Notes
A Level UK Politics Democracy
Content of the notes (2)
Page 1
1.1 Representative and Direct Democracy
Features of Direct Democracy
Referendums
Used in addition to representative democracy
Advantages of Direct Democracy
Purest form of democracy, the people's voice is clearly heard - e.g. 52% Leave in 2016 EU Referendum, 68% No vote on Alternative Vote, 55% No in Scottish Independence referendum
Decisions made directly by the people have more authority - only 1 MP voted against allowing PM to trigger Article 50, showing they respect the authority of the people, Robert Hazell "an important legitimising unit"
Can educate people - Scottish Referendum educated on tax, economic growth and EU membership referendum taught people about workings of EU
It can avoid deadlock within the political system - referendum on Good Friday agreement helped end violence in N. Ireland and bring powersharing, 1975 EEC referendum strengthened Wilson's position and reduced conflict in Labour Party
Disadvantages of Direct Democracy
Tyranny of the majority - e.g. 2008 California ballot voted 52% against same sex marriage, EU Referendum 62% remain in Scotland
Plato says swayed by short term emotional appeals - e.g. £350 million pounds a week to the NHS, "Take back control"
Some issues too complex for the ordinary citizen - e.g. Scottish Independence and EU very intricate
Features of Representative Democracy
Accountability - MPs held accountable at elections
Social representation - representatives should resemble to people
Representing the national interest
Constituency representation - represent constituency as a whole, individual constituents and constituents views on national issues
Party representation - adhere to party manifesto
Functional representation - represent occupational and social groups
Causal representation - represent ideas, principles and causes
Advantages of Representative Democracy
Representatives can protect minorities against rule by the majority - e.g.Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Act 2013, Race Relations Act 1965
Representatives may have more knowledge and judgement than the mass of the people and are less likely to be swayed by emotion
Elected representatives can be sensitive to changing situations
The Case for Reform (Democratic Deficit)
Peaceful transition of power
Positives - in the UK, transition of power is conflict free
Free elections
Positives - Majority of over 18s can vote, little electoral fraud and strong legal safeguards
Negatives - House of Lords unelected, Prisoners and 16/17 y/os can't vote
Fair elections
Positives - Proportional systems in place in Scotland, Wales and N. Ireland and for European Parliament elections
Negatives - FPTP is disproportionate and many wasted votes
Widespread participation
Positives - extensive membership of pressure groups, growing participation in e-democracy
Page 2
1.2 Wider Franchise and Debates over Suffrage
Key Milestones
Information
- Description
- A level POLITICS Note on A Level UK Politics Democracy, created by Charlotte C-G on 11/05/2018.
- Created by
- Charlotte C-G
- Views
- 5
- Rating