Notes
Liberalism
Content of the notes (1)
Page 1
What is Liberalism?
Liberalism is probably the "official" ideology of
our time, it is dominant in many countries. We live in a liberal democracy,
whereby the people are represented and our allowed to elect their
representatives. There is an intimate connection between liberalism, and the
principles of free trade that are so evident in capitalism. Liberal thought
developed in England during the 17th century, driven by John Locke in "Two
Treatises of Government" (1689); this book was written at a time of rapid
social change- requiring a shift from relationships of subordination to the
allegiance (the social contract). Particular concerns of Liberals are the
limitation of authority and an opposition to state interference with
individuals.
The individual is
paramount, and the rights and liberties of an individual serve to delimit the
area in which the state is entitled to act. Society is no more than the
aggregation of individuals.
Core elements of
Liberalism
1. The
individual;
2. Contract
and consent;
3. Constitutionalism
and the Law;
4. Freedom
as Choice;
5. Equality
of opportunity;
6. Social
Justice based on merit;
7.
Tolerance;
8. Private
and public life.
The Individual
In theory, the
preservation of the individual and the attainment of individual happiness are
the supreme goals of a liberal political system. Violence prohibited unless
in a war to protect liberal society itself, as human life is sacrosanct. Individuals are rational and are the best
determiners of their own best interests. Thus, politics is participatory, not
authoritarian – rational political man maximizes his utilities through
participation and choice. For Locke, ‘the laws of nature’ give man the right
‘to preserve his property – that is, his life, liberty and estate’. The only
task of government is to aid him in this.
The natural state of man is freedom and the duty of
government is to provide conditions for him to enjoy the maximum possible level
of freedom within a framework of law. Are people social? For liberals, they
aren’t anti-social, but they’re not naturally sociable either. They are assumed
to be ‘mutually indifferent’ due to their independent nature – the pursuit of
self-interest may result in either conflict or cooperation on occasion.
Liberals do not invoke ideas such as the common good to justify state
intervention – it is all about the maximisation of individual benefits.
Contract and Consent
If individuals are free and rational, government can only
occur with their consent. Locke hypothesised that government came about via
disputes – no impartial judge was there to arbitrate. To resolve this, men
would peacefully form a society with a government that operated on majority
decisions. Governments can be removed for: destroying or enslaving subjects,
ruling by arbitrary decree, transferring its own powers to others, or taking a
man’s property without consent. Is this tacit consent or active consent?
Liberalism does not entail democracy, but democracy is probably the best way to
secure liberalism.
Constitutionalism and
Law
The constitution and
the law run parallel in liberal theory; The constitution is there to prevent
the government transgressing against the individual. The law is there to
prevent individuals from transgressing against one another. Classical liberals
only want laws in a small number of areas (“small government”). In modern reality, the idea of ‘due process’
is more important for liberals.
Freedom of Choice
- Freedom is paramount in liberalism, the means by which a
rational individual pursues their own interests. But liberals also associate
freedom with humanity itself – a good in itself, not just as a means to an end.
Freedom is linked to
choice – e.g. you can spend your money on what you like (neo-Liberal
justification for low taxes, private schooling, etc.) J.S. Mill focused on the
more humanitarian aspects of freedom in the nineteenth century – freedom of
speech, thought, and religion is a right for all, unless it threatens direct
material harm to others. Choice in politics requires a variety of doctrines to
be on offer – pluralist democracy.
Equality of
Opportunity
Liberalism evolved
alongside capitalism, an economic system which operates on the basis of massive
inequalities of wealth and income.
Q: How to reconcile
the liberal idea of the egalitarianism of humans with the substantive
inequality caused by capitalism?
A: Equality of
opportunity. Liberals attribute formal quality to all, such as rationality,
self-interest, rights, etc., and argue that we all start life equal.
This takes the sting
out of competition, as it takes place in this context of equality of
opportunity. This is different to substantive equality (of outcome). Thus, if
we all start equal, what everyone gets is what they deserve. This is the
assumption/(myth?) underlying liberal ideology.
Social Justice based
upon merit
Individuals gain rewards in proportion to their talents and
merits in exchange for their contribution to society – this contribution is
assumed to be an approximate measure of talent.
The system is
organized to reward the most deserving – those who gain most have deserved most.
This is linked to classical economic
theory and the idea of the ‘just price’ resulting from market forces, but in no
way reflecting the intrinsic worth of something. Liberal ideology argues that
given equality of opportunity, free enterprise and competition produce a just
distribution of income and other goods. Again, the focus is on procedures, not
outcomes.
Toleration
Tolerance is the non-supression of dissident or
nonconformist views.
It is seen as a core
good of liberal societies, and liberal countries tend to look down on countries
that do not practice it (e.g. North Korea).
Classic argument is
from Locke (1689) – government should concern itself with the preservation of
peace, while morality is the business of priests.
J.S. Mill makes a
further argument that tolerance drives us towards truth. Thus, tolerance is
necessary to accommodate lots of different beliefs which can bring use towards
human good.
