1. Organizational Capacity (institutions
& bureaucracies) 2. Political Skill (bully,
buy and bargain; build coalitions)
Nye: Coerce with
threats (authoritarian)
Cooper
democratic peace theory may not be so important in the realms of the international society
SMART
1. Contextual IQ
(understand evolving
environment)
SOFT
1. Policy Vision (balance ideals & capabilities) 2.
Communications (persuasive words) 3. Emotional
IQ (manage relationships with self-awareness
and control)
Nye: Induce with payments (imposition =
influence)
Hart
1.Control over resources 2.Control over
actors 3.Control over events/outcomes
(interdependence power): rational choice
theory
Nye: Attract and co-opt
WAR
New
Liberal
Derrida
Failed States
religion is not pure; democracy/liberty
should not be defensive
+ or - freedom
Just
Bellamy
legal vs. moral
Geneva Convention, Hague Convention
Old
'rules of war':
London Charter,
UN Charter
Five PSCM are in top six world arms
producers (SIPRI 2012) 1.USA 2. Russia
3. Germany 4. France 5. China 6. UK
THEORY
THE ENGLISH SCHOOL
international society which despite the
condition of anarchy, remains a society of
states with common interests, which leads
to the establishment of international rules
International system (realism/neo-realism): power politics amongst nation-states (structure and process of
international anarchy at centre/ national priority): does not seem to work. (Hobbes); International society
(rationalism/constructivism): institutionalisation of shared interests and identity amongst states (shared
norms, rules and institutions at centre/ international priority) – too narrow. (Grotius); World society
(revolutionism/liberalism): individuals, non-state organisations and the global population is the focus of
global societal identities (transcendence of the state system at centre/ humanitarian priority) – cultural
perspective. (Kant) Links the English School to both globalisation debates and EU debates.
Problems of World Society: Isomorphism: instead of diversity of political units, there is significant evidence
of homogeneity. Rational actorhood: the state is not only rational, but also nice. Decoupling: nation-states
are supposed to be tightly coupled structures; in reality, there is contradiction between commitments and
policies. Expansive structuration: exogenous models not rooted in local circumstance lead to irrational
development.
CONSTRUCTIVISM
Wendt
importance
of
psychology
and culture
RATIONALISM
REALISM
use of power between states and
the tendency towards conflict
Sovereign states act for their own security, in pursuit of their
own national interests, and against a struggle for power
Korab-Karpowicz
Waltz
structural constraints—not strategy, egoism, or motivation—will
determine behaviour in international relations
Morganthau
Six Principles: laws are in line with human nature; driving force self interest for power
Conditions: anarchy; state sovereignty; power/interests
Products: balance of power vs. hegemonic stability
LIBERALISM
Nye
Keohane
in international politics there are, in fact, multiple channels that connect societies exceeding the
conventional Westphalian system of states. This manifests itself in many forms ranging from informal
governmental ties to multinational corporations and organizations
IOs are better suited to
maintaining the peace than
nation states
Conditions: absolute gains; reduce information and transaction costs
stresses the possibility of cooperation between states, supports the emergence of
international institutions and international law, and wishes to protect the rights
and interests of individual human beings.
support both the rule of law, and
the liberties of states and
individuals, as well as the freedoms
of a hegemon and economic
arrangements containing gross
inequalities
STATES
Balance of Power
Long Peace
League of Nations
United Nations
Inclusive and exclusive model; Fully supported by the victorious states and the
losing states; Has its own military capabilities and states obliged to put their military if
called upon to do so; General Assembly has qualified majority of 2/3rds for security
resolutions and membership applications - everything else is simple majority;
Security Council: 15 members, need no veto and nine votes; Failed to uphold the
balance of power model – Bipolar, Unipolar BUT ensured long-term global peace
was maintained
Failed to prevent the Second World War – 20 Year Crisis;
Adopted exclusive model of the system of IR; Lacked
support of most powerful states in IR (US); No military
capability of its own; Voting by unanimity – lack of
efficiency; Failed to uphold the balance of power model
Bipolarity
Cold War
Unipolarity
Interdependance
Huntington
Remaking of World Order: "Clashes of civilizations are the greatest threat to world peace"
DEMOCRACY
Democratic institutions as part of good governance require:
1.Independent judiciary 2.Rule of law 3.Civil society fostered
4.Free press supported 5.Free market systems encouraged
Kant
Democratic Peace Theory
Fukuyama
Democracy is the end of history
PEACE
Positive
Treaties
Inclusive
'Peace feelers' ; diplomacy
Potsdam Proclamation
Exclusive
unconditional surrender ; reparations
domestic tort model ; deterrence
Cairo Declaration
Peace-making;
Peace-keeping;
Peace-building
Negative
Nehru
the human condition wretched throughout history on account of: exploitation and expropriation; class
struggle; conflict; enlightened 'interludes'; the ‘unpleasantness’ and ‘slowness’ of history
The behaviour of men can be changed by conscious effort and a new civilization can be created
Resting on Satyagraha, conflict ought to be removed from IR and replaced by cooperation.