Help shape GoConqr. What should we add next?

Notes

Violence in Social Life

Huatai Cui Sociology 1A 8 English 1 page

Content of the notes (1)

Page 1

Introduction

- Most sociologists relegate violence to the domain of criminology an deviance

- Two overarching assumptions of violence:

` Motivated by hostility and the wilful intent to cause harm

` Violence is deviant - legally, socially, or morally - from the mainstream of human activity

` Thus when violence is motivated by positive intentions, or is the incidental by-product of other goals, or is socially accepted or lauded, it escapes our attention.

- Four issues have irresolutely shaped our understanding of violence

` Most analysts have restricted their attention to actions that result in physical injuries (psychological, material, social injuries)

` Conceptions of violence are usually restricted to physical behaviours and the threat of physical behaviours (verbal and written actions)

` The issue of victim compliance has led to uncertainty about the status of some injurious actions

` Our narrow, legalistic concept of agency has led scholars to highlight interpersonal violence (fragmented or corporate agency, amorphous or anonymous victims, delayed or probabilistic injuries)

- Violent actions are a normal part of the human repertoire of strategic social behaviours

Existing Definitions of Violence

- Definition: Reiss & Ross, Understanding and Preventing Violence

` Interpersonal, inflict or threaten physical harm, motivated by harmful intent

` Psychological injuries are selectively included in the context of family and sexual violence, and then only when they result from threats of physical injury

` Excluded from the definition:

`` Self-inflicted (restriction to interpersonal violence)

`` Inflicted by state authorities in the course of enforcing the law, punishment, or providing collective defence (common focus on criminal or deviate behaviours)

` Aggression:

`` Any form of behaviour that is intended to injure someone physically or psychologically

- Definition: Centres for Disease Control and Prevention and the California Policy Council on Violence Prevention:

` Violence is the threatened or actual use of physical force or power against

another person, against oneself, or against a group or community that either

results in, or has a high likelihood of resulting in, injury, death, or deprivation.

` More inclusive, but less precise

` Includes self-inflicted injuries, as well as injuries inflicted on groups and communities

` Includes injuries that are either certain or probabilistic

` Physical violence is emphasised, although not exclusively

` Internal inconsistency: Self-

inflicted injuries are included, thereby implying that victim complicity does not

negate the definition of an injurious act as violent, but it also stipulates that all

violent actions involve the use of physical force or other means of coercion.

- Another way to approach the conception of violence: through the lens of nonviolence, since the latter involves the self-conscious renunciation of the former

- Researchers influenced by legal definitions of violent crime

` e.g. many scholars working on domestic violence have been interested in informing legal policy and have thus relied primarily on definitions that stressed codified behaviours used in the criminal justice system

- Funding for research on violence has overwhelmingly come from agencies with a strong interest in social policy

` This slant has shaped both the kinds of violence that have been studied and the way in which they are conceptualised

` Forms of violence that produce little or no physical injury have an uncertain status

- Concern for maintaining consistency with legal definitions has also steered researchers to focus overwhelmingly on interpersonal acts of violence and to restrict attention to acts that are clearly premeditated with an intent to harm

- Wolff, 1971: the notions of illegitimate force are too central to conceptions of violence

` Killing of a police officer by a civilian is considered homicide, whereas killing of a civilian by a police officer inline of duty is considered justifiable homicide, outside the realm of violence.

` since the concept of legitimate authority is itself problematic and the identification of violence depends on distinguishing illegitimate from legitimate force, the concept of violence is inherently confused, as is the correlative concept of non-violence.

- Reiss & Ross observe that their own definition of violence (quoted above)

excludes from consideration the important question of why some violent behaviors

are criminalised while others are not, and why this varies over time and across cultures

` they “recognise that understanding will be

enhanced in future research by studying a broader range of violent behavior using

classes based on behavioral rather than legal categories”

- We are overdue to cast a broader, more systematic conceptual net.

` The place to begin is with a brief assessment of the key sources of variation that have been glossed over, side-stepped, or summarily assumed away in most research on violence.

The Range of Injurious Outcomes: Physical, Psychological, Material, and Social

- The apparent concreteness and immediacy of physical injuries heightens their visibility and ease of observation

` Other kinds of harm are also highly consequential and sometimes devastating for human welfare (psychological, material, social), and the personal pain caused by some of these injuries may be more severe or prolonged than from many physical injuries.

` The most profound effects of physical violence itself are often non physical

- The boundaries between different types of injury are fundamentally clouded

` The sensation of physical pain itself is a complex intermixture of physiological and psychological stimuli

- Given humans' high sociability and manifest desire for material gain, certain social, psychological, and material injuries are considered more daunting than physical injuries

- The only violence research to have routinely incorporated psychological injuries is that on family or sexual violence.

` Even in that context, actions that inflict solely psychological injuries are usually bypassed.

- Social injuries are the least likely to be acknowledged in discussion of violence

- We need to be consistent about what kinds of injuries are consequential, and to develop more systematic criteria to assess the severity of various injuries.

Injurious Behaviours: Physical , Verbal, Written

- Primacy has usually been accorded to physically violent behaviours, but this is misleading on two main counts

` Verbal and written actions may also accomplish the infliction of physical injuries, either by directly initiating them (contracts) or by inciting others to acts of physical violence (newspapers, magazines, tv)

` Verbal and written actions may directly accomplish a variety of non-physcial injuries

`` Our legal code recognises the significance of such actions against individuals, but not against groups

- In many contexts, verbal and written assaults carry more credibility and are therefore more damaging than crude physical assaults

- There are diverse and often quieter ways of inflicting injuries than by physical assault alone

- We should respect their potency and analyse the conditions under which agents of violence choose one or another method of delivery

Victimhood and Compliance

- Violence is typically thought to involve force

` Compliance or complicity from the recipient of the injury is usually thought to negate victimhood and thus to jeopardise the characterisation of the event as violent.

` Yet certain injurious behaviours that do not involve force are occasionally included

`` Inflicting injury on oneself; suicide (?);

` some behaviors involving agent-to-victim injuries are

subject to doubt because of ambiguity about the degree to which the victim is

willing, compliant, or even has complicity

`` Sports; spousal abuse, sexual harassment, rape

- Three main reasons why the force criterion should be abandoned:

1) The compliance/noncompliance distinction is inherently ambiguous because people rarely act as free agents, but instead must usually make choices from a constrained set that has been predetermined by organisation or situational factors beyond their control; the victim's alternatives to compliance may be risky or futile. Poverty of resources and lack of access to information can also work to produce compliant victims

2) The compliance/noncompliance distinction is also difficult to observe empirically. People's revealed behaviours do not always reflect their preferences, especially in threatening situations. The victim may lack either the self-confidence or the social

credibility to counter the agent’s claims effectively, or she may be too shaken or

humiliated by the event to formulate allegations with fortitude. Even when there

are outside witnesses, those witnesses are rarely unbiased or free from perceptual

error.

3) A priori reason to exclude those injurious behaviours that do manifest relatively clear instances of voluntary submission to injury: suicide, masochistic self-mutilation, voluntary submission to hunger or injury on behalf of a political cause, voluntary submission to painful or hazardous beauty practices, religiously motivated abstinence from food, sexual gratification, or material possessions, or religiously motivated self-mutilation. In such instances, injuries are nonetheless sustained, and those injuries still affect the welfare of the victim.

- To comprehend the human propensity for violence, we need to analyze not only the factors

that cause people to inflict injuries on others, but also the conditions and dispo-sitions that lead people to tolerate—or even to seek—the infliction of injuries on

themselves.

Agents and Victims: Individual and Corporate

- The legal/criminology impetus in violence research has led to an ambiguity over corporate acts of violence

` Specific forms of collective violence have been the subject of inquiry, e.g. political violence, civil unrest, labour violence and intergroup conflict

` War, genocide and armed conflict arising from ethnic, racial or religious differences are recognised as corporate violence writ large, but the analysis of such corporate actions is disconnected from research on interpersonal violence

` More mundane corporate actions with injurious outcomes are unlikely to be couched in terms of violence at all

`` The decrees, decision s and activities of governmental agencies that adversely affect the welfare of group s and individuals

`` Production and marketing decision of corporations that endanger the health or safety of workers or consumers

- Our legalistic concept of agency requires a plainly visible actor, and there must be a directly observable, deterministic connection between the behaviour of one and the suffering of another

` In the forms of collective violence analysed there are plainly observable events with injurious effects on persons or property

` Other forms of corporate violence are harder to recognise, specifically actions that

`` result from the fragmented or cumulative activities of multiple factors

`` the agents or victims are faceless and amorphous

`` there is a lag or a probabilistic relationship between the actions taken by agents and the outcomes experienced by victims

- The repeated spotlight on interpersonal violence fosters the impression that the institutional backdrop is nonviolent, thereby sustainning the view of violence as an individual-level, deviant behaviour

What Motivates Violence?

- Violence is commonly associated with the intent to cause harm, and with anger, hostility, coercion or conflict

` But once we step away from the legal and moral imperatives that have shaped research on violence, we see the diverse and complex motivations of violence in social life

- Further motivation for violent actions:

` to benefit the community

`` ritual human sacrifice, witch hunt, Tuskegee Experiment

` to benefit the victim

`` self-flagellation, violent female beauty practices, painful surgical or drug therapies

` to satisfy recreational or entertainment needs

`` gladiator games, bull fights, dog fights, boxing matches, action movies

` tolerating it because it is incidental to other goals

`` Not deliberately sought, but not a mere accident, but a knowing tolerated by-product of one's actions

`` high-risk sports, Tuskegee Experiment, manufacturers

- Annual death toll > Homicide, but less attention

` relatively faceless, corporate perpetrators, outcomes probabilistic, absence of a deliberate harmful intent

- Humans are over to use violent means in the pursuit of a broad array of personal, social, material or political goals

` perform an instrumental service, e.g. make political statement

` satisfy expressive needs

` incidental

` violence may be carried out with malice, good will or indifference for the victim

- Restriction of our field of vision solely to those acts that are inspired by hostile intent is gravely misleading and undermines the endeavour to decipher the human relationship with violence

Varying Incidence and Social Acceptance of Violence

- We like to think that humans have a natural repugnance for violence and that such actions therefore deviate from the main impetus of social life

` Gender relations constitute the only context in which a sustained argument has been made that violence is an integral part of social interaction

`` normality of violence against women

- There is wide variation in both the frequency of occurrence and the social acceptance of the diverse acts of violence that mark social life.

` Our own culture, like others, lauds a number of violent practices as exemplary

- The confinement of research to those injurious actions that are socially deviant truncates and distorts the observed variance in violence

- Social response to violent actions or events is malleable

` Not all acts of violence meet with uniform interpretations within the same culture

` The perpetrators, victims and third party observers often perceive and view them quite differently

`` Perpetrators: deny/obscure, minimise, claiming it to be accident, claiming the victim precipitated it, wilfully desired it or benefitted from it, glorifying it as altruistic or necessary for the common good

`` Victim: emphasise/exaggerate the incidence, frequency, severity of injuries, attributing base motives to the perpetrators, claiming the victim's innocence ad lack of complicity, claiming the violence is detrimental to communal goals or values

- Research on violence against women:inventiveness of social actors in their responses to various kinds of violence against women

Generic Definition of Violence

- Jackman's definition of violence: Actions that inflict, threaten, or cause injury. Actions may be corporal, written or verbal. Injuries may be corporal, psychological, material, or social

- Violence is a multifaceted genus of behaviours whose component elements vary on continua

New Research Questions

- Cursory evidence suggests that human capacity to commit, endure, and observe violence is elastic

` actor's goals and the presumed efficacy of the violence in delivering those goals

` The immunity or vulnerability of the actor to sanctions or negative repercussions stemming from the behaviour

` The relative status and group affiliations of agents, victims and observers

` the spatial, temporal, or organisational insulation of actors from victims

` The availability and relative efficacy of other strategies

- 3 key steps in building a systematic understanding of violence in social life

` Define and measure the myriad components of violence

`` Assessments of severity

`` Assessments of the character of violent acts

` Examine the way in which institutional arrangements facilitate or obstruct the practice of various types of violence

` Analyse the ideology of violence, to try to assess how and why various acts of violence are repudiated, ignored, denied, praised or glorified.

Information

Description
8 Sociology 1A Note on Violence in Social Life, created by Huatai Cui on 22/11/2015.
Created by
Huatai Cui · Nov 2015
Updated
Apr 7, 2018
Views
10
Rating

Feedback

What is it about?

What should we add next?