Private and Public
life
- There is a tension in liberal thought between the private
and public, based on Locke’s distinction between society and government:
implying that government should not pervade every area of social life, which is
a separate sphere. This gave rise to the idea of civil society – institution
protected by the rule of law but immune from state interference.
For Mill, citizens
gain most satisfaction from the private (different to Ancient Greek ideas about
the public realisation of citizens). Liberals do not like anything close to
compulsion in politics (i.e. compulsory voting). But – a risk here of a total
lack of political power for most people?
End Result?
Put together, all
these elements combine to make a coherent model of society in abstract.
Some liberal writing
assumes that the value of liberty and the individual is timeless, not
time-bound or culture-bound (e.g. Fukuyama).
This means that liberalism is to some extent a historical
and hazy about the future.
The liberal model is
of society as a voluntarily and rationally constituted aggregate of
self-interested individuals.
Based on the above
assumption, this is seen to have arisen spontaneously based on human desires
and interests (at all times, in all places).
Why do liberals place
such emphasis on the individual?
Ancient Greek thought saw individuals only in terms of their
social function, and the middle ages saw the same as society was hierarchical
in nature. The idea that an individual is uniquely valuable is relatively new,
seeded by Christian ideas that all souls are equal in the eyes of God.
The birth of liberal individualism happened at a time of
rapid social change and mobility – this gave rise to the idea that an
individual (just men at this point) individuated themselves by their achievements
and resulting possessions. At the same time, during eighteenth-century
revolutions saw the individual as the bearer of political rights, and
economists saw individuals as free vendors and consumers of goods and services.
The strongest argument comes from the view that egoism is
natural; as such, human desires are the most important consideration for
deciding human good.The desires of the social whole are a false aggregate,
could go against individual interests. The pursuit of self-interest is a core
value of liberalism, and this in turn requires a belief in the sanctity of
human life.
So liberals broadly argue for a ‘right to life’, but are
less clear about the ‘right to a decent life’ – what about severely disabled
babies who live in pain? Is the value of life self-evident without a guarantee
of standards? Can liberal idea of self-preservation explain sacrifice for
others, suicide bombings?
The Welfare State
What is a welfare
state? An interventionist state which goes beyond the minimal state functions
of providing defence and security of property, and legislates to improve
people’s well-being. E.g. state-run hospitals, schools, roads, etc.
Three main arguments
from liberalism against welfare states:
1. They can be seen as interfering with individual freedom –
individuals are forced to contribute to the maintenance of services they may
not want to.
2. They can be seen as interfering with individuals’ lives
for their own good, sometimes against their interests.
3. They are too paternalistic – if someone cannot support
themselves, they should not be supported by the state.
However...
Against arguments 2
and 3, you could argue that people have first, a right to life, and second, a
right to a decent standard of living.
The overall argument
of paternalism is more difficult to refute – people must in part surrender
their free and rational status to the state to facilitate the existence of a
welfare state. But, this should be pitted against the benefits (on an
individual level) of having a welfare state – e.g. for those who need the
services. Hobhouse (1911) makes the key contribution to liberal thinking on the
welfare state. He argued that the welfare state is essential to creating
equality of opportunity.
Modern Variations:
Libertarianism
An anti-state
ideology – the logical extreme of liberalism. Fundamentally Lockean – right to
life, liberty and property paramount. To achieve this, the state must be
removed as it is an agent of coercion and the foremost violator of liberty. Key
writers here are Nozick and Hayek.
Libertarian arguments
attack liberal governments for incursions into individual freedom, and
socialist ideas for suggesting that an extension of the state is necessary to
create greater equality.
Nationalism and liberalism
In 19th Century, liberals supported nationalist movements
and revolutions which overthrew oppressive regimes..
Less of a clear relationship now – are they antagonistic?
Liberalism and feminism
How does feminism relate to liberalism?
Some (e.g. Carole
Pateman) have argued that the principles of liberalism are based on an
acceptance of patriarchal societal structures.
- A key (the ?) contribution to modern liberal thought in
1971 – A Theory of Justice. How can we form, collectively, a social contract by
which we would all choose to live? How to overcome who we are and what we
prize? A hypothetical original position is proposed by Rawls. Imagine choosing
the structure of society if you didn’t know who you were – what you had, your
race, skills, sex. You choose from behind a ‘veil of ignorance’. Rawls thinks
we would all choose equality.
Conclusion
Liberalism is the world’s dominant ideology – it feels
natural…is it? Or is it just an ideology like all others?
The freedom of the individual is paramount – they are rational
and know their own interests.
Society should be structured to allow individuals to pursue
these interests.
- Liberals have a strange relationship with the welfare
state – how do they justify it? Can they (fully)?
New Page
Information
- Description
- Note on Liberalism, created by kieran.chandler on 04/03/2014.
- Created by
- kieran.chandler · Mar 2014
- Updated
- Feb 19, 2016
- Views
- 36
- Rating