(6) Comparisons between US and British constitution


A level Governing the UK - 2C (The Constitution) Mind Map on (6) Comparisons between US and British constitution, created by Marcus Danvers on 09/19/2013.
Marcus  Danvers
Mind Map by Marcus Danvers, updated more than 1 year ago
Marcus  Danvers
Created by Marcus Danvers over 9 years ago

Resource summary

(6) Comparisons between US and British constitution
  1. Strengths
    1. US
      1. Codified
        1. Accountable to the constitution
          1. Social contract theory
            1. Citizens were entitled to a government that protects there natural rights
            2. Representation
              1. Representative government carries with it own notions, notably majority rule and the imprecation there are clear limits to democracy
              2. Separation of power
                1. To make show that no intuition have to much power
                2. system of check and balances
                  1. Both houses have to pass the bill but president can veto it
                3. UK
                  1. Flexible
                    1. effective government
                      1. creates a strong and more effective government
                      2. history and tradtion
                        1. link to the past
                        2. democratic rule
                          1. long unbroken record so the constitution must work
                      3. Weakness
                        1. US
                          1. Non flexible codified
                            1. The separation of power mean that any decision will take time
                              1. system of check and balances
                                1. One part of the system could be particular uncooperative
                              2. UK
                                1. Potential for elective dictatorship
                                  1. Centralization
                                    1. Critics for over centralization of government ineffective check and balances. UK government is characterised more by the contrition of power than it fragmentation
                                    2. Weak protection of rights
                                      1. Uncertainty
                                        1. Have to decipher
                                    Show full summary Hide full summary


                                    Creating the Constitution
                                    Selam H
                                    The Constitution and Bill of Rights
                                    Niat Habtemariam
                                    (4)Source of the British constitution
                                    Marcus Danvers
                                    (7) A Codified Constitution for and against
                                    Marcus Danvers
                                    (5) What are the principles of our constitution?
                                    Marcus Danvers
                                    (1) Constitution
                                    Marcus Danvers
                                    (3) Purpose of a constition
                                    Marcus Danvers
                                    (2) British Constitution
                                    Marcus Danvers
                                    (8) Check and Balances
                                    Marcus Danvers
                                    (9) Constitutional change under labour
                                    Marcus Danvers
                                    10) What constitutional reforms have the coalition proposed?
                                    Marcus Danvers