust under the Re Denley principle. - 22Re Denley's trust - CriticismBARNETT - Questions whether the reasoning of the judgement. Weren't the individuals in the case really beneficiaries in the sense that they were owners of the property in equity?
Could they not have terminated the trust under Saunders v Vauiter, sold the pitch and distributed the proceedings? If they were not owners in equity, do they really have the locus standi to enforce the trust? - 23Gift to an Unincorporated AssociationAn unincorporated association generally includes clubs and societies of a non-commercial nature but have important social value.
- 24Conservative and Unionist Central Office v BurrellUnincorporated associations include;
1. Two or more persons;
2. Coming together for a non-commercial purpose;
3. Whose relationship is governed by contract (terms being the rules of the association). - 25Why can't trusts be given to unincorporated associations?UA's do not have a corporate body and therefore, have no legal personality. Therefore, it cannot be the recipient of a gift. The gift would therefore be to the association, which infringes the beneficiary principle.
However, social usefulness of UA's has meant courts have wanted to ensure that gifts to UA's are valid. - 26Leaky v AG for New South WalesThe court held that there were two ways such a gift could be interpreted to be valid;
1.. As a gift to the members as joint tenants/ tenants in common;
2. A gift for the association's purposes - 27Neville Estates v MaddenA new category emerged after issues with the interpretations were identified.
New category was held as category 2 and stated that it was a gift to the members subject to the rules of the association (known as the 'contract holding' theory). - 28What are the possible interpretations?Category 1 - Gift to the members as tenants in common / joint tenants
Category 2 - Gift to the members subject to the rules of the association.
Category 3 - Gift on trust for the association's purposes. - 29Universal Tankships Inc of Monrovia v International Transport Workers FederationWhen a gift is made to a UA, the law presumes that it is Category 2.
- 30Rebutting Category 2Where a gift is made 'on trust', the gift will be category 3.
However, a category 3 might be saved by application of the Re Denley principle as long as it is for an "inward" looking purpose.
A gift that is clearly for the members as joint tenants will automatically be category 1. - 31Issues with Category 2Whilst it prevents individuals from immediately severing their share, there is nothing stopping the members from winding up the association and distributing funds amongst themselves.
If a specific purpose is mentioned, the UA can use the funds accordingly to its rule and does not need to comply with the terms of the gift.
GREEN - Largely unenforceable by the testator 'the price of validity of the gift of unenforceability'. - 32Category 2 - Breaking formalities of a trustUnder Category 2, each member has a subsisting equitable interest in the gift. When a member leaves the association, what happens to his share depends upon the terms of the association. Where association has not rules on this, his share will be lost.
If a new member comes to the association, the new member may take the share. However, LPA 1925 s.53(1)(c) states that subsisting equitable interest can only be transferred by writing and signed - this does not happen but still interest is transferred. - 33Dissolution - Re Sick and Funeral Society of St John's Sunday SchoolDissolution of a UA occurs when there is a formal meeting to wind up. Mere inactivity is not enough.
Where meeting does not occur, unequivocal conduct to demonstrate that the association is winding up must be shown. - 34Re West Sussex Constabulary Funds TrustOn dissolution, the funds can either go;
1. Bona vacatina to the Crown.
2. Where there is an identifiable donor, the funds will go back on resulting trust to that donor. - 35Re Buckingham Constabulary FundsUnder Category 2, all gifts belong to members. Therefore, on dissolution, they funds will be distributed between them. If there is only one member, funds will go to the Crown.
If Category 3, it will revert back on resulting trust.
Information
- Description
- Equity and Trusts (Block 1 - Beneficiary principle) Flashcards on The Beneficiary Principle , created by Chantal Briancon on 16/04/2018.
- Created by
- Chantal Briancon
- Views
- 4
- Rating
More on Beneficiary Principle and Purpose Trusts