GoConqr has a new look! Let us know what you think.

Notes

Bad character evidence: the seven gateways

Yee Woei Lee Tort Law English 2 pages

Content of the notes (2)

Page 1

GATEWAY - D's BAD CHARACTER

1. All parties agree

2. D adduce himself

3. Important background evidence

MUST show that

jury/court would find it impossible/difficult to properly understand other evidence in the case w/o the BE

BE has substantial value in understanding the case as a whole

4. Relevant to important matter in issue between D and P

prosecution only

propensity to commit offences of the kind charged

propensity MAY be established by previous CONVICTION of an offence of the same description (same offence) /category (Theft/Sexual)

propensity to be untruthful (fraud, perjury etc)

making of false statements

giving of false evidence

D can apply to exclude evidence - admission have ADVERSE effect on FAIRNESS of proceedings that the court ought not to admit it (s101(3))

5. Has substantial probative value to matter in issue between D and co-D

defence only

MUST give notice to court, prosecution & other Ds - as soon as reasonably practicable & not more than 14 days after P discloses material on which application is based

6. Correct false impression

prosecution only

covers express/implied assertion

7. D attacked another person's character

prosecution only

D attacks by adducing evidence that other person committed criminal offence/behaved in a reprehensible way

MUST give written notice to court & defence - 28 days (MC), 14 days (CC) after not guilty plea

D can apply to exclude evidence - admission have ADVERSE effect on FAIRNESS of proceedings that the court ought not to admit it (s101(3))

* Previous offences committed < 14 years old - inadmissible, UNLESS

both previous conviction & current offence are TRIABLE ON INDICTMENT, and

in the interest of justice to admit the evidence

* Exclusion

must be made no later than 14 days after receipt of notice from P to adduce bad character

s 101(3)

D can apply to exclude evidence - admission have ADVERSE effect on FAIRNESS of proceedings that the court ought not to admit it

ONLY for (i) matters in issue between D and P, and (ii) D attacked character

s 78

GATEWAY - non-D's BAD CHARACTER

*** COURT'S LEAVE IS REQUIRED

1. Important explanatory evidence

2. Substantial probative value in relation to matter in issue in proceeding + substantial importance in the context of the case as a whole

evidence that deals with credibility

adduce non-D's previous conviction etc

3. All parties agree

application - applicant must apply - as soon as practicable, and not more than 14 days after P discloses material on which application is based

oppose application - must serve notice not more than 14 days after service of application

D's GOOD CHARACTER

D gave evidence and/or made exculpatory statements - full good character direction i.e. take into consideration GC while assessing D's credibility as witness + less likely that D would have committed the offence

D has not given evidence and not relying on exculpatory statements - ONLY less likely that D would have committed the offence

Page 2

Police detention period

- normal maximum DP = 24 hours from relevant time (earlier of - time which D arrives at 1st police station, or 24 hours after arrest)

- extension of DP applicable to INDICTABLE OFFENCES = up to 36 hours (Officer of Superintendent rank and above) / 96 hours (Magistrates Court)

- information relate to summary offence must be laid within 6 months of the time when the offence was allegedly committed

- indictable offence - no time limits apply

Information

Description
Tort Law Note on Untitled, created by Yee Woei Lee on 17/04/2019.
Created by
Yee Woei Lee
Views
10
Rating

More on Character and Similar Fact Evidence

Feedback

What is it about?

What do you think of the new look?

How do you like it?