Help shape GoConqr. What should we add next?

Mind map

Source Memory: Memory for Contextual Details of an Event

Emily Collyer English

Map content

Source Memory: Memory for Contextual Details of an Event

  1. Recognition Memory Asking somebody to make a decision whether they have encountered something before or not

    • Encoding/ Study Phase: presenting participants with stimuli (eg. words). Ps may be asked to do some sort of task with these words. They may (or not) know that their memory is going to be tested
    • Retrieval/ Test Phase: presenting p's with items with the previous stage, mixed in with new items - they are asked whether each item is old or new
      • New items can be called Distractors, Lures or Foils
    • By looking at 'hits' and 'false alarms', we can tell if a p can do a task. A correlated Recognition Rate = Proportion of Hits - Proportion of False Alarms
  2. Dual-Processes Accounts

    • Two processes contribute to recognition memory judgments: how familiar a stimulus seems (Familiarity) or by recalling the particulars of the experience (Recollection).
    • Familiarity: Awareness of a prior encounter but with no recovery of contextual details. Fast and automatic
    • Recollection: Recovery of contextual details e.g. location, colour, task. Slow and more attention demanding.
    • Remember/Know Procedure (Tulving, 1985): For each judgment in the test phase, p's are asked why they feel they recognise the item - Remember (they consciously recollect the particulars of the study event/ Know (they feel they have seen item before but there is no memory for details of the event)/ New (item was not presented in study phase
      • Remember = Recollection; Know = Familiarity
      • A subjective paradigm
  3. Source Monitoring (SM)

    • The processes involved in examining the origins of what we retrieve and whether it is from a particular source.
    • The Source Monitoring Framework (SMF; Johnson, Hashtroudi & Lindsay 1993) - 3 important types of SM:
      • External Source Monitoring: discriminating external sources
        • E.G. "was this presented in red or green?"
      • Internal Source Monitoring: discriminating internally generated sources
        • E.G. "did I just think about sending that email or did I actually send it?"
      • Reality monitoring: internally generated/ externally derived
      • In all 3 situations, there are multiple cues to determine the source - Perceptual info (e.g. sound and colour), contextual info (spatial and temporal); semantic details (meaning); affective info (emotional reactions); cognitive operations (records of organising, elaborating)
        • We look at the differences in these characteristics to derive the source of the information - something you see has a lot of perceptual info, but something you have imagined may have more details about the cognitive operations involved.
      • Many decisions are made rapidly and relatively automatically, however others require more strategic processes. These are slower and more deliberate and may involve retrieval of supporting memories and external reasoning.
  4. Schizophrenia

    • One of the most profoundly affected cognitive domains iin SCZ s episodic memory
    • It has been suggested (e.g. Frith 1992) that some symptoms of SCZ might result from deficit in reality monitoring. 2 key questions:
      • Do individuals with SCZ have deficits in Recollection and/or Familiarity?
        • Van Erp er al 2008: Study phase - memory as much about items as possible. Test phase: R/K/N judgement. No apparent deficit in Familiarity, but levels of recollection in SCZ is sig less than controls - p's with SCZ have deficits in recollection but not familiarity
        • Weiss et al 2008: Study phase - words spoken in male or female voice. Test phase: male/ female/ new? Encoding accuracy good in both patients and controls. Corrected recognition rate (ability to discriminate old from new) is sig less than the control group. Source accuracy (given that they have correctly said that the item is old, what is the prob that they will get the source correct?) rates are sig above 50% so both groups could discriminate source by chance (no sig difference between groups) - individuals with SCZ may have deficits in familiarity and not recollection
        • Libby et al 2013 review: highlighted some methodological issues in some R/K/N studies and recalculated stats. There are large deficits in recollection AND smaller more variable deficits in familiarity. No objective source memory tasks in the review
      • If there is a deficit in Recollection are certain types of source memory (e.g. reality monitoring) more affected than others
        • Vinogradov et al 1997: Reality monitoring - Study phase of 40 sentences, some were complete and some had a blank for the p to fill in. Test phase of word pairs - experimenter generated/ self-gemetated/ new. SCZ ps made more source discrimination errors - more likely to say that the experimenter generated the words.
        • Achim & Weiss 2008: Meta-analysis of source memory studies in SCZ - no evidence for a specific deficit in reality monitoring, there seems to be deficits in other types of source memory
    • Relationship to symptoms? Mixed Evidence!
      • Hampton, Linden & Evans: Word task (3 conds: p performec/ p imagined./ exp performed) and Action Task (variety of objects on table with cue cards: p performed/ p imagined/ exp performed). At test: who performed it/ did I imagine it/ is it new? Ps high in +ve dimension of schizotypy had deficits in old/new discrimination, internal source monitoring, reality monitoring - But relationships only found in the action task!
  5. Conclusions

    • A number of different tasks can be used to examine source memory, which each have their strengths and weaknesses
    • Individuals with SCZ have greater deficits in Recollection than Familiarity
    • It might be predicted that SCZ ps will have deficits in particular types of source memory - however a meta-analysis on the subject found no sig differences in effect sized between reality monitoring, external source monitoring or internal source monitoring in SCZ

Information

Description
Mind Map on Source Memory: Memory for Contextual Details of an Event, created by Emily Collyer on 18/05/2018.
Created by
Emily Collyer · May 2018
Updated
Jun 10, 2018
Views
1
Rating

Feedback

What is it about?

What should we add next?