Flashcards
Tort - Intentional Torts
Cards in this deck (15)
- 1IQBAL v PRISON OFFICERS ASSOCIATION- All trespass to the person torts require 'intentional conduct'
Intention also included "ACTING WITH RECKLESS DISREGARD FOR CONSEQUENCES"
This is controversial - 2ASSAULT STEPHENS v MYERS- D got up and aggressively started towards C
An assault - because he was in the position to immediate touch C, making C reasonably fear immediate battery - 3ASSAULT R v IRELAND [1998]SILENCE CAN AMOUNT TO AN ASSAULT
- Silent phone calls, C did not know where D was - she could reasonably fear immediate battery - 4BATTERY WILSON v PRINGLE [1987] overturned by RE F [1990]Wilson: CoA said HOSTILITY was a requirement (although did not require malevolencE)
Overturned - Re F: hostility was not a requirement, an unwanted kiss could be a battery - 5BATTERY INNES v WYLIE- Battery requires SOME POSITIVE ACT
- If D is purely passive, cannot be a battery - 6FALSE IMPRISONMENT BIRD v JONESNeeds to be total restraint, where C feels as though they have no other option
"mere obstruction of passage is insufficient" - Patterson LJ - 7FALSE IMPRISONMENT IQBAL v PRISON OFFICERS ASSOCIATION [2009]- False imprisonment requires some POSITIVE DUTY
Prison officers not letting prisoners out of the cell for the day is not false imprisonment because there is no positive duty to let them out
A prison officer not letting a prisoner out at the end of his sentence WOULD BE false imprisonment because there is a positive duty - 8FALSE IMPRISONMENT DAVIDSON v CC of NORTH WALES [1994]- DIRECTNESS is a requirement in false imprisonment
- Needs to be a close link between D's action and the imprisonment - 9WILKINSON v DOWNTON [1897] CREATED TORT OF - INTENTIONAL INFLICTION OF PHYSICAL OR EMOTIONAL HARM- D wilfully did an act, calculated to cause physical or emotional harm to C
'Calculated' - "the act was so plainly calculated to produce some effect of the kind that was produced, that an intention to produce it ought to be imputed"
SOME SIGNIFICANCE TAKEN AWAY BY PROTECTION FROM HARASSMENT ACT 1997 - 10HARASSMENT - INTENTIONAL INFLICTION OF PHYSICAL OR EMOTIONAL HARM MAJROWSKI v GUYS AND ST THOMAS' NHS TRUST [2007Lady Hale - "all sorts of conduct may amount to harassment and the court must draw sensible lines between ordinary banter of life and genuinely offensive and unacceptable behaviour"
- 11INTENTIONAL INFLICTION OF PHYSICAL OR EMOTIONAL HARM O (A CHILD) v RHODES [2015]Clarified requirements for Wilkinson tort -
1. CONDUCT ELEMENT - requires words directed towards C, with no justification or reasonable excuse
2. MENTAL ELEMENT - must intend to cause severe mental or emotional distress
These should be confined narrowly to ensure minimum contradiction with freedom of expression - 12DEFENCES 1. Lawful Authority SUNBOLF v ALFORD- Pub landlord believed he had the right to detain a customer who hadn't paid - he did not
- He committed false imprisonment - does not matter that he thought he had the right to do so - 13DEFENCES 2. Consent GILLICK v WEST NORFOLK HEALTH AUTHORITY [1986]Requirement 1 of consent defence: CAPACITY
Considering capacity of teenage girls to consent to receiving contraception - 14DEFENCES 2. CONSENT CHATTERTON v GERSON [1981]Requirement 2 of consent defence:
CONSENT MUST BE REAL
C must understand in broad terms the nature of what is being proposed - 15DEFENCES 2. CONSENTRequirement 3 for consent defence:
CONSENT MUST BE FOR ACTUAL THING THAT HAPPENED
Consent for one type of touching does not count as consent for another
Information
- Description
- Undergraduate Laws LLB (TORT ) Flashcards on Tort - Intentional Torts, created by Bethany Fieldhouse on 18/08/2018.
- Created by
- Bethany Fieldhouse
- Views
- 1
- Rating
More on Intentional Torts and Trespass