Mind map
Mitigation

Mind map: Mitigation
Map content
Mitigation
Measures of Mitigation
- Scales of Mitigation
- Global
- Kyoto
- 2nd commitment?
- argument that there's a need for a broader legal basis
- Annex 1
- industrialised
- legally binding rules
- industrialised
- non Annex
- voluntary
- 2nd commitment?
- COPs
- Kyoto
- Regional (EU)
- 2012 - cut by 8%
- 2020 - cut by 20%
- 2050 - cut by 80-95%
- difficult but no-one is worrying yet - leave to next PM
- 2050 - cut by 80-95%
- easy - outsourcing
- measured by source :(
- 2020 - cut by 20%
- ECCP (2000)
- identify and develop all elements of EU strategy to implement Kyoto
- commission reps; member state reps; industry and environmental groups
- 2012 - cut by 8%
- National (UK)
- CC Act (2008)
- long term framework
- legally binding targets
- reduce by 34% by 2020
- 80% by 2050
- reduce by 34% by 2020
- carbon budgets
- cap on total quantity of GHGs in UK
- clear framework - can see where going
- CC Act (2008)
- Global
- Policy Instruments
- used by different actors to achieve desired effect
- Voluntary Agreements
- different levels
- international; national
- tried and tested a lot
- some positive impact
- necessary but not efficient
- Benefits
- info gathering
- diffuse best practice
- raise awareness and understanding of mitigation options
- different levels
- Tradeable Emission Permits
- allowance - limit on emissions
- CO2 priced by tonne
- unused permit sold on to those who need it
- Benefits
- makes emissions market based
- Stern Review
- governments in agreement
- makes emissions market based
- Costs
- allowances are too high
- just shuffles CO2 around
- allowances are too high
- fined if over permit and haven't bought more
- allowances decrease over time to reduce emissions
- Carbon Reduction Commitment
- mandatory for large organisations which have resources to do it
- self reported
- temptation to underreport
- self reported
- mandatory for large organisations which have resources to do it
- GHG Taxes
- charges on fossil fuels
- correct market failure
- Technology Support
- money from taxes invested in clean tech
- Scales of Mitigation
Carbon Sinks - Forests and REDD+
- Carbon Sinks
- natural way to absorb CO2 - reduce emissions
- forests; oceans
- forests more manageable
- models estimate forests have absorbed 30% of human produced CO2 over past 150 years - oceans = same
- REDD+
- Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Degradation
- Deforestation - reduced quantity
- Degradation - reduced quality
- + (also conservation measures)
- Proposed at COP 11 (2005)
- Global Division
- focus on South
- tropical forests are better CO2 sinks
- North doesn't work as well
- snow reflects back heat
- dark trees - low albedo
- focus on South
- Benefits
- natural method
- improves biodiversity
- strengthens nation states
- development funding
- increased influence of the South
- Challenges
- Economic
- abatement costs = low for North - cheaper than sorting themselves out
- South - reduced income - less timber sales etc
- distribution of funding = complex
- Laws
- definition of forest = complex
- boundaries; land use; cover
- Who owns the forest?
- corruption and fraud widespread
- Sikor et al - Vietnam
- definition of forest = complex
- Institutions
- justify emissions by planting trees?
- affects indigenous people
- Politics
- redistribution of agency
- national > global
- disempowers locals
- redistribution of agency
- Economic
- Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Degradation
- Forest Inventories
- accounting for forest value = complex
- biomass/timber = economic value
- carbon concentration doesn't really
- accounting for forest value = complex
- Problems with the Idea
- Nutrient Limitations
- plants need nutrients to grow; are there enough?
- Climate Change
- increased temperature can cause forests to flip from sink to source
- less storage capacity
- grow faster; die faster
- increased temperature can cause forests to flip from sink to source
- Tree Life Cycle
- leaves on tree = sink; on ground = release CO2
- Nutrient Limitations
- Carbon Sinks
Has Mitigation Failed?
- Helm (2008)
- policies have achieved v little
- Flaws
- measure production not consumption
- should be enduser
- Stern Based Economics
- underestimates impact on GDP
- discount based on morals
- measure production not consumption
- Prisoners Dilemma
- Game theory
- have to make choice without knowing what others will do
- Game theory
- Observations
- av temp has increased by 0.74 degrees since 1800s
- 9 of last 10 years highest on record
- sea level rose by 10-20 cm over 20th century
- temp could rise by 1.8 to 4 degrees by 2100
- no action
- Mitigation Policies
- Kyoto
- voluntary agreements
- Cap and Trade
- GHG taxes
- tech support
- carbon sinks - REDD+
- Kyoto
- Conclusions
- UK
- 1990-2011 - decreasing trend in emissions
- haven't reached endpoint yet so can't know
- Issues with the Goal
- What is it?
- measurements are invalid
- ignore aviation
- measured by source; not enduser
- measurements are invalid
- Who sets it?
- developing countries were not as developed in 90s
- goal unfair on them
- developing countries were not as developed in 90s
- how do we know if reached?
- Temporality
- time scale small in comparison to scale of problem
- e.g president only in office for max 8 yrs
- time scale small in comparison to scale of problem
- What is it?
- UK
- Knowledge
- GHG concentration is directly linked to global temperature
- steady increase since Industrial Revolution
- CO2 = most abundant
- Unknowns
- tipping points
- what happens if trapped methane is released?
- Helm (2008)
Carbon Capture and Storage
- How does it work?
- capture CO2 from fossil fuel power stations
- Technologies
- Post Combustion
- Scrubbing - CO2 seperated from flue gas
- passed through liquid - chem reaction
- Can be retrofitted
- Scrubbing - CO2 seperated from flue gas
- Pre Combustion
- CO2 removed before burning
- separated into H2 and CO2
- H2 fuels plant
- new stations only
- CO2 removed before burning
- Oxyfuel
- fuel burnt with nearly pure oxygen
- flue gas = steam + CO2
- steam cooled off
- flue gas = steam + CO2
- new/existing
- fuel burnt with nearly pure oxygen
- Post Combustion
- Transportation
- One captured - compressed to liquid - transported in pipelines
- Storage
- Deep Saline Aquifers
- Depleted oil and gas fields
- How is it trapped?
- Structural
- trapped by impermeable rock
- Residual
- Solubility
- dissolves in water
- Mineral
- dissolved CO2 reacts with rock formation > mineral
- Structural
- UK
- UKSAP
- £4 million research project
- review of storage sites to estimate capacity
- Ferrybridge
- pilot
- test technology and optimise
- £125 million to spend on CCS until 2015
- research at unis
- support for companies
- pilot scale demos
- UKSAP
- Enthusiasm
- energy efficiency and renewables are more sustainable but CCS needed to meet targets
- Challenges
- need reduced cost
- market framework
- How does it work?
Information
- Description
- Climate Change Mind Map on Mitigation, created by Hannah Fillier on 20/05/2013.
- Created by
- Hannah Fillier
- Views
- 49
- Tags
- Rating
More on Climate change mitigation and adaptation