Mind map
Vicarious Liability cases: Tests for employment
Map content
Vicarious Liability cases: Tests for employment
Mersey Docks v Coggins and Griffiths
- Control test
- Based on old 'master and servant' laws
- Looks at whether or not the employer has the right to control what was done and ways in which it was done
- Crane driver hired out to a company by Habour Board caused damage negligently
- It was held the driver was still an employee of Habour Board because he would not accept control by the other company
- The company could not tell the employee how to operate the crane (legal principle)
- Control test
Stevenson, Jordan, Harrison Ltd v MacDonald & Evans
- The intergration test
- Contract of service: work is done as an integral part of the business and the employee is part of that business
- Contract for services: work, although done for the business, is not integrated into it
- A management engineer wrote a book while working for his firm both as an employee and executive officer. He died before publication
- The Copyright Act states that the author is the first owner of copyright , if the author was under a contract of employment then the employer would use the copyright in the author's absence
- Presented the issue between what is classed as a contract of service and what is a contract for services
- The intergration test
Ready Mixed Concrete Ltd v Minister of Pensions
- The economic reality test
- Distinguishes between between employees and independent contractors
- Uses payment as a distinguishing factor
- Drivers were hired by the company to deliver concrete in vehicles, which they owned but had been painted the company colours
- The court held that the drivers were not employees because they had flexible hours and thus the employers were not responsible for the NI contributions
- The economic reality test
Information
- Description
- A level Law (OCR Law - Law of Torts) Mind Map on Vicarious Liability cases: Tests for employment, created by Ellie Sisson on 30/04/2017.
- Created by
- Ellie Sisson
- Views
- 1
- Rating