Ajude a dar forma ao GoConqr. O que a gente deve adicionar?

Notas

'A Minor Role'- U.A. Fanthorpe

T P English AS level Inglês 1 página

Conteúdo das notas (1)

Página 1

U.A. Fanthorpe, 'A Minor Role'

The speaker of the poem is seriously ill. She admits that being ill requires her to play a role to maintain the illusion that everything is okay. Fanthrope also outline the mundane realities of illness; hospital waiting rooms; listening to consultants; taking medicines; pretending to other that she is 'getting on, getting better'. The poet lists what she does when she is at home. such as finding happy novels to read, tidying up and answering the phone. At the end of the poem the speaker affirms the value of life.

Commentary- At the centre of the poem is an exploration of how we respond to illness and death. Up to the final line 'A Minor Role'. Fanthrope is suggesting that we respond by desperately maintaining an illusion - to ourselves and others - that everything is fine. in effect, the speaker feels she is acting, performing the minor role of the title

This conceit is acting is established in the first stanza, and returned to again at the end. The idea of acting assumes an audience - one of the reasons why the speaker feels a need to play a role is for other people. She knows she is being 'observed on stage'. The conceit continues as the speaker imagines playing the part of a servant in her own life, rather than the main protagonist. But even a small part like a servant can ruin the whole performance if the actor gets their lines wrong if they don't act convincingly enough.

The poem, therefore, contains this tension between the desire to maintain an illusion and the stark reality that the performance is hiding. it is worth searching the poem for indications of the mask slipping. The illusion is described metaphorically in the first stanza as a 'monstrous fabric'- something colossal, fearful perhaps. Stanthorpe has also carefully crafted her line breaks in the poem:

"Cancel things, tidy things; pretend all's well,

Admit it's not"

The idea of a gap between illusion and reality is given a physical form here. the painful admission that everything is not fine at all is given added poignancy through the simple, brief poetic line 'Admit it's not'. The space surrounding the line suggests that the truth of the illness is silencing the speaker; there is nothing more to say. Line ends are also intending in this poem. What do you think is the impact of place, for example, 'civility', 'misery' and 'yearnings' at the end of their lines?

As part of its exploration of the impact of illness, the poem makes interesting use of lists. the second stanza consists almost entirely of a list, suggesting the dull montony of hosiptal visits, reinforced by the repeated -ing verbs. The metaphorical conjugation of 'misey' also results in an inevitable list. Towards the end, the items in the list are separated not by a comma or a semi-colon but by fll stops. The silences are becoming more final, more keenly felt. It is as through the speaker is trying to control or repress her real feelings about illness by resorting to ticking things off, and gaining some consolation from routines.

Fanthrope returns to the conceit of acting and performance in the final two stanzas of the poem, but her position has changed. She concluded by rejcting the performance: 'I jettison the spear' Powerfully, the speaker also rejects thoughts of suicide, or atleast giving in, in the defiant exclamation: 'No it wouldnt!" Being honest and direct wins out in the end as the poem makes a dramtic turn in the moving final stanza, which is a powerful single line of poetry.

Informações

Descrição
AS level English Notas sobre 'A Minor Role'- U.A. Fanthorpe, criado por T P em 28-12-2019.
Criado por
T P · dez 2019
Atualizado
28 dez 2019
Visualizações
3
Avaliação

Mais sobre Identity and Society in Poetry

Fale Conosco

Sobre o que é sua mensagem?

O que a gente deve adicionar?