Flowchart
Dependency claim & loss of support
Flowchart content
dependency claim
dependants can claim reasonable expense incurred as a result of deceased death under: s.7 CLA 1956
few things to be aware before going further
deceased must have been able to sue: s.6 CLA 1956, Sambu v pitchakkaran
limitation period from date of death: s.7(5) CLA 1956, lee lee cheng v seow peng kwan: very strict
dependants
husband, wife, parents, child: s.7(2) CLA 1956
definition of parent and child: s7(11) CLA 1956
illegitimate child and adopted child also dependants: s.7(11) - Zulkifli ayob v velasini KM
married under custom cannot, not under LRA is void - Dee Bee Yoke
not dependants
divorced wife - Payne collins v taylor woodrow construction ltd
step parents - puteh b mahood v ng twee
bro' and sis - chan chin ming & anor v Lim yoke Eng
Loss of support
loss of financial support/service from deceased to dependant - Zulkifli ayob v velasini KM
to proof LOS, dependant must show receiving actual loss of support until death of deceased - Chan Chin Ming v Lim Yoke Eng
even the support is from 3rd, still can claim - Hay v Hughes
if dependant continue receive deceased income after his/her death, no claim - Yap Ami v Tan hui Pang
condition for Loss of support
s.7(3)(iv)(a) CLA 1956 -
- below age 55
- good health before accident
- had been receiving earnings
illegal earnings cannot be taken account - Chua Kim Suan v Govt of malaysia, provided didn't play an active role in illegality - tay lye seng v nazori bin teh
bonus not taken into account - jub'il bin mohamed taib taral v sunway lagoon sdn bhd
prospect of increment, no - s.7(3)(iv)(b) CLA 1956
if got govt pension, wife cannot claim loss of support - yap ami
however if non-govt pensioner died and pension stop, can claim loss of support follow - lee in Fong
assessment
(multiplicand)
mum take 750 and give 375 to bro and sis, as bro and sis cannot claim, mum can only claim RM375 - Chan chin ming
illegal earnings cannot - cases mentioned
if part of contribution is for deceased himself, must potong sikit - minachi v mohd yusof bin zakaria
Multiplier
s.7(3)(iv)(d) CLA 1956
- same as LOFE
Information
- Description
- CLP tort law ( potential claims) Flowchart on Dependency claim & loss of support, created by cheng ping ng on 25/04/2019.
- Created by
- cheng ping ng
- Views
- 1
- Rating