Many environmentalists argue against geo-engineering because it allows pollution to continue, then applies a 'fix' to clean it up
Environmentalists argue that a change in attitude is required, whereby we stop polluting in the first place
Many advocate the use of alternative energy technologies such as solar, wind and geothermal power
Technology and environmental sustainability are not
mutually exclusive
It is possible to harness technology to maintain our lifestyles and
the environment, for example through the use of microgeneration
Energy Microgeneration
Renewable microgeneration includes energy gained from small scale solar, wind, biomass and geothermal sources.
In most cases, energy is generated for an individual building such as a house
These are small-scale, bottom up projects, as householders themselves decide to install such systems
The systems themselves are relatively high tech
In 2008 around 100,000 systems were installed in the UK, compared with over 1 million in Germany
Solar thermal systems accounted for 90% of installed capacity in 2008
Usually roof-mounted, they use the energy from sunlight to heat water
Direct generation of electricity from solar panels is popular in Germany, but less so in the UK
The potential to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and fossil fuel dependency is huge, but take up of microgeneration in the UK is low
Initial costs are high, often similar to the cost of buying a car, and savings are made over many years
These technologies are not for families on low incomes
Many sites are not suitable for micro wind turbines or solar power systems
Government grants to help with initial costs stopped in 2007 because demand was so high
The technology is not widely known about or is assumed to be unsuitable
Some estimates suggest there are 10 million sites in the UK that could benefit from some form of micro generation and that this could cut carbon emissions by 5%, or 30 million tonnes per year
Solar thermal
panel provides
hot water
Most popular green
technology in the UK
Costs £3,000-4,500
Ground source heat pump provides heating and/or hot water pre-heating. System of pipes collects heat from the ground
Costs £8,000-10,000
Solar photovoltaic panels cost £5,000-8,000
Must face within 90
degrees of South
Micro-turbine costs £1,500-20,000 depending on size
Many urban sites unsuitable due to turbulence
Biomass burning
system replaces
heating boiler
Costs £3,000-12,000
Sustainability
Quadrat
Equality
Megaprojects involve both winners and losers
Technology must be cheap, or grants and subsidies made available for low-income groups
Negative externalities
must be minimised
Futurity
Technology needs to last. Replacement
after a few years uses up resources
Low-income groups need technology
they can maintain and run
themselves to avoid long-term costs
Environment
Technology should produce minimal waste
and pollution
It should not deplete resources
during manufacturing
Materials
used should
be recyclable
at end of life
Public Participation
People must be involved
Technology imposed from above, such as CCTV may lack public